Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Sweetly illustrated, with text that will grow with your child, this classic story is told in a way that parents and little ones alike will enjoy. A great one to keep in your library.
*I received a complimentary copy of this e-book from Barbour Publishing through NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully done pictures. I loved how the animals looked almost realistic throughout the book. Well told beloved story. Will definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

More than just your basic retelling of the Nativity story, this book provides small snippets throughout the book that are educational and explain the story from the timeframe of Jesus. Explanations include the work/trade of a carpenter, the design of a manager, commons type of sheep in Israel, etc. The book also highlights many concepts/ideas that are included in the Nativity story but aren't specifically mentioned in the Bible but could be plausible for this time (Mary riding a donkey, Wise Men riding camels, etc.)

This is a great book for sharing the Nativity/First Christmas story and teaching children more details and the history at the time of of Jesus' birth.

Was this review helpful?

This lovely telling of the Christmas story is aimed at children, probably in the 4-10 year range, but its quiet approach will appeal to all ages. The illustrations have a simple style that matches the bits of historical context that are included to pique a child's interest without overwhelming them. There is a confidence in God as a loving being, yet without religiosity.

Was this review helpful?

Great illustrations. A child friendly version of the Christmas story with interesting historical, scientific, and geographic facts about the Biblical Christmas story. More suited for older children. Thanks to NetGalley and Zonderkidz for the early digital copy.

Was this review helpful?

Cute illustrations and a sweet, basic retelling of the Christmas story. There were also some interesting facts and background information scattered throughout the pages.

Was this review helpful?

The Wonders of the First Christmas by Andy McGuire is a children’s book coming out in October this year. I was struck by the historical accuracy and the definitions of customs of the times. Between the explanation of Roman rulers and gifts from the wise men and even how much a camel can drink, I found this book quite refreshing and interesting, as I’m sure so many children will as well. I highly recommend this book.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions expressed are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

These illustrations were GORGEOUS. My 3 year old boy loved learning about the birth of our Savior. He wasn't old enough to appreciate some of the facts but he liked to point out things in the pictures and asked a lot of questions.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Zonderkidz for an advanced reading copy of this book. It will be released to publishers on October 7, 2025.

The wonders of the first Christmas is great for upper elementary students who want to find out more about the first Christmas, from a biblical standpoint to a historical standpoint.

A great buy for parents and church leaders!

Was this review helpful?

this is a retelling of the nativity story, lovely book, enjoyed the illustrations and the story. would highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

Thank you ZonderKidz for allowing me to read and review The Wonders of the First Christmas (Explore the Birth of Jesus through History, Archaeology, and Art) by Andy McGuire on NetGalley.

Published: 10/07/25

Stars: 4

McGuire traditionally tells the birth of Jesus with muted colored illustrations respectfully done. In addition, he gives explanations and definitions of terms that relate to the times.

The formatting caught my attention. There is the story itself, and throughout the pages are information boxes. I liked the setup.

Giftable.

Was this review helpful?

As an adult, this Christmas story didn’t add much that I didn’t already know; however, I appreciated the fun animal facts sprinkled in. I always loved how animals are featured in the story, and our own family nativity has more animals than people peering down at baby Jesus. The illustrations in this book were absolutely lovely and done up in calming and peaceful colors. This would be a wonderful addition to a child’s personal library.

Thank you to Zonderkidz and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Well written and kept the retelling of the account of the birth of Jesus simple. The account says that the word translated a carpenter more likely means builder and that Joseph probably worked building houses which meant he worked with stones. I can find some info on this online but not much and the bibliography is vague. At there risk of being overly critical, I will share that there is reference to "wild ass" meaning a type of donkey- some families will object to this and there was no reason to include that random reference: "Donkeys are ancestors of the African wild ass, which has stripes on its legs like a zebra." The book says the shepherds were watching their sheep but the illustration shows a shepherd clearly sleeping on top of a rock- I'm sure they did sleep now and then lol but it seems unnecessary to show that in this context. The book doesn't address the "how many wise men were there?" aspect and shows 3 travelers. It does point out that they probably didn't visit Jesus as an infant and that he was more likely 2 or 3 years old.
Thank you to Netgalley and Zonderkidz for providing a digital copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

As a lifelong Christian but one who has not read The Bible completely, I like to read biblical stories that are set at a child’s level. This helps me to ensure understanding of difficult concepts even though I am an avid reader who reads at a collegiate level. But, when it comes to The Bible, I just feel better absorbing the stories at a child’s level. So, I was more than happy to review this new children’s book that explores the story of The Nativity from new and different aspects.

What first enticed me to the book was the illustrations and I really enjoyed the artwork with its muted soft tones throughout the story. But I also enjoyed all of the new information regarding what was considered a manger during this time period and that all the “inns” were actually second-floor guest rooms that were full. And that Jesus was more likely born on the first floor of one of these buildings because that is where the animals were housed. I enjoyed learning about the shepherds and the wise men and how angels are truly represented in The Bible.

I liked that this story takes you beyond just the night of Christ’s birth into His early years and the reason for His family’s flight into Egypt. And the information regarding all of the different animals is insightful and relevant teaching to the age group for which this book is intended.

My only issue with this being a children’s book was the word “kill” as regards Herod wanting to assassinate Jesus as a baby. I thought maybe “harm” would be a better word. But my husband, who has read The Bible in its entirety, believes this is perfectly normal biblical language and not too harsh for today’s children.

So, as a parent or grandparent who might be reading this book to a young child, just know that Herod’s feelings toward Jesus are explored. Otherwise, I found this book to be a lovely and well-researched inclusion into the story of Jesus’ conception and birth.

Thank you to Netgalley for my advanced digital copy. All thoughts and opinions are expressly my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Wonders of the First Christmas by Andy McGuire is a children's book that talks about the birth of Christ and also give some historical information about what some of the references actually meant. It explains a little about the Wise Men, shepherds, and even the manger. This book is a "picture book" that is great for young children, but it also is nice reading for adults and children of all ages. Thank you NetGalley.com.

Was this review helpful?

“The Wonders of the First Christmas”
(Explore the Birth of Jesus through History, Archaeology, and Art) by Andy McGuire
A Very Good 1st Christmas Book
The story is well done as is the art work. The ‘Fact Blocks’ are, for me, what sets this book apart from the others. I would enjoy reading this book with little ones and hear their questions and exclamations, too! Happy Reading ! !

Was this review helpful?

Review of eBook

The Christmas story told with a combination of gorgeous, full-page illustrations, the Gospel text, and historical, biological, and geographic about Israel at the time of the birth of Jesus.

The target audience for this amazing, full-color book is the young reader, ages four through eight, but readers of all ages are certain to appreciate the added facts about Israel at the time of Jesus’s birth and relevant gospel texts. These all work together to strengthen the reader’s understanding of the Christmas story within the context of the world at that time. An exquisite book with an inspiring story sure to strengthen the reader’s faith.

Highly recommended.

I received a free copy of this eBook from Zonderkidz and NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving this review.
#TheWondersoftheFirstChristmas #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

A nice, basic book about the Biblical Christmas story. I appreciate the little helpful historical details included; such as word meanings, translations, cultural context, etc. Some of the info feels a little speculative, and could be confusing to young kids who are just hearing the Christmas story for the first time. But overall its a good book to use as an intro to the Biblical focus of Christmas and Jesus's birth. Most of the illustrations are good, a few are so-so. The map at the end is great-- so many kids books don't have this and its so helpful!

Was this review helpful?

READ - 5:38 PM 7/9/2025 --THIS IS A PRELIMINARY REVIEW, PENDING CORRECTION OF FACTUAL ERROR P.9-- NOTE; THE STAR RATING BELOW WILL *N*O*T* BE PUBLISHED. See notes. I would be delighted to review a revised edition for the 5* rating I believe it deserves.

Started reading as soon as I downloaded. I've had a problem with thorium every time I've tried to use it. Although I was successfully able to read the beautifully illustrated story, when I tried to highlight and use annotations, I ran into a dead end. I sent notes to myself (below) by dictating into my phone.
- - -
The following comments are for the publisher:
P. 9 - QUERY: Are donkeys the ancestor of the African wild ass? AI REPLY: "No, it is the other way around: the African wild ass is the ancestor of the domestic donkey." PLEASE FIX!!!
P. 13 - The illustrations are Charming but I'm afraid I have a problem with a half-inch crew cut on the Christ Child, who appears to be a toddler rather than a newborn.
P. 19 - The illustration of the Christ Child on page 19 is more likely, although the child looks Native American rather than Judaic; and again, rather a lot of hair for a newborn.
PP? - [Maps at the end] LOVED the maps, but a third showing the whole region, to illustrate the locations of Israel versus Egypt would be useful. Also, regarding The Wise Men, traditional pageantry has the wise men showing up at the manger in storytelling rather than historic technique. Depending on the age group this is aimed at, the quibbling about time of arrival might be confusing. It might make more sense for younger children to have the traditional presentation, with footnotes or afterword explaining, as with definitions of stable and manger, the reality of the era, translated into images a modern child could understand.
- - -
Potential review: "A charmingly told story, beautifully illustrated. I loved the maps showing Egypt and Israel as well. Lots to discuss with your children."
- - -
My initial note, for your amusement (capitalization courtesy of my phone's AI): The traditional Pageantry , of course, has the wise men showing up at the manger , and depending on the age This is Aimed at, The Quibbling about Time of arrival Might be Confusing.

Was this review helpful?

What an incredible book. The illustrations are great and the story is so good. I love the story of Jesus being born and in this book I love how there are side note descriptions continually through the book. I highly recommend it!!
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an advanced copy. I will be purchasing it for me and my church.

Was this review helpful?