Cover Image: Aquaman Vol. 1: Unspoken Water

Aquaman Vol. 1: Unspoken Water

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Though there were some cool ideas, I ended up not really liking this book I was so in the dark for pretty much all of it. When I pick up a first volume, I expect to be given enough context to be able to pick up the book as a newcomer, but this did not give it to me, and as the book progressed I just felt like I had more questions rather than having my initial confusion addressed.
The art is pretty good, at least.

Was this review helpful?

For good or for bad, this comes across as a heightening of the mythology of Aquaman – well, it was never that good so they just have to try and reboot and make it differently dodgy every couple of years; that's a given. King Arthur is washed up and being called Andy on an island, which – lo and behold – is peopled by a handful of old codgers. Unfortunately we only meet the kindly housewife one and the bonkers one, ignoring the fact we ought to be told about the others, before he's sent on a mission that isn't what it seems, which will ultimately reveal the whole island's codgers to be not what they seem, either. It's hokum, and you have to hope it knows it, for it doesn't read that way – it's hard to believe this is actually played straight, though. The one saving grace of the book is the quality of the artwork – this won't get churned out at this quality month after month after month, for it's just too detailed and interesting-looking. If only the story could match. Two and a half stars.

Was this review helpful?

A cool new adaptation of Aquaman. The art is classic and the new storyline is a lot of fun. I'll definfitly recommend this one.

Was this review helpful?

The images and text unfortunately did not come through in this download. I am more than happy to review a hard copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Launching out of the big recent cross-over of Drowned Earth - this very clearly stands on it's own. It does have Kelly Sue DeConnick going for it but I suspect Aquaman (despite or maybe even because of the movie) is a character a lot of people will just bounce off of.

Was this review helpful?

I found this comic to be very misleading. If you are going to sell the creators of the content as these super stars, make sure that the story at least makes sense. No where in the Drowned Earth Arc did Aquaman ever forgot who he was. This trope is boring... Come up with something original please.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Publisher for the early copy!

I'm new to the DC comic world and comics in general but I'm slowly starting to love them. The art in this one was stunning, I would have liked to see more of Aquaman's powers but understand why it was understated in this volume. I recommend checking it out this well-written and interesting new comic series.

Was this review helpful?

I don't read many superhero graphic novels but this one caught my eye because it is Aquaman.

I haven't seen the film and so I was hoping this would be an intro to the film. It wasn't but it was ok to read. The artwork is very colourful and I really enjoyed that but I thought the actual content of the story was just ok. Aquaman fans might really enjoy this though.

Copy provided by Netgalley in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

I'm admittedly very behind in my Aquaman reading, though I've been doing better about the more recent series. This series caught my attention for a very specific reason; Kelly Sue DeConnick is the author. I love what she did for Captain Marvel, and thus will try almost any series she writes.
Aquaman Vol. 1: Unspoken Water is the latest collected edition for Aquaman (duh) and follows the events of Drowned Earth. So if you haven't read that plotline, you might want to read it first. But honestly, you don't really have to. Just be aware that it starts out with Aquaman having lost his memories.
Aquaman Vol. 1 was a great followup to Drowned Earth. Though like I hinted at earlier, it could also be read as a standalone volume too. It's fairly self-contained, and most of the references in there are explained at least in part. Obviously, there is more of an impact if you know what happened to him before this, but sometimes you just have to jump into a series or you'll never get started.
This volume is exactly what I was expecting for Kelly Sue DeConnick. You can so clearly see her writing style. So fans of hers will absolutely love this (like I did), while people who don't like her writing style has much will not enjoy this one so much (probably).
I really loved the way the story progressed in this volume. The start was nice, subtle, and distinct. From there the pace shifted back and forth, sometimes moving forward rapidly, and at other times giving us a chance to really focus on a specific event. It was the perfect ebb and flow for the story they were telling. I honestly wouldn't mind seeing more of this style, to be honest. But then again, I am a fan of Kelly Sue DeConnick's writing style, so I'm a bit biased here.
I do think that shippers of Aquaman and Mera might be irritated at times here, but just remember that there's no clear indication of any confirmed relationship here. Arthur is simply a man who has lost his memories and is desperately seeking to find himself. Anything else is secondary.
The conclusion to the plot was...intense. And it was beautifully drawn as well, which admittedly did help the impact of what was being shown/told. So major bonus points there. Both the imagery and the truth of what was happening was fascinating and expertly done.
I'm actually a bit sad that this volume is over, but all good things must come to an end. I'll be curious to see what will be next in the Aquaman continuity though, as he has been through quite a lot in the last couple of years.

Was this review helpful?