If We Play Fair
The Dramatic Hearts Club
by Nathalie Theodore
You must sign in to see if this title is available for request. Sign In or Register Now
Send NetGalley books directly to your Kindle or Kindle app
1
To read on a Kindle or Kindle app, please add kindle@netgalley.com as an approved email address to receive files in your Amazon account. Click here for step-by-step instructions.
2
Also find your Kindle email address within your Amazon account, and enter it here.
Pub Date Feb 25 2026 | Archive Date Feb 06 2026
Talking about this book? Use #IfWePlayFair #NetGalley. More hashtag tips!
Description
FROM IPPY AWARD-WINNING AUTHOR NATHALIE THEODORE
Author's Note: If We Play Fair is Book Three in the Dramatic Hearts Club, a series of interconnected standalone contemporary romance novels. While those who've read If the Stars Align and If My Wishes Came True will enjoy seeing returning characters, If We Play Fair can be read on its own.
TWO PLAYERS. TWO PITCHES. ONE SHOT AT FAKING TRUE LOVE.
Christy Andersen and Holden McBride bring out the worst in each other. Too bad the fates of their careers lie in each other’s hands.
Disillusioned with dating, Christy’s a powerhouse literary agent at the top of her game. But when a scandal threatens to shatter her hard-won reputation, she pins her hopes on signing pop icon Lola Piper, rumored to be writing the juiciest tell-all of the decade. There’s just one problem: Lola’s gone off the grid.
Holden, a starting pitcher for the Chicago Starlings, is a notorious player on and off the field. After a devastating loss sends him streaking across Soldier Field, his fans are outraged. All but Christy—until he manages to get on her bad side. When she tells him off, the clip goes viral, getting Holden the best press he’s had in weeks. Fans adore the feisty redhead, and his agent insists she’s exactly what he needs to clean up his image.
Christy and Holden pitch each other a deal: she’ll pretend to be his girlfriend, and he’ll introduce her to his best friend’s sister, the elusive Lola Piper. The plan is simple—fake the romance, fix their reputations, and they both walk away winners.
But as their staged relationship heats up, so does the chemistry they can’t ignore. With their hearts and careers on the line, Christy and Holden must decide whether they should keep playing fair…or change the game.
Advance Praise
If We Play Fair is Nathalie Theodore’s best book yet. Christy and Holden’s enemies-to-lovers dynamic is on point, the banter is top-notch, and the spice sizzles. If you’re in the market for a witty fake dating romance with nuance and heart, then this is the one for you. Pitch-perfect from start to finish!
—Emily Colin, New York Times bestselling author of The Memory Thief
Marketing Plan
Please tag me on social media! Instagram and Tiktok @nathalietheodorewrites. Facebook @DramaticHeartsClub
I can't wait to hear from you! :)
Please tag me on social media! Instagram and Tiktok @nathalietheodorewrites. Facebook @DramaticHeartsClub
I can't wait to hear from you! :)
Available Editions
| EDITION | Ebook |
| ISBN | 9781966472056 |
| PRICE | |
Links
Available on NetGalley
Average rating from 1 member
Featured Reviews
Reviewer 1657991
“Being loved by you is gift enough.”
Christy is a book agent and Holden is a professional baseball pitcher. They are both dealing with PR scandals and make a deal to fake date to save their careers. (TW: disordered eating, body dysmorphia, grief)
⚾️ Fake dating
📖 Dual POV
🌺 One bed
🏝️ Enemies to lovers
⚾️ Family drama
📖 Baseball pro MMC
🌺 He falls first
🏝️ Curvy FMC
⚾️ MCs in their 30s
📖 Hilarious
🌺 Mental health rep
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Five stars, no notes! If this is not on your TBR, it should be. I love fake dating. I love sports romance. Wow this book was so fun!! It would make a great movie! The chemistry and banter had me kicking my feet and giggling. The romance is so sweet. I loved the characters and their development. Christy is so relatable! Holden is so swoony.
There’s so much plot and drama going on in this book that I couldn’t put it down! I loved the updates and appearances of characters from books 1 and 2. Can’t wait for the next book!
Release date 2/25/26. Thank you to the author and NetGalley for the ARC!
“Because now, I know that you don’t play fair—which means I don’t have to either.”