“A must-read historical fiction meets folklore horror novel. Rich and compelling

• The powerful imagery of the harsh, wild landscapes the characters traverse, along with the tension that fills the air in every chapter, kept readers on the edge of their seats.

• The balance the author found between the violent supernatural events of the story and the need for survival that takes center stage in the narrative made this novel soar.

• Narrative (was) compelling and thought-provoking. It was the powerful themes of this book that stood out.”

—Author Anthony Avina 10/10

(https://authoranthonyavina.com/2025/11/09/swallowing-the-muskellunge-by-lawrence-p-obrien-review/)

• “Utterly gripping while also being slightly mysterious. A riveting and thought-provoking read.

• A haunting, mystical tale that draws the reader into a lingering tale of sadness and loss. There is something in the American wilderness that is timeless, overshadowing the human inhabitants and even the animals.

• (O’Brien) displays an innate, instinctive understanding of the grandness of nature.

• O’Brien’s strength is his ability to throw himself into a number of character viewpoints, each as compelling as the last.

• (Thoughts of each person) never overdone and add depth to the storyline, as does the authenticity of the dialogue.

• The wildness of nature, the myths and legends and the human struggle all merge to create an incredible and haunting story that will keep the reader guessing.

• Unputdownable.”

—The Historical Fiction Company 4.5/5