Cover Image: Disrupters

Disrupters

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This book is a bit of a mixed bag for me. It had some nice ideas but overall everything what was actually usable isn't really doable outside of America, and not being American i can't even say if it is actually usable inside the USA. So while it had some nice inspirations... overall this book is not actually that usable in my option.

Was this review helpful?

Fascinating - will incorporate into my leadership education curriculums.

Was this review helpful?

Disrupters is “not about what companies and institutions can and should do to promote gender equity,” says author Dr. Patti Fletcher in her introduction. “It’s a business book on finding success in the world by doing things your own way."

Fletcher includes many statistical charts and research findings which show the disproportion between male and female leadership even in companies where women are the majority. Women who claim not to be bothered, may be forced to grapple with reality, especially when they think of the future for their offspring.

The interviews at the end of each chapter are motivational. They include disrupters in prestigious companies like Procter & Gamble, Netflix and IT companies in the Silicon Valley. They include entrepreneurs who have made contributions to global business. They encourage women to become game changers in their move forward. They also prove some prejudice is not as much against women, as toward the traditional views some have always known.

This book may not interest every woman, although all can learn from it. Some may be turned off by charts and lists with strictly-business terms, but it is a business book; and those who venture may obtain some brain exercises in memorizing her definitions.

I received this book from the publisher through NetGalley (https://www.netgalley.com). There was no request for a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This book will be out on January 30th and I'm grateful to have had the opportunity to review it. That said, I was not a fan. I loved the cover, title, and the idea of this book- I was excited to read about how to push myself in my career. This book was very "corporate America" and had very little that could be applied to women in human service careers. I guess I was hoping for a book that could apply to a broader range of professionals.

Was this review helpful?

When I got the approval to read this book I was so excited. I mean, who doesn't want to be able to read tips from those who have already paved the way and know how to navigate success.  I know I read a lot of these books, but I really do enjoy them and I typically get a nugget or two that I can then apply to my life.

Each chapter of this book was structured with her writing then at the end there would be a specific person she'd interview and ask questions.  I thought that layout was smart, it gives you a chance to learn about the world and how things typically are at the moment and how to navigate it then get some real life application from a women who has kicked ass.

For me this book didn't really have a lot of new information, and I honestly expected more advice from the women interviews.  I also found the layout of the book made it hard to read at times, like at the begining you get a list of words you need to know, I'm not sure I needed them and I feel like that maybe should have been in the back and then included as they come up in the footer.  I also found the writing at times still needed a bit of editing, she had a lot of extra comments (like this) in her writing that sometimes was distracting.  I get it when you need it occasionally but at one point it felt like every line had comments like that and it made me want to put the book down.

I gripe about the above however I do think there were some great points made in this, and I think it's a book that everyone could read and walk away from knowing more. 

For example, I love that she talks about using tech to help take away bias since a lot of times we are bias but don't see it.  One of her examples was talking about a program on computers that helped prevent cyber bullying by analyzing writing for keywords and phrases that were considered mean and before a teen could submit a post they'd get a popup commenting on it and asking if they were sure.  Apparently in this study 90 percent of the time the student would not end up posting what they'd written. 

She then takes that study and applies it to the workplace "Say you’re sitting down to do the dreaded performance review. Everybody hates doing performance reviews, so you rush through them as quickly as possible. In doing so, you’re often making rushed judgments. For example, in the HR world, you’re not allowed to penalize someone for a leave of absence, right? You’re not supposed to let that influence your performance review of anyone. So if you were to score someone comparatively low, you might have a message pop up that says, “I see you’re about to rate this person lower than you did last year. I also noticed that they took a leave of absence earlier this year. Is it possible that that’s influencing your score?”"

I saw this and my first thought was "why doesn't this already exist?" it sounds so smart. 



Another thing that she says in the book is 

"If I hire a “diversity candidate,” but I’m fine with all the heads of major projects looking just like me, then I haven’t actually changed anything.

I’ve achieved diversity; my team includes someone who isn’t like the rest of us. But if I don’t include you in our discussions, consider your point of view, or value your contributions—if I dismiss your ideas, talents, and experience . . . then while you may be physically present, you don’t really have a seat at the table. If you have to act like me to succeed, then I wasn’t really looking for new ideas; I just wanted a nice picture for the website.

I may have diversity, but I don’t have inclusion."

 So while I do find that a lot of this book was stuff I've read, it doesn't mean I didn't need to read it again.  The more we can read about the changes that need to be done the more likely we are to see it and be able to apply it in real life.  I won't go into much more because I don't want to end up putting a majority of the book in my review but needless to say I'm happy I read it and do think it's worth picking up.

Was this review helpful?