Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This started off quite lovely, but gradually I noticed discrepancies in the illustrations and the text. The story didn't make a whole load of sense, with sections reading like a story, and others like a poem, in this confused way.

Others noted that this may be AI, and if it is, I don't believe that it should have a space in the publishing world. If it is not AI, I think that the book would benefit from more editing both to text and illustrations to make it more consistent.

Thank you to Netgalley, the author, and Chantilly Cat Press for the opportunity to read this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was a cute and sweet book, I was a little surprised by the amount of illustrations vs amount of words, I expected it to be more text heavy. Still the content is quite cosy and cute, which always leaves nice fuzzy feelings inside.

I am concerned by the sheer amount of other reviewers that are talking about this book potentially using AI. If this is the case, I would be extremely disappointed and uninterested in the book.

Was this review helpful?

This book felt very strange to me, and now that I see other reviews have mentioned the possibility of it being made with AI I think that would certainly explain the odd vibes. The author herself has shared a note about her process and what was used to create the art, and it was apparently Adobe Illustrator and Canva. Aside from all that, I thought the art style was very cute, if somewhat repetitive, and the amount of illustrations in between text broke it up in such a way that the narrative was thrown off. The premise of the book was a sweet idea, but the "voice" of George ended up making it feel a little too forced. I think with some further tweaking this could be an enjoyable children's book, but in it's current iteration it just doesn't feel quite complete.

I'd like to add a note about why AI seems to be coming up a lot for this book. There are some strange inconsistencies with the illustrations that are the kinds of things one often sees with generative AI. For example, there are pages where George is in a cardboard box and the placement of his tail outside the box does not make sense. There is also an illustration where he appears to be missing a foot, and people in beds who have no heads/bodies, only feet. These details combined with the fact that there are repeating images and variations of the same images make the book feel less thought out and more generative. This goes for some of the text as well. I mean absolutely no shade to the artist, but as an illustrator myself these are the types of things I am going to pay attention to. The art style is adorable, the colors are friendly and comforting, but a second pass to tighten things up wouldn't hurt. If the artist is using her own art in combination with AI, I would just offer to be cautious and careful, even if the initial design is her own. It's easy for things to get lost in translation with this technology.

Was this review helpful?

This was soooo cozy and cute. I loved everything about it. It was exactly what i needed in this moment. thank you so much netgalley i will buy this when it comes out!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, I guess, to Netgalley and the publisher for gifting me a copy of this AI book.

When I saw the cover, I thought "What a cute art style!" I have three cats of my own, so I was curious what George thinks. Then I started reading and admiring the art... At first, I thought how cute and cozy... Then the writing felt repetitive and weird. Then the cat's ear grew from its back. I started noticing how from page to page the cat looks different. Changes in fur colour, eye colour, eye style, fur type...

Then, lying on a bed and supposedly on top of a human, only feet can be seen - no human head peeking at the top where it should be. This happens twice. Then the weird perspective of a cat lying/floating next to a bed. The cat sits in a box and its tail peeks out as if the box has a hole perfectly placed for its tail.... and then suddenly the cat has two front paws, with a third front paw stretching in front of it.

This could have been a very cute book, if not for AI. I'm glad I did not spend money on it, though at first I thought it would be a perfect cute little book for some kids in my family. Feels like it would have been better, had it been done in Canva. Disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

With beautiful art on each page, easy-to-understand writing, and a cohesive meaning, What George Thinks When He Sits Still is an excellent short read that I see being easily enjoyed!

Edit: I have just learned that the illustrations in this book were created using AI. Since this information was not divulged, I feel it is appropriate to change my rating.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very calming, feel-good book. It felt partway between a comic and a poetry book to me. I really enjoyed the art style. Overall, this was a really cute, quick read.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a sweet and cozy picture book about Caroline's cat George and the daily life and feelings he has as a cat in her home. I loved the sweet illustrations and the colors she used to portray it all. I will be purchasing this one for my collection, 100%!

Was this review helpful?

This was so pure and beautiful. My cat very helpfully laid at the foot od the bed, purring, while I ventured into the soft big quiet love of George’s world and I’m so glad I did.

Was this review helpful?

The graphics in this were absolutely amazing. They were incredibly cute. This is a sweet little story about the author's cat and provides examples of what cats might be thinking about while they are sitting still. I think that this would be a good book for any age and especially if you are a cat owner!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley and the author/artist for allowing me to review this beautiful book.

I will never say no to a book about a cat, and 'what George thinks when he sits still' doesn't disappoint. It is a lovely and warming picture book for adults and children alike. The art work is stunning. Every page made me smile.

I just hope it's for sale in the UK.

Was this review helpful?

This is why everybody wants to be a cat. Anyone who's ever spent time around cats knows how they really do focus on the moment and relax and sleep more than anything. I want to be more in the moment! I also really love the illustrations and the unique way they were made

Was this review helpful?

Awww this was adorable.
I loved the pictures and the story of George and being still in the moment.
We should all take a leaf out of cats books and just be !
I love cats a lot so looked this book.

Cats are just amazing.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Net Galley and the publisher for providing a copy to review.

This is such a warm and cozy book. I could feel the love the author has for her cat, George, in every drawing and text.

Definitely recommend for cat lovers, and anyone looking for a cozy read.

Was this review helpful?

As a counselor, I enjoy how this book very subtly talks about Mindfulness and the importance of staying present with your surroundings. I found it adorable hearing about how George enjoys watching cat tv and giving you love. I wasn't the biggest fan of the art style personally, since it was cute but the art wasn't consistent from page to page. However, the day to day vibes of this book could fit with a reader of any age.

Was this review helpful?

Well this was just fantastic. So cute and I loved the art so much. I’m a cat lover so if I had a child this woulr 100% be going on their bookshelf.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Chantilly Cat Press for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Very cute book about the love that a cat gives. It gave a sense of calm and the drawings were adorable.

Was this review helpful?

It’s just really a cute quickie read about a kitty named George. I had to read this since cats are cool even though they can scratch your face off👍😅🐱🐈🐈‍⬛

Thanks Netgalley and publisher!

Was this review helpful?

I love it and feel like this book would be ideal for reading with children (although adults can often learn a lot from these readings too).

As someone who feels like they're wasting time or not making the most of the day if they're not doing anything, this book is ideal. Because sometimes just sitting and watching a butterfly fly by, or feeling the wind, or closing my eyes and existing... is more than enough.

I loved how the book evolved, all the little phrases and thoughtful moments we can draw from it.

Thank you so much, Chantilly Cat Press, for the ARC I read through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is a really sweet picture book with a lovely art style. It is very comforting to read, but feels a little disjointed at times.

Was this review helpful?