Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Ginny and the gang are back and find themselves accidentally involved in solving another murder mystery. What’s not to love above this series? Full of warmth with loveable characters and lots of humour about village life this time the mystery took the gang to a neighbouring village and a bitter village rivalry that goes back generations. Part of the charm of this series is the village of Little Shaw and all the quirks that come from living in a tiny community so while it was interesting to contrast the 2 communities I did miss the charm of Little Shaw while the widows were getting doors slammed in their faces by their snobby neighbours so I hope that future books in this series see them staying closer to home. This is a wonderful series, perfect for fans of cosy mysteries and a fun enjoyable read and I can’t wait for the next instalment!

Was this review helpful?

This is a tale of two towns. The friendly little village and the adjacent wealthy town. A wedding including both towns is about to begin when it is disrupted by a dog with a skull. The bride calls off the wedding, both towns blame each other, and Ginny and friends are involved in another mystery. I loved the first two books in this series, but spent most of my time being confused. Although I normally don’t like them, a cast of characters would have been helpful. Although this wasn’t my favorite, I look forward to another book in this series. #netgalley

Was this review helpful?

The Widow's Guide to Skulduggery by Amanda Ashby

This is book three in the Widows' Detective Club Series.

Ginny, Edger and her friends are back with a new mystery to solve. This time, it involves Romeo and Juliet-style warring families, rival villages, vintage maps, and the threat of a curse.

DI Wallace is away on holiday, so there's less of his stern-but-affectionate character in this book; there's also less of Edger, and I missed them both, but I did enjoy the strong (older) female leads. Like the rest of the series, it features all my favourite cosy mystery tropes, including library shenanigans, busybodies, arts and crafts, and a mischievous cat.

If you like The Thursday Murder Club, The Marlow Murder Club or The Paradise Heights Craft Store Stitch-Up, or cosy mysteries in general, then I think you'll enjoy the Widows' Guide series.

Body Count = 2 Thumbs up. Thank you to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for this ARC in exchange for my review.

#NetGalley #StormPublishing @stormbooks_co @netgalley @authoramandaashby

#BoWidows'am #booksdeevaareads #2025bookshelf #deevaasbookshelf #goreadabook #allthebooks #booknerd #Designer #GraphicDesign #DesignNerd #designdeevaa #CreativeLife #DesignInspiration #ArtAndDesign #Designer #DesignNerd #murdermystery

Was this review helpful?

The third installment in the “Widow’s Guide” series will entertain readers just like the two previous books! A beloved cast of characters returns to solve two mysteries that become intertwined, one from the past and one from the present. This book is a quick, fun read and I can’t wait for another!

Was this review helpful?

Mystery, intrigue, rivalry.

A super fun premise, an interrupted wedding, a 20 year old skull and village rivalry. Ginny Cole one of the guests, enlists her friends in the Widow’s Detective Club to solve the case. Loads of personality, loads of great characters, fun twists and vivid painting of English villages.

A really solid 3.5 star read (rounded up to 4), due to the at times clunky writing and my personal frustrations at the deep stereotyping.

I haven’t read the first two books of the series, but it didn’t impact in the least my reading of the third.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher Storm Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The characters are well-crafted and lovable, especially Ginny's mischievous cat, who steals the show with his charming personality. We learn more about Colin’s family as his sister Grace’s wedding is interrupted by the discovery of a human skull!

The quirky characters and sense of community in Little Shaw add to the novel's charm.

The mystery is well-plotted, with plenty of twists to keep readers engaged until the very end. I enjoyed guessing and second-guessing the outcome, and I managed to piece together the clues before Ginny did.

Overall, this book is a must-read for fans of cozy mysteries and heartwarming fiction. Amanda Ashby's writing is engaging, and her characters are lovable and well-crafted. I highly recommend this charming novel and look forward to the next instalment in the series.

I requested and received an advance readers copy from NetGalley and the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I liked this one, but it didn’t quite hit the same way the first two did. There were just so many characters, and it got a little hard to keep up, which made it tough to really stay connected to the story. That said, it still had the fun banter and light humor I love about this series, so it wasn’t a total miss. It just felt like it was missing a little of the magic the earlier books had. Still enjoyable, just not my favorite of the bunch. 2.5 stars.

Thank you Netgalley and Storm Publishing for this arc!

Was this review helpful?

This book was chock full of happenings. A skull is discovered, a wedding is stopped, there's a jealous exm rival villages, deep secrets and no DI Wallace and Ginny and gang have to navigate all this to solve an old and new muder to bring the two young lovebirds back together and married.

Lots of twists and turns and deadends made this an interesting read.

#netgalley #TheWidowsGuidetoSkulduggery

Was this review helpful?

This third installment in the Widow’s Guide to Murder series is just as fun as the first two. Ginny, Hen, Tuppence and JM are back for another hilarious mystery that they have no business solving but still solve anyway. So fun!

Thanks NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

The Widows’ Guide to Skulduggery, the third novel in The Widows’ Detective Club series, is a wonderfully delightful cozy mystery. Ginny and her friends do have a bad habit of stumbling into murder scenes. Even a wedding isn’t safe when Colin, the dog meant to carry the rings, drops a skull at the bride’s feet. This is a great read. I love the storyline and the quirky characters. I look forward to the next book in this series. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

The Widows' Guide to Skulduggery: An unputdownable cozy crime novel is book #3 in The Widows' Detective Club series by Amanda Ashby.

This book is a great addition to the series. Ginny is attending a wedding that is interrupted in a most unusual way. Did the dog find his “treasure” by accident or was it planted in an attempt to stop the wedding? This was an interesting mystery for the widows to investigate. As much as I enjoy the mystery, my favorite part of this series is the characters. They are well written and entertaining. I look forward to more of this series!

Thank you to the author, Storm Publishing, and NetGalley for the Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) copy of this book and I am voluntarily leaving an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The groom’s family does not want the wedding to go through. So when the dog they insisted partake in the ceremony deposits a skull at the feet of the bride, the wedding is off. Who could stoop to such a low to stop the marriage? The skull is bad enough on its own but when it is discovered to be the skull of a woman who was murdered by her husband twenty years ago, there are more questions than just who was responsible for a cruel trick. For instance, where has the skull been all this time and did the possessor of the skull have something to do with her death. Things are complicated by the animosity between the posh town from which the groom hails and the somewhat down market town where the bride, Ginny and Ginny’s friends live.

The feud is ages old. There is such disdain for the neighbouring town that when Ginny and her cohorts decide to solve the mystery of the skull, they are stymied everywhere they turn. But these ladies are clever and determined and they discover there are more things afoot in the present than just the discovery of the skull and the disruption of the wedding. Dark things. And as they inch closer to solving the mystery, those who most want it hidden resort to extreme measures that could mean more death.

Those who dismiss the four friends do so at their jeopardy. They are smart and spunky and each brings different skills to the table. They figure out the answers and in the process bring rapprochement to the warring towns. Five purrs and two paws up.

Was this review helpful?

I was,drawn into this book from page one.
With vivid characters, humour, and layers of deceit, this is really engrossing tale.
I enjoyed reading it immensely.

Was this review helpful?

Ginny is attending the wedding of Colin's sister, Grace, in the next town over. It's a staunch and uncomfortable affair with tensions brewing up until the nuptials, as both towns believe in a curse that affects anyone who crosses the town borders. It only gets worse when a skull shows up, and brings the entire event to a disastrous halt.

*****

We're back in Little Shaw again for the third book in this cozy detective series. Just like with the others, we get the brigade of Ginny and her widow friends together to solve a local murder, with the usual ample quirks worked in.

I loved that this was a different setup than the other two, with the initial case already being closed, the ladies needing to infiltrate a new town, and Wallace being away on vacation. They were all able to move freely, not be told off by police, and also had new challenges and opportunities outside of their home town gossip. It made for a cozy mystery that still had the same vibes as the first two novels, but didn't feel repetitive, with so many new characters and scenes worked in.

I loved seeing Ginny grow outside of her grief, as well as the characters from previous novels brought back in in new and developing roles. Overall this was the perfect cozy mystery with a comical ending in the nick of time, and was exactly what I look forward to in this series.

*****

Thank you to Storm Publishing for the digital ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I am loving this series and another visit to Little Shaw was another exciting installment, Ginny Cole is attending a friend’s wedding when the dog, who was ring bearer, after running and digging in the church yard dropped a skull at the bride’s feet, well this stopped the wedding and Ginny is again with her friends from the Widows’ Detective club using their sleuthing skills to get the answers.

The two families involved in the wedding do not get along as one of them comes from the next village and there has been some sort of feud between the two villages for way too long to remember but when the skull turns out to belong to a woman murdered twenty years ago and that case was never investigated correctly as far as Ginny, Tuppence, MJ and Hen are concerned they are going to make sure that they do especially when the bride’s notorious family has asked them to do so.

What they uncover was a terrible plot but when another body is discovered and this one is one of the peopled Ginny and team had been talking to the plot thickens and with DI Wallace away on holidays and DI Sterling in charge of the investigation The Widows’ Detective Club are not happy and determined to get answers.

This is a fabulous installment in the series one that I highly recommend Ginny and the ladies are so easy to like and they leave no stone unturned in their hunt for answers and I am thrilled that there will be more in the series. I loved this one witty fun and a fabulous cosy mystery.

My thanks to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for my copy to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun follow-up to the other Widow's Guide books. Perfect for a cozy mystery section. The characters are real and well-rounded and the storyline is complicated enough that this requires a little focus, but it doesn't have the creep factor that thrillers have, which is great for readers who like the puzzle aspect of murder but not the gore.
This series is an auto-buy for my store now!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Amanda Ashby for providing me with a complimentary digital ARC for The Widow's Guide to Skulduggery coming out June 30, 2025. The honest opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Somehow, I missed the second book in the series. I really enjoyed the first book so I was excited to receive this. I really love murder mystery books. I think the characters are really fun. I would definitely read more books in this series.

Was this review helpful?

I’m so happy to be back in Amanda Ashby’s cozy mystery series—this is book 3, and it’s just as delightful as the first two! The atmosphere is charming, the mystery is engaging, and the characters are truly the cherry on top. Especially Ginny, the main character—returning to her and her quirky group of friends feels like getting a warm hug from an old friend.

What makes this series shine is the cast: well-developed, funny, and full of personality. The murder mystery is just the right level of tricky—not too easy, not too complex—and the cozy setting makes it all the more enjoyable. While each book has a standalone mystery, I’d definitely recommend starting with book 1 to really get to know the characters and their relationships.

If you’re looking for something fun, heartwarming, a little dramatic, and full of cozy crime-solving, this series is a gem. Highly recommend the whole series!

Was this review helpful?

A fun, magical cozy with a biting edge. I loved the clever writing, strong female leads, and mix of dark humor and witchy charm. It’s cozy, and perfect for fans of practical magic with a twist.

Was this review helpful?

This is the third book in the series, but I had no trouble jumping right in. After finishing this book, I’m eager to go back and read the first two. The story pulled me in blending mystery, charm, and small-town drama in just the right way.

A wedding is abruptly halted by the discovery of an old skull, reopening a long-cold case and setting off a wave of gossip. As the mystery deepens, a new murder adds fresh complications. Rivalries between neighboring towns (reminded me of Parks and Rec’s Pawnee vs. Eagleton) add fun tension, while a group of determined widows-turned-sleuths brings warmth and wit to the investigation.

One plot point that gave me pause was the abrupt decision by Grace and Theo to call off their engagement. While the town gossip about a supposed “curse” added intrigue, the sudden dissolution of their relationship felt a bit underdeveloped. I found myself wishing for more context or emotional buildup to that moment.

Also, while the mystery kept me engaged, the ending arrived too quickly and didn’t feel fully earned. The resolution came with minimal groundwork, and I was left wishing for a bit more development before the final reveal.

Still, the character dynamics, especially among Ginny, JM, Hen, and Tuppence, were strong and engaging. Despite coming in mid-series, I had no trouble getting to know Ginny and her group of detective friends. The writing does a great job of weaving in enough backstory for new readers while keeping the pace brisk and engaging for returning fans.

The mystery, peppered with moments of humor and heartfelt reflection, makes this a satisfying read.

Was this review helpful?