Really sad I didn’t enjoy this and had to DNF at about 35% as I had such high hopes for it.

I’m still very grateful to have been given an early copy for review.

Sadly I don’t think this stand on its own without the fanfic background and lore as the author does very little of their own world building or set up their magic system to invest you in to the story. It’s incredibly slow.
If you stripped away away all the preconceived potter thoughts of the characters you are left with the very bare bones of a story

I didn’t feel connected to any of the characters and considering there are dark themes in this book they’re not adequately explored (until the point I read up to anyway). There should be very traumatic and complex emotions surrounding certain topics like forced sterilisation and threat of/ anticipated non consensual sexual acts but they’re all just kind of washed over and barely given any thought.

The constant timeline skipping made it really difficult to settle in the story too.

I wanted to love Rose in Chains, but it left me disappointed and exhausted. This was my third Julie Soto book, and, unfortunately, likely my last—her writing just doesn’t land for me.

The premise had promise: a post-war fantasy world, a heroine sold to a man she's long pined for, political intrigue, and repressed longing. But the execution? Flat. Briony, our heroine, felt like a passive observer to her own story—naive, repetitive, and hard to root for. Toven, the male lead, had all the ingredients of a brooding romantic hero but lacked believable motivation or emotional depth. Their romance, which should’ve burned with tension, felt lukewarm and hollow.

The pacing dragged. Flashbacks interrupted the narrative flow without adding real emotional weight. Much of the story felt stagnant—Briony moping in captivity while very little happened. I kept hoping for momentum, but even when things finally picked up near the end, it was too late to care.

Worldbuilding was another sore spot: lots of names and kingdoms thrown at the reader, few of which ever felt meaningful. The political backdrop served more as vague set dressing than integral plot.

One bright spot? The audiobook narrator. She brought far more life to these characters than the text ever did. Her performance made the story more bearable in audio format.

This was fantastic. The narration was amazing and very immersive. THE SLOWEST OF SLOW BURNS. I wish they would have given us more at the dinners Briony was forced to attend. That's what would've made this a 6 star read for me. It was a bit too slow of a burn. But overall, amazing tension, longing and plot. One of my new favorites.

The world in this book really captivated me. I loved the world building and the magic system. There is a slow burn romance but that is not the focus of the book. I think if I was more into Dramione fanfiction this story would have pulled me in more.
The narration in this audiobook was done by Ella Lynch. She did a really great job voicing the story. I loved her tone and pacing of the story.

I would give this book 6 stars if i were able too. Julie Soto totally knocked this would out of the park. The relationship between Toven and Briony is exactly what you want in a romantasy - they hate each other but pine in private.

I thought the world building, the magic system and the character development was something to just fall and just immerse yourself into.

As we know it is a rewrite of The Auction , but it is its own story- although it is still Dramionie coded. That being said, every change that was made , I believe made the story 1000 times better and I loved it even more.

It is a slow born story, with minimal spicey content noted throughout the story. maybe 2.5 🌶, and I would like to note - trigger warnings should be read ahead of time.

It is a very well written romantasy novel, but may not be for you if you have certain triggers. Triggers Warnings are listed on the first page.

The Narrator Ella Lynch is British, which I thought she was wonderful, and really brought the story to life. She read at a pace where I only had to speed it up to 1.2x vs my normal speed up to 2x and the British accent was EVERYTHING to this story.

tropes including :
*touch her and die
*enemies to lovers
*slow burn
*dual timeline

Overall I couldn’t put this book down - I really enjoyed the story in spite of the writing, which I found to be a little underwhelming.

What I enjoyed: while this wasn’t a direct copy of The Auction, it was still heavily Dramione-coded, taking some elements of Harry Potter fanfic but really creating its own world, magic, and characters. I was pulled into the story quickly and am already looking forward to books two and three. While Briony herself wasn’t my favorite, I loved a lot of the others and feel confident there are going to be some great character arcs developing over the series (e.g., Toven’s entire family, Larissa, Finn, even the enemies you love to hate).

Where I wanted more: my biggest issue was with how Briony comes across - naive to a fault. I realize it is often a stylistic choice to help bring the reader along, but in this case it was at odds with who they claimed Briony to be (I.e., it’s hard to believe she is the smartest in her class when she was so obtuse/naive/childish). I also thought the first ~30% of the book was a bit rough to jump into (not a lot of world building, a lot of characters that aren’t fleshed out, writing was more telling than showing).

Finally, I read and listened to this as an audiobook. As I mentioned above, the intro was a bit jerky, thus making it a bit hard to follow via audio (but still doable). Other than that, if you like audio books it’s a good one to pick. The narrator was British which was a delightful yet subtle nod to the fanfic origins. She does a good job bringing the story to life without adding unnecessary emotion (e.g., it would be easy to make Briony come across more whiny for a lot of her conversations and internal dialog but that didn’t happen).

Thank you to Julie Soto, Forever Publishing, Hachette audio, and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced listener copy in exchange for an honest review.

My freaking goddess, this book! I am new to the Dramione world, and while I don’t condone the insanity that JKR promotes, it’s hard to deny the pull of this couple…

Yall, Julie Soto slid so seamlessly into fantasy world building, I would NEVER had assumed she was a contemporary romance writer. This book starts off with a bang and does not. Let. Up. It hit all the right boxes for me: good pace, easy to understand world, slow burn, complicated morality, and a little magic thrown in.

Given Soto’s previous books, I was surprised by the low spicy level, but I imagine book 2 might have more…

The narrator was excellent, too. She nailed it!

Thank you to Hachette Audio ans NetGalley for this ALC! It was such a treat to experience this book in audio format. Can’t wait to read it with my eyeballs when it releases!!

Advance Listener Copy Review, thank you NetGalley, Julie Soto, and Hachette Audio!

Rose in Chains by Julie Soto
Narrated by Ella Lynch
Duration: 16h01m

Rose in Chains follows two opposing wizarding groups, the Eversuns and the Bormardi. The Bormardi have won the war, resulting in the Eversun women being auctioned off, including Briony, the Princess of the Eversuns.

This was one of my most anticipated reads of the year, so getting the chance to review it was an absolute highlight.

The first 15% is heavy on exposition, introducing a lot of characters, locations, and the magic system. If you’re unfamiliar with the origins of this story (iykyk), it might take a bit longer to follow this, feel fully immersed and could risk the potential of being a little confusing.

I loved the use of flashbacks to build the world and give deeper context to Briony and Toven’s relationship. These glimpses into the past reveal hidden motivations and emotions that tie beautifully back into the present day narrative, adding extra layers to the story.

This is truly the slowest of burns, with so much sexual tension, which made the eventual payoff even more satisfying. Without spoiling anything: it might just be the slowest burn I’ve ever read (and I mean that in the best way)!

The pacing and plot felt solid throughout, though I will say it gave off strong ‘book one of a trilogy’ vibes (which it is). The ending definitely left me shook and had me wanting more.

Just a heads-up: while this is marketed as romantasy, the tone leans quite dark. Definitely something to keep in mind depending on your preferences.

I listened to the audiobook version and, at first, wasn’t sure how I felt about the solo narration. I’ve become so used to dual-narration formats that it threw me off. But Ella Lynch captured the essence of the story really well and ended up being a delight to listen to.

Tropes:
~ Enemies to lovers
~ Dark Fantasy
~ Forced Proximity (Captivity)
~ Past and present timeline
~ Slow burn

I loved reading this book. It is a true slow burn where you know both characters are yearning for each other so you become invested in their relationship. Julie Soto writes stories so well that you don’t want to stop until the book is completed.

Thank you to Hachette Audio, NetGalley and Julie Soto for the advance listener copy of Rose in the Chained.

This was the slowest of slow burns - the tension builds with excruciating precision. Soto’s storytelling is rich and immersive, weaving a unique magic system into a dark, dystopian fantasy that isn’t afraid to confront brutal truths.

While the worldbuilding and character dynamics are brilliant, this isn’t an easy listen. The themes are heavy, and the trigger warnings at the beginning are essential. Despite being a fantasy, at times it reminded me of The Handmaid’s Tale, in so far as this story explores the use of systemic sexual violence as a weapon of war and oppression, and it does so with unflinching honesty. Whilst the depiction of sexual violence isn’t explicitly graphic or gratuitous, it is a major theme of the book. Soto handles this with care and respect whilst challenging you as the reader. This is not a rinse and repeat romantasy.

It left me with a million questions, a heavy heart, and a desperate need to talk about it. Thought-provoking, devastating, and unforgettable.

*Check your trigger warnings because Soto does not gloss over topics of enslavement, SA, and torture.

Imagine a romantasy book where the author chooses the road less traveled. The plot of this is original. I love the fantasy romance genre, but it has been getting quite tiresome with the same formula.

While the world building feels slightly underdeveloped at times, leaving me with more questions, I can’t bring myself to lower my rating. Soto definitely weaves world building throughout seamlessly. This is shown through the narration and how it supports the story as it moves, but I still feel as though we needed more information at the beginning. We are thrust into the world with little context and an influx of character names.

The majority of the action happens at the beginning. A large chunk of the story is spent on character work and exploring the dark themes of the world. We are also very focused on the romance. This story is a slow burn. And I am not just saying that like people say Fourth Wing was, when in fact it wasn’t. This may be too slow for some, but it was perfect for me. I’ve never read a Julie Soto book before, but I can tell that romance is a strength of hers. The yearning is immaculate!

Soto uses a past to present timeline and transitions well between each. The chapters connect in a way that make the story flow wonderfully. It was well written and the author succeeds in immersing the reader into the story.

I am aware that this was initially a Dramione fan fiction, and that shows. Sprinkle in a little Bridgerton vernacular and Handmaid’s Tale politics, and you have one of the most intriguing reads. For me at least. I devoured this book. It’s safe to say it is amongst my top reads of the year so far. I’ve already preordered a special edition. This will be a book I reread time and time again.

⭐️:5/5
🌶️:1/5
🎧:4/5

Audio narration 4/5
The narrator did an amazing job and really nailed down the voices for the time period the novel is intended to be set in. Her emotions and ability to differentiate tone was amazing.

She did a decent good job with the males voices. Making Toven come off haughty at times was exactly how I pictured him, since he is based off of Draco Malfoy.

4.5 Stars

I’m a sucker for anything Julie Soto writes and this book is no exception. I was utterly consumed and devoured this ALC within 24 hours. I thought Ella Lynch did a phenomenal job with the narration. She felt like Briony to me and I really enjoyed how distinctive her various voices felt, I was able to easily distinguish who was who. The production was crisp and thoroughly enjoyable. I highly recommend getting the audio!

The story itself is everything I was hoping for! I loved the two different approaches/sources to magic and how these different techniques have created a divide among kingdoms. My only critique in the magic system right now is we spend a lot of time learning about the 2 ways to harness the magic, but not much on what the magic itself encompasses. I'd love to learn more in the following books.

I loved the flashbacks and feeling the conflicting emotions of Briony as she interacts with Toven through the years. Julie Soto is the queen of tension and the slowest of burns and this book delivers that! Loved the ending and I can’t wait for book 2!

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for sending me the ALC.

All opinions are my own.

Wow!! I simply could not stop listening to this story. julie Soto could have made this an 100hr long audiobook and I would have been hanging on every word!! Unfortunately, now I have to wait patiently for the next book in the series! I was left with so many questions. This definitely had some darker elements, so check content warnings. I was captivated by the story of strength, perseverance, and the will to keep fighting even when the outcome looks bleak. Told in alternating timelines, this allows the reader to get glimpse of the whole story from past and present. I am invested in Briony and Toven’s relationship and how it is going to progress! Julie Soto you can just go ahead and publish the next one now!

This was one of my most anticipated reads of the year, and I’m so happy to say it didn’t disappoint!

As someone who did my due diligence and read the original version (if you know, you know), I was delighted to see how Julie Soto blended familiar elements with fresh twists. It honestly felt like a fun literary scavenger hunt trying to match up who was who while reading and listening. While I didn't feel the same level of stress or emotional tension as I did with the original (likely because I knew the major beats), I was still deeply invested in the characters and their journey.

I’m really enjoying how Julie is building out the world and magic system here. I know some readers might not be totally sold on it, but personally, I'm just here for the vibes—and they are very good. The romance delivers in classic Julie Soto fashion: secret pining, enemies-to-lovers tension, and that delicious touch her and die energy that never fails to hit.

The twist at the end caught me off guard in the best way. It’s something new that wasn’t in the original, and I’m super intrigued to see how it develops in the next installment.

I’m not someone who tends to analyze every detail or look for deeper meaning—I just want a swoony, angsty, well-written romance—and Rose in Chains absolutely delivered. I’m impatiently counting down the days until book two.

Huge thanks to NetGalley and Hachette Audio for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

4.5
AT FIRST I struggled. The world-building felt excessive and didn't quite gel, with too many characters that didn't contribute to the story. The pacing was slow, and I found myself waiting for something to happen. Even at the 40% mark, the main characters hadn't really interacted much, which was frustrating.

However, things took a dramatic turn for the better in Part 2, by Part 3, I completely fell in love with the book. I'm so glad I stuck with it, because now I'm eagerly anticipating Book 2.

The romance is beautifully written, and I'm invested in the slow burn. One of the highlights was the spilled whiskey scene - 🎬 smoking hot! 🥵 I'm also craving more of Tovin’s POV; I want to know what he's thinking. The payoff was worth the slow start, and I'm so happy I pushed through it.

Such a good romantasy. Any Dramione fans need to read this!

"The war is over, the dark forces have won, and the hero who was supposed to save them is dead."

Briony is captured after Heart Magicians take over her kingdom. She is stripped of her Mind Magic and auctioned off to the highest bidder. She ends up being sold to Toven, who is part of a powerful Heart Magic family known for their dark magic.

I loved reading this book! It was truly one I could just dive into, completely sucked into the world. I cannot wait for the next book in the series!

The audiobook was fairly well done, but I wasn't a huge fan of the narrator's male voices. I am already thinking I will reread with my eyeballs, rather than on audio.

Tropes:
* Enemies to Lovers
* Dramione vibes
* Magic
* Animal Familiars
* War Captives
* Rival Kingdoms
* Political Intrigue

5 stars!

Oh my goodness! This ALC was AMAZING. I didn't realize that Julie Soto was a "fan-fic girlie" before a fellow bookish friend shared that little piece of gold with me. This story was FULL of epic fantasy moments. The narrator's accent (and character's voices) really brought this story to LIFE. I'm still giddy at having an early copy of this audio. TEN of five stars! "You're not a gentleman, Tovan" sent me to giggles. My mouth dropped to the floor multiple times in awe and shock. This gal cannot wait for MORE BOOKS! Can you get them to me now?! Screaming from the rooftops in magic love and OG HP feels! Thank you Julie Soto, NetGalley and Hatchette audio for my very first ALC on NetGalley. I’m HOOKED!!

This was such a good book. I loved the story and the writing so much. The characters were great and the story flowed smoothly. Will definitely read more books by this author in the future.

Rose in Chains is mysterious and moody - a “can’t-put-it-down” kind of read.

Briony Rosewood has been captured, her twin brother and heir to the throne has been killed, and her magic taken away. To make it worse, she’s been taken captive by. . . her childhood crush! Play End Game by Taylor Swift because “Ooh, you and me, we'd be a big conversation” is the soundtrack of this book. His family has ambitious goals that might happen at Briony’s expense, but she’s no damsel in distress.

Julie Soto captures so much magic in this story and I think the audiobook adds another level.

The production is phenomenal and I can’t give enough kudos to the voice actress for the great work she did to bring this story to life. The narration illustrates the story without getting in the way of the author’s work, and I would definitely listen to other audiobooks read by this narrator in the future.

Thank you to Hachette Audio, Forever Publishing, Julie Soto, and NetGalley for the audio ARC in exchange for a review!

hands down one of my favorite books of the year so far! i really enjoyed this world & the magic system as well as the political intrigue! the tension was tensioning & i found myself giggling at multiple points! this story was just so unique for a romantasy & i cannot wait for the next installments! 🍇

thank you to netgalley & hachette audio for the early listener copy!