Thanks to Netgalley and Hachette Audio for the audiobook, I enjoyed the Duet Narration by Patricia Santomasso(a new narrator to me) and Sean Patrick Hopkins so it was entertaining Thank you.

Gemma is a new debut author and Mason is a well-known Hockey Player that have a meet-cute many many years later that in truth didn't disappoint. Yes, they had a rocky beginning, with disappointments and miscommunication but when it finally worked out many years later what more is there to ask? Even the epilogue was cute!

Writing Mr. Wrong is a delightful blend of second-chance romance, fake dating, and forced proximity, all wrapped up in a slow-burn story that kept me hooked from start to finish. I listened to the audiobook version and thoroughly enjoyed it. The duet narration by Patricia Santomasso and Sean Patrick Hopkins was fantastic—both narrators did a wonderful job bringing the characters to life, and their performances added extra charm and energy to an already engaging story.

Gemma Stanton is a debut novelist who believes readers prefer the "bad boy" hero, so she models her male lead after her high school crush, Mason Moretti—a decision that backfires spectacularly. Mason, now a professional hockey player with a somewhat tarnished public image, finds himself reunited with Gemma during a surprise on-air interview. When the public learns that the arrogant fictional character in Gemma’s book is based on him, Mason comes up with a plan to fake date Gemma to boost both their images. What starts as a publicity stunt quickly becomes more personal.

One of the most compelling parts of the story is Mason’s character arc. After reading Gemma’s book and seeing himself reflected in a less-than-flattering light, he begins a journey of self-awareness and growth. His proposal for a private getaway—where he’ll pamper Gemma and she’ll teach him how not to be an asshole—leads to some heartfelt and hilarious moments.

The chemistry between Gemma and Mason is electric, and their banter feels natural and fun. Their dynamic is equal parts tension and tenderness, making the slow burn all the more satisfying. And while their romance takes center stage, the book also delivers plenty of humor and heart, especially thanks to side characters like the unforgettable Grandma Dot—an absolute standout and scene-stealer.

If you enjoy second-chance romance, fake dating, hockey heroes, or stories where opposites attract and ultimately grow together, Writing Mr. Wrong is a must-read (or listen!). Kelley Armstrong delivers a witty, romantic, and emotionally satisfying story that I’d happily recommend.

Thank you to NetGalley, Hachette Audio, and Kelley Armstrong for the ALC!

This second chance romance, childhood friends to lovers story had me kicking my feet. Such a cute, fun read. I listened to the audiobook, and both of the narrators did a fantastic job bringing these characters to life. A lighthearted and funny little romcom.
Mason, an aging hockey star and Gemma, a recently divorced novelist are thrown back together after 20 years on television. In an attempt to both promote Gemma's new book and realign Mason's image in the public eye - the fake dating begins.

I found this a witty, heartwarming gem that ticks all the boxes for a satisfying contemporary romance. From the clever premise, where a romance author accidentally exposes her high school crush -turn star hockey player- as the real-life inspiration for her fictional bad boy, to the fake dating twist and viral chaos that ensues, every beat of the story is delightfully engaging. The chemistry between Gemma and Mason crackles with authenticity, and their journey through second chances, professional reinvention, and emotional honesty is both fun and meaningful. Armstrong excels at blending laugh-out-loud moments with touching depth, all set against the vibrant backdrop of publishing drama and a hint of sports-world swagger. It touches on some more serious topics as well, including abusive childhood, which adds depth to the characters, and made me root for them and their happy ending. The narrators made the whole thing even better, great pace, emotions, and tone throughout from both of them!

It took a bit to fully get into the story in general. Once the characters were more fully developed and the plot began to move forward more fluidly, the story really came to life. The narrators did a terrific job with the main characters - Mason and Gemma. I loved the back and forth speaking between them, it was natural and brought more depth to the plot. While I'm not much of a sports fan, I appreciated learning more about NHL and the emotions and feelings of a pro hockey player. My only disappointment was the ending which seemed a little rushed.

Kelley Armstrong is such a versatile author who can write all the genres! I look forward to every single book she writes and have for about 5 years now.

I blew through Writing Mr. Wrong in just one day and loved it so much! It was a fun rom-com that made me laugh and root for Gemma and Mason. I've recently gone to my first hockey game which I loved and thought it was fun to do that along with reading this book at the same time.

I also loved the narrators, Patricia Santomasso and Sean Patrick Hopkins. They were very easy to listen to, and I felt like the voices fit the characters really well.

Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to read Writing Mr. Wrong! All opinions are my own.

Publication date: 24 June 2025

3.75-4 stars

I did enjoy the story. I felt like it had a lot of tropes, possibly some included to have more tropes but honestly enjoyed them.

Tropes (a lot of them)
- hockey romance
- dyslexia rep
- Jewish rep (with a fantastic Jewish grandmother)
- second chance romance
- childhood friends to lovers
- a little bit of miscommunication

Trigger warnings
- parents with alcohol use

Mason's insecurities and immaturity did get to me a little bit and at times was distracting. The awkward moments wen they didn't think of each other's feelings / wants... I did find a little bit distracting and immature. It was interesting having Gemma's ex featured in the book. Mason doesn't put the pieces together for things that I think was a bit immature. But, I did enjoy the childhood crushes finally get their happily ever after. Gemma was definitely an FMC to root for and I did find myself rooting for Mason and his growth arc. I think he is a good man at heart that didn't always have the best people in his corner giving him the tools to be his best self. I enjoyed the story and following along with their romance.

Audio specific feedback - I enjoyed the dual narration. I thought the narrators were chosen well to give voice to these characters. I think the dual narration added a lot to experiencing the story. I am grateful I was granted access to this advanced audio copy of the book.

I will check out more books from this author!

I loved Writing Mr. Wrong. The premise of this story was pure perfection. The characters were lovable and their chemistry was top notch. I loved how the story unfolded and the ending was beautiful. This is my first book by Kelley Armstrong and it won’t be my last. My only issue is a personal one… Normally I’m not a huge fan of third person narration, but it wasn’t too bad in the book once you got used to it. I listened to the audiobook and both of the narrators did a wonderful job. 💖

I would like to thank Hachette Audio and NetGalley for giving me an ARC (which did not sway my opinions or review).

Thank you to NetGalley and @HachetteAudio for this ALC in exchange for an honest review.

Writing Mr. Wrong was such a fun, feel good listen. I’m love a good second-chance romance, and this one did not disappoint, with great chemistry, plenty of banter, and a nice dose of emotional depth. The duet style narration made it even better. Both narrators brought so much personality to Gemma and Mason, and their voices worked perfectly together. It felt super immersive and made the story fly by.

Gemma is a debut author who based her romance hero on her high school crush, Mason Moretti—a now pro hockey player with a bit of a bad-boy rep. She never expected the world to find out especially not during a surprise live TV reunion. Things get awkward fast, but when the moment goes viral, Mason suggests they fake date to ride the publicity wave. What starts off as a smart business move quickly turns into something much more real.

Their dynamic is fun, he’s cocky but charming, she’s guarded but relatable and the growth in both characters felt natural and well paced. I also loved the bookish angle and behind the scenes look at publishing mixed with the chaos of fame and internet drama.

If you’re into romance with humor, heart, and great audio performances, definitely check this one out. It’s light in all the right ways, but still leaves you smiling by the end.

4.25 Stars!

#NetGalley, #HachetteAudio, #WritingMrWrong, #KelleyArmstrong, #RomCom

I finished this audiobook yesterday and was pleasantly surprised. I'm not usually a fan of second-chance romance, but the author did a good job at showing how both characters had grown over the past twenty years. I am, however, confused at how neither of them were aware of the other's crush when they were younger, as from both of their perspectives, their own interest seemed blatantly obvious. I also don't understand how they didn't resolve their feelings in high school, because had they had talked for five minutes instead of one they would've been able to talk it out. I enjoyed the addition of Nonna and her no nonsense attitutde. This book also made me hungry. I think the author did a great job at showing how Mason had neglected to take responsibility for how his actions hurt others before, and learning and growing to change that and think of the consequences of his actions on others first. And I like that Gemma slowly got her confidence and her no nonsense attitude back. I'm also intrigued by the descriptions of her novels. 3.5/5 and already recommended it to my mom who loves romcom books!

Cute book with a typical happy ending. It was an easy read, a beach read. Based on the description from Netgalley, it was exactly what was promised.

Heartfelt, hilarious, and flawlessly narrated

Writing Mr. Wrong by Kelley Armstrong is a charming, emotionally satisfying second-chance romance set in Canada—and it hits all the right notes. I listened to the audiobook version courtesy of NetGalley, and honestly? It was an absolute delight.

This dual-POV story brings together NHL enforcer Mason Moretti (no, I don’t really know what an enforcer does either, but apparently he protects the other players and occasionally scores goals) and Gemma Stanton, a divorced romance author and college teacher. They knew each other in high school—she was the brilliant valedictorian, he was the popular hockey jock. They once shared a kiss, and then he blew it. Years later, her new romance novel just so happens to feature a fictional hero who sounds suspiciously like Mason. 👀

Enter: a delicious fake-dating arrangement to promote Gemma’s book and give Mason the PR rehab he desperately needs. Cue the slow-burn rekindling of feelings, personal growth arcs, and all the swoony, cinnamon-roll vibes from Mason you could ask for. He’s sweet, loyal, a little bit broken, and just trying to be a better man. Gemma is clever, grounded, and genuinely lovely—a heroine you actually want to root for.

🎧 The narration? Chef’s kiss. Patricia Santomasso and Sean Patrick Thomas absolutely nail it. It’s a performance-style audiobook—each narrator sticks to their character’s chapters without trying to mimic the opposite voice, which I loved. It felt polished, immersive, and natural. Add in clean production and subtle sound effects, and you’ve got a listening experience that flows effortlessly. Well done Hachette Audio.

Gemma’s family is another highlight: supportive, warm, and full of personality. Her grandmother is an absolute treat. It’s refreshing to read a romance where the heroine isn’t constantly at odds with her family. On the flip side, Mason’s relationship with his parents adds just enough emotional weight to balance the humour and romance. And his relationship with Mason shows where he gets his kindness and protective nature from.

There are funny, romantic, and emotionally rich moments in equal measure. And the ending? So satisfying. I already bought Finding Mr. Right—which looks like it follows Gemma’s brother—and I’m thrilled it features the same voice actors.

A completely delightful listen. Five stars. Thanks to NetGalley for the advance copy!

Thank you to Kelley Armstrong, Hatchette Audio, and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest review!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This was so cute! I loved the main characters and how well they flowed together. The story was paced wonderfully and really helped capture each characters “redemption” arc individually while building up their rekindled friendship/relationship. I do wish there had been more about Mason actually seeking help through a therapist or psychiatrist but the self-introspection was great. I LOVE GRANDMA DOT, I want to be her when I grow up.

Writing Mr. Wrong is a charming and heartfelt rom-com with great chemistry and just the right dose of humor. The narrators did a fantastic job capturing the characters’ personalities and emotions, making the story feel lively and authentic. While some plot points were predictable, the strong writing and engaging narration made this an enjoyable listen from start to finish.

It's been a minute since I last finished a book in under 24 hours but this audiobook was GOLD. I mean how you not fall in love with an MMC who looks tough but is sweet and caring as well. Add in a tough female lead and I'm hooked. Love when both the MMC and the FMC are willing to fight for the other. I 100% recommend.

Kelley Armstrong delivers a charming, smartly layered romance in Writing Mr. Wrong, blending heartfelt second chances with witty banter and a twist of mystery. The story follows aspiring screenwriter Daphne McFadden, who’s roped into helping with the memoir of reclusive thriller author Chris Stanton—a man infamous for killing off his fictional female leads and ghosting his past collaborators.

What begins as a professional project quickly turns personal as Daphne peels back Chris’s prickly layers and uncovers a man with regrets, a sharp sense of humor, and a soft spot he’s long tried to hide. Their dynamic is electric—equal parts snark and vulnerability—and Armstrong paces their growing connection beautifully, allowing emotional intimacy to build alongside the professional tension.

But this isn’t just a romance—it’s a quiet exploration of grief, reputation, and how the stories we tell (and avoid telling) shape who we become. Daphne’s resilience and Chris’s guarded charm make for a slow-burn with substance, and the behind-the-scenes glimpses into writing and publishing give it a unique meta twist.

Warm, funny, and unexpectedly poignant, Writing Mr. Wrong hits all the right notes for readers who like their love stories with depth, dry humor, and a dash of bookish angst.

Thank you to NetGalley and Hachette Audio for the ALC in exchange for an honest review!

Writing Mr. Wrong follows Gemma and Mason as they meet again after knowing each other from kindergarten through high school. They had crushes on each other and shared one kiss during high school. However, things ended poorly and they went their separate ways.

Gemma wrote a book with a main character inspired by Mason because he needed to be a jerk to get people interested. This is outed and they are thrown together to make things better for each other in a PR way because he’s a famous hockey player with a recent scandal and she needs to promote her book.

While I do think they had a good connection, I really think that Gemma was a lot more upset about what happened in high school than she should’ve been at her big age of 36. That was almost two decades ago. I think Armstrong could’ve found something else or just had her uninterested in a reunion rather than her hating him.

Mason really wanted to grow and be better, I just wish we saw more of that. He also seemed to have some mental health stuff that I wanted explored a bit more. I think he was on the right track, but the book ended pretty abruptly and we didn’t have a chance to see that or other things wrap up.

I think there was so much potential here, and while it was definitely a fun read, I wanted more.

In regards to the narration, Patricia Santomasso and Sean Patrick Hopkins did such a wonderful job! They made it all the more enjoyable.

3.25 rounded down

This one was ok for me.. to be honest it didn't overly draw me in - now I've finished it I could barely tell you what happened. The audiobook kind of became background noise for me rather than my focus and keeping me hooked on the story. The narrators were good.

This book was so much fun! I loved listening to it. The dual narration was fantastic. I loved the second chance trope in this one, the chemistry between the two was evident. I enjoyed the hockey/writer storylines without either of them being overdone, it felt very natural, each of them having their job/life/hurts/etc. but the storyline never focused on any one part too much. This is my first book by Kelley Armstrong, and I will look for more from her.

This was my first hockey romance, and I gotta say—I liked! The narrators were great, and while this is mostly a fun, smutty romance (no complaints here), there were some thoughtful touches too.

Kelley Armstrong weaves in mental health themes and gives the characters some growth, which I always appreciate. Steamy and entertaining.