Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I have just finished the book and oh boy... It was beautiful.
The story about ferry man and ghost falling in love with each other was just part of it.
More is the book about grief, lost, death and the way how to handle them.
We follow Wallace, lawyer, who I did not like at all at the beginning as mc. After a few chapters I have fallen for him. Entire tea shop atmosphere is great, so the people in it, especially Hugo and Nelson. Mei was also an interesting character, but I had a feeling she was a bit behind the scene.

However without spoiling anything I cannot recommend the book enough.
I am giving 4,25 stars just because the ending was a bit dragging.

Favourite quote->
”The first time you share tea, you are a stranger. The second time you share tea, you are an honored guest. The third time you share tea, you become family.”

Was this review helpful?

First things first--eBook ARC graciously provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Thank you! Now that that's out of the way...

This book blew me away.

I knew I loved T.J. Klune already, but wow, wow, wow, wow, wow. I saw that it was being marketed as A Man Called Ove meets The Good Place, and that couldn't be more accurate.

Look, I'm a sucker for books about people learning humanity and found family tropes. This had both, PLUS queer stuff PLUS dogs. I probably cried for the last 30% of the book--in the best possible way. Want to feel uplifted? READ THIS BOOK. I *gasp* liked it even better than House in the Cerulean Sea.

Walk, don't run, to this book when it comes out.

Was this review helpful?

The second I saw that TJ Klune was releasing a new book this year, it was an automatic pre-order and arc request. After receiving the email that i was approved for the arc, I was overjoyed and immediately started reading. Stepping back into Klune's writing is so easy and effortless. There is no period of adjustment to the writer's voice. You feel like you are immediately in the story. Under the Whispering Door follows Wallace Price, a successful attorney who had just suddenly died. After waking up at his own funeral, a Reaper is in attendance to bring him to a way station for the newly departed in order to prepare for the beyond. After arriving at the way station, a motely crew of characters help Wallace come to terms with this death and try and make him understand what will be coming next.

While this book has the same voice as Klune's last novel, The House in the Cerulean Sea, it has a much slower pace and plot. There are points where additional details could have enriched the story line a bit but overall, the book had me crying at the end and has solidified Klune as an "automatic buy" author for me.

4.5/5

Was this review helpful?

This is a very sweet, fantastical read, yet it doesn't read as quite "done" for me. We're told Wallace is a jerk, and in the first couple of chapters, he is. And then we're told he's not. For a story about finding love and redemption, the "finding" part read as glossed over. The reader is told that Wallace is learning how to be a better person (well, ghost), but we don't actually go on the journey with him. It's frustrating.

It's still a delight to read--I'm always ready for a love story that doesn't focus on beautiful people trying to save the charming village landmark from an evil developer or emotional abuse = LOVVVVEEEEE. I enjoyed reading this, but it felt like it needed a finishing draft to really focus in on Wallace's redemption.

Was this review helpful?

What I Liked:
-This was SUCH a unique concept.
-I LOVED the characters. Klune always does a fantastic job at creating beautiful, real characters and this was no exception.
-Wallace's character arc was beautiful to watch.
-Apollo -- need I say more?

You Should Read If You Like:
-Any other TJ Klune book
-Books about what comes next

Was this review helpful?

Wallace Price thought he had a good life. Then he died, and then he met the ferryman….

Guys, I was worried about this one because it started off with a warning about the themes of this story (TW: Death and grief and suicide). But it’s a beautiful and at times hilarious story about life, death, family, and regrets.

With a blend of humor and sensitivity and a wonderful cast of side characters, this one held me in place for a one-day-read that I loved. I’m a smidge teary eyed, but the world is brighter for having read this lovely book!

Confession: I have not read any of Klune’s prior works, so this is my first. And based on this I am now adding Klune to the never ending TBR pile.

5/5 reaper penguins, pointing the way home.
🐧🐧🐧🐧🐧

ARC from NetGalley, release date September 21! Go preorder it now!!

Was this review helpful?

TJ Klune does it again! This is a heart wrenching read about death and the afterlife. It’s got his signature humor and wit while also being able to discuss very difficult topics with such ease. The writing is beautiful and simple and makes you think about the kind of person you are in life and the legacy you leave behind when you’re gone. I loved this story. I liked how it went through the stages of grief. I liked how the characters came together as a bunch of misfits to become a family unit. Some of the underlying stories gutted me and I actually ended up crying while other parts made me laugh out loud. What an excellent read!

Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Tor/Forge for access to this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Really lovely novel. I always love to see LGTBQ+ Affirming novels and this one hits a home run with fantasy meets romance.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this overall, but I wasn't really gripped by it nor did I feel especially connected to it. I think the main character being so incredibly AWFUL in the beginning, and the fact that his redemption arc only started because of his death... it just set me off on a very "meh" path with this.

Also the conversations on grief and loss and death didn't resonate with me on a personal level. I can definitely see how they would with most people, though.

Was this review helpful?

This has my name written all over it. The “someone dies and then they fall in love” trope is my absolute favorite. I love the way TJ Kline writes romance and found families. It just feels so cozy. The only thing that kept this book from being a five star read for me is Wallace’s sudden shift from a complete asshole to a good guy with a sense of humor. I would have liked to see that take a little more time and feel more earned and less jarring.

Was this review helpful?

I received an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review

My rating: 5 Stars

Content warnings: Death, Suicide, Murder, Violence

Proceed with caution as the books central theme is death and dying in all manners. The premise of this book is basically a bonafide asshole (dead) meets sweet, loving ferryman who is supposed to help him move through his life after death. The story follows as Wallace (asshole) learns to navigate his life after death, and the involvement of the handsome, kind ferryman, Hugo.

Wallace is the kind of character you love to hate (at first). You meet him and he instantly stands on every single nerve ending you have in your body. However, by the end of the novel, he has developed into a character you are rooting for and feel for. Mei (a Reaper) is the wholehearted comic relief of the novel. She is strong, independent, charismatic, and is not afraid of a fight. Mei is also down to earth and realistic about her job and takes it with intense pride. Nelson provides the jovial, witty old man banter throughout the novel and ultimately has everyones best intentions at heart. The characters in this novel all develop in ways that make you fall in love with them, and make you want to cheer for them.

The pacing of the novel was exactly what it needed to be. It explored the stages of grief and showed how it could be applied to people living and dead. It showed the importance of death in the world. The novel really did an amazing job of highlighting how death was not something to be feared as much as it was to be expected and met with grace and beauty. Reapers and Ferryman/Ferrywomen are there to promote peace and comfort to those who have died so that they can move on with no disdain in their hearts.

As someone who works with death all the time, I really couldn't have enjoyed this novel more. It really made me smile and brought a sense of peace that death isn't always regarded as a bad thing. Even the utilization of murder and suicide was done with a sense of poise. Would highly recommend to anyone, and wish I could think of more amazing things to say!

Was this review helpful?

This was weird, whimsical, gay, and I really enjoyed it. I think that the premise was very interesting, and I loved the entire cast of characters that reside in the tea shop: Hugo, Mei, Nelson and even Apollo. I think that TJ Klune does a really good job of creating these full of life zany characters to support the main character whose perspective we follow. Wallace went through a lot of change in the book, but I felt like some of the changes were too quick or abrupt; we are introduced to this completely different person and personality and then I feel as if he did a 180 on many things in just a few days, whereas I feel that some of the changes could have appeared more gradually. Nevertheless, I do recommend picking this up if you like TJ Klune's writing style and characters.

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5 stars

I adored this book, it was in my opinion, way better than the House on the Cerulean Sea. Please don't hate me, I did like that book, but loved this one a lot more.

So, we follow a man, Wallace Price, who literally worked himself to death (stress and being a workaholic played large factors in his life). When he was alive, he was a surly character who didn't care about anything in life other than working. He was mean and unlikeable. Then he dies, he’s guided by a Reaper, Mei, and taken to a ferryman, Hugo who will help to transition Wallace to his next journey.

It was slow paced for the first 50% - of the book, but then you get to see the wonderful character development and the bonds that Wallace makes. We also get introduced to Nelson, the grandad of Hugo and Apollo, Nelson’s dog, they’re both dead and are ghosts. However, Nelson impacts Wallace’s storyline and growth as a character. I absolutely loved all of the characters, even Wallace at the end.

Each character has their own story and the more I learned about it, the more I fell in love with the characters.
TJ Klune goes into sensitive topics in the book. There’s discussion about grief, death, closure, moving on, and love. We encounter different types of loss, partner, suicide, murder, etc. It gets hard to read about them, several times I had to stop reading and pick up later. There were several scenes that made me tear up and the ending made me cry, but I loved it anyway.

The book was a very emotionally impactful book, and I’ll definitely be getting a physical copy. Please make sure you are in the right place/mood, etc. before reading this book. The topics discussed are heavy and emotional. But do read it, I think it’s one of TJ Klune’s best novels.

Was this review helpful?

The more TJ Klune I read, the more I love him. This one was a bit slow on the beginning but probably around 40% I didn't want to put it down and I didn't want it to end. I adored Hugo and Nelson. The parts with Nancy and Cameron made me cry. And the bittersweet ending was just so perfect. Also, Klune includes the funniest moments that just work so perfectly.

Thank you so much to the publisher and author for the eARC. A review will be posted on www.instagram.com/bookendgetaway closer to the publication date.

Was this review helpful?

Under the Whispering Door is a beautiful tale of a hard and cruel man’s journey through death and the life lessons he learns along the way. First, I would encourage readers and lovers of The House in the Cerulean Sea to not go into Whispering Door expecting the same lightheartedness. Whispering Door is heavy with trigger warnings for suicide, loss of a child, and deep grief. However, it’s an absolutely beautiful story of loss, redemption, and love. I did find the description of the book a little misleading, as the Manager giving Wallace seven days before he must cross over doesn’t occur until about 70% into the book. There were some slow parts in the first half where it felt like not much was happening, however the ending tied everything beautifully.

Thanks to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Under the Whispering Door is a gentle novel about processing your life, death, and everything that comes with it. Wallace Price, a cold-hearted lawyer who owns his own firm, dies suddenly and ends up in the care of Huge, the ferryman, his reaper Mei, his grandfather Nelson, and their dog Apollo. The characters are vastly different and bounce off each other perfectly, the way any close knit group would work. The love between them holds them and the story together and makes it what it is.
To be honest, I had a hard time getting into it. I wasn’t sure what it was. I enjoyed the characters, especially Hugo. The story’s interesting, but it just wasn’t grasping me. However, once I reached around the 50% mark, I quickly fell in love with all of it and couldn’t put it down. Wallace turned into a beautifully written character that drove the narrative, all with the support from the others in the house. Once again, Klune wove together a story filled with heart, wonder, and love. The realistic world problems blend perfectly with the magic in the world.

Was this review helpful?

I love T J Klune's voice and this book is no exception. The subtle yet intimate romances, the inclusion, the banter between characters. A story of love and loss and a contemplation on death and making the most of the time that we have together. Klune is quickly becoming an "automatic TBR" whenever he publishes anything.

(Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an eARC in exchange for an honest review!)

Was this review helpful?

Who knew that a story about death could be so uplifting?

This is one of those books I went into completely blind. For reasons unknown, I assumed this connected to the House on the Cerulean Sea, maybe because of the playful cover. However, it became clear early on that this book that it was very different from Cerulean Sea (one of my favorite reads last year) but that difference doesn't make this book any less special.

In life, Wallace Price lived for his job.
Literally, that is all the man cared about.
He had no time for the small pleasures of life - laughing with friends, enjoying dinner with family.
Work was his whole life.

So you can imagine that after his death, he is lost, confused, and in his true nature, belligerent. Enter Mei, a Reaper, who delivers him to a ferryman named Hugo, who is there to help him transition for his new journey. I will admit, the early parts of this story felt a bit slow at times as Wallace is not at all likeable and I was unsure what Hugo had planned for him. But with time, the message and directly of the story became clear.

"Death isn't a final ending, Wallace. It is an ending, sure, but only to prepare you for a new beginning."

This story deftly covers some emotional themes involving death, and in the process, show Wallace how much he missed out in life. Is Wallace's time with Hugo his second chance? I adored how he found his place with the crazy cast of characters at Hugo's tea shop, and how those characters, including Hugo's granddad, Nelson, and their dog, Apollo (both dead), made an impact on him. Wallace's transformation during his stay, and the impact he had on others, truly brought tears to my eyes. Yes, once again, the author has left me in tears at the end of a book (happy ones to be clear).

". . . the one thing I've learned about being human is that we can't do this alone. When we're lost, we need help to try and find our way again."

Officially one of my favorite books of the year! An absolute must for those that loved Cerulean Sea.

Was this review helpful?

This book has turned me into a blubbering mess!

As usual, Klune has written an enchanting story full of beautiful, flawed characters. It asks all the right questions, and sets your mind spinning. I'm left breathless with emotion.

I don't think I'll ever pass a tea shop again without wondering...

Was this review helpful?

This is a warm, moving, emotional book about kindness, self-discovery, acceptance, loss and grief, And about found family, which is something Klune excels at.

We meet the protagonist Wallace— a driven, ruthless, detached attorney—just before his premature death. We follow him beyond—to a way station as he comes to terms with his death and what comes after. In the process he meets the small cast of characters that help him along the way and bring him to a fuller understanding not only of himself but of the human condition and the meaning of giving and connection and love.

The characters are rich and varied and relatable. They became quite dear to me but it took awhile for me to warm to them and I think that worked because the progression got me more invested in their stories.

There are some very emotional impactful scenes and some that are hard to read. I teared up a few times.

This is about closure, hope, redemption, self-discovery, grief, death, profound loneliness and isolation, found family, and moving on. Having lost a close family member not all that long ago this book resonated deeply. It makes you think and evaluate and re-evaluate priorities and expectations.

You’ll think about it long after you’ve finished it.

Highly recommended.

“The first time you share tea, you are a stranger. The second time you share tea, you are an honored guest. The third time you share tea, you become family.”

My thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan-Tor/Forge for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?