Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This was my very first time hearing about the Scary Book of Fairy Tales. Being able to hear "The Real Endings to 50 of Your Favorite Stories" was pretty cool. Stories from all over the world. Stories I've heard as a kid. Some that have beautiful and cute endings but these? These stories are dark and full of gore.

It was jaw dropping to hear these stories, to here where they originated from, and how multiple countries may have variations of the same or similar stories. These stories made my skin crawl and stomach turn.

The last story?! This is the very very first time I've ever heard the full story of this one. It gave me the shivers.

I received an ARC of this audiobook from NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

thought this was gonna be a twist on fairytale endings, but is instead just a collection of original fairytales, so ... be aware of that going in.

for the most part, this collection tells of fairytales that we’ve all heard of – cinderella, snow white, rumpelstiltskin, goldilocks, etc. – which was largely underwhelming, though entertaining, since i haven’t heard them in so long. the more interesting ones were ones that i was previously unfamiliar with, from a variety of cultures (italian, romanian, russian, german, french, egyptian, nigerian, japanese, mongolian, brazilian, mexican, etc). granted, they generally don’t have original lessons or premises, but the new (to me) way in which they were presented had me far more interested than the standard ones in disney adaptations.

also dennis kleinman is the narrator and CHEF’S KISS i loved his voice and the way he told the stories sm. i would like him to narrate my life story someday thanks xx.

Was this review helpful?

Tim Rayborn's The Scary Book of Fairy Tales commits the cardinal sin of assuming its readers have been living under a particularly fluffy rock for their entire lives. Apparently, Rayborn believes he's the first person to discover that Cinderella's stepsisters had their feet mutilated and that Hansel and Gretel involves attempted child murder. Breaking news, Tim: some of us actually read the Grimm Brothers before they were sanitized into Disney content.

This book reads like someone who just discovered Wikipedia's "Dark Origins" section and decided to monetize their shock. "Did you KNOW," Rayborn seems to gasp on every page, "that fairy tales used to be VIOLENT?" Well, yes, Tim. Those of us whose parents didn't wrap us in bubble wrap and feed us exclusively bowdlerized bedtime stories are well aware that the original tales make Game of Thrones look like a church picnic.

The author's revolutionary "discovery" that traditional fairy tales contain dark elements is about as groundbreaking as announcing that water is wet. You can find these exact same stories in any respectable Grimm collection, complete with all the gore and psychological trauma that apparently scandalized Rayborn so deeply. Even many children's picture books maintain the original violence – a fact that makes one wonder if the author has actually set foot in a bookstore lately.

The marketing team's decision to slap a "Horror" label on this collection is particularly baffling. Horror fans expecting genuine frights will find themselves more likely to die of boredom than terror. Speaking of dying of boredom, I made the unfortunate decision to experience this as an audiobook. What should have been dramatic retellings of these allegedly shocking tales instead became the most effective insomnia cure I've encountered in years. The narrator's delivery had all the emotional range of a GPS system, somehow managing to make child abandonment and cannibalistic witches sound as thrilling as a grocery list. I found myself checking multiple times to make sure the playback speed hadn't accidentally been set to 0.75x. These tales have all the spine-chilling intensity of a lukewarm cup of chamomile tea.

Save your money and buy a beautifully illustrated edition of the actual Grimm collection instead. At least then you'll get the authentic experience without the condescending narrator acting like he's just invented fire.

Final verdict: A solution in search of a problem, marketed to an audience that probably doesn't exist.

Was this review helpful?

This contains a lot of varied fairy tales/folk tales from around the world, and I think this would be a marvelous read for late elementary or middle schoolers who are wanting to know more about the origins of some of their favorite fairy tales!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley, Tim Rayborn and Neil Evan’s for the ALC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

WOW- so glad I picked this one up! I listened to the whole thing while working on projects. I read a lot of these classic fairytales growing up and forgot how harrowing and brutal some of the endings were. But as explained in the beginning, these stories were for teaching life lessons. We tell children that Santa won’t bring them presents if they aren’t well behaved- similar to how some of these tales warn of not speaking to strangers or roaming about in the woods.

I loved the narrator for this, his voice somewhat reminds me of the narrator for the Haunted Mansion ride- a perfect choice for the eeriness of some these tales.

Overall this is a fun listen.
Thank you for allowing me to review your work.
Valkyrie

Was this review helpful?

Feel like the Brothers Grimm had something? Feel like you miss how The Little Mermaid suffered and died a horrible death – and that should have been how the Disney movie ended. Well, you will enjoy this one. The author has taken 50 of your favorite fairytales and given them gruesome, unhappy endings. Well, for some of the characters. I would argue that others have pretty happy endings in a twisted way. Gold stars to the ending of Hansel and Gretel. If you love scary things and fairy tales, this is for you.

On an aside, the artwork in this one is gorgeous and really brings out the macabre of the stories.

The narrator did so well in this - and brough the right amount of whimsey and creepiness. This is a great listen for you horror fantasy lovers out there.

Was this review helpful?