Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you, NetGalley and Macmillan-Tor/Forge for an ARC of this book. This review contains spoilers from the first book The Extraordinaries.

The good:
-A much more woke approach to police violence
-Aaron Bell's mission to embarrass Nick at all costs is pretty hilarious
-A nice, but predictable, twist at the very end
-Miss Conduct

The bad:
-Although this book is much more critical of the police, the main and side characters who are police officers are still portrayed as the good guys. They do recognize their mistakes and work towards improvement though.
-Seth being Pyro Storm is this big secret, but they talk about it literally every day in the cafeteria! Are they not concerned someone will overhear? Probably not that big of a deal, but it annoyed me.

The meh:
-There is a lot of setup for the next book. So a lot of events happened that we don't see the full consequences of, but are used to set up a character as the Big Bad.
-We found out Nick is an Extraordinary at the end of book one, Nick did not figure it out until about 40% through this book. That was a long 40% of dramatic irony that got a little old.

Although the plot wasn't as strong, I think this is a better book than the first one. We see the characters grow and question many of their beliefs from the first book. The introduction of Gibby and Jazz's parents was a good choice to bring in some comic relief as well as a way to include the missing social commentary. If you were turned off by the pro-police nonsense of the first book but loved the queer superhero aspect, I recommend reading this one to let Mr. Klune redeem himself. Plus, after that ending, I am already ready for book 3.

Was this review helpful?

Amazing!!
Middle book syndrome? Don’t know her!
Everything I was hoping for and so much more!!

Our little squad of disaster friends has come so far from book one and I enjoyed every minute of their story in book two! Flash Fire has the perfect mix of returning and new characters, and seeing these long-time best friends learn to trust outside their group was so cool! After enjoying The Extraordinaries so much last February, (and then binge-reading most of TJ’s backlist because I needed more of his genius in my life) I have been eagerly awaiting this sequel to find out what happens next!

With just as much fun-filled chaos as The Extraordinaries, Flash Fire also does an incredible job of broaching important topics such as police brutality, blind hero-worship, accepting due consequences for your actions, the importance of communication and consent in any relationship, and of course... the power of friendship and family.

And for anyone who is as curious as I was ... yes ... the bowties do make a reappearance in the sequel!! 😂

Now ... how on earth am I going to hold out for book 3?!

Rating: 5⭐️
Release date: July 13 2021

A huge thank you to @raincoastbooks and @tjklunebooks for the earc!

Was this review helpful?

I'd hoped I would enjoy this book more than the first, but I found myself having a lot of the same issues. I was still frustrated by the utter lack of consequences Nick has for any of his behavior. He was out of line many many many times in the story, but more often than not, he would manage to make himself the victim, and the other person would somehow end up apologizing (namely Seth). The relationship between Nick and his dad still weirded me out, and despite the work that was done to distance this book from cops, which I think was the right move, but I didn't think it was done in a great way. Gibby's character in this book was basically just reduced to just be a way to convey that info, which I found really frustrating because I was hoping we would get to see more of her as an actual character. There were some fun new characters, though I found some of the plot decisions came a bit out of the blue, and I just couldn't really connect with anything happening since I found Nick pretty unlikable. I'll still read the last book when it comes out since this book left off with such a revelation, but I couldn't really get into this book.

Was this review helpful?

Once again TJ Klune has delivered an entirely predictable superhero story that is all the more enjoyable for that fact. You come into this book expecting several things to happen—and they do—and most of the internal superheroic twists and turns are highly telegraphed to anyone who has read a comic book or watched a good superhero cartoon, and it is absolutely delicious. It's really masterful how so many references and allusions to superhero tropes are worked in!

The first book in this series was entirely too credulous toward the police and entirely too flippant about police brutality. This book revisited and reworked that aspect in a big way, grappling with issues that in the first book were oversimplified and underexamined. It was awkward and made me wish again that those mistakes hadn't been made in the first place, but it was absolutely necessary if this series is going to continue, and I think the next book will be much stronger for the changes that happened in this one.

Klune's characters and their speech patterns and phrases suffer from a little repetitiveness and lack of differentiation—it can be confusing when a lot of characters are having a conversation with each other, because many of them speak so similarly. I hope this continues to improve in future entries in the series as well!

Was this review helpful?

Hey book buddies!
-
Review time: Flash Fire by T.J Klune!
-
As you all know, The extraordinaries was probably one of my favorite books of all time. So thank you @torteen and @netgalley for the E-arc.
-
So let’s get down to it. Flashfire Has left me with a mixture of emotions. On one hand I love Nicky and Seth and their developing relationship. Chapter one had me dying laughing and I was like YES YES YES. But sadly, that excitement got smooshed for me when the author tried to “fix” the wrongs in the first book. The dad whose a cop and hit a suspect. The scene this happens feels like he’s TRYING to fix it but it came off as just very poor taste. And this is dragged out in little snippets throughout the book. To me if the extraordinaries was just a small fire, instead of putting out the flames he tried to stomp on them and spread them. It was all just a mess for me.
-
I loved the new characters we got to meet and seeing the relationships between the squad. And anytime Nicky and Seth were alone together was gold. Unfortunately the author did another thing at the end of the book (no spoilers) which was a major boner killer for me.
-
I’m going to read book three purely for Nicky and Seth. But I can confidently say, this is no longer going to be my favorite trilogy sadly. 3/5 for Flashfire for me. I hope you all check out my favorite lil adhd riddled gay boy though!
-

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much, NetGalley, Macmillan-Tor/Forge and Tor Teen, for the chance to read and review this book! I love this saga so much and I was so happy for this opportunity!

Nick and Seth are happily together, but their lives are complicated when other Extraordinaries arrive in Nova City and with their friends they have to understand who's good and who's evil. Between secrets and powers, corruptions and discoveries, Nick, Seth, Jazz and Gibby have to rely on one other and their family to fight for the right thing and themselves.

I LOVED reading Flash Fire! It's hilarious, sweet, amazing and I loved everything about this book. I laughed, I cried, I swooned, I smiled with these awesome characters, captured by the story, their lives and adventures.
It's impossible not to love Nick and his beautiful mind, his writing fanfictions, his love for Seth, his friends and his dad.
Nick and Seth's relationship is one of the best I've ever read. The way they love, support, laugh, joke with, one other is truly beautiful and it warms my heart every time. They are impossibly cute together, as best friends, boyfriends, partners. I love how they communicate with one other, how they talk and share their fears and doubts, how truly intense is the bonds between them, but also between every character. I love when people talk and there aren't miscommunications and useless dramas! This book gave me so much life!

I loved everything about Flash Fire, it's filled with plot twists, new characters, old enemies, secrets and discoveries, sweet and intense moments, so many laughs and I can't wait to hold it in my hands.
TJ Klune has a wonderful way to describe relationships and their intricacies, between friends, boyfriends and girlfriends, parents and sons and daughters, in a relatable and realistic way.
With sensitivity and care the author talked about all kind of relationships, safe sex (I'll laugh forever reading those moments), but also police corruption, the way Black people are seen and treated by them, the strength and difficulty of holding onelself accountable, realizing one's mistakes and trying to be better.
I love the message in this book, the hope that, even in the face of hate and danger, it's important be oneself, be together, support and love one other, that there's strength in love and friendship.

It's a book about all kind of love, queer love, parental love, friend love and it filled my heart so much, reading about these characters, Nick, Seth, Jazz, Gibby, but also their parents and family, be ready to do anything for one other, supporting, helping, talking with, one other and it's truly beautiful and moving.
(I've also loved how Nick corrected those saying Seth was gay, instead of bisexual, not wanting his sexuality to be erased.)

Flash Fire is probably one of the funniest, most intense and most moving book I've read this year and it's unbelievably AWESOME! It makes you fall in love with love, believe in friendships and families and in hope.
These characters have all my heart.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoy TJ Klune's works and this was no exception. His characters are always fun and over the top and it always makes for a fun read. Perfect follow on from the first one, and I will eagerly await the third book.

Was this review helpful?

You know how in films and on TV when someone has a second child they say that they don't love their first any less, their heart just expands instead....well that is how I feel about T.J. Klunes books.

I had no doubt that Flash Fire would be just as amazing as The Extraordinaries (which I raved endlessly about to anyone that would listen) and my faith in T.J. Klune was entirely justified. Nick and his friends are so freaking amazing and the cuteness was out of this world. Saying that, this book isn't all sunshine and roses, it covers a variety of different serious topics and promotes awareness for them throughout the story in a way that feels completely natural.

If I didn't already know about the whole heart expanding thing from my experience reading first Wolfsong, then The Extraordinaries and The House in the Cerulean Sea, I might have thought it was impossible for me to love these characters any more but I know that when book 3 comes out my heart will be expanding once again!

Thank you NetGalley and Macmillan-Tor/Forge for providing me with a free digital copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

What a sequel! In this second installment of The Extraordinaries, Nick Bell finds himself navigating so many typical teenager moments and so many that are not so run of the mill. The major one of these is balancing his emotions about his relationship with new-boyfriend/lifelong bff Seth while also balancing his place beside the superhero Pyro Storm who, book one spoilers, *is* Seth.

There was a lot of discussion after the first Extraordinaries about how Nick’s dad is a cop and painted in a very favorable light. When the book was released in July of 2020, this was… a very fair critique. Klune was vocal about how there would be changed moving forward. I expected there to be some light dialogue, but Klune does not shy away from it. He addresses the concerns of the characters in the book who are Black, and their discomfort over Nick’s dad being around them and their families. There’s a lot of commentary about the police in this book and it’s done incredibly well.

In this book especially, I felt the cheekiness of Klune’s prose. Maybe it’s that I was more attuned to it, but there are parts that are too over-the-top obvious or parts of dialogue (with one-off characters) that are in no way how any person would speak. And that’s part of the charm of this book and this series. The voice and the prose work to make this feel like a comic book, a superhero film, and a novel all rolled into one. There is a uniqueness to how this book reads that is entirely intentional and part of what makes it sing.

And then we have main character, Nick Bell. I love Nicky’s voice, his internal dialogue, his louder than life ideas, and how honest he is to everyone and himself. His interactions with his dad (especially when it comes to his relationship with Seth oh my god) are some of the best in the book. The second-hand embarrassment at having a parent repeatedly address The Sex Talk is too real. It works so well because we care about Nick immediately. We want him to succeed and we want him to find his place and we want him to feel extraordinary.

I am going to be counting down the days until the third one is released. I cannot get enough of this world. I will also be on the hunt now for a certain tuxedo mentioned in this book. I need it. I need it badly.

5 ~extraordinary~ stars.

Was this review helpful?

I have become such a fan of TJ Klune's writing, especially over the last year, and I am thrilled to say he is back on top form here in this follow up to the sensational The Extraordinaries.

Was this review helpful?

This follow up was everything I wanted from TJ Klune!

The characters were just as entertaining and endearing as they were in The Extraordinaries. I liked that we got a bit more from the adult characters, and (as an adult reader) I really thought their perspectives on their children's superhero and life experiences was well done. Each character and relationship got some more development and substance that made them feel more real.

I also felt this book was much stronger in the plot. I didn't feel like the plot twists were as obvious as they were in The Extraordinaries. I was shocked time and time again about where the plot was going, whereas I felt the first book was very easy to predict. I continued to love how "teenager" this book felt with school, college decisions, and changing friendships all featuring prominently. It would be easy to ignore or spend less time on these to focus on the exciting superhero plot, so I was happy to see them included. Oh, that ending. Once again, I have to start counting down to the next book!

One of the things I was happiest to see was how well Klune addressed the criticism of The Extraordinaries in relation to Nick's dad, and the police in general. Klune has said he would be addressing it in the second book after listening to the critiques after the first book, but I didn't expect it to be such a major plot point. You really got to see Nick struggling with how he feels about his dad when it comes to race relations and police brutality. I can't speak to how well this was done as a white reader, but seeing how seriously he was taking the issues expressed to him was very heartening.

Was this review helpful?

This was almost everything I wanted in a sequel to the extraordinaries. Cute, SO funny and with engaging dialogue between interesting characters. The only disappointment was that the story wasn't quite as good as the first, with the antagonists not being as developed and the plot twists being predictable.

Was this review helpful?

Wholly lovable, charming, readable, and fun. I adore everything TJ Klune does and this book is no exception. This is the heartwarming superhero romance we all needed. Who knew!?

Was this review helpful?

I just finished Flash Fire and I am in a severe book hangover. The characters in this book are all so well developed that when the book ends, you feel like you are saying goodbye to good friends. I love spending time with all of them. They make me smile and laugh and cry and even teach me a few things. The Extraordinaries series is one of my favorites and I can't wait for more!

And speaking of endings, WOW. I think that ExtraordinariesSuperFan put it best when they said "OMF GOD! This was AMAZING! But why did you have to leave it on ANOTHER CLIFFHANGER???!!! AAAAAAAAA (Quote from The Extraordinaries)

Was this review helpful?

Flash Fire is everything I was hoping for and more. The story picks up after the epic battle of the bridge and continues with team PyroStorm and lighthouse. Nick has given up trying to become and extraordinary but little does he know that being an extraordinary is in his blood, and he will soon have to navigate what it means to be an extraordinary.

Being an extraordinary is more than just being a superhero, but being true to yourself, your family and friends. Flash Fire made me laugh out loud and cry multiple times, with a cliffhanger that I never saw coming. If you enjoyed the first book you will enjoy Flash Fire and be wishing you could read what is happening next now!

Was this review helpful?

This book is just terrific. I so enjoyed the first book in the series, and this sequel met -- and exceeded -- expectations. It is the story of Nick, his friends, and their family as they navigate the responsibilities that come with being extraordinary -- what they owe each other, their communities, their family, and themselves. If you enjoyed the Extraordinaries, you will definitely enjoy this book. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

This book is funny, exciting, and inclusive. So often YA books are written as if the characters are adults, but here is a book where parents are present, students attend school, and dialogue is realistic.

The premise for this sequel is great, and the ending was perfect. I loved how unique the story was, a real stand-out in YA new releases.

Was this review helpful?

A FANTASTIC follow up to the first book! I need book three now, that was such a wild cliffhanger! Another triumph from TJ Klune!

Was this review helpful?

Flash Fire's characters were random and its fanfiction a little cringe-worthy, but this book made me laugh more than I have in years.

The characters were sweet. The plot was solid and moved well, and while I knew some twists, it wasn't predictable--the last twist I got wrong (I wasn't expecting quite that) .

Overall, Flash Fire is definitely worth reading, and I really look forward to the next book.

Was this review helpful?