Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I received a free E-Arc of this book in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own. This book is a modern retelling of the Jane Austen classic "Pride and Prejudice." The story about Hara, a woman aspiring to be a sports reporter, and a famous basketball player. Both characters were not very complex or given much depth. There was some family background given about Hara, but I felt too much emphasis was placed upon her multi cultural heritage. Darcy was too willing to jump to conclusions and people's supposed intentions without really having the much needed conversations with the individuals. I did not really like how fast the relationship developed between the two main characters. It felt really rushed and more lust and not a deeper meaningful connection. The writing was good and appropriate for the age of the various characters as well as the setting. The events of the story moved along well, but were not really believable and seemed too convenient. Overall, this was a nice twist on a classic, but fell short in drawing me into the characters and the story line. I would like to read more by this author and I would recommend this book to those who like modern twists to the classics.

Was this review helpful?

Ms. Eva is on to something writing this sports romances.
The Wrong Mr. Darcy was a sweet story of a reporter cutting her teeth on a big story and unearthing a story bigger than the one she went in for.


—————————

Thank you to Netgalley & the publisher for granting me this free ebook in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A young women is trying hard to be a reporter. But being a young women in a mans world is tough. What she thinks is a stroke of luck turns around the other way when she stumbles into some bad things going on. Does she continue to try to further her career or let it go, and first impression are not always right!

Was this review helpful?

I had high hopes for this story as it sounded like a modern re-telling of Pride and Prejudice with a sports twist. While I think that basics of the story are here I think that the execution leaves much to be desired.

I liked few aspects of this story, like the idea of a sports writer finding her love with a basketball star, I liked the diversity in the story and characters, I liked the way the main character Hara was presented and detailed (with a few misunderstandings), and I liked the development of the romance as it felt fluid and true. Also for a sports story there is a severe lack of sports knowledge that went into the story, even just the basics like what a specific sport is called.

I didn’t like the way the character traded perspectives within the story without any clear delineation; it caused me to get confused at times with who was speaking. I didn’t like some of the choices the authors made in regards to furthering the plot; they simply did not make sense in a realistic way. I didn’t like the lack of respect for the other woman in the story. I didn’t like the way the authors seemed confused over their own characters and story ideas. For example: Hara is from a small town but gets first class tickets to fly, stays at high end hotels and the like all paid for by her boss, even thought there are only two employees (small business), the fact that Hara doesn’t know the origin of her name or cultural aspects of her linage. That didn’t jive for me.

This story read to me more like an outline and not at all a final version. I hope the authors take some time to revisit their story and fix a few of the issues to make the story smoother. It has great potential but was not one I enjoyed. This is not Pride and Prejudice, not even really a re-telling. I think the only thing in has in common is the use of the Darcy name. I received an ARC via Net Galley and I am leaving my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was...not my cup of tea. I thought the premise was good and I enjoyed the basic storyline, but I did not enjoy the writing. A lot of religion and it didn’t flow for me. Very choppy?

Was this review helpful?

I’m sorry to say that this book didn’t hold my attention. Partly the writing, partly the formatting, and lots of repetition means three stars from me. I imagine the authors know about basketball, but they need to work on their writing ability. For me, wring inthe first person is preferable, but not a deal breaker. The third person writing was awkward.

Was this review helpful?

I liked the premise of the story, as it gave a different twist an many of Austen's characters from Pride and Prejudice. However, the writing didn't flow well and seemed blocky.

Was this review helpful?

I thought I would give this author another chance since I had many issues with her other novel, The Perfect Date. Yet, I found myself unable to read this novel all the way through. It was choppy at best and just not anything that I would consider Austen inspired.

Was this review helpful?

Great beach read! I love modern re-tellings of Jane Austen's classics and The Wrong Mr. Darcy told this story with a brand new angle of Pride & Prejudice where a journalist falls in love with an NBA star despite her desire to avoid him at all costs. This fun rom com is an easy entertaining quick read that you'll breeze through quickly. Fans of re-tellings of any of Jane Austen's work will enjoy comparing this take on the tale to the original and others like Eligible, etc.

Was this review helpful?

I didn’t really see this as a Pride and Prejudice retelling. I had high hopes, but I don’t feel the book is as advertised. Other than some character names and chapter quotes I didn’t really see the Jane Austen novel. I love a good rom com but this was light on the comedy. Not something I would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This was pretty good! I liked the relationships and the story line! I would definitely like to try out more from this author!

Was this review helpful?

The Wrong Mr. Darcy is a retelling of Pride and Prejudice set in the world of professional basketball’s reporters and wives and players. Player Derek Darcy represents the elite with both his pride and prejudice set against reporter Hara Isari. There’s even a dastardly Bingley sister! Other characters such as Hara’s mother and father are true to form while the sinister aspects of basketball and gambling are new. Written by an insider wife the book is clever, fun and suspenseful.

Was this review helpful?

The write up (which is very brief) on this is very misleading. When you first read the description/ see the cover you think a modern day Pride and Prejudice with a basketball twist. Something light and fun. The story needs either a major overhaul to match said “charming multi-cultural P&P inspiration” or a new marketing campaign.

Trigger Warnings: Abortion, miscarriage, sexual harassment, attempted suicide, death by gunfire, near drowning, blackmail, cheating...there were more but that’s what I can presently recall.

Not what one would expect in a contemporary romance.

There is little connection to the classic novel save for the names of a handful of characters and a couple scenes, outside of the quote in the chapter header. The characters themselves are more like caricatures then believable people. Some of their speech patterns, thought processes, and behavior are generally too much or not enough.

The story itself, is not at all what was expected. The first couple chapters help a lot of promise. Hara as a journalist working the story, catching the eye of a pro athlete and going from there ok. It was the execution that did not work. They have a “hate/misunderstanding/annoyance to hop into bed to this is the one” relationship that transitions very quickly. Less then a week quickly. It really bothered me that she has the impression that this man shes getting into bed with has had hundreds of one-night stands but there is no talk of any kind of safe sex practices, none. In this day and age that’s just encouraging bad choices. That’s just one of several examples that left a bad taste in my mouth as a reader.
When it comes to the plot and over all feel of the story...again, not at all what was expected. This as a Romantic book doesn’t work. Steamy scenes aside. Your antagonists are so callous and intense that they do not belong in this kind of setting. The last 40% of the book where Hara is uncovering all the scandals (bet rigging, forced blackmail abortion, threatening of harm to persons or loved ones, deviant sports managers, etc) was a good concept. If you’re going to go this route, plug the story as suspense and tie it in more throughout the story. Not so much from Hara’s POV but from the other characters involved.

This was an advanced copy so it is possible this could be a completely different book by the time it is released. As it stands it is not a book I can recommend.

E-Arc kindly provided by St. Martin’s Press via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I received an uncorrected digital proof for review.
A unique concept - linking Pride and Prejudice with a sports romance. Derek Darcy, rising basketball star is the “other” Mr Darcy to Hara Isari, Pride and Prejudice fan and struggling newbie sports writer. While anticipating reading a sports romance there was a lot of suspense in this novel. I did not care for how there was no clear separation between the POV of the main characters which could easily be fixed with better formatting before publishing. While the storyline seemed just a tad fantastical at times with the authors throwing every sports cliche in here, overall, I enjoyed the read.

Was this review helpful?

This book was described as a Pride and Prejudice inspired and with the name Mr. Darcy in the title I was expecting a modern retelling of one of my favorite novels. However, I was disappointed in this book from a retelling standpoint. There were some character names taken from the original story like Mr. Darcy, Charles, and even a passing mention of a character named Kitty but beyond a few name commonalities most of the characters didn’t have much in common with the originals. I kept finding myself trying to decide which characters here were inspired by which Pride and Prejudice characters and it distracted me from the story itself. If I hadn’t been making those comparisons I think I may have been able to get into this book a bit more. I also had some issues with the pacing and the romance felt rushed at times. Sadly, it just wasn’t what I expected.

Was this review helpful?

I love Pride and Prejudice retelling. Unfortunately I didn’t think this one had many parallels to the original story at all. I was hoping for more of a clever connection. I love the cover! If you like “bad boy” romances, this book might be for you.

Was this review helpful?

This was marketed as hilarious, but I didn’t find it very funny. I don’t think I laughed out loud at all a single time.

The writing wasn’t bad and the story was entertaining, but I just didn’t find it funny. Things are fairly fast paced and keeps you reading.

Grab this book if you want a romance with a hidden twist.

Was this review helpful?

This book made my head hurt.....I will say ive never read this author before and the description sound like a great lite rom com but it was a disaster.....

Was this review helpful?

The premise had potential to be a nice modern Pride & Prejudice but it fell short on so many levels. Contains spoilers.

There’s race/ ethnicity involved, but none of the characters claim their background. Various characters have P&P names but they don’t really follow their characters’ name same personality. The two male MC’s are supposed to be bff’s but one of them proves he was a fake friend. Darcy’s side of the family never makes an appearance. There’s a bad guy straight out of left field, which is hard to fit into the story. I liked the connection the two MC’s feel, it felt real enough, but it still left me wanting more. Being a Bostonian myself, I hated how the authors wrote out the ghetto dialogue for Charles, his on-and-off-again girlfriend/ fiancée, his side lover and some of the WAGS. Most people don’t really speak that way. Yes. Even minorities go through basic schooling and learn proper grammar. I felt like the authors just used that to showcase these characters were black or latina. So overall, I was really disappointed with this story.

Already posted on Goodreads.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.

CW/TW: parent in jail, sexual harassment, cheating, miscarriage, attempted suicide by a side character (happens off page, but mc walks in after), talk of abortion, death by shooting of a side character.

*I’m going to start off by saying that I listed what I could remember for the content/trigger warnings. Some of these things will be mentioned in passing in this review. This book is marketed as light and fluffy, but a lot of things happen that some people may find triggering and I want them to be aware. *

I am disappointed to say that this book was actually really bad. I thought it would be a fun, cute P&P retelling involving basketball. What I got was a story lacking in a clear plot with pacing issues and some scenes that left a bad taste in my mouth. There were some things said in the story that felt racist, ableist, and just gross. There were a few flippant comments about eating disorders peppered in too. As well as, a suicide attempt by a side-character that wasn’t handled with any kind of care or nuance. There was also a hyper-focus on the main character being African American and Japanese American with light blue eyes and “caramel skin” and, though I do not have heritage from either of those races, the way it was constantly brought up felt very uncomfortable and kinda ew.
The way that difficult topics and scenarios were just used as plot devices was abhorrent to me. There was no nuance in dealing with abortion, miscarriage, and attempted suicide, and definitely not any related to other topics like sexual harassment in the workplace. I feel like the author was trying to cram in a ton of hot topics but never took the time to do it with care and people stumbling onto this book thinking that it would be a cute rom-com based on the cover could end up being triggered and hurt by this.

As for being a Pride & Prejudice retelling, it barely stuck to the original storyline. The author took some names and a couple lines from the original. This premise was so great: a hot shot b-ball player and an up-and-coming reporter disliking each other at first and then coming to realize their prejudices were unfounded and then falling in love? I wish that was what we got here. The idea was solid, but the execution was severely lacking and with all of the issues noted above I doubt there was a sensitivity reader within a hundred feet of this manuscript. Needless to say, I did not like this book.

I would love to hear what others have to say about this, but, truthfully, I wouldn’t recommend that anyone read this book.

Was this review helpful?