Cover Image: Girl One

Girl One

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Oh the wicked thoughts I had while reading this book! Not needing men to procreate is a great way to topple the patriarchy. Immaculate conception completely invalidates the Bible. If women can make themselves pregnant can they really can shut down a pregnancy when they are raped? All these ideas make this a terrific book for a book club. An open-minded and diverse book club. Really, it comes down to this being another instance where men are trying to control a woman's body. I loved the underlying concepts that ran through this book! It makes you think and wonder. Character development was secondary to the plot and I think I would have really liked more there. But if you are a fan of female centered dystopian fiction, this will be a must read!

Was this review helpful?

This was a ride that had me hooked from the first chapter. Sara Flannery Murphy is having the opposite of a Sophomore Slump in this propulsive, Feminist, witchy thriller. For those of you who are put off by the scientific overtones, know that this is first and foremost a plot-drive puzzle of a story: A mystery that blends science, magic, and politics to illustrate the ways that women are written out of their own stories. The book lives up to its hype: Atwood’s cryptic genius and Orphan Black’s binge-factor are both on display here. It felt refreshing to see a genuinely unique concept come to life in such a propulsive and chilling manner. The story feels expertly plotted without ever dragging, and the novel additionally packs strong action, sexual tension and gripping a-ha moments that will leave the best sleuths guessing that mysteries lie ahead. To say I loved it is an understatement. One of my favorite supernatural mysteries – ever.

Was this review helpful?

There is what you know about your life, then there is the "truth" about your life.

Josephine Morrow (Girl One) may have been the first, but there were more "miracle babies" born on a commune called the homestead. Dr. Joseph Bellanger created nine miracle babies (all female) conceived without male DNA. Their existence troubled people. There was outrage, anger, and fear. When a mysterious fire burned down the homestead, killing two people, the women took their daughters and fled. Hoping to start new lives, safe lives, out of the public eye.

Years later Josephine Morrow (Girl One) has learned that her mother, Margaret Morrow (Mother One) is missing. Naturally, she is worried and returns to their home, where another mysterious fire has occurred. Is there a connection? All her mother's belongings are still there including a phone number for a journalist. Could he hold the answers? Does he know something? Soon the duo is on a guest to find the truth...

Science fiction blends with mystery and fantasy in this book. I was excited by the synopsis and thought this would be a thrilling, dark and suspenseful book. For me, although enjoyable and intriguing, it left me wanting more. I admit, I am not a big Science Fiction reader and fantasy is hit or miss for me, but I thought it would work for me in this book as it is also marketed as being a thriller and dystopian. Two genres I love. This book took me longer than usual to read as I kept putting it down to focus on other things as I was not fully invested in this book. Having said that, I enjoyed the quest-for-truth aspect in this book. There are secrets, truths, and shocks for the characters.

Original, thought provoking and Intriguing.

Thank you to Farrar, Straus, and Giroux and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The story was amazing and thought-provoking. A very intriguing, action-packed, sci-fi, mystery thriller that will surely get your attention from the beginning until the end. An imaginative, dystopian theme exploring the ideas of virgin births and children with extraordinary abilities is something I find innovative and exceptional.

The story follows Josephine Morrow, the first-born girl of the nine Miracle Babies, conceived without the presence of a male reproductive cell and was raised in a community called the Homestead. When a suspicious fire broke out at the Homestead claiming the lives of its two members, the remaining mothers, and their daughters fled to live quietly and inconspicuously in different states. Several years later, Josie pursued a degree in experimental embryology at the University of Chicago to follow the footsteps of his "father". A year after leaving for college, Margaret Morrow, Mother One, was reported missing. Left with a few clues from their burned house, Josie, with the help of a news reporter named Tom, tracks down her fellow homesteaders to find her mom.

Narrated in the first-person perspective, the story is well-written with fully developed world-building and interesting characters. I loved that each chapter leaves you with a cliffhanger that encourages you to keep on reading. I love the surprising revelations and unwavering bond between the main characters. I wished there was more backstory regarding Dr. Bellanger's wife and his other son, Bobby.

Overall, this book is a must-read for lovers of sci-fi, mystery, and thriller, I hope the author decides to write a sequel to this amazing book.

I'm grateful to the author, the publisher, and Netgalley for allowing me to read and review an e-ARC of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

GIRL ONE tells the story of Josie Morrow, one of 9 girls created through a process called parthogenesis. Raised with the other 8 girls and their mothers, they live in a scientific compound called the Homestead. Already mired in sensation, the commune draws even more attention when a mysterious fire breaks out and kills one of the girls and the man behind the Homestead, Dr. Bellanger. Fast forward to the near-present, the past comes rushing back as Josie finds her mother’s house burned with no sign of her mother. Mysterious and fast-paced, the journey to find her missing mother thrusts Josie into a dangerous world filled with conspiracies and secrets, where she learns things about herself and her sisters that she would’ve never imagined.


𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐈 𝐥𝐢𝐤𝐞𝐝:⁣
* the feminist bent. Children are created solely from their mother’s DNA, no male required
* all of the different scientific bits. The author presented them in such an easy, straightforward way that even I, a notorious duddits, could understand them
* the mystery surrounding the original fire and deaths
* the super-intriguing atmosphere. So many secrets needed to be uncovered before Josie could even begin her search for her mom, and the mysteries continued to deepen until the big reveal
* the fast pace and the unrelenting feeling of impending doom
* the strong feeling of sisterhood and how all of these girls were inextricably linked, even apart from their unorthodox creation
* the questions, and the moral implications that go hand-in-hand with creating life outside of the accepted methods


Bottom line — GIRL ONE is a fantastic feminist thriller that will keep you turning the pages. There’s also plenty of food for thought, and it’s a book that will leave me thinking about it long after finishing.

*e-ARC received courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

This is so well-written and interesting that I almost believed that it could work. That the ending would make sense and pull everything together in a satisfying way. That doesn't happen. At the end, I realized that there was just no way to explain what was obviously not possible. Fun read, but not quite enough and I really felt bad that Jr wasn't in on the end.

Was this review helpful?

The comparisons to Orphan Black and Margaret Atwood hooked me immediately (I mean I don't have a Handmaid's Tale tattoo for nothing) and had me diving right into this book. And certainly those elements are there: a commune in the 1970s where nine girls are born by asexual reproduction. A mysterious fire that kills the brilliant doctor responsible. And one of those daughters on a quest to find answers about her past and present twenty years later.

There's a lot to like about the book's concept and writing style. Sara Flannery Murphy has written some gorgeous sentences here that I kept marking up to revisit later. I also love the insertion of documents like old letters and articles. It's one of my favorite moves as a writer and reader to fill in backstory.

Still, the plot's needs, the unraveling of the truth, becomes a bit tedious as the main character travels from place to place, learning a bit more information with each stop. It often feels like the story is barely progressing with more talking and reflection than action, so if you're looking for something fast-paced or an edge of your seat, this book isn't the stop for you. There's also a rushed confession at the end from the villain which reveals no new information but kind of neatly ties up the end.

I'd like to see more from this writer and could easily see this as a limited run television series where that plot progression would work well with segmenting the story.

Thank you to Farrar, Straus and Giroux Publishing And NetGalley for the eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The main character of this novel, Josie, is the Girl One of the title, the first of nine babies who were born on a commune of sorts called The Homestead by way parthenogenesis - that is, their mothers became pregnant without any male DNA being added, giving birth to babies who were genetically identical to them. But Homestead burned down and their mothers scattered with their daughters. 20ish years later, when Josie’s mom goes missing, she goes searching for her by seeking out all the other mother/daughter pairs, and finds out some surprising things along the way. Interestingly, this is not a dystopian book - it’s set basically in our world and in the past - the girls were born in the 1970s and the book takes place in the 1990s. The publisher’s blurb compares this book to Orphan Black and Margaret Atwood and that definitely gives you a sense of the tone of this one (perhaps shades of Naomi Alderman’s The Power as well). However, the book is also described as a thriller which I wouldn’t necessarily say it is, as despite the search for answers, the book moves VERY slowly. It was interesting though, and I bet it would make a good movie or limited tv series. 3.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Girl One: A Novel by Sara Flannery Murphy
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
Genre: Mystery & Thrillers
Publication Date: June 1, 2021

Girl One is a standalone novel by Sara Flannery Murphy. It is a work of science fiction brilliance with a great mystery! As a fan of Orphan Black and other like works, I loved Girl One! I really hope there will be a follow up!

I found this to be so fascinating! The story was fast paced with lots of twists and turns and unexpected happenings! I enjoyed that it was set in the 1990s. The story felt more plausible in a time before cell phones in every pocket and instead, with home phones with answering machines and pay phones still in existence!

I definitely recommend this book to anyone who loves genetics based fiction or someone who loves a great mystery! This is a great read and is one you won't soon forget!

I'm so grateful to Sara Flannery Murphy, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, and NetGalley for providing me with a free copy of this ARC ebook in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Fans of the X-Men and The Umbrella Academy will love this tale of superwomen “conceived” on a rural Vermont commune and slowly realizing their full capabilities while trying to fully understand their origins. The ultimate story of girl power, finding inner strength, learning the truth and achieving full potential. With numerous twists and a delicious slow burn, this story will keep you riveted from beginning to end.

An advanced copy of this book was sent to me by the publisher. The opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was definitely a book out of my norm and it kept my attention! I saw someone compare it to Thelma and Louise meets The X-Men with it set in the ninety's, which was a pretty accurate feel for me. This is a story about a young woman who finds her true self and her true family while also finally learning the truth of her childhood and living with it. Thank you #Farrar,StrausandGiroux #NetGalley for providing me the opportunity to review and provide feedback on #GirlOne #SaraFlanneryMurphy #PubDate06-01-2021.

Was this review helpful?

Girl One is perfect for those of you that want to see a little bit of science fiction in their thrillers. Or is it a little bit of thriller in their science fiction? Either way, that's the simple truth.

Josephine Morrow is a woman who has made it into hundreds of biological textbooks. In those books, she is most commonly known as Girl One. She was the first of her sisters (of a sort) to be born without a father.

Literally, her DNA is entirely of her mother's, with no father to help in her creation. There was a time when she and her family were happy about that fact. Now, years later, Josephine has begun to delve into the mystery surrounding her and the other eight girls – and what it will mean for them all.

"For a while I had lost myself in these calculations and the illusion of stability they offered."

In many ways, Girl One was very much not the novel that I was expecting. To be clear, that isn't a bad thing. I loved the blending of science fiction and thriller and sincerely wish there was more like it.

I think the reason for my surprise stems from my lack of knowledge surrounding two comparisons for this read. Girl One is marketed as ideal for fans of Margaret Atwood and Orphan Black. While I know that the show is wildly popular, I haven't actually watched it yet. So I was surprised by how far down the rabbit hole this book ended up going.

I was pleasantly surprised, as it turned out. I really enjoyed Josephine's story and all of the investigating she had to do in order to reveal the truth. That being said, readers who do not enjoy a slow burn might find some parts of this novel to be a bit dry or repetitive. As per usual, it all depends on your perspective and preferences.

It was easy for me to picture how Girl One could easily transform into a show (or audio serial, for that matter). Part of me is really wishing that will happen, while the rest of me doesn't want my hopes to get too high – again.

Was this review helpful?

This science fiction story of parthenogenisis (did I spell that right?) involves a 1970s cult of sorts with just nine women, and their daughters. The one man on site is a mad-scientist who has assisted the original nine women in reproducing without male DNA. There are nine healthy mothers, and their nine daughters, until in-fighting chases several pairs away shortly before a tragic fire leaves all the research destroyed, and two integral figures dead.

Josephine (Girl One) and her mother, Margaret, move to a quiet town where Margaret just wants to forget all the press of the Homestead commune and the 'Miracle' babies. She wants to be a good, normal mother, and raise a happy, normal daughter out of the spotlight that had brought so much hatred and devastation to their lives.

But then Margaret goes missing, and Josephine's childhood home burns. Josephine makes it her mission to find her mom and untangle the mystery that was life on the Homestead with the other eight mothers and daughters. She picks up some interesting partners along her journey, attempting to visit the other mothers and daughters spread around the country, and recreate her mother's journey to find where she ended up and ensure that she's okay.

While the storyline was unique, I also appreciated the subtle social commentary on the necessity of men. Somehow, even when they were creating offspring without a genetic contribution of men, a man was still in charge. And let's just say, it didn't end well.

I'd give this book 3 out of 5 stars. I can totally see the comparisons to authors like Margaret Atwood for the concept, but the writing felt more of a popular style than the speculative fiction and suspense that could have worked with the topic.

Was this review helpful?

Such a fantastic book. My favorite I’ve read so far this year. In a time when we as women face the likely loss of autonomy over our own bodies, this book is more relevant and important than ever. Sara Flannery Murphy’s writing is clear and concise, she presents the different viewpoints of her characters distinctly and, without turning preachy or maudlin delivers her message brilliantly. The world building is meticulous but never boring and I did not see any of the twists coming. But what I loved most is Girl One’s humanity. She could have so easily lost that throughout the story and yet she doesn’t. Highly highly recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

Josephine Morrow, also known as 'girl one', is one of few children created without any male DNA. Originating from a community known as the Homestead, the girls and their mothers separate after the doctor responsible for their creation dies in a tragic fire. Many years later, Josephine's mother goes missing and she sets out on a journey to find her that digs into her past and the lives of the Homestead girls.

This was certainly an interesting read with an original premise. Sara Flannery Murphy crafts a well-thought out, detailed story, that is layered with suspense and mystery. I found this book to be well written and enjoyed the endless amount of twists and bombshells. I would recommend this to anyone looking for a sci-fi book with a unique storyline. However, there was a lot going on at all times and you need keep track of several details while reading to avoid confusion.

Thank you to Sara Flannery Murphy, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, and NetGalley for an advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

Special. thanks to Farrar, Straus and Giroux Publishing And NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

I really like books about communes. This book is about a commune called Homestead. The book reads like a Marvel comics movie, with its supernatural touches. I liked it. It's not my favorite book on communes but it still was a good book. 3.3 stars

Was this review helpful?

Different... distinct... and interesting. The blurb doesn’t really let on how shocking this book is and it leads you on a thrill ride. These girls leave a trail of destruction a mile wide. Once Pandora’s box is open you really can’t put the knowledge back. The book deals with a ton of stuff that I didn’t see coming nor felt comfortable reading. Which made it a fence book for me. Three stars.

Was this review helpful?

This book is so good! I loved the blurb. I mean who can resist Orphan Black meets Margaret Atwood, right? The premise had me intrigued instantly and I can say that with authority (having read the book) that this book does not disappoint.

In the early 1970s, nine baby girls were born at a commune called Homestead and it generated a buzz in the world. There was a media frenzy with people for and against it. There was outrage from some men around the country against the scientist, Dr. Bellanger for it and one night there was a raging fire that burnt down the homestead, killing two people. A small child and Dr. Bellanger, the man who made it all possible.

The women and their children go their different ways, and the story picks up years later when Mother One, Margaret Morrow, the first woman to have given birth, is missing after another suspicious fire.
Her daughter, Girl One aka Josephine' goes out to find her estranged mother. I was instantly invested in Girl One's character and journey. She was the first of nine girls to be conceived from only her mother's DNA. I felt her emotional arc, her unresolved feelings towards her mother and the man who she considered her father, scientist Dr. Bellanger who helped in this phenomenal breakthrough.

Her journey leads her to all the other girls and is fraught with twists and turns which lead you to turn the pages as fast as you can.

Brilliant plotting and pacing. The characters feel real and I was fully connected with them. The end was a satisfying one too.

Definitely recommend.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for sending a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is a really awesome story. It follows a young lady Josephine aka Girl One as she searches for her mother. This reshapes what she has always thought about the beginnings of her life and about her mother. The story is an excellent page turner that is gripping. The characters are interesting and carries a wide range of emotions. The story unveils the cross between science and paranoia. It also explores the different forms of love. There are lots of surprises to be discovered as you uncover all the plot twists rushing to the wonderful conclusion.

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to NetGalley and Farrar, Straus & Giroux for gifting me a digital ARC of this intriguing book by Sara Flannery Murphy - 4 stars!

In 1971, Dr Bellanger "created" the first baby born without male DNA when Girl One, Josephine, was born at a remote commune called "The Homestead." Nine girls in total were created that were perfect clones of their mothers. But when a fire hit The Homestead and Dr Bellanger and one of the Girls died, his research died with him and all members spread out to live their own lives. In 1994, Josephine is now in medical school in Chicago, trying to follow in her father's footsteps and recreate his research. Then, there is another suspicious fire that destroys Josephine's mother's home and her mother, Margaret, is now missing. With the held of a journalist, Josephine sets out on a cross-country mission to find her long-lost "sisters" and mother.

This is a well-crafted science fiction thriller with lots of interesting topics - cloning, control, sexism. I loved that it was set in interesting time periods - in the 1970s when test-tube babies were first conceived and then in the 1990s, before cellphones, which always makes these types of thrillers more interesting. I really enjoyed the "sisterhood" that developed and the relationships between the mothers and daughters. I felt it was a little slow in the first half but I was fully invested in the second half and couldn't put it down!

Was this review helpful?