
Member Reviews

Brilliant blend of historical and fiction writing. Good character development from a reserved woman to more leadership influencer. Tingley starts her journey from a reoccurring vision that leads to romance and heartache. Lots of historical learnings from ancient civilisations.
A fascinating turn of the century book that should be on your read list.
Not read Hall’s novels prior so this was a welcome treat thanks to #NetGalley for the opportunity to read via the ARC programme.

I had a passing understanding of Theosophy, and this intriguing historical novel filled in many blanks in my knowledge. It is clear from the author’s note on her research that, while this is a work of fiction, it is based on a deep dive into the life of Katherine Tingley and the Theosophy movement. According to the notes all the characters (except for one at the mission in NYC) were actual people involved in the movement.
Katherine Tingley’s story is unique, not only in her paranormal abilities, but also in her leadership at a time when the role of women was severely constricted by social norms of the late eighteenth – early nineteenth centuries. The descriptions of her accomplishments gave me a deep appreciation of her commitment to her vision in the face of betrayal, lies and even slander. The pacing as the novel began kept me engaged, but I found myself becoming a bit fatigued by all the drama and power struggles described in great detail. Additionally, the ending felt rushed after the extensive focus on the beginning of her involvement.
Leaders of spiritual movements that defy traditional religious roles are often met with disdain, contempt and even violence. As I reflected on the description of Lomaland compound from today’s perspective, I wondered if it would be labeled a cult with all the weight that label carries. Regardless of one’s perspective concerning the community and its adherents, the Theosophy movement/philosophy itself held pure intentions for universal brotherhood, love, and peace – much needed qualities then and now.
Overall, this was an informative and enjoyable read that pays tribute to the courage and resourcefulness of a remarkable woman.
My thanks to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for the privilege of reviewing this book. The opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
This review is being posted immediately to my GoodReads account and will be posted on Amazon upon publication.

So silly old me accidentally posted the wrong review to the wrong book earlier so thankfully I figured out my mistake. Lol
This intriguing late nineteenth century and early twentieth century novel explores the art of the occults. I read a novel a while back that was similar but this one is a bit more lighthearted although they are both equally good books. Overall I was very impressed with the characters and the writing itself was goos and easy to understand.
Our main heroine Katherine Tingley has always felt like an outsider to her family who were frightened at her ability to have visions. Deciding that she wants to seek her own destiny she leaves her home and travels to find people who understand her gift. Along the way she manages to help those who have lost loved be able to communicate with them.
She then meets William Q Judge who is a very influential mesmerist and teaches her to embrace her gift. Overtime she manages to become much more confident with her abilities. After Mr. Judges passing her takes up her leadership role in the society and moves to San Diego to grow her prospects. However some of these people don't have the best intentions and if she isn't careful she could possibly lose everything.
I received an arc copy from Netgalley and all opinions are of my own.