Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A beautifully written, well researched novel. The authors note at the end is a must listen. The story explores the anti-Chinese movement in Portland in the late 1800’s. I love historical fiction and this one was fantastic. I had no idea about this piece of history and loved learning about it. The story followed Celia in two timelines and my heart broke for her in all scenarios. Every character was purposeful and had depth. The dual timeline was easy to follow. This was a heartbreaking story with many topics that were explored such as racism, motherhood, deception, and survival.

Was this review helpful?

I love historical fiction because it gives me a glimpse into important events through compelling character POVs. The Girls of Good Fortune started off strong in that vein, opening my eyes to racial and class inequities in deeper ways through Celia’s unique struggles. Unfortunately for me, the last 1/2 or so was nonstop action, which I I found far-fetched in a way that can take away from the message. There are many people who prefer thrilling fast-paced action even so, and I hope they love this book. I am glad I read it for what I learned.

3 stars for the story plus 1 for Cindy Kay who is becoming a favorite narrator of mine. Her voice is very emotional and she was able to balance Celia’s early naivety with her eventual strength well.

Was this review helpful?

This historical fiction follows Cecilia, a Chinese American who passes as white,in 1880s Oregon, where tensions and hate towards Chinese Americans are high. This story, told in a flashback timeline paints a picture of the events that led up to Cecilia being "shanghaied" one night. Following her story from, maid, to lover, to brothel worker, to political advocate, and to prisoner is one heck of a historical journey. Cindy Kay, the narrator, does a fine job bringing this story to life, and I enjoyed the listener experience with her fine articulation and different inflections. It was easy to visualize this story.

Was this review helpful?

What an incredibly well written and researched book. It explores a topic that I have read (and learned!) very little about - the anti-chinese movement that took place in Portland in the late 1800s. The story is told from Cecilia's perspective, a few years apart. Both stories are heartbreaking and wonderful. The two timelines are clear and well written - no confusion as to which time it was. Cecilia was a maid in the mayor's house until she was impregnated by their son. She is then a half Chinese woman raising her child on her own. When she finds herself in the Shanghai tunnels, she fears that she will become forced labor. She must do her best to escape to save her child. A wonderfully written story about a difficult time. The story is emotional and it was easy to feel for Cecilia and the tragedy that she faces. If you are a fan of historical fiction, this is a fascinating and heartbreak topic that everyone should read about.
Thank you netgalley for my advanced reader copies.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Sourcebooks Landmark, RB Media, and Netgalley for the ARC!

Did someone cut onions while I read this book?

When this book started, I was pretty sure I knew where it was headed. I thought it would be the same old story, girl falls in love with rich boy, he lies, her life is ruined. But NOPE! It was so much more.

This was a book about learning to check one's biases, about the pain and racism that Asian immigrants had to deal with as a result of American xenophobia, the strength of sisterhood and friends, and the beauty of motherhood. Celia had to learn how strong she is when forced not just to deal with the dangers of being an unwed mother but also part Chinese. Her life was filled with challenges, dangers, and joys, and I loved how McMorris wove this story. I really recommend this book, especially after COVID and the hatred that Asian communities have continued to face.

Was this review helpful?

As a fan of historical fiction, this book was right up my alley. I would consider this a heavy read and would advise readers to check TWs before diving in. Overall, it's a riveting story full of heart-break and hope.

Was this review helpful?

This was a good book with a different perspective on historical fiction but definitely offers an unusual story line. Celia works as a maid for the mayor in Portland, but has plans for a much better life for herself. She is in love with the mayor's son, Stephen, and he plans to marry her when he comes back from earning his medical degree. Shortly after he sets sail however, she discovers she is pregnant with Stephen's baby. Celia implores the mayor & his wife to contact Stephen to let him know, but instead, they terminate her employment and send her to a brothel to work as a maid. Celia - being half-Chinese, passing as white during an era fraught with anti-Chinese sentiment - discovers that her father is killed in a goldminers massacre, and vows to get revenge. However, in the process of trying to obtain information, Celia gets "shanghaied" . She awakens in an underground cell, drugged and disguised, in the subterranean labyrinth of the notorious Shanghai Tunnels. Celia realizes she is on the verge of being shipped off as forced labor, leaving behind those she loves most. Desperate, she must find a way to escape and return to a place where unearthed secrets can prove deadlier than the dark recesses of Chinatown. Definitely would recommend as there is a lot to this story and it was well written. Thank you to NetGalley, the author and Sourcebook/Landmark.

Was this review helpful?

I’m floundering between 3- 4 🌟 for this title in all honesty. I’ve opted for 3 purely because it felt like 2 separate books and I struggled to get to grips with part 2.

I love when you can learn through fiction, and the author has clearly researched the time very well, I definitely learned some Chinese American history that I was unaware of. There is a trigger warning at the outset for racism and language of the times. I’ve never heard some of these words, I hope not to hear them again.

Our protagonist Celia is of mixed heritage, half Chinese and white passing, being white passing allows her to gain employment and move through life a little more freely in a time that was dangerous for Chinese Americans. While the story becomes an action packed adventure in the second half, the sentiment of knowing your lineage and having pride in your heritage shines through.

I struggled a little bit with the narration, it was a little monotone, and may have impacted my rating, but I’d happily read from the author again.

Many thanks to RB Media and NetGalley for the opportunity to review this audiobook which is available now.

Was this review helpful?

The Girls of Good Fortune follows the story of Cecelia, a half Chinese woman, in late 1800s Oregon. She is a housekeeper for the mayor of her city and, because she passes for white, only the fact the family's tween daughter saw a letter from her father outed her as Chinese. This is a seemingly progressive family who allow her to stay on. Cecelia falls in love with the wrong man and this is reciprocated. However, the relationship has challenges. The novel opens with her imprisoned somewhere and then travels on various timelines that leave us constantly wondering when she was kidnapped or jailed and why. However, her bad fortune preceded this predicament when there was a falling out with the family she worked for. She is left on her own with some serious challenges ahead.

Central to this story is the fact that Chinese laborers were being massacred at mines all over the west/northwest by angry white minors who saw them as taking jobs from white men, partly by "accepting" lower wages. Cecelia becomes interested in these horrible, near daily reports of such murderous conduct and pursues this. Over the course of this novel, she is a bit of a "Perils of Pauline" character as she falls into dangers that she must overcome. This definitely could have been a serial movie of the silent film era or an early talkie. Ultimately, Cecelia navigates through the challenges with the help of others who are similarly challenged. People die. People live. People are prostitutes. People are small town cops. People are ship captains. People are evil. People seem evil. People are redeemed. People are forever cast into hellfire. But overall, it's a story of adversity and resilience, as the publisher notes and a very fun read. The epilogue gives us a modern day review of what happened to the characters we rooted for. All a good romp.

Was this review helpful?

The Girls of Good Fortune is an intriguing Historical Novel about a half Chinese and half Caucasian woman living in 1800s Portland. This is a very well written and well researched novel that explores themes of racism and xenophobia in late 1800s America as well as broader themes of class and motherhood. This novel also has a very engaging plot with interesting characters. This is just a really solid piece of historical fiction that does a fantastic job at bringing to life the late 1800s Portland in a way that felt very realistic but also captured the unique aspects of the setting and time period. My only major complaint was that I wish the novel was a little longer so that the storylines of some of the side characters could be tied up a little better, but when my biggest complaint is that I did not want the novel to end you know it is a great novel!

Thank you to NetGalley and Recorded Books for an ARC Audiobook of the novel in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this audiobook just as much as I loved the book! A great historical fiction that I hope more people read!

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars
The first half of The Girls of Good Fortune was engaging, with an appealing setup and characters that seemed poised for depth. Unfortunately, the second half veered into implausibility, undermined by a series of increasingly irrational decisions by the protagonist. What began as a promising story unraveled into a string of far-fetched misadventures that felt disconnected from the tone and structure of the beginning. Ultimately, the novel lacked the cohesion and restraint needed to deliver on its early potential.

Was this review helpful?

Celia is an amazing character! I admire how she remains optimistic, never breaking and never giving up in creating her own fortune. And boy does she experience everything! After being sent away due to falling in love with Steven (the Mayor's son) and getting pregnant, Celia finds a way to make a home for her and her daughter in the Dewdrop Inn, along with friends that help when the going gets tough. And boy does that happen, especially when she searches for justice in the Chinese miners massacre (which also happened to her father). Her sense of right and wrong, and fight to help those seen as lesser is very admirable, even if some of the short sighted choices and her fiery temper leads to the cell and even more craziness (like jumping ship, hopping trains, and ending in a jail cell) though also people who are willing to help and her quick wits do create a bit a fortune out of all the misfortune she experiences. Celia never loses her hope despite all that and I am happy that the ending was well deserved and is a bright spot after all the darkness, leading to later changes and future generations receiving the rights that Celia worked so hard to get started.

The author did a good job with the research of this time and it really shows in the story. And I enjoyed the recipes at the end for some of the baked goods Celia made at the Dewdrop. It was a nice touch making things feel even more real. The narrator also did a wonderful job in bringing Celia to life and all the adventures she went through amid the prejudice and violence of that time.

Was this review helpful?

This story was not what I thought it was going to be but it was still really interesting. It is told in two timelines. 1888 when Celia is taken and needs to escape. 1885 when she was a maid and what happens after. Do not want to spoil anything. This was a somewhat heavy book with some heartbreaking themes. I will say Celia was a very strong and brave character during this time and I really wanted to see her thrive. The writing and details of this book were suburb and made me not want to stop listening. I need to go back and listen to this author`s other works.

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to NetGalley, Sourcebooks Landmark and RB Media for gifting me both a digital and audio ARC of this historical fiction novel by Kristina McMorris, with the audiobook wonderfully narrated by Cindy Kay. All opinions expressed in this review are my own - 4.5 stars!

It's Portland, 1888, when a woman awakens in an underground cell, drugged and disguised. Celia soon realizes she's a "shanghaied" victim on the verge of being shipped off as forced labor. In an era fraught with anti-Chinese sentiment, being half-Chinese she is used to adapting for survival. She must find a way to escape.

This was a historical time period in Portland that I have never heard about. As always with McMorris's books, it is meticulously researched and you can definitely feel like you are in another world. As Celia awakes, she goes back in time to 1885, remembering how she got where she is, determined to fight for her life. I had to pay close attention to the year so as not to be confused, but once it was all set in the same time period, it flowed easier for me. It's a beautiful reminder of how important stories are to be passed through the generations, as well as a story of hope and human resilience in the face of evil. The narration was wonderful and added to the atmospheric feel of this book.

Was this review helpful?

The Girls of Good Fortune by Kristina McMorris is a brilliantly crafted historical novel that immerses readers in the shadowy depths of Portland's Shanghai Tunnels in 1888. Celia’s story is one of resilience, ingenuity, and the silent strength of those who navigated a world rife with prejudice and danger. McMorris masterfully brings to life the gritty atmosphere of the era, painting a compelling picture of a woman caught between two worlds—her Chinese heritage and her attempts to pass as white to survive. As Celia awakens in her underground prison, the narrative swiftly pulls you into her desperate fight to escape her captors and uncover the truth behind her kidnapping. The novel delves into dark themes like forced labor, secretive political plots, and the plight of women in peril, all woven seamlessly into a suspenseful and emotionally charged story. What sets this book apart is McMorris’s meticulous research and vivid storytelling, which breathe authenticity into every scene. The twists and revelations keep the pages turning, leaving you eager to see if Celia can outsmart those hunting her and protect an innocent child caught in the chaos. The Girls of Good Fortune is a powerful testament to the enduring human spirit amidst darkness, and a must-read for fans of historical fiction that combines mystery, social commentary, and heartfelt bravery.

Was this review helpful?