This book is incredible! I couldn’t stop listening to it! The narrator is so good! She pulls you into the story. I’m already recommending this book to everyone. Love it!

Book Review: The Story Keeper by Kelly Rimmer
Thank you to Harlequin Audio and NetGalley for the gifted advance listening copy of this emotionally rich and beautifully atmospheric audiobook.

Kelly Rimmer’s The Story Keeper is an intricately layered gothic historical fiction audiobook that blends family mystery, dual timelines, and emotional healing. Narrated with quiet intensity by Siho Ellsmore, this novel is more than just a story—it’s an immersive experience. Set on the haunting east coast of Australia, the tale begins when Fiona Winslow, newly divorced and emotionally spent, returns to her crumbling ancestral home, Wurimbirra, after the death of her estranged uncle.

What starts as a renovation project quickly becomes a psychological and emotional excavation. Inside the dust and decay of the mansion, Fiona discovers The Midnight Estate—a mysterious manuscript that seems to echo her own life. As she reads the novel, Fiona realizes the characters and events feel oddly familiar, uncannily aligned with the unspoken traumas and secrets that have haunted her family for generations. As the fictional narrative unfolds, so does Fiona’s own—creating a book-within-a-book structure that mirrors her emotional unraveling.

Kelly Rimmer excels at character-driven storytelling, and here, her signature strengths shine. Fiona is a quietly powerful protagonist—resilient, broken, searching. Her internal conflict feels genuine, especially in her strained relationship with her emotionally distant mother. The dual timelines—one modern, one historical—interweave with skill, each layer deepening the stakes and slowly unraveling a legacy of silence, shame, and survival. There are moments of deep melancholy in this story, but also flickers of hope and redemption.

One of the most striking aspects of The Story Keeper is its setting. Wurimbirra, the family’s decaying estate, is not just a backdrop but a living, breathing character. Rimmer paints it with such vivid detail—the creaking floorboards, the chill in the air, the dust motes dancing in forgotten sunlight. The house holds secrets, and you can feel them pressing against the walls. Listening to this audiobook with headphones is like stepping into the house itself.

Narrator Siho Ellsmore brings the story to life with a voice that is both calm and emotionally attuned. Her Australian accent adds an important layer of authenticity, anchoring the story in place. She captures Fiona’s uncertainty, strength, and fear with nuance. Her performance enhances every emotional beat, making this audiobook one of the most immersive listening experiences I’ve had this year.

Thematically, The Story Keeper dives into generational trauma, domestic abuse, coercive control, the silence of women, and the emotional burden of legacy. These topics are handled with compassion and gravity, especially through the narrative Fiona finds herself reading. At times, the plot’s predictability may be noticeable—many listeners will guess the central twist early—but that doesn’t weaken the impact. The real power of the story lies not in surprise, but in the emotional weight of recognition. As Fiona pieces together the truth, so does the listener—and the revelation is still deeply satisfying.

A line from the book has stayed with me: “Some houses keep their memories in the walls, and some make you live them all over again.” That sentence encapsulates the gothic atmosphere and emotional complexity of this novel. The Story Keeper isn’t about ghosts in the traditional sense—it’s about the ghosts of memory, the echoes of pain, and the resilience it takes to confront them.

While there are moments where pacing dips—particularly in the early chapters—the payoff is worth the patient buildup. If you’re a reader who values atmospheric storytelling, character-driven plots, or dual-timeline narratives with emotional resonance, this audiobook delivers. Fans of Kate Morton, Kristin Hannah, and Wendy Webb will find much to love here.

Whether you read the physical version or listen to the audio, The Story Keeper lingers long after the final chapter. It’s not just a mystery to solve—it’s a story about survival, about the power of stories themselves to heal and reveal. This audiobook is one I’ll be recommending to readers who crave intelligent, emotional fiction with substance.

⭐⭐⭐⭐½ (4.5/5 stars)

The Midnight Estate/The Secret Keeper
Thank you Harlequin Audio for the #gifted alc!

🗓️ July 23, 2026
🎧 Siho Ellsmore

I love going into a book completely blind. Kelly Rimmer is an author I love but she writes different genres so really… all I had to go off was the title and cover. Both of which are changing before release. I texted my group chat with, “I’m ** far in and I still don’t know what genre this is!”

Expect 👉🏼 Historical Fiction, Dual Timelines, Gothic Mansion, Australia

Fiona has long-dreamed of restoring her childhood home back to its former grandeur. After a terrible year where her life imploded, she decides it’s time to take some time to herself and move back to the mansion that everyone else seems to think is haunted. While cleaning and renovating, she finds a book that calls to her. The story is eerily familiar and tells of loss, sacrifice and secrets that were meant to stay hidden.

This book was immaculately atmospheric. I felt like I was in the story, hearing the wind whipping through the home, Fiona’s shock and attempted rational when things had been moved or broken, trying to unravel the book’s mystery while also coming to terms with what was going on physically around her.

Kelly Rimmer is fantastic. I’m not someone who reaches for Gothic reads normally, but if she writes it, I’m gonna love it.

🎧 This story was beautifully narrated and brought to life. There is something so soothing about an Australian accent!

4.5/5

Thank you, @htpbooks_audio and @netgalley for the gifted ALC! #htppartner #ad

Story Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Audio Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Rundown:
✨️a crumbling/gothic mansion
✨️east coast of Australia
✨️mysterious book
✨️family secrets
✨️a book within a book
✨️DV/coercive control

Synopsis ✒️
Fiona returns to restore her family's crumbling estate after the death of her uncle. She finds a mysterious book called The Midnight Estate among his things. She's drawn to the tragic yet hopeful story and feels connected to it in an unexpected way.

Thoughts 💭
Initially, I was really confused as to what was happening in the story. There was one story going on with Fiona, who returns to her family home, and another story she's reading in a book that has two separate stories in it. It was hard to see how all three storylines would cross. The more she reads The Midnight Estate, the more things start to overlap and make sense. There is a twist at the end that I was able to figure out early on, but that didn't make it any less satisfying at the end. The story wrapped up nice and cohesively. I love that the house seemed to have a personality of its own with a gothic feel that helped set the mood of the story. This does have domestic violence in it, so that's something to be aware of. The story was narrated by Siho Ellsmore, who has an Australian accent and went perfectly with the story and made it feel more authentic.

This was an intriguing audio book which kept me listening for hours. The dual timeline took some time to intersect but with a satisfying connection. The development of the characters, time and place was interesting. This is my first book by this author and I look forward to reading more.

4.5⭐️
This was such an interesting premise: a book within a book! I was invested in the characters, the setting, and appreciated how the twists unfolded in the story.

I must admit that I approached this book with two primary motivations: its captivating cover and the author’s reputation. As a reader of her previous books, I am particularly fond of her writing style. Historical fiction is my preferred genre, and I genuinely anticipated a tale centered around a haunted house. But I was proven wrong in the theory.
Upon reading the book, I was pleasantly surprised to discover that the narrative deviated from my initial expectations. The protagonist, Fiona, emerges as a formidable woman navigating the challenges of a difficult divorce. Her emotional journey evokes empathy and sadness, while her strained relationship with her mother remains a mystery. The distance between these two characters is palpable, yet both feel relatable.
The narrator’s narration is exceptional, drawing the reader into Fiona’s world as if they were uncovering the secrets alongside her. I genuinely hope that Fiona will continue reading the book to unravel the mysteries of the characters she encounters.
It is important to acknowledge that the book addresses domestic violence, a topic that was not extensively discussed during its time of publication. Unfortunately, many individuals remain isolated, and women have suffered due to the reluctance of others to intervene when they come forward.
I highly recommend this audiobook, and I eagerly anticipate acquiring a physical copy. In fact, any work by this author is consistently exceptional.
My review will be up everywhere including instagram and tiktok..

The story Keeper
by Kelly Rimmer
Pub Date: July 21, 2025
Thanks to the author, Harlequin Audio and NetGalley for the ARC of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
Told in a dual narrative and set against the Gothic backdrop of Wurimbirra, Kelly Rimmer, bestselling author of The Things We Cannot Say, weaves an intricate and compelling tale, inviting readers into the heart of a family’s deepest secrets with an absorbing book-within-a-book mystery.
The MIDNIGHT ESTATE is a blend of historical mystery with some emotional drama mixed in. I liked the dual timelines, there were many secrets and surprises. I thought the old estate in Australia was spooky and very cool. Even though I guessed what was happening early on, it was still a very enjoyable book to listen to. I really liked the narrator, she did an excellent job of keeping me entertained!

Fiona, a recently divorced empty-nester, returns to her childhood home in remote Australia after inheriting it from her uncle. With plans to restore the estate, Fiona moves in and slowly starts re-exploring the home. She tries to settle into her new home, but can't quite feel comfortable there are odd things keep happening--doors slamming shut, glasses knocked off tables, and when she comes across a book, The Midnight Estate and starts reading it, certain details feel vaguely familiar. Has her uncle left her a clue to a puzzle she didn't even know needing solving?

The Midnight Estate is a book within a book. Chapters alternate between Fiona's present-day restoration of the estate and those of the mysterious novel she's discovered. Early on in the novel these two storylines feel very disconnected, though any even mildly astute reader will quickly put the two narratives together. I love Kelly Rimmer's books, and I was really let down by this one. It just felt off. The pacing was odd--I'd been waiting for a big reveal to arrive, only to realize, that in fact, there wasn't one. This novel has a bit of an identity crisis--is it a ghost story, a mystery, a domestic suspense? A bit of all of those, and though I love a genre-blending novel, this one didn't do it well. I almost suspect that this is an earlier novel of Rimmer's that was never published and then re-vamped with a few new chapters (there were a few chapters that felt like they didn't fit the narrative at all and were thrown in just to update the feel of the book). I am still a huge Rimmer fan and will excitedly read the few I have left of hers, but if you're new to this author, I recommend you start with one of her older titles. I tandem read and listened to this one and enjoyed both formats.

This pains me to write, but I'm calling this book a DNF at 37%. Here's why:

I felt the characters lacked development and depth.

Pacing is incredibly slow.

The timelines feel disjointed, with the switches jarring. I couldn't settle into any one story. I know these timelines will intersect, but it's taking a long time and a lot of mundane detail to get there.

I didn't feel any emotional connection.

I started with the audiobook. No offense to the narrator, but her style just didn't work for me. She speaks in a staccato rhythm, choppy and punchy, with an unnecessary pause after every few words. This is especially pronounced with the male POV and dialogue from men.

I switched over to the ebook, which was slightly better, but not enough to keep me engaged.

But this is just my opinion. Other readers have loved this one, and you might too.

*Thanks to Harlequin Audio for the free audiobook download, and to MIRA Books for the free eARC.*

Thank you Netgalley for this fantastic audio ARC by Kelly Rimmer. I really enjoyed the narration of this book and the story itself. I loved the spooky ghost vibe and I really felt for the main character, Fiona as she struggles with family secrets and the restoration of her uncle's house. The story was original and captivating! I thoroughly enjoyed the dual narrative and timelines of this novel. To hear the backstory and secrets from Fiona's ancestors made the book more interesting and I really liked that the author chose to tell the story through a book written by her uncle. A great read I will reommend to many!

"The Storyteller" by Kelly Rimmer is a truly moving and powerful book. It's an unforgettable story about family, secrets, and finding strength, with characters you'll genuinely care about. It's a book within a book, and I enjoy that trope a lot. I highly recommend it!

The Story Keeper is a beautifully layered and emotionally resonant novel that showcases Kelly Rimmer’s signature blend of historical intrigue, richly developed characters, and heartfelt storytelling. From the very first page, Rimmer pulls readers into a dual-timeline mystery that is both haunting and hopeful, weaving together the past and present with masterful precision.

The novel’s setting, a sprawling, mysterious estate, is as vivid and compelling as the characters who inhabit it. The story moves seamlessly between generations, unearthing long-buried secrets while exploring themes of identity, legacy, and the enduring power of love. Each chapter builds suspense and deepens the emotional stakes, keeping the reader fully invested until the final, satisfying revelation.

Rimmer excels at crafting female protagonists who are complex, resilient, and deeply human, and The Story Keeper is no exception. The intergenerational connections feel authentic and powerful, and the emotional payoffs are well-earned. With lyrical prose and impeccable pacing, this novel is a must-read for fans of historical fiction, family drama, and gripping mysteries.

Kelly Rimmer continues to prove she’s one of the most talented voices in contemporary fiction. TheStory Keeper is a poignant and unforgettable read that lingers long after the final page.

A story within a story, the past and the present, a haunted house, Fiona who at 50 lost her husband, her best friend and her career and who is trying to understand why her mother holds her at arms length and is so angry with her are all important to The Story Keeper. But the most important part is the beautiful story told in the mysterious book that Fiona finds. Even though I figured out the secret of the special book I still couldn’t wait to listen and find out the rest of the story.

I really enjoy reading multiple-timeline novels and have particularly enjoyed Gothic-style stories that have a focus on an old house and a mystery from the past. The Midnight Estate is the first novel I have read by Kelly Rimmer and I highly recommend it to other readers who enjoy this type of fiction.

One of the timelines in this case is actually a novel within a novel. As you learn from the synopsis, the main character Fiona purchases Wurimbirra, the former home of her late uncle and a house she once called home. Her uncle was a well-known author and, while cleaning out his office, she discovers multiple copies of a novel that draws her in immediately.

Local stories tell of ghosts at Wurimbirra, and strange happenings at the house disturb Fiona, but don’t deter her from her desire to renovate the rambling house so that she can call it home once again. As she works on the project and delves into the novel she finds, fiction and reality seem to draw closer and closer together.

I found both Fiona’s story and the one told in the novel she finds (also titled The Midnight Estate) captivating. There was a bit of spookiness, just the right amount of mystery, and plenty of emotional drama. I listened to the audiobook version which doesn’t give me the time to reflect on writing skill and characterization that a physical book does, but I remained interested throughout and appreciated the narrator’s Australian accent which added an air of authenticity.

One aspect of the story that put me off a bit was that Fiona missed obvious clues to the mystery that was unfolding before her. She was a smart and thoughtful woman; I felt she would have been more savvy to what was so obvious to the reader. However, that particular issue didn’t deter me from enjoying the novel as a whole and I look forward to reading more books by this author.

I’ve enjoyed every Kelly Rimmer book I’ve read and had high expectations for this one. I don’t often listen to audiobooks through Netgalley, but I was captivated by the narrator for this one. The voice work was lovely and added to the story immensely.

The story itself was good but the dual plots didn’t always work smoothly. I enjoyed the contemporary story much more and felt it was far more developed than the “story within the story.” The cast of characters is appealing and the protagonist engaging, but the real star here is the house. My imagination worked over time imagining the house and all the secrets it held.

I had high hopes for this book based on the description, but sadly it just didn't work for me. The pacing was slow and I lost interest in the story and "mystery," which was too predictable. The characters were well done though. I love this kind of story, but maybe reading the book would be better for me with this one.

Thank you NEtGalley for an advanced audiobook. All opinions are my own.

I enjoyed The Midnight Estate by Kelly Rimmer. In general, it is about domestic abuse; however, the story builds upon character relationships. I liked that it ultimately revolved around domestic issues and family drama, but the setting felt like it was going to take a turn into horror, which it didn't (thankfully). The characters kept alluding to the house being haunted, and only until the end does the reader understand the rationale behind this theory. Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my opinions.

Thank you NetGalley for allowing me the opportunity to review this e-audiobook.

If you enjoy mystery, family secrets with a little dash of creepy then this is a great book for you!

There’s a crumbling mansion, a rediscovered book, and a mystery spun through it all. After a long burdening year, Fiona returns home after many years to restore a mansion that she used to refer to as home. The family home is well known amongst the regulars as Wurimbirra, and located on the east coast of Australia.

This gothic mystery is a layered story, and character-driven for those that have a passion for mysteries intertwined.

I really enjoyed learning about the family estate, and the readings from the discovered book found at Wurimbirra. This was a book that I didn’t want to put down!

I had a hard time with the beginning of this one, but the further I got in the harder it was to put down. I had heard many great things about Kelly Rimmer and her work and was excited to try this one. I think I will be looking for more of her work to try! I enjoyed how the two timelines came together in the end to make so much sense.

Thank you NetGalley, the publisher and Kelly Rimmer for the opportunity to read an ARC of "The Story Keeper"!