
Member Reviews

Spring Breeze is a fascinating tale of Stalinist era tragedy and intrigue, featuring compelling real-life characters. It is also quite a beautiful and sophisticated story of unconventional love and devotion. Full review here: https://www.jbspins.com/2025/06/snergurochka-of-spring-breeze-manga.html

This was such an interesting one shot manga that focuses on 1930s Russia. I will be honest I wasn’t sure I would like this one but I absolutely loved it. It had a mixture of intrigue, alternative history and espionage. This mixture was created in a wonderful read that I couldn’t put down. At times dark and with moments of light as well I really enjoyed this one and think any history manga fan will enjoy it too.
As always thank you to Kodansha Comics for the advanced copy to review, my reviews are always honest and freely given.
#SnegurochkaOfTheSpringBreeze #HiroakiSamura #Netgalley #KodanshaComics #ARC #ARCReview #BookReview #FreeReview #AdPR #Gifted

This one shot manga explores the very distinct time period of 1930s Soviet Union and deals with certain historical events in that period. It was an interesting read as you try to understand the backstories and motivations of the two leads- Squirrel and Puppy. This is a great book for fans of dark historical fiction, or of Samura's other works, like "Blade of the Immortal"

Thank you NetGalley and Kodansha for this ARC. I would love say this is wonderful manga, the art is superb, and the references spark curiousity. But the implied rape makes me think a lot why the guy in the end didn't get punished a lot or the girl could be super rude to him instead of acting like he's her father.
The plot twist in the end regarding the pair tho. I was like wow. Nice read but well there's that thing i can't accept

Two seemingly lost young Russians at the beginning of the Bolshevik era find themselves more or less indentured as servants at a large home, though one must utilize a wheelchair and the other has a serious medical condition. Both are each other’s lifeline, and they stay close to the home despite the hardships it brings them because they are looking for something very valuable from before the fall of Tsar Nicolas II. They endure terrible treatment, endentured servitude masquerading as work for The Party, and much more to achieve their goals.
Though it’s nice to focus on a Romanov story outside of Princess Anastasia, the pacing of this story marred the overall delivery. There beginning was methodical and set a slower development of scene and relationship between the two leads, but the second half became a sprint of information overload and reveals that hardly lets the absorption of information happen before another important fact is cresting and threatening to overwhelm. There's a three-year time jump that sets off a deluge of information and action. If that transition were a bit smoother, this story would have been better overall.
There is nudity and repeated sexual assault, so this title would be better for adult audiences if there is a need for more historical fiction stories.
Sara's Rating: 6/10
Suitability Level: Adult

Samura's art is lovely as always, I'm a big fan of the way he draws expressions. This story was very engaging and I love the historical setting. I eagerly look forward to the next volume of this series.

Snegurochka of the Spring Breeze is a poignant historical manga set in post-World War II Soviet Russia. Through restrained dialogue and atmospheric artwork, it explores the psychological aftermath of war, loneliness, and unlikely companionship. The narrative follows a former sniper and a mysterious young girl, unfolding slowly but powerfully against a stark, wintry backdrop.
The manga excels in subtle storytelling, emotional nuance, and a distinctive visual tone that mirrors its themes of isolation and memory. Though minimalistic in structure, it leaves a lasting emotional impact.

Thank you to Kodansha for the e-arc of this manga. Wow, this manga blew me away! Set in 1930s Russia, it follows two individuals, Bielka and Shchenok, who are bound together by a tight bond. They travel on a mission in Russia (but what mission, we aren’t aware of), encountering potential allies and foes. This was a very dark story, but a compelling read. Rich with historical background and a detailed art style, I felt transported to a Russian winter of the 20th century. I had no idea who to trust and was surprised by the slow reveals. I would recommend this to dark historical fiction lovers. Please check trigger warnings!
4.25 🌟

I vaguely understand the storyline, however you need to be knowledgeable about the setting of the story beforehand to understand when jumping in. I'm unsure if this was originally written in english or translated, but it felt a bit choppy at the beginning. It was an interesting read, but not one I felt too strongly about. Personally, I'd give it a 4/10

There are a lot of things wrong with this story. Especially the stuff related to certain threads... it was hard to read. I didn't have a TW, and I think that made me constantly fear what was going to happen after a certain moment. It's a shame that some situations were so graphic (either they're warned or they're made a little lighter and less graphic) because the story and plot are interesting and have some really cool twists.
(Although it says it's for people over 18, there's another issue that should have been mentioned.)
Thank you so much, Kodansha Comics, for the ARC I received through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing this advanced e-copy.
This... was not for me.
While I love me a good twist on the Anastasia Romanov storyline, this was too much. Too violent. Too twisted. We follow Bielka and Schenok in 1930s Russia. This provides a very sparse background for anyone not familiar with the different political parties in Russia during this time and it can be overwhelming with the info dump at the beginning, the nuances between ideologies. Bielka is wheel-chair bound and Schenok is her assistant, helping her move through the world. They are looking for some kind of artifact that is currently in a party member's possession. Secrets about both of these characters are revealed as the story moves, but it feels very detached. I didn't care for either of the characters. They were very one-dimensional.
Now, I could have gotten behind the twisted storyline if there hadn't been two things: Bielka (a double amputee) is raped by a party member. Repeatedly. As part of a torture tactic in the house she and Schenok are staying in. And then, when they return to this house as part of there artifact-seeking mission, she opens her arms to her rapist and hugs him. This... just doesn't make sense to me. She willingly returns and greets him like a long-last friend. It made my stomach roil and I cannot condone this.

Snegurochka of the Spring Breeze is super interesting, dark and nasty. Samura is very good at those. The story is set in the early 20th century after the revolution in Russia. The main characters are Bielka, a girl in a wheelchair, and Shchenok, the guy with just one eye, that helps her. They are on the run and the CCCP's agents are after the pair and the country is in turmoil. It takes time, but once we we get to know who these two are? It's awesome, really. Very well crafted, I have to say. As I live in Finland, the story hits close and the turmoil in modern Russia makes this manga even more poignant. Sadly so the manga is a standalone and I so wish this had been longer. The setting is delicious, but the beginning is too scattered and it takes time for the story to grow.
The art is good, it works nicely with the historical setting and the rape scenes were nasty, but so well done. This is not everyone's cup of tea, but then again, Samura isn't. The story would need more space and air, but otherwise it's great. Also, there's this weird notion about Bielka's period...

3.25/5
Thank you to Netgalley and Kodansha Comics for an arc. All opinions are my own.
The art in this manga is absolutely amazing. The hatching and shading creates a sense of depth in a way that almost reminds me of field journal sketches (in a good way).
The story I thought was interesting. I am not overly familiar with the real history that this is based off of, but it seems to be well researched and informational. Personally, I was a little put off by the sexual violence against a teenager, especially since the perpetrator is a character we are supposed to like by the end. I understand that this is something that is pretty common in historical fiction, but I didn’t love it.

The art in this manga is very striking and beautiful with detailed close ups and unique angles of view that help the darkness of the plot. The use of black and white really lends itself to this story set in Soviet Russia; balancing light and dark, innocence and violence, snow and rebirth. The characters are intriguing with a great final twist, that makes you want to learn more about this time in Russia's History.
Thanks to Netgalley and Kodansha for the eARC for my review

Thank you Netgalley for a copy of this story
I feel like reading the description I should have loved this but I think it fell a little short for me. I loved the historical aspect and I loved the twist of their true identity but I felt like this was lacking context. I think this need more context. while I have always been interested in the families the two main characters come from I don't know much else about what was happening in Russia at the time they were alive or dead so I think the context would have helped. I also was completely thrown off for the love for victor. I understand he helped them find what they were looking for but after being raped by a man for 3 years I don't think I would ever voluntarily embrace them

Thank you, NetGalley, Kodansha Comics, and Hiroaki Samura, for a copy of this comic in exchange for an honest review.
Final Verdict: 3.00/5.00
I'm honestly not sure what to think of this one. I've read it twice, trying to form an opinion on it. I chose to read it because I am quite fond of historical stories and seeing more recent authors' takes on the events; however, I couldn't bring myself to connect with this story and/or its characters. The first thing I wasn't a fan of was the art style. While this is personal preference, I did feel like I was fighting the flow of the panels or skimming over them, which made it harder to connect to the story. I also find that the story just throws you in with little context as to who anyone is or what's even going on. While I don't think that's bad storytelling per se, for those who aren't familiar with the historical events happening, a brief summary of what was going on during the time period would have been helpful before we're thrown into the rather brutal events. I was also confused about who the characters were and what was going on with them half the time. There were a few sexual assault scenes spliced throughout the book, and while they aren't graphic, they are still quite uncomfortable near the end of them because it seemed like the female character had come to start enjoying it. I don't claim to know the mental state of all assault victims, but this certainly began to feel less horrifying and more gratuitous, which didn't vibe well with me. For the historical parts, I don't know enough about the timeline of events to give an accurate review of it; however, from the little I know, it does seem quite accurate to the brutality of this period.
Overall, I don't know if I enjoyed the story, but I certainly didn't hate it.
Thank you again, NetGalley, Kodansha Comics, and Hiroaki Samura, for a copy of this comic in exchange for an honest review.

bielka, a young woman who uses a wheelchair, and her quiet companion shchenok must conceal their true identities as they travel through the tense political atmosphere and harsh terrain of soviet russia on a mission that is both deeply secret and personal.
filled with suspense and historical depth, this political drama blends well-known and notorious historical figures into the world of hiroaki samura's fiction.
i'm familiar with the history of the soviet union in the 1930s so i was excited to read a manga set in that era. i really appreciate the research the author put into creating this story.
i think the overall experience is better if you have some understanding of how the soviet era functioned - without it, diving into the story might be slightly confusing at times.
the story itself was quite intriguing. the main characters are looking for something, and they go to extreme lengths to achieve their goal. that said, some parts made me uncomfortable. (TW!) the rape scenes felt unnecessary, and the fact that that bielka forgave him was terrible. that part didn't sit right with me.
the ending also felt slightly rushed.
on the positive note the art style was gorgeous - very detailed and visually striking.
this story is definitely for a mature audience, as it contains heavy themes such as rape, murder, tortures and dismemberment. beware of those elements before reading.
if you're interested in russian history, this manga is worth a try.
*thanks to NetGalley, Kodansha Comics and the author for providing me with an ARC of this manga.*

First, thank you Netgalley, Hiroaki Samura, and Kodansha Comics for this e-arc in exchange for an honest review!
I will start off my saying the art was beautiful. I do really like the two main characters and thought the twist on their real identities was interesting.
However, you do need prior knowledge to the history this manga was inspired by, and I do not have that knowledge. It made it hard to follow and really understand what was happening and the importance of it all. Secondly, there was a very unnecessary rape scene, and it’s implied she was raped for the three years she spent living as a servant for this man. Only for him to have a redemption arc of sorts. And she forgave him instantly and rushed to hug him on their reunion. AND the man that was supposedly over protective of her did nothing to this man in the three years it happened nor did he hold a grudge. It seems the author does not take rape as serious a subject as it is, and if you’re going to give your character a weak redemption, perhaps don’t make him so cruel earlier on.

Thank you to netGalley and Kondasha for the eARC.
Snegurochka was a manga I had a hard time following, but the art was gorgeous and the pacing quite unrelenting. It was sharp and poignant, but very unforgiving if you have no context for the situation.

Snegurochka of the Spring Breeze by Hiroaki Samura I was so excited to read. I love historical dramas, so I felt this was right up my alley. However, I would say you need some historical knowledge prior to reading this manga, so you don't get lost. It gets complicated and political without giving much historical context, making it easy for a reader to get lost. I feel like the character's background should have been explained a little bit better, given more context, or even made the story a bit longer. I found myself not caring much for them, even though they are shown suffering or making big sacrifices. lastly theres the rape scene, I'm used to reading a lot of "tragic" and "traumatic" books and manga, in some cases it adds context or depth to a character or story line. Still, in this case, it was completely unnecessary, especially when the manga decided to give a whole unnecessary redemption arc. We as the reader are suppost just to forgive and forgett because the victim is now fond of her rapist, and the man who swore to be by her side to thick and thin also had no problem with that at the end, is very unrealistic and poorly done. would not recommend.