Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thanks Netgalley for this ARC.

Lisa See did it again! "The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane" definitely has the Lisa See winning formula. The book explores the Ahka, an ethnic minority group living in a mountainous region of China famous for its ancient tea trees. We meet the main character at a young age and over twenty years we share some of her most intimate experience.

Once again Lisa See introduces us to the culture of a group of people we have never known about. We learn about their history, customs, food and way of life throughout the course of this book. What a great cultural experience- and I didn't even have to take a plane!

That is the one thing I love about Lisa See's book- the way she is able to take her readers on a cultural journey, where they not only entertained, but where they learn so much.

Another great novel by Lisa See!

Was this review helpful?

The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane is a well-written story about a part of the world that I admittedly knew little about. I couldn't definitely see why people would give this four or five stars, but this type of book just isn't my cup of tea (sorry, not sorry for the pun).

Was this review helpful?

Lisa See will be at The Bookstall on Monday, April 3rd at 2:00pm in a program co-sponsored by the Women's Exchange which is such a great local organization. See, of course, is the best-selling author of titles like Snow Flower and the Secret Fan and Dreams of Joy. Her latest, THE TEA GIRL OF HUMMINGBIRD LANE, is about Li-yan, a member of the Akha minority from Yunnan province, in China's Southwest. Fate, spirits, and omens are all important in her culture, as is the local tea trade. Eventually, Li-yan has a daughter out of wedlock who is given up for adoption, named Haley, and raised in California by Caucasian parents. Yet, mother and daughter seek to find each other in this emotional story which Library Journal says, "deftly confronts the changing role of minority women, majority-minority relations, East-West adoption, and the economy of tea in modern China." Like See's previous works, there is clearly much to explore and the publisher provides a book club reading guide for THE TEA GIRL OF HUMMINGBIRD LANE. I will definitely be recommending this new book and it will certainly appear on next year's Junior Theme list. In addition to meeting Lisa See, you can read an excerpt on the author's website.

LINKS in the live post:
http://www.thebookstall.com/ AND
http://www.womens-exchange.org/ AND
http://www.simonandschuster.com/books/The-Tea-Girl-of-Hummingbird-Lane/Lisa-See/9781501154829/reading_group_guide#rgg AND
http://www.lisasee.com/books-new/the-tea-girl-of-hummingbird-lane/tea-girl-of-hummingbird-lane-sample-chapter/

Was this review helpful?

Historically accurate and compelling, Ms. See has written another well-researched novel. The Akha people of China are fully immersed in the growing of tea, all family members involved. Family secrets, aspirations, tragedy...it is all here and written in beautiful flowing language. Recommended.

Was this review helpful?

I am addicted to Lisa See's books -- I pick up pretty much each new one that comes out. I love the way she focuses in on time periods and cultures I know little or nothing about and brings them to life through memorable characters.

In this book, she takes on the Akha people, an indigenous tribe of China, who are also found throughout Southeast Asia. In China, they live in the mountainous tea-growing region of Yunnan province.

This story takes place in the present day, beginning in the 1990s, but in the beginning it's hard to remember that. Because of Communist policies of cultural preservation, the Akha people live fairly isolated lives, and continue the cultural traditions spanning back years. There is a superstition and a ritual for almost everything, and the slightest deviation from the norm is considered dangerous and some sins (like giving birth to twins) can result in outright exile from the tribe.

Our main character, Li-Yan, is born into one of these tribes and grows up steeped in tea culture and traditional ways until she finds herself in a bind - she becomes pregnant and her would-be husband has gone to Thailand to seek his fortune and never came back. In order to save herself from exile, she has her daughter in secret and gives her up for adoption.

From there we follow Li-Yan's journey from a simple tribal woman who endures many hardships to become a wealthy tea entrepreneur with an international lifestyle, and a fancy house in Pasadena. We also follow her daughter Haley as she grows up with a middle class white family in Southern California, grateful for her privileged life but unable to repress the urge to know where she comes from. The only clue to her origins is a tea cake that was left with her from adoption.

It's a fascinating read that touches on not just the life and circumstances of the Akha people in China, but also goes in depth on the origins, process and economy of pu-erh tea - the fermented tea cakes that are highly prized by tea enthusiasts. If there is a con, it's that the book is so highly researched and at times it feels that See wanted to include everything she learned and wasn't able to edit herself. This results in several "info dumps" that interrupt the story, rather than appear naturally within it and these can grow a bit tedious. I think I personally would have jettisoned these sections in favor of more character development for Haley. By the time we enter her point of view as a young adult, it's hard to feel as if we know her, since her story has been told entirely through third party sources - doctor's reports, group therapy transcripts, etc -- many of which focus more on the general experience of an international adoptee than on Haley as a character in her own right.

But if you have any interest in the subject matter, it's well worth the read, and the character of Li-Yan (and her mother) will stick with you for a while.

Was this review helpful?

Just finished reading yesterday! Loved it. Will be back with my full review soon. Hopefully today or tomorrow!

Was this review helpful?

This is my most highly anticipated book of 2017. In fact, I've been anticipating this book since shortly after Lisa See's last book, China Girls came out in 2014. To say , it was a disappointment is kind of an understatement. I have 3 of the 4 Lisa See books that I read and the adoption angle in this book really had me intrigued, but unfortunately even the adoption story was not enough to win me over on this one. This story went too into the technical aspects of tea production and just did not hold my interest in that regard. Whenever the story seemed to start getting good, Ms. See started back on the technical and historical aspects of tea. The historical aspects of tea in China and among the minority group, the Akhas, would have been fine and it is evident that much research was done, but every aspect of tea making that was learned did not have to be explained to us. Ms. See's stories are well loved for their historical storytelling and character development. I felt the although the characters were pretty well-developed and most of the storytelling was well done, it could have been so much better. The ending seemed rushed, like the length of the story was realized and an ending was quickly written. I don't want to get into the ending anymore, because I don't want to spoil the story. Although, I am glad to have read the story, I just find there to be something lacking from this story, but I do look forward to Lisa See's next book.

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me a ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Book review: Sip tea while you savor Lisa See's latest novel
By SANDY MAHAFFEY THE FREE LANCE–STAR

Traditions, heritage, superstitions, sacrifices and rituals all play important roles in Lisa See’s “The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane,” but tea is at its heart. It takes place in a more modern time than most of her other books, but still delivers wonderful insight into the old traditions.

Li-Yan and her family, members of the Akha hill tribe, live in a remote village of the Hunnan region of China. Their lives revolve around the seasons, as they are tea farmers.

Although the story begins in 1988, their village is so far from modern civilization that they are still ruled by superstitions and archaic millennium traditions such as only one child per family and twins viewed as human rejects who must be killed. Li-Yan’s story is one of a girl breeching the divide between the old traditions and the modern world. There are moments of heartbreak and pure joy.

She will inherit a very special grove of tea trees passed down the women in her family. One tree in the well-hidden grove is a source of the rare Pu’er’ tea, but things become more complicated when she has a child out of wedlock. Her mother assists her in getting the baby girl safely to an orphanage, but Li-Yan is banned from the village.

See masterfully guides the reader through Li-Yan’s journey from the old traditions to the modern world of tea. (Her research into tea is amazing.) But at the same time, she follows her daughter Haley, who was adopted by an American family, and is struggling to find her identity. The passage of time reveals parallels and coincidences which are not only fascinating but very satisfying as well. Her characters really do come alive on the pages.

This is a beautifully written, compelling novel, which takes one deep into the complicated world of tea growing and brewing. It’s the perfect companion to sipping a cup of your favorite brew.

Sandy Mahaffey
is former Books editor at The Free Lance–Star.
More Information

THE TEA GIRL OF HUMMINGBIRD LANE

By Lisa See

(Scribner, $27, 384 pp.)

Publication: March 21

Tags
Lisa Ethnology Literature Folklore Tradition Tea Food Trees Li-yan Superstition Grove

Was this review helpful?

In this novel Lisa See introduces us to the life of Li-yan, born in the remote tea growing mountains of Yunnan province in southern China. Her people, the Akha are a minority race living a marginal hand to mouth existence growing and picking tea to sell their local tea centre. Although the story starts in the 1980s, the Akha are still living a very basic village life without running water and electricity. The tribe have many traditions and beliefs about spirits and life and death. Li-yan’s mother is the village midwife and herbalist and hopes that Li-yan will follow in her footsteps. However, Li-yan is one of the first of her tribe to stay on at school and has hopes of attending University or college. But all her plans are disrupted when a wealthy stranger comes to her village looking for a very special fermented tea called Pu’er. She also falls in love with a boy from a nearby village and when she becomes pregnant, must have the baby in secret and abandon her in the nearest town in the hope an orphanage will take her in.

As with Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, Lisa See excels at immersing us Li-yan’s world. Her research into the way of life of the Akha and their beliefs and rituals is extensive as is her knowledge of the world of tea and Pu’er. As Li-yan herself pulls herself out of despair to learn about tea, she still longs for her baby now growing up on the other side of the world. As well as being a tale of the struggle of a primitive tribe to enter the modern world, with all the good and bad that that entails, it is also a story of friendship and betrayal, greed and generosity and the eternal bonds between mothers and daughters. With beautiful prose and great characters there is a lot more to this novel than the tale of a tea girl.

Was this review helpful?

I wish I could give this book more than 5 stars. I am fascinated by historical fiction and love when books like this have so many actual facts. Written by a Chinese American woman,The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane. Is absolutely amazing and sure to blow you away. I love reading all about the Chinese culture and beliefs including following what they believe their dreams tell them to do. Full of superstitions and what they must do to not have the spirits harm them. Fascinating reading about the growing and harvesting and different grades of teas in China. Two parallel stories about a young Chinese woman who has a daughter when she is unmarried. She must give the baby to an orphanage and (leaves something with her baby that affects her whole life as she grows and matures )then she marries the baby's father. Her and her husband return to the orphanage to claim the baby and find the baby has been adopted by an American couple. At the same time it tells of the baby's life as she grows and matures in America and the struggles she goes through not looking like her adoptive parents and feeling different than the other Chinese children in her school and neighborhood. When the girl matures she thinks about her birth mother all the time and tries desperately to find her. Meanwhile the birth mother regrets giving up her baby and spends much time trying to find her as well. I suggest you read this book, I believe you'll be as fascinated as I was! Pub Date 21 Mar 2017
Thank you to NetGalley and Scribner for a review copy of this book for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Absorbed from go to whoa!

A powerful story woven around the Akha people, a Chinese ethnic minority, their culture and customs, the developing market of rare teas, and the adoption of children from China by Americans.
The story of Li-yan's life as a girl, her ambitions always surrounded by the religious and cultural mores of her Yunnan village is amazing. When she falls pregnant she gives birth in secret and leaves her child at an orphanage, wrapped in a blanket with only a tea cake from the secret female family tea grove. From there the story of her daughter Haley continues. However we constantly come back to Li-Yan's journey...and tea.
Haley is adopted by a Californian couple and her story here is filled with coincidences that verge on the mystical, especially as she pursues her chosen career.
I was engrossed in all that happened to Li-Yan and those of her village. Tea is a central motif, the cross roads that brings things to a head, opens up new challenges, endangers family secrets, and brings birth mother and daughter together.
An amazing and engrossing story that gives light to a little known people, and life to a story that will endure.
One of my best reads for 2017 thus far.

A NetGalley ARC
(March 2017)

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars (although I was willing to give it a solid 4 up until the end)
I should have gone to bed hours ago, but I couldn't put this down...which made the unsatisfying ending all the more disappointing. True, the Thing that I desperately wanted to happen <i>did</i> happen, but it happened in such rushed manner that I felt cheated. And that's how it ends! No exploration of how the Thing affects the characters, or anything that happens after. It happens and...that's it. Nothing more.
Not cool.
I'm working with an egalley, mind you, but a very polished one that looks ready for publication, and I highly doubt that another chapter or an epilogue were added before it was published. I need closure, and if this is an attempt to create a sequel hook, it was done poorly.
There are a few other things you might want to know going in:
1. <i>This is not a happy book</i>. It is probably the most depressing thing I have read for some time. Here's a list of some of the tragedies you have to look forward to if you decide to pick this up: SPOILER/TW babies dying in horrible ways (this happens very early on, and I almost abandoned the book at this point); drug addiction; people getting disemboweled by tigers (no, really); lots of animal death; orphanages full of neglected children; and intense feelings of loneliness, isolation, and abandonment.END SPOILER There's probably more, but you get the idea. It's good, but damn, it's a bummer. If you're not in a good place mentally, or are triggered by death, abuse, or substance abuse, stay far away from this one.
2. There will be some science infodumps towards the end. You'll know them when you get to them, and you can skim them. They're interesting, but largely unnecessary, and are given far too much space. Maybe a section full of facts AFTER the story would have been better? They bogged it down a bit, to be honest.
3. I was glad to have some Pu'er/Pu'erh (Numi's Chocolate Pu'erh, which I definitely recommend) on hand, as this book made me crave it like nobody's business. You might want to have some handy too.
4. I'd thought this story would give Li-yan and Haley equal attention, but most of the story was devoted to Li-yan. This is not a good thing or a bad thing, but it's something you should probably be aware of all the same.

Also, this isn't really something you need to know, but I'm going to complain about it anyway: I was not wild about the way "young people" were written. Li-yan felt very real to me, but Haley...not so much. Something about her narration didn't ring true, possibly the fact that the final chapter from her pov made her sound more like a spoiled teenager than a hardcore science major in her twenties researching her thesis. (She just would not calm down about the small furniture. It's small. And plastic. We get it. Hush.)

All in all, I enjoyed this one, but I don't think I would have picked it up had I been able to check out other readers' reviews first; it's largely a sad book, with a bit too much infodumping, and an abrupt, disappointing ending. It also managed to feel both too long and too short at the same time somehow? There's a good story in there, though, if you're willing to overlook its flaws, as well as interesting lessons about tea and the Akha people. This was my first See book, and is unlikely to be my last, despite my complaints.

A big "thank you" to NetGalley and the publisher for letting me read this in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane sounds like just another pretty name, when you first spot it. It brings promise, as does the author's well-known name, Lisa See. A promise of secrets, twilight and fantastic cultures it might take you too.

I'm going to tell you that it delivers. Brace yourselves for this book.

First of all, this is probably the first book about China that has not given me nightmares or made me feel like I don't ever want to go there. Perhaps that's because it was written by a Western author? Second, I am prone to reading books about China or Chinese culture, as a vacation of sorts - but due to the said reason, it's mostly fantasy (fantasy books don't tend to shock and terrorize you with their harsh realities, and harsh realities about China seem to be often harsher than realities about the nazis. Honestly.) But this book wasn't like that, and although there was some shock involved, there was also redemption, joy, happiness and a very meaningful ending.

The story is mostly made up of two parts: the tragic hardship and the glowing growth and redemption, from which the characters look back on the past. The story is arranged simply and linearly, but there are these distinct two parts which were both charming in their own way.

First the hardship part shocks you, and it shocks you hard. From the rough and sometimes very cruel traditions of the Akha to the understanding that in the years you were already born people still lived like this, and perhaps they still do somewhere in the world now. The way most of these ideas will be so alien, so baffling to you in their cruelty and lack of any common sense, so to say, will shock you beyond expectation. And yet, you will have to admit that some of them make sense. As hard as it will be to see through it, you'll have to try to accept the way these people live.

The story centers around losing your child, losing your mother, but it's also deep on not belonging - be it because you're far away from your home, physically different, culturally different, a minority or just outcrowded by race. This is a tale about a mother who had to relinquish her child because her situation and the tradition would have guaranteed her baby's death if she hadn't abandoned her. So we follow through with the story, seeing how it leaves a mark on everyone, how things like that leave a hole in a person's heart, never to fully heal. Despite where our lives lead us, the threads of fate always bring us back to our roots, and this is done so meaningfully in this story I am simply in awe at the ending.

Aside from the story itself, this is a manifest to tea. That part I also loved. In the end, I even contacted my tea master from ten years ago, because it brought back so many strong, deep memories.

Thank you to Lisa See and Scribner for letting me read this gem before most readers had access to it. Truly a wonderful gift! (Needless to say that receiving a review copy does not influence my opinion of the book at all.) I enjoyed this book a lot, and as this was my first one of Lisa's, I will be looking forward to checking my library and bookstores for more of her wonderful stories.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book I have read by Lisa See, and it wont be the last. The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane goes right to the heart of what it would have been like to live in a rural village in China where growing and picking tea is the primary way to make money. The main character, Li-Yan, known as girl to her family, is brought up to follow the many rules and superstitions of the Akha, the ethnic minority she was born into. This is at a time when females are not considered to be as important. Although, because they are a minority, the Akha are not limited to having one child like other parts of China. Li-Yan has three brothers.

The descriptions of people and places are so vivid that I can picture them in mind. Lisa See describes circumstances in such a way, that I became totally caught in the story and did not want to put the book down. The book follows Li-Yan through the choices she makes in her life. Those choices, at times have very difficult outcomes. However, she does have a big supporter in her mother as her love always shines through, and she helps her daughter in ways that go completely against the superstitions they hold. The mother-daughter connections continue when Li-Yan, who was forced to abandon the baby born out of wedlock, yearns and searches for her daughter.

One of the traditions is that young people are expected to go into the forest, and “do the intercourse” before marriage to try each other out and make sure they are happy with that aspect of a relationship with a future spouse. This is mentioned quite often—not in a graphic way. It’s just a part of their culture.

I thoroughly enjoyed the book and highly recommend it. While a lot of books have a period where things slow down, and I really hope the story gets moving again, this book kept my interest from beginning to end.

Was this review helpful?

<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25150798-the-tea-girl-of-hummingbird-lane" style="float: left; padding-right: 20px"><img border="0" alt="The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane" src="https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1472151037m/25150798.jpg" /></a><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25150798-the-tea-girl-of-hummingbird-lane">The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane</a> by <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/713.Lisa_See">Lisa See</a><br/>
My rating: <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/1845062287">4 of 5 stars</a><br /><br />
This book is available today!<br /><br />I really enjoyed this story of Li-yan, born in a remote Yunnan village in China, of the minority Akha people.<br />Rare tea is made from the trees here, and we learn so much about tea making, Chinese customs and beliefs, and life in a small village. <br />Li-yan has a child very young, and she has a tough journey, but this shows the resilience of her people in this is a heartfelt story.<br />This is my first novel by Lisa See and I really enjoyed it!<br /><br />Thank you to NetGalley, Simon and Schuster, and the author Lisa See, for the opportunity to read this book!
<br/><br/>
<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/review/list/12851291-karen">View all my reviews</a>

Was this review helpful?

Lisa See created beautiful characters against a background of rural China to envelop readers in the world of the Tea Girl. Social issues are subtly addressed: the one child rule and the impact of adoption of Chinese girls, drug abuse and the education of girls are most prominent. As the main character grows and changes throughout the novel so do those around her. Ancient traditions are often appalling but the reader gains an understanding of their importance in the lives of the characters as they examine how to relinquish some superstitious/traditional beliefs. Surprisingly there are changes as the world of the mountain people grows. This is a glimpse into the way modern society influences change around the world. Tea is a main character in the book and the history is very interesting and is explained as part of the story. This is a page turner of the highest quality.

Was this review helpful?

The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane by Sara See released this march 21 is like a very good cup of tea: intense, vibrant, low, delicate, calm, refreshing and precious.

When you drink tea you take your time for absorbing the moment, isn't it true?

Cuddled by a warm sensation and a moment suspended by the time.

You don't rush, you enjoy to taste the intensity of tea, its warm, its delicacy.
Drinking tea is a ritual in slow motion for loving yourself.
A moment dedicated only to you.
Tea is a philosophy of life.

I am a tea lover and I lived reading The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane like this­.
I can compare this book at the best cup of tea I have ever drunk.
The book has its own times, narration is quiet, meditative, sweet, peaceful, absorbing, wise, tender.

This wonderful book written by Sara See follows in the narration the times of tea and the times of a different philosophy and religion explaining to us the importance of tea for the East part of the world and what it means to them this commerce.

Lisa See is enchantingly poetic in describing the microcosm and little society of Akha like also all their traditions, most of them ancestral, old like the Time and the World and her writing-style is captivating from the first words.

The narration of the book is in first person and they're the words of Li-yan, the daughter of a-ma and a-ba to resonate.
Her mom very considerate in the tribe, a woman magical for many ways.
She knows the old traditions and sacred guidelines of her tribe.
Li-yan grows up more modern and rebel and in a society in evolution falling in love with a guy called San-pa that for magical reasons not at all good for her.

It was intriguing and captivating to learn which were the most profound animistic traditions of Akha.
They believed in them keeping the society very united. Each person had his/her own place in that specific land and tribe.

Many rituals, from birth to departure passing through acts of purification described with great intensity and penetration giving to the reader the exact mirror of the mentality of that wonderful people and creating so a big impact to the narration of the book, dense and felt from the beginning to the end.

Nature, magic, work, descriptions are poetic and together create a spectacular masterpiece.

The reader is transported in distant lands with great poetry and for some while our dimension will be forgotten, falling in a complete different atmosphere for mentality and spirituality.

You will stay relaxed while you will read this book because this book is a book of hope, a book of traditions, a book of strength and sacrifices of women. A book of past, present, memories, new beginnings. And a book with a different time. More absorbing.
You will notice a complete different writing-style only when the narration will involve the USA. Quick, modern.

The story of this society will change with the arrival of Mr Huang - the story starts in 1988 - the new arrival in this closed society in search for great tea.

The protagonist is intelligent and she decide to study and to become someone but then it happens the unplanned...
She becomes pregnant and helped by her mom she decides to bring the baby in an orphanage to Menghai, China.
In opposite case according to a very old tradition the baby couldn't survive.


Her big love, San-pa is back but he has a frail character and happiness maybe is still distant for this girl, considering that she discover her husband brought her in a place insecure, with drug traffickers and a commerce of opium and heroin.
She run away. She run away from San-pa, her first love, she run away for being free. Back home she will discover that she can become who she wanted to become before the arrival of her baby, and before her wedding with San-pa.

At the same time the little baby adopted a Californian family living in Los Angeles. Although Dan and Constance are growing up Haley very well, Haley will search for her mom...

The end of this book is touching.

You will discover reading this book how precious is tea and how important it is to give great quality tea to tea drinkers. It is an ethical story.
You will learn everything about tea and its commerce, like also about humanity and changes caused by the arrival of the so-called progress in the remote village where the protagonist of the book live, with, of course, modernity able to replace religion, old habits and rituals.

Another big thematic is the search for the past, because past unforgettable. A baby is too precious for not thinking of it.


Highly recommended! for sure.

I thank NetGalley and Scribner for this book.

Was this review helpful?

History and culture come to life in this engaging story. I haven't read any of Lisa See's books before and was looking forward to diving into this one.

This book is like opening a treasure chest into an less known but richly cultured world. The Akha are a poor, small and remote mountain tribe in China, who produce Pu'er' Tea. The history, daily life, politics, and ideologies of this people are brought to life in a way which grabs and lets the reader fall into their world, while gaining an understanding of their values and ways of thinking. The author handles this with beautiful finesse while bringing in an engaging plot.

Li-Yan is a wonderful young woman, who grows up in this setting. She's a lovely character, easy to befriend and follow as she faces the difficulties not only of her people, but later in bringing a balance with the traditional and the modern world. When Li-Yan falls in love and becomes pregnant, she's faced with horrible choices and decides to sneak her child and abandon it in a neighboring village so that it won't be killed.

The emotions in this book are as raw and intriguing as the historical and informational details, making this a read which teaches as well as drives to thought with characters which are hard to forget.

Was this review helpful?

I thought that I had already submitted my review, but it appears lost. I have loved Lisa See's books for a very long time. This book reminds me why I loved Peony in Love and other early stories. The characters were beautifully drawn and I felt I learned a lot about the Akha,, a small ethnic minority in China, their ways and culture, and then I had the chance to see them enter the outer world first as an individual, the heroine of this story, and then as a whole village. It is also a story of the tea industry within China. All of it is richly shown and at times you could almost feel and smell the places and events portrayed. Li Yan and her abandoned child, Haley, are well done but I did find the group therapy session transcript really off. This is possibly the only time I have ever suggested to the publisher that the author should have had a Psychotherapy Group practitioner read through the long section and review both for validity as session notes as well as if a group of young to middle teens would ever talk in such a sophisticated manner. Most teens would never have access to the feelings these young girls were sharing in group therapy. Psychotherapy is never a quick process and this section was, for me, very off putting.

This is, however, Lisa See at her best. It is well researched, a compelling, unique story that mirrors the prejudice that existed in the not so long ago past China. I never knew a lot of the information she shared and much of it really surprised and intrigued me to want to know more. I found myself looking up places and events and, of course, hoping for the happy ending that our heroine deserves. A very good book!

Along with

Was this review helpful?

This is my first novel from Lisa See and she immediately pulls you into the story of Li-yan with her powerful prose. Li-yan has spent her life following the Akha customs and farming tea with her family. So much happens to Li-yan throughout her life, including having a child out of wedlock and abandoning it at the nearest city instead of disposing of it like tradition says. No matter what I say it will not do it justice to the wonderful story of Li-yan, her family, and the obstacles they must overcome. You will not be disappointed by this novel!

Was this review helpful?