Cover Image: The Heart

The Heart

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

There was much to enjoy here, but I found I couldn't connect with it. I'd read more from this author in the future though.

Was this review helpful?

I selected this novel for the Read Around the World Challenge, The Heart is the work of French author Maylis de Kerangel translated into English by Sam Taylor.

Three young men are on their way home from an early morning surf when they are involved in a devastating accident. Simon Limbres is thrown through the windscreen, and is declared brain dead, though his heart is still beating.

Set over the next 24 hours, The Heart illuminates Simon’s journey between life and death. As Simon’s parents, Marianne and Sean, try to come to grips with their nightmarish reality, we are given a window into the lives of those with whom he intersects, from that of the Coordinating Committee for Organ and Tissue Removal who must broach the delicate subject of donation, to Claire, who is waiting for a miracle.

Kerangal’s writing is at times quite exquisite, however I often struggled with the style of prose. With page long sentences, a complete lack of speech marks, and sometimes an odd rhythm, I thought that the translation may have played a part, but I’m assured that it is faithful to the original (Sam Taylor won an award for it).

I believe strongly in the value of organ donation. I’m a registered donor and actively encourage family and friends to be also, so I feel that The Heart bears an important message.

“Simon’s heart was migrating to one part of the country, his kidneys, liver, and lungs entering other regions, rushing toward other bodies. What would remain, in this fragmentation, of the unity of her son? How could she attach her singular memory to that diffracted body? What will become of his presence, of his reflection on earth, of his ghost? These questions circle her like fiery hoops, and then Simon’s face forms before her eyes, intact and unique. He is irreducible; he is Simon. She feels a deep sense of calm.”

For the literary high-minded, The Heart will likely draw praise, but I’m afraid for most of us, myself included, the authors stylistic quirks will be too off-putting to truly appreciate it.

Was this review helpful?

This book felt very French in tone-almost academic, a somewhat verbose intelligent detachment which dwells in details in order to explore and define. At times, I wondered if we were going to get some plot but I also became intrigued by unexpected details so I felt like my attention was being rewarded. I appreciate the lack of melancholy but I wonder if it relies a lot on the symbolism of the heart to evoke an emotional response. Since I personally don't subscribe to the symbolism of the heart organ, I found myself wondering if getting to know Simon before hand would have brought me more into the emotional upheaval of the novel.

Was this review helpful?