"This journey of self-discovery while growing up in a biracial, interfaith family is sure to resonate with young readers exploring the intersection of their interests and identities."—Booklist

"Vibrant illustrations of McKinney's life also contribute to the accessibility of the story; that a majority of the book is about McKinney as an adult will leave children encouraged that growing up is a forever process and there will be plenty of time for life-altering decisions. Ades treats questions of identity with a light touch, which only gives the story more power."—School Library Journal

"This story just sings with Jewish joy, struggle, and connection."—Sydney Taylor Shmooze