Skip to main content

Member Reviews

It's definitely an interesting concept. *spoilers*

I liked the part where he was blind much more than the part where he could see. It seemed like Will just expected the universe to grant him immediate understanding of a new sense as a reward for having been blind, and he was put out when he realized it was something he was going to have to learn and adjust to.

Was this review helpful?

After reading the synopsis, I was set on reading this book. After reading the first few pages, I was a little concerned it was going to be another one of those after school cornfests ( I secretly love those, so it's okay)...but I'm glad this was so much more.

Love and First Sight is about Will Porter and his life as a blind teenager. After coming from a special school where all the kids also had visual impairments of one sort or another, he ends up going to a mainstream high school where he encounters things like never before. He befriends a small group of quirky teens and fits in just perfectly.

The way Will changes and grows throughout the story is wonderful and I especially love how the author did quite a bit of research about blindness and the changes one would face if they went through what Will had.

I will be recommending this to many and gifting to some. :)

Was this review helpful?

I received an eARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Will was born blind and has been sheltered by his parents since the "Incident" when he was still a small child. After the incident he was sent to a boarding school for the blind where he grew to master the skills necessary to survive in the sighted world. Now that he's sixteen he wants to enroll at a mainstream high school. The descriptions Sundquist uses to describe the sensation of blindness and how everyone still uses sight based explanations to describe things they think are being made perfectly clear is really interesting. The characterizations of the other cast of kids are pretty standard and don't really engage the reader. Much of it is predictable, but that doesn't stop it from being a fun read. I've ordered it for my library.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. I loved reading about Will and his friends. I am glad he was able to have the surgery and get his eyesight. I am slo glad he was able to be with Cecily.

I think fans of John Green would enjoy this book.

Was this review helpful?

I laughed and gasped throughout this book. It was if you were on the adventure with them for each situation, wanting to help, warn or celebrate their fates. Thank you for allowing us to experience such a delightful read.

Was this review helpful?

Love and First Sight by Josh Sundquist is a sweet YA story that follows a young man named Will, who is blind. He finally transfers out of the blind school and into a regular high school where he wants to live as easily as he can--even in the face of people who constantly want to help him with things he can do on his own. During his time at the new school, he makes friends and tries new things, like journalism. But when he's offered the chance for a life-changing surgery that has the possibility of giving him sight he's never had before, will he take it?

This is a story that is filled with a lot of stereotype-busting about the blind and provides a picture of how blindness doesn't make people as different as they appear to be because of their ability to adapt their other senses. However, the narrator does seem to be a bit long-winded at times, wanting to give big explanations to the reader for the things he's about to do. Other than that, this is a great story.

Was this review helpful?

I first discovered Josh Sundquist by reading his memoir, and giggling the entire way through it. I'm not generally a non-fiction reader, but I devoured that book. That meant that when I found out that Sundquist had written a YA book, I knew I had to read it. I couldn't wait to see how his wit and honesty translated to a fiction novel.

First off, I have to give credit where credit is due. It's very obvious from the first few pages of this story that Sundquist did a tremendous amount of research on visual impairment, and worked hard to make sure that he was accurately portraying Will's day to day routine. Pair that with a lovingly crafted character, complete with Sundquist's signature wit, and you have a story that is a joy to read. I fell in love with Will, and the rest was history.

When the experimental surgery came into the picture, I found myself riveted. Everything was described in intricate detail, but it never felt overbearing. Instead, I found myself in the same situation as Will. Wondering if the surgery would be worth it, cheering him on when he was doing well, and lamenting with him when things weren't going well. His parents were so wonderfully supportive, if a little over involved at times, and there was this whole aura of growth and love to this book. It was a happy place to be.

Even if the friendship turned romance hadn't been a main portion of this book, I would have still loved it. Still, I couldn't help but fall for the slow growth of Cecily and Will's relationship. Cecily's acceptance of Will, her ability to open things up for him with wonderful analogies, tugged at my heart strings. I knew that fight was imminent, and of course I was right. What is YA without teenage tension? Still, it all felt so perfect. Not a single sentence of this book felt out of place. It all worked to build up Will, and show how amazing a person he was.

I'd highly recommend this for your reading list! If it's not there already, it's well worth a second look.

Was this review helpful?

This was so cute and funny. I've never read a book from a blind person's point of view and found this very interesting. I really didn't think I would enjoy this as much as I did. I loved that Will was able to make friends so easily and none of them cared that he was blind. Everyone was really supportive of him and that is something I love seeing in books. More often then not we see people bring others down or bully scenarios more than supportive roles taking the lead.

After the surgery I was glad to see Will struggle a little bit with grasping sight for the first time. As bad as that sounds it's realistic and that made it better in my opinion. He obviously got the hang of it eventually but being able to read about someone growing and changing in such a huge way was very humbling. I rooted for Will every step of the way and couldn't even begin to imagine what it must have been like to go through such a transformation.

Was this review helpful?

I figured this would be a quick but silly read, but I was wrong about the silly part. Will is a newly mainstream 16 year old blind kid. He was born blind and has always attended the blind school. now he has to/gets to try to make his way in his new public high school. This is YA but it's also wonderful. Josh Sundquist did so much research to try to understand blindness and blind culture. as someone who is newly aware of impairments of this nature, I found this book both fascinating and wonderful.

Was this review helpful?

High school is hard enough, but imagine going through it blind. Will is going to a new mainstream high school for the first time. He is the only blind student there. As he learns to navigate the school and make friends he learns that there is an operation that could give him sight. What he doesn't know is how hard the results can be and how it will affect his new friendships and himself.
This is a great new book, with a perspective I have never seen. I found myself loving Will and his friends. I feel like I learned a lot from this book too on being blind and all the complicated steps to having sight (if it's a possibility). This was a lighthearted read, but touched on deep high school issues. I think many students will be able to relate to this book, just in dealing with the stresses of school and being bullied. Not everyone can relate to being blind in high school. I felt the author did a great job of helping us "see" as Will sees and really helping us get a feel for what he was going through.
I thoroughly enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

Love this book! The flow, the sounds, the incredible insight, it's compelling and genuine. Five stars

Was this review helpful?

What first stood out to me while reading this book, is that Josh did a ton of research regarding the topic of blindness. There were sections where a lot of medical jargon was thrown around, but as a reader I could understand what was being said. This was only because it was explained so well.
Will was an amazing character. He was extremely witty, and had an amazing take on things. He also had such a great sense of humor it was hard not to laugh along with the things he said. I thought the side characters were solid. I loved that Will's parents were really involved in his life and in the story in general. I could feel his mom's hope and other emotions through Josh's writing, and I just loved that. Cecily was a great side character, she was extremely insecure about her looks, but Will couldn't tell by talking to her, which was a plus.
Overall I loved Josh's writing style and how easily the story flowed. I loved the whole premise of the book mainly because it was a topic I knew little to nothing about. Josh made you feel his characters emotions through his writing and it was simply beautiful. I would highly recommend this book it you are looking for a different kind of contemporary read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the opportunity to read & review this book. Unfortunately, I did not get to download this galley before it was archived. I look forward to working together on future titles!

Was this review helpful?

Love and First Sight by Josh Sundquist was a book that I would have to say grew on me. The dynamic of the book shifts from that of a blind teenager who has gone from interacting primarily with other blind students to making his way in a normal high school and all the issues that come with it (making friends etc.), to a story of seeing for the first time and how that can effect perceptions and relationships. The book ends with a whirlwind adventure of sights, friendship and romance.

The book started off a bit heavy on the stereotypes, both of blind people and high school for me. Once past the beginning, the relationships Will built with his friends and Cecily took over which brought life to the novel and I began to enjoy it more.

I also appreciated how Josh Sundquist displayed significant research into the field of the blind gaining vision (as supported by the Authors Note).

Overall, Love and First Sight was a good, well-paced, and enjoyable read. There are lessons learned about life, appreciation, and friends that this book emphasizes which should not be missed. I happily recommend.

(I voluntarily reviewed an ARC of this book I received from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for my fair and honest review.)

Was this review helpful?

I have a friend who is blind, so I was interested to see how the author handled things with this book. From what I know of it, it seemed pretty accurate, so he obviously did a lot of research. (Of course, each individual experience will be different, each attitude and how they view things. I'm talking about things like how someone without sight might prefer to be guided, or how they typically get from point A to point B.)

What made this book particularly interesting to me was having things described in such a flat dimensional way - because he wouldn't understand things like perspective or how some shapes look different depending on the angle you view them from. It was intriguing to have things explained in such a way that I could "see it" from a non-sight perspective.

Some parts of this book seemed a little orchestrated - and I didn't always believe things would happen the way they happened. Mainly this was concerning Cecily's appearance. It was obvious based on things other characters said and things that happened around him, that there was something they weren't telling him. Yet he never picks up on all these clues. Someone who is blind would probably be *better* at picking up these clues, not worse. Maybe that's just my opinion though.

I enjoyed reading it. It was quick and interesting. I liked how things ended. My appreciation goes to the publisher for sending me an advanced copy for review.

Was this review helpful?

I was pretty excited to see Josh Sunquist diving into YA fiction. Sundquist's <i>We Should Hang Out Sometime</i> was a great, relatable memoir, and seeing a book that might have some of his signature humor and storytelling in fiction form was fun to see. The book isn't perfect, but it ends up being a fairly pleasant read nonetheless.

In this book, Will is a blind student entering a regular school for the first time. He's able to be largely independent, but he makes a series of mistakes that start things off weird, but he quickly settles in with a group of people and ends up falling for a girl. The girl is guarded, but when Josh receives a chance to take part in an experimental treatment that could give him sight, he's forced to confront a lot of what he thinks he knows.

It's an interesting story, for sure, and has a lot of good, basic messages about disability and acceptance that aren't a bludgeon. The writing itself is kind of simple, which is maybe a drawback for some but worked for the story being told, and the end result of a surprising science fiction element of sorts made it even more enjoyable for me, personally. I'm not entirely sure whether this will work for all audiences, but with the rise of disability lit throughout, this definitely deserves to be part of the broader conversation. Absolutely worth a look.

Was this review helpful?

Pleasantly surprised by this book. Having read a Josh Sundquist's memoir, and knowing about his friendship with author John Green, I was fully expecting this book to have a The Fault in Our Stars vibe. But the characters felt very real, and the situations were crafted carefully and with research and attention to detail. I would recommend this book to Young Adults.

Was this review helpful?

I love this book!

Will is a wonderfully flawed and believable character. His irritation at the manner with which sighted people describe things to him was spot on. The unfolding of his relationship with Cecily happened so naturally that readers will likely find themselves fully immersed and expecting Will and Cecily to still be together in twenty or thirty years.

One part that irked me was Will's reaction to Cecily's "secret". I felt that his reaction was somewhat unrealistic and more melodramatic than was necessary. As a whole though this was a minor complaint, and I found myself more sympathetic as the book continued.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful, funny, novel about really learning to see. Will is such an amazingly developed character that you just want to keep reading about him.

Was this review helpful?

Will has been blind since birth. After an incident where he was taken advantage of, his parents sent him to a special school for the blind. But now he's decided that he wants to be independent, and Will believes the best way to prove that he can be independent is to go to a normal school. What Will doesn't expect is to find a group of friends that he feel more like family. And maybe even more.

Cecily is first introduced when she runs out of the classroom crying on Will's first day because he was "staring" at her. Only he wasn't staring...because he can't see. But she didn't know that. Will and Cecily end up becoming friends and feelings start to develop. I really enjoyed seeing how Cecily and Will learned to relate to each other. Cecily trying to describe the things that she sees--a painting, a sunrise, etc. She's a photographer so all things visual are especially meaningful for her. And Will trying to explain to Cecily what he can understand and perceive and what he can't.

What neither one of them expects is for an opportunity to arise for Will to have an experimental surgery that might result in him getting his eyesight. This isn't a spoiler because of the title and because of the description, but Will does get his sight. But things that we take for granted daily are things that his eyes and his brain do not recognize. Shapes. Colors. People. He is starting from scratch. Part of this was frustrating for me because I don't always handle books with an excessive amount of description, but I also found myself fascinated because I did just kind of assume that once his eyes were medically fixed then he could just...well...see (and understand). So it was interesting to watch him learn basically the same things that my one year old daughter is learning (shapes and colors, names for objects etc).

Things aren't all blue skies and rainbows for Will and Cecily though. Cecily has been keeping a secret. I was intrigued by this part of the description. What could be the thing Cecily was keeping from Will? Is she "ugly"? Overweight? And what kind of person is Will that it matters to him? Ultimately, I was okay with how Josh Sundquist worked this part of the story. I was never completely surprised by Cecily's secret. And Will's feelings actually turned out to be fairly understandable.

Favorite quotes:
-"Your inability to see doesn't stop your face from speaking what's on your mind."

-"Are your people maybe sensitive to sunlight?" "I think you are getting us confused with vampires."

-"I always expected yellow would be...quieter."

Love and First Sight was a fun read that kept me hooked into the story. I enjoyed the characters (main and secondary). And I was particularly fascinated by Will's journey in gaining his sight. As an added bonus, this book doesn't have any potty mouth which I really appreciated. Love and First Sight gets 4 Stars. Have you read Love and First Sight? What did you think? Let me know!

Was this review helpful?