Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A laugh out loud rom com about a newly divorced 29-year-old who creates a list of all the things she missed out on as a young bride, including a one-night stand. But when he turns up in her life again she has to make some difficult choices. This is Brunnbauer's debut novel and what a hoot - I am still laughing out loud about the blob (blob blob blob). This book had all the feels making me sad, angry, happy and giggly! Look forward to seeing my version of Beau (Liam Hemsworth) onscreen soon.
Thanks to Netgalley and HarperCollins Australia for the opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

This was a funny and sweet read in parts, but overall, it didn’t land for me the way I’d hoped. The story had potential, but I struggled with the FMC’s character—she came across as messy and selfish, often treating the people around her, especially Beau, poorly.

Beau felt like the more mature, grounded one in the relationship, and I couldn’t understand why he kept getting strung along. The FMC’s hot-and-cold behavior—pushing him away for reasons that didn’t feel emotionally convincing (like her ex’ and a car??)—just made the romance frustrating instead of swoony. The constant back-and-forth got confusing and, honestly, exhausting to read.

That said, the supporting cast really shined. They brought most of the humor and heart to the story and were the main reason I stuck with it. I just wish the main relationship had the same charm and emotional payoff.

Was this review helpful?

What Did I Miss?
by Holly Brunnbauer
⭐️ 4/5
🌶️ 3/5

I received an eARC of this book via NetGalley. Thank you to Holly Brunnbauer, HarperCollins Australia, and NetGalley.

What Did I Miss? is a heartwarming story about love and grief.
Makayla and Beau are high school teachers who hook up before realising they’ll be working together.
I loved the build of their relationship. The background characters were well written too.
Oftentimes when a breakup is inspired by poor communication that’s a negative for me. However I empathise with Makayla and what she had been through, and how not dealing with it kind of messed her up.

I kind of wish I’d read content warnings about this book before diving into it, though. SPOILER: The miscarriage content snuck up on me – though I suspected it early on – and it was well-written but definitely tugged at my heartstrings.

Was this review helpful?

I went into this book really hoping to connect with the story, but unfortunately, it just didn’t work for me and by the end, I was left wondering why I didn’t just DNF it when I had the chance. But of course, I powered through… because apparently I like to torture myself.

One of my biggest struggles was with the FMC. Her decisions and the way she treated the people around her felt incredibly selfish, especially in her relationships. I found it hard to relate to her or even root for her at times. Yes, she did eventually acknowledge her flaws and start to work on them — and I can absolutely respect that — but for most of the book, I felt disconnected from her growth and emotional journey.

The writing style itself didn’t help either. There were moments that felt off or strangely handled, and I just couldn’t fully immerse myself in the story. It often felt like the tone didn’t match the emotional weight of what was happening.

And I have to be honest, I was completely caught off guard by the inclusion of a miscarriage as a central emotional plotline, especially since there were no trigger warnings at all. That’s a deeply sensitive and personal topic, and the way it was introduced with no heads-up felt careless and jarring. I understand the importance of portraying difficult experiences in fiction, but it deserves to be done with care — and with a warning, so readers can choose how and when they engage with it.

Overall, I really wish I could say I liked this more. I could see what the story wanted to be, and I think some readers may still connect with it but for me, it just missed the mark on too many levels.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book so much! Any book that uses a reference like 'in a tizz' correctly has my attention!
There wasn't a character in the book that I didn't want to get to know better, even the side characters were described so perfectly that I could envision them as I was reading and I felt like I knew them.

I can't wait to see more from Holly Brunnbauer I love her writing and will be pre ordering her next book!

Thanks to NetGalley and Harper Collins for the early access.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a delight and very impressive for a debut novel.
It ticks all the boxes, emotional, heartwarming, funny, family, and a little bit sexy.
One of my favourites in recent months, it was so enjoyable.
I look forward to reading more from Holly Brunnbauer and will be recommending this one to everyone.

Was this review helpful?

"She's the poster child for resting bitch face" 😂

This book had so many laugh out loud moments for me!! It was witty, funny, heartwarming, sexy & relatable.

I was hooked from page 1 when Makaylas story starts with a bang! (pun intended 😉) & I loved how we were introduced to Beau. What a FUN premise which set the book up so well.

The secondary characters were such awesome additions, shoutout to Agnes, I feel like we all know an Agnes 🙈 & don't even get me started on Waz! ✋🏼

The book also tackles some deeper themes & I love how Holly navigated them. Sometimes the hardest person to be truthful with is yourself! I loved seeing Makaylas character growth throughout the story.

A new book boyfriend has been added to the list, Beau...the man that you are. The romance, the chemistry, the tension, the emotions. So good!!

This book has me wanting to write a no regrets list & join a car club. What a gorgeously funny rom-com. This is going on my list equally to the likes of Funny Story & First Time Caller!

4.5 STARS ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨

Was this review helpful?

Holly Brunnbauer’s What Did I Miss is a debut novel that’s both hilarious yet emotionally weighty. A rom-com that’s not just romantic, but genuinely comedic. ✨

From the first few pages, I was sold on Makayla’s voice. She’s 29, freshly divorced from the only boyfriend she’s ever had, and hurtling into rediscovery mode by listing everything she “missed” while in a long-term relationship. The story is told with such crisp, self-deprecating wit that I laughed out loud (like, actual cackles) multiple times. Makayla is sassy, a little chaotic, sometimes hard (but soft underneath), funny on purpose, and occasionally on accident, and I enjoyed being in her head. ☺️

Then, there’s Beau, our MMC. Refreshingly, a good guy. Not a tortured soul or an aloof billionaire or any of the usual cardboard cutouts we’re taught to swoon over. He’s warm, reliable, a little bit of a simp (in the best way), but also sets boundaries. He’s clear about what he wants and doesn’t let Makayla bulldoze him emotionally (even when she tries). 💕

The writing is fast-paced, clever, and full of texture. I can’t believe this is a debut; it reads with the confidence of someone who’s been doing this for years. By the end, I could see the final scene like a rom-com on the big screen. Funny, heartfelt, satisfying. The kind of story you want to watch with popcorn and a glass of wine. 🍷

I feel lucky to have read an e-ARC via NetGalley (thank you HarperCollins Australia!) but I loved it so much, I bought the physical copy too! This book is smart, funny, and full of heart. For rom-com lovers out there, this is one you surely shouldn’t miss. 😘

Awesome job, Holly! Congratulations! 🙌🏼

Was this review helpful?

Not gonna lie, romances don’t really scratch my reading itch. BUT Something about It’s Been a Pleasure, Noni Blake by Claire Christian struck a chord with me a few years ago and I haven’t felt it with similar books since… until now! Enter What Did I Miss? by Holly Brunnbauer. A debut no less, it’s fun, a little bit spicy and ultimately a big embrace of a story about facing your fears, your past and living your best life. While still a fab book in its own right, it also filled the Noni Blake void for me, big time.

Newly divorced high school teacher Makayla is facing turning 30 and makes a ‘No Regrets List’ to catch up on all the things she missed out on because she married young. A one night stand turns up again in the unlikeliest of places and interferes with her revenge on her ex - let a rollicking romp of a story ensue!

Loveable characters, will they won’t they moments and snappy dialogue had me hooked and sniggering til the very end. Look no further if your brain needs a break from the world

Was this review helpful?

An easy to get into, fun read from a debut Aussie author.

Makayla is coming up to 30 and finds herself divorced from her teenage sweetheart, in a job she believes strongly in but is jaded with.  As is the case when many great decisions are made, we begin with Makayla and her best friend making a list from which Makayla sets off to tick a few life boxes.

There is something about Aussie humour. Normally when I read a romcom I wonder if my sense of humour is broken but, HURRAH, Holly's style of dry observational humour and  one liners was spot on.

Makalya is definitely her own biggest hurdle. Yet her character shows growth and depth over the course of the book. Her aunt is a character I'm happy to love to dislike. That particular extrinsic motivator had me scratching my head.
Beau is a sweetie. I would have loved more of him but his stoic gentleness was the ideal counter to Makayla's prickliness. Warren deserves a little slack, his emotional capacity was in the range of a teaspoon but again, we saw him growing up too. 

As a "reformed" teacher I recognised so much of the school politics, teacher-teacher and teacher-student dynamics. Sadly I could picture Agnes (who is a low-key showstopper) and the  Whiny Bunch from many a staffroom.

Be warned, it's not all cracking jokes, spicy bits and falling in love. There is sensitive story of infant loss and grief and of growing up, or growing into your maturity in a way life often forces upon you. I appreciated the open ended nature of the story. There must have been a temptation to offer an epilogue but, I'm so glad that we, the reader, get to imagine a future for our couple. Whatever that might look like.

With enormous thanks to the author, Holly Brunnbauer, Harper Collins Publishers Australia and Netgalley for the opportunity to to read What Did I Miss? ahead of publication. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

What Did I Miss? is the debut rom-com from Holly Brunnbauer, out July 2nd.

Newly divorced and staring down the barrel of thirty, Makayla’s determined to reclaim the wild twenties she never had. Armed with a no-regrets to-do list and a few questionable decisions, she’s ready to make up for lost time—until a one-night stand reappears and revenge on her ex gets a little out of hand.

The premise drew me in, and from chapter one, this rom-com delivers a distinctive voice. With Makayla working as a teacher, the school setting and staffroom antics added charm to the story. It’s a setting ripe for comedy, and Brunnbauer leans in with energy.

The novel also touches on deeper emotional themes—divorce, grief and growth. At times, the emotional logic didn’t quite land for me. I would have loved more space to sit with Makayla and Beau early on, to better understand what pulled them together and feel their connection build. Beau’s backstory, too, felt a little under-explored.

Still, there’s a fun supporting cast here, including little Piper the French bulldog and the vintage car Gertie, who practically becomes a character in her own right.

Readers looking for a light-hearted, list-ticking journey of personal rediscovery may enjoy the blend of chaos, comedy, and heartfelt moments.

Thanks to Netgalley and HarperCollins Publishers Australia for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Makayla is newly divorced, nearly 30, and ready to reclaim the years she lost to a marriage that began when she was just 18. Armed with a bucket list of all the things that she missed out on, she kicks things off with a daring one-night stand. To her horror, she discovers that the man is, in fact, Beau, the new graduate teacher at her school. Determined to embrace her newfound independence, Makayla tries to keep her distance. But Beau keeps reappearing, challenging her carefully laid plans and reminding her of everything she didn’t know she was missing.
Makayla is a wonderfully flawed, endearing character whose inner voice is as loud as her missteps are frequent. I laughed out loud at her chaotic adventures and admired her willingness to put herself out there, even when things went spectacularly wrong. This is an entertaining, warm, and refreshingly honest story about second chances, self-discovery, and the unexpected ways love finds us.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A fabulously fun debut that starts with a bang. Makayla is a 29-year-old divorcee who starts a bucket list to catch up on all the things she missed out after marrying at 18. The first item? A one night stand with the rules 'no names, no repeats'. To her horror, she discovers that his name is Beau and he's the new graduate teacher at her school.

Holly Brunnbauer writes such an engaging and fun journey as Makayla battles to keep the steady and lovely Beau at arm's length so not only can she inherit her nan's classic car from her aunt , but also to protect her heart. Makayla was frustrating at times with her inability to stand up to her aunt and ex-mother in law, but you could understand why she was allover the place. I loved all the high school hijinx, from the staff room factions to the students - they all felt real and I like I was part of the school community. If I had any quibbles I think it just needed a bit more of Beau's backstory. We're just told about it, but don't really see any impact on his own psyche.

A delightful gem that was full of heart. I devoured this book in one sitting. I can't wait to read more from Holly Brunnbauer.

Thanks to Harper Collins Australia and NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I read What Did I Miss? in a couple of days. It was an engaging and entertaining story.
The main character is Makayla, who is fast approaching her 30th birthday and aims to tick off a list of things she never got to experience in her younger years due to marrying her high school sweetheart and being with him for a long time.
Now, divorced and hoping to experience some new things, she starts off by having a one night stand. However, when he shows up for the new teaching position at the school she works at, she is shocked as she was hoping to never have to see him again.
But she can only go so long avoiding Beau, and they form a friendship, which soon leads to more.
I enjoyed Beau’s character and also Cece, Makayla’s best friend.
Makayla was a determined woman, and although I didn’t quite like her character initially, she definitely won me over by the end of the story.
The secondary characters were all mostly great, including Makayla’s aunt, Māori coworker and her ex.
Just a trigger warning: the book covered the topic of pregnancy loss (in a sensitive way).
I’d rate this debut novel a sold 3 1/2 stars and look forward to reading more from Holly Brunnbauer in the future.

Was this review helpful?

High school teacher has a one night stand with Beau, next thing you know he’s a new teacher at the school she works at. All the while she’s working on her to do list, while dealing with her former mother-in-law not coping that she’s split from her ex-husband and trying not to fall in love. While at times Makayla was frustrating, she became more likeable the further the story went on. Beau was delightful. Cece tried to be a great best friend and Agnes grew on me as the story flowed. Overall a great story.

Was this review helpful?

This is a fun and zesty romance that also has a few worthwhile things to say about life in general. I thoroughly enjoyed it, and I think most romance readers would agree.

Makayla married her high school boyfriend far too young, and took a decade to admit it was a ghastly mistake. Now divorced and eyeing the rapid advance of her 30th birthday, Makayla sets out to discover some of the things she missed by marrying young.

But when her one night stand turns up again in a most unexpected way, Makayla finds herself with some decisions to make. She doesn’t want to risk missing out on something good, but she also sees the importance of knowing herself a bit better before she gets involved with someone again.

This is a romance, and so some of the plot beats are pretty predictable. But there’s a fresh energy to this novel, and a zip and enthusiasm which infects the reader and makes it a lot of fun. I laughed often.

Brunnbauer invests the novel with just enough seriousness to make this feel like a real story – her main focus seems to be on helping the reader (and Makayla) have some fun.

I enjoyed Makayla’s voyage of self discovery, and also her wry voice. The characters are strong and appealing, and quite a few will hit a note of recognition with readers.

Highly recommended for readers who want something light and humorous, with just enough reality to keep it grounded.

Was this review helpful?

Not what I was expecting but a pleasant read with some funny parts that made me laugh out loud.

As it is written in third person limited past tense I found it a little hard to get into at first but reading more it gets easier although I’m not a fan of that style.

Overall an enjoyable story that I’m sure will be loved by many.

Congratulations on your debut novel Holly.

Was this review helpful?

A big thank you Netgalley, Harper Collins and Holly Brunnbauer for allowing me a chance to read an advanced copy!

Firstly, do not read this immediately after finishing Love Overdue- you will confuse yourself between schools and supporting characters 😂- maybe thats just my mum brain haha

Makayla is our FMC. This is a woman who has been with the same man since she was 16, she never got to ‘find herself’ in her 20’s, she never got to sow her oats… after a quick divorce and approaching her 30th birthday, she is setting herself a list.

I think initially I didn’t like Makayla as a character, i thought she was selfish and a bit of a dick- especially towards Beau. But reading on and understanding her back story, its clearly a defence mechanism and she needs to grow into the new her.

The character of Beau. Oh my god. He is perfection. I adored him, truely so patient and caring- The perfect book boyfriend!

I enjoyed reading the development and maturity of our main character. But also found the supporting characters integral to the story.

Also justice for Agnes… shes a bad ass 💁‍♀️

A wonderful debut, if you love a romcom you will enjoy this read. Another win for aussie fiction!

Was this review helpful?

Gosh I love a good rom com but boy am I proud when an Aussie author belts out such a brilliant story ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 I can see @ being a really big name in the Aussie romance scene. Think Clare Fletcher and Karina May.

Makayla is newly divorced, about to turn 30 and sets herself a challenge of completing her newly single wish list. Her first daring act, finds her entwined with the perfect guy who falls in to her lap at simply the worst time. Despite her efforts to resist him and continue on her new single trajectory, he keeps popping up and reminding her time and again what she’s missing out on. She is her own biggest obstacle. Riddled with complicated and unresolved feelings Makayla keeps everyone at arms length, including Beau. Will she work up the courage to face her past and open her heart again?

This is so much more than a rom com. This book explores many deeper issues including traumatic pregnancy loss, friendship changes, abusive parents and being heart broken. This book also combats these issues with found family, humour and the perfect guy all women dream of (with out him being her saviour 👌🏻). What really stood out to me was that Makayla’s problems were her own to solve and that felt really healthy. She wasn’t a damsel and she cared deeply for others even when her life was falling apart. It was really lovely to see her character grow and find closure.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a heartwarming rom com book!
My normal go to is dark spicy romance but sometimes I like to shake it up and I’m so glad I did with this one!
Makayla was such a sassy badass but gentle soul who just needed to take the time to let people in
Beau was suchhhh a sweet heart and I’d have loved him to be my teacher 🤣
I love how real and honest this book was!
Definitely a trigger warning to pregnancy loss but it is handled so beautifully!
If you need a light refreshing Aussie love story - definitely pick this one up!

Was this review helpful?