Cover Image: Manga Classics: Great Expectations

Manga Classics: Great Expectations

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This was an interesting book, it follows a poor boy who is being raised by his sister and brother in law. He goes through a lot of things which we get to see him struggle and grow as a person. It is redone from a classic book and it was done very well as well as the art is very well drawn as well.

Was this review helpful?

The art style is beautiful, lots of colors. Really helped consume this story. I have tried to read the original and could never push myself through this, but this made it a lot easier!

Was this review helpful?

This is actually the first Manga Classics story I read where I wasn't familiar with the original text or even another adaptation. I was impressed enough by previous ones I read that strived to be faithful to the original text even as alterations inevitably had to be made that I wanted to expand my horizons with something wholly new.

So I come to this story for the first time, and I find it to be an exploration of the upper class's hypocrisies, prejudices, and presumptions masquerading as a rags-to-riches story. Pip thinks he's Cinderella but he's actually in Parasite, basically.

It's also a look at just how alienating it is, to chase after the appearances the upper class is expected to keep up, being able to spend money on servants and such (Pip reflecting on how he doesn't even know what to do with a servant yet can't comprehend NOT employing one hit me hard). And worse, cutting out and snubbing people who are "beneath" you but genuinely care for you, as Pip tries to do with Joe and Biddy and as the child Estella did to the boy Pip.

The art is also beautiful as always, particularly the decadent ruin of Mrs. Havishham's mansion and the room where she keeps her moldering wedding cake. The setting was wonderfully realized, lush and occasionally action-packed between a fire scene and angry convicts trying to kill each other.

The characters were overall compelling as well. Pip is an unlikeable snot at points but that's very much the point, Estella is disagreeable but it's hard to not root for her with her well-realized "I must be taken as I am" speech with Mrs. Havishham, Mrs. Havishham is horrifying in how she twists two children left in her care and yet quite pathetic as well. Magwitch deserved better and I'm glad Pip came around to him in the end.

I'm glad the manga adapters were keen-sighted enough to keep Estella's and Pip's future together ambiguous, as they noted in the afterword explaining adaptation choice. To me at least, this is more a parable than a romance (and it's real easy to read Estella as aroace, too!), so I'm content to imagine they move forward as friends alone.

Was this review helpful?

Great Expectations is one of my favorite stories ever. I especially love Pip and Miss Havisham. Estella is obviously a problem, and she is beautifully portrayed here and shown to be the problematic person that she is. This is a fantastic manga adaptation and I hope that it brings this story to a wider audience.
The only thing missing is the humor, which is hard to translate to another edition, because Dickens basically used exaggeration for humor.
Thanks so much to NetGalley for making this available to me

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this story less than I expected. The classic literature stories are often so romanticized, but when I see them through a modern lens, I'm often confused on why the characters were so naive, or dense. Reading this manga did give me the beautiful artwork that I always enjoy from these titles, and the writing was digestible which makes it accessible to the younger generation as I personally struggle to read the classics in their original form due to the language that is used.

However, the story itself was not my favorite, however that isn't really something I can critique these creators for as they are simply retelling an original in manga form.

Pip was ignorant, and rude to his family, and loved a girl that wanted nothing to do with him, and just seemed so dense! I was shocked his childhood friend married his brother-in-law, I assumed the age gap would have been weird, but back in those days, age gaps were more common. And the was that Miss. Havisham lived was so unbelievable. Ther was also just a LOT going on in the story, like his deal with Miss. Havisham, the guy that escaped from prison, his friend that helped him that was related to Miss. Havisham, it all became very convoluted, but again, that's a critique for the original writer, not those reproducing it.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first Manga Classic read where I hadn't read the original book first. It made for a different experience, to be sure. As always, the art is stunning, and the backgrounds make everything more vivid than reading alone would have.

I always love the author and artist's notes, describing what their thoughts were, and their processes throughout the adaptation. I thought the "summary monologue" pieces were great, to move the story forward to the next important scene, but still have an understanding of what was happening in between.

Yet again, I'm interested to read the book - this time not a re-read! I am curious if I'll find Pip a bit more of a sympathetic character as I read an unadapted version. Though from the notes, it sounds like many find him lacking in this regard. His world seems very singular, especially after he's pushed away those he used to hold most dear. Normally, the Manga Classics have helped me to draw <i>more close</i> to the character, with the stunning visuals.

Was this review helpful?

I love a lot of Dickens' novels, but Great Expectations was not one of them.
It was incredibly dense, boring and overly repetitive.

But this manga adaptation does a really great job of capturing the essential of the story in a captivating way and with outstanding illustrations.

I'd say that this is a great way to dip your toes into a big classic and decide for yourself if you want to take the plunge and read the original book by Dickens.

Was this review helpful?

This was another great book where a classic is remade into a manga graphic novel!
Let’s be honest, really, are there many young people out there who really WANT to read old-timey books, be they classic or not, even if they are pushed to be read at school? Most will avoid it at all costs. Let’s not pretend that everyone wants to read Charles Dickens. Even me, no matter how much I love reading, no matter how fast I read – nope, I’m not really interested in reading any of it. I have read most of it at school, but the books I didn’t read back then, well. I will never read them. I can’t blame kids for not wanting to read those either. In fact, I understand them all too well.
And then, enter the classic books remade as manga. It is seriously a game-changer. All of a sudden, the story comes alive, and it turns into an exciting read. My 10-year-old read this one also, she said she loved it, she said she enjoyed it so much, she said the story was really compelling and she wanted to talk about it for days. I consider that an absolute win!

Was this review helpful?

A retelling of a classic using manga style artwork. Excellent art, story is true to the original. I love the the bonus stuff to use in the classroom. Excellent addition to curriculum.

4 stars

Was this review helpful?

Wow! I wish I had had this edition when I had to read this for an English Lit class years ago. I understood the characters, emotion, (or lack thereof in Estella's case), and storyline much better than back then. The manga artwork is excellent and the story flows well expressing character traits, action, and emotion. I will be reading more Manga Classics in the future!

Was this review helpful?

Another great telling of a classic novel! The manga version of these always helps me understand them more than it would if I were to read the regular classic, great job on the retelling of this one!

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful rendition of a tale as old as time. I really enjoyed this retelling of Great Expectations! Sometimes having an illustrated edition makes for an even better experience!

Was this review helpful?

Another great edition in the Manga Classics series! My daughter and I both love these books, This was a wonderful interpretation of Dickens' classic. It was a fun and enjoyable read that helps introduce readers to this well-known classic.

Was this review helpful?

Let me preface this review with stating that the reason I gave this book 4 rather than 5 stars is due to my personal tastes. Objectively, this Manga Classic is very well done. I always say that MC's art is superb, and I will continue to do so as long as it continues to have the same quality. It's always clear that so much thought was put into character design, and absolutely nothing is neglected; the outfits, backgrounds, and really everything are always interesting to look at, and there aren't any of the shortcuts that many mangas take to produce pages faster. The way that this Manga Classic left the ending intentionally vague is really elegant and well done. Returning to why I didn't give this book a perfect score, was because I felt that it was rushed. The time skips make sense, as there's only so much that one can fit into a graphic novel adaptation, but to me, they did feel rather abrupt and jarring. I do like that this adaptation went to the end of the original work, as many adaptations stop when it is revealed that Miss Havisham had set Pip up for massive disappointment all along.

Was this review helpful?

The art of this manga classic was beautifully done and adapted. Unfortunately not even the manga format helped me to enjoy Charles Dickens. Regardless on my thoughts about Dickens I will happily recommend classic lovers and novices to Manga Classics for a fresh spin on an old story.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley for providing me with a complimentary digital ARC for Manga Classics: Great Expectations. The honest opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Great Expectations is a classic novel by Charles Dickens. It’s about a young man named Pip who grows up in dire circumstances. He receives money from a mysterious benefactor in order for him to get an education. He meets the capricious Miss Havisham, who was jilted on her wedding day, so she spends her time in her wedding dress in her crumbling mansion. She has a ward, the cold and beautiful Estella who Miss Havisham has influenced into being heartless towards men. Pip struggles to make his way in the world.

I loved this graphic novel. I’ve read the original in school so I wanted a refresher. I think it followed the book well and made the story fun and interesting for people who might not want to read the classics.

I would recommend this to anyone who enjoys classic mangas!

Was this review helpful?

I read the actual classic last December, and although I enjoyed it, it was way too slow for my taste. So when I found this manga, I knew I wanted to give it a try. Although I think not everything translated well into the book, I really did enjoy it, and the pace was a lot higher, which was really nice. All in all a great read!

Was this review helpful?

This was a brilliant graphic novel. I have read the great expectations book before, and I loved being able to read it again in graphic novel format. Plus, how often do you get to read a book from the back to the front. The pictures were in wonderful detail. It flowed so well and was very well written. I just loved the atmosphere that was created. It was such an amazing reading experience. This book will be perfect for school/home education from young to adult as it's easy to understand the storyline. I certainly recommend reading it. I love manga classics as I have read a few now and thoroughly enjoyed each and every one. It's a great alternative to reading a classic or to accompany reading the classic. It will definitely better clarify the story. I just loved all the emotions that this book brought out of me.

Only the highest of praise goes out to the author, illustrator, and publishers for creating such a wonderful reading experience. I will definitely be reading more books from this series.

The above review has already been placed on goodreads, waterstones, Google books, Barnes&noble, kobo, amazon UK where found and my blog today https://ladyreading365.wixsite.com/website/post/manga-classics-great-expectations-by-crystal-schan-nokman-poon-manga-classics-5-stars under ladyreading365

Was this review helpful?

I am not a fan of classics and defiantly not of Mr. Dickens. However, I am a fan of manga. Reading this was a true delight. Honestly, I wish all classics could be adapted to manga. Awesome story telling and artistry.

Was this review helpful?

I’m currently on a bit of a Manga Classics binge. I’m loving the fact that they’re manga but also that they’re giving me the opportunity to dip my toes into classics that have intimidated me for years. I read two pages of Great Expectations when I was about ten and have never made it to page three.

After getting a bit lost in The Count of Monte Cristo, I tried a different approach here. I found myself a book summary and read that first before tackling this manga adaptation. It helped. A lot. I really enjoyed this read.

The illustrations are brilliant. Young Pip is absolutely adorable. Miss Havisham is amazing!

I’m definitely going to keep reading Manga Classics.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and UDON Entertainment for the opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?