Thank you to NetGalley, Ten16 Press, and Orange Hat Publishing for providing me with an ARC of The New Witch in the Northwoods.

I absolutely loved this book. It felt incredibly realistic, and I found the main character so relatable and easy to connect with. Watching her discover the Otherworld and learn about its creatures was such a fun experience—the descriptions gave me a blend of Halloweentown and Harry Potter vibes, which I really enjoyed.

The author’s setting descriptions were outstanding. Each location was brought to life in such vivid detail that I felt completely immersed in the story, as if I were right there alongside the characters.

I especially loved the different layers woven throughout the plot—her journey in discovering her own powers, the blossoming relationship, the secrets surrounding her grandfather, and the constant tension of the vampire hunting her. All of these elements combined to create a truly captivating and engaging read.

The cosy atmosphere made it an easy and enjoyable book to sink into, while the characters were all so lovable and memorable. The world itself is one that will definitely stay with me.

Overall, this was a magical and unforgettable read that I thoroughly enjoyed.

First I would like to give a thank you to NetGalley for this read.

A New Witch in the North Woods is a cozy, engaging fantasy that blends small-town charm with magic, mystery, and just the right touch of danger. The story follows Mary, who moves to a quiet town after inheriting her grandfather’s house, expecting a fresh start. Only to discover she’s a witch and that an entire supernatural world exists around her.

One of the book’s biggest strengths is how clearly the supernatural realm is explained. The magic system is easy to follow and thoughtfully developed, making the story feel immersive without ever being confusing. It allows you to settle into the world quickly and stay engaged throughout.

Mary is a strong adult female lead who is both relatable and compelling. Watching her navigate this unexpected new reality while growing into her abilities adds depth to the story. The supporting characters are also thoroughly explained and genuinely enjoyable. They feel purposeful, fun, and well-suited to the story rather than just background figures.

While this is a shorter read, it’s incredibly satisfying. The story wraps up nicely without leaving unanswered questions, which makes it feel complete and well thought out.

A New Witch in the Northwoods is the kind of cozy, magical escape that feels like curling up in a cabin with a warm drink and a hint of something spellbound in the air. The Northwoods setting is easily the standout: lush, atmospheric, and just a little eerie in the best way, giving the story that perfect balance of comfort and mystery.
The story follows a newcomer stepping into both a new town and a new identity, and I loved the slow unraveling of her powers alongside the town’s secrets. It leans more cozy than dark, with light magic, small-town dynamics, and just enough intrigue to keep things interesting without getting too heavy.

At times, the pacing can feel a bit gentle, especially if you’re expecting high-stakes twists, but it works for the overall vibe. This is more about atmosphere, found community, and personal growth than edge-of-your-seat suspense.

Perfect for readers who love cozy witchy reads, small-town charm, and a touch of magic without the intensity. A great fall (or anytime) comfort read. ✨📚

This is a cozy, magical escape that feels a bit like curling up in a cabin with something quietly enchanted humming in the background. The Northwoods setting is the true standout—lush, atmospheric, and juuust eerie enough to keep things interesting. The story follows Mary as she discovers both her place in a small town and her growing magical abilities, with secrets unfolding at a gentle pace. A perfect pick for readers who want vibes over urgency!

First, thank you to NetGalley, Elise Posledni, and Orange Hat Publishing for providing me with an ARC of this delightful read.

This cozy, magical story is all about coming into your own and finding where you belong. It beautifully captures the challenge of building friendships as an adult and creating a support system that truly feels like home. The world-building is immersive and atmospheric—the kind that makes you want to step right into “the Other” and stay there awhile.

At the heart of the story is Mary, who discovers she’s a half-witch and begins to uncover both her powers and the truth behind her grandfather’s mysterious death. Her journey is equal parts self-discovery and quiet strength, and it’s incredibly satisfying to watch her grow into herself. There’s also a compelling romance with Andras—the undeniably alluring demon—which adds just the right amount of tension and charm.

With its small-town feel, found-family themes, and a touch of the supernatural, this is a perfect read for anyone who loves cozy magic, coffee shop vibes, and stories about building community.