Cover Image: By Any Other Name

By Any Other Name

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

First of all, I really enjoyed this book. A lot. The author’s prose is just a work of art. It kept me so engaged I read it all in one sitting. I just loved it- about 75% of it. My gripes are small, but significant. Lanie’s relationship with Ryan. The author really presents them as solid. It feels like the break up comes out of nowhere. It feels forced almost after Lanie meets Noah. My second gripe is the ending. You know it is coming. The anticipation is there. And then it just…. Ends. I would have liked to see more to the story. Because really, the writing was that good. And I feel it would have been nice as the reader to get to explore lanie and Noah being together. All in all this was a solid 4 stars for me. Thank you to netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Awww! I realized happy tears of a person also look smudgy and ugly! I keep dropping them nonstop! This book is magnetic, heartfelt, magical! It awakens your soul and gives you enough hope to chase your own happiness!

Lanie lives her own dream: thriving career as romance editor, working with her all time favorite author Noa Callaway, having a full filled relationship with her fiancée who checks 99 boxes she’s created for finding man of her dreams.

After two decades she still misses her mother who gave her the real life purpose: chasing the love of her life and never letting him go!

Now she gets the promotion she’d worked so hard: she becomes youngest editorial director of Peony Press but there’s a catch: this promotion is only trial for three months. They didn’t get any manuscript from Noa Callaway for four months and if Lanie cannot get NY Times bestseller- worthy manuscript out of Noa during her promotion period, she will be sagged!

But she says she can do that! But she knows it’s truly hard to connect with her favorite author in person. Noa Callaway is the publishing company’s powerhouse author with forty million books in print around the world. But she’s also the rare publishing phenomenon who doesn’t do publicity. Nobody knows how she looks like instead of Alice De Rue: Lanie’s ex boss who retired after her maternal leave.

Even she never saw her face: Lanie believes they have a unique connection with the author. They are playing online chess for years and Noa always sends her inspirational and entertaining text messages.

What could go wrong? Well, she didn’t count two things: Noa is having a terrible writer’s block and Noa keeps a scandalous secret from them for seven years which shake Lanie to the core and make her question everything she believes in love. Because she wrote that those 99 boxes inspired by Noa’s novel. But what if everything she believes about love is full of lies like Noa has been telling them for years.

Overall: I loved the main characters a lot. But BD is my favorite, smart, entertaining supporting character. I also enjoyed to read Rufus and Meg’s parts.

Romance parts were slow burn and magical. The author’s location choice of Gapstow Bridge Central Park couldn’t be so right. Me and my husband shot a movie in NYC and we also chose this location at the ending tear jerking, emotional scene of lovers! That’s also my favorite place in the city!

I always love to read books about books. The end of Elizabeth and Edward’s story was amazing. I wish the author wrote a real book about them.

Only thing I didn’t like much was lack of enemies to lovers troupe: because at the beginning MCs’ first encounter gives us that vibe. But they quickly made truce and moved on. I wish the main characters spend more time together. And there were more chapters in this book showing they’re discovering new places in NY together.

I loved the slow burn romance idea and conclusion at the end. But I wish we see more chemistry and intimacy. We only see those parts from Lanie’s perspective. But we didn’t know what’s going on in our hero’s end till the end of the book.
I’m giving my romantic, big apple, books in books, romance reader, smiling, feelgood stars.

Special thanks to NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Putnam/ G. P. Putnam’s Sons for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange my honest opinions.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the premise of this book- and it was a light refreshing love story with lots of likable characters. I especially love the ending. I was given an ARC of this one from NetGalley in exchange for a review.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book! I loved how it took place in the book publishing world. I was invested in the story & happy with how it ended. I would recommend it to friends!

Was this review helpful?

Maybe 2.5 stars? It seems unfair to rate this one at three stars, since I also gave Helen Hoang's books three stars, and they were SO much more charming. (it's possible now that I'm reading more contemporary romance, that I need to go back and re-rate Hoang's books in relation to the actual genre, rather than in relation to Crooked Kingdom.) In the end, IDK, I liked this as a filler book? But I don't know that I'd enthusiastically recommend it to anyone?

Pros:
• Unlike some other romance ARCs I've picked up and abandoned, I actually wanted to read this one to the end.
• The main characters were kind of charming and the whole thing went down really easy.

Cons:
• The supporting characters were the same NY stereotypes that we've been seeing since SATC days (and Probably Before Then, I just don't have that reference point)
• Ends pretty much at first kiss, just in case you were hoping for Steamy Bits

Also, I now am very very interested in the physics of confetti cake balloons. That just seems...unsanitary.

Was this review helpful?

I love romantic stories set in the world of writers and book publishing, so I was predisposed to love this story about Lanie, a New York-based romance publishing editor, and her publishing house's prolific blockbuster writer, whom Lanie's admired and worked with for many years but has never met. When the author's writer's block starts to cause headaches for the publishing schedule and her work life, Lanie has to level up and level with one writer's massive ego and reclusive work habits to earn a coveted promotion and help produce a manuscript they can all be proud of. This is a sweet, smart, heartfelt (closed-door) romance that has you rooting for this endearing couple.

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited to try By Any Other Name! This was one of the few times I started an ARC as soon as I received it. Unfortunately I only got 35% of the way into the story before realizing I do not like the characters enough to continue. I am also concerned that it is labeled as a romance but the FMC is engaged to someone else for the majority of the book. DNF

Was this review helpful?

- 2.5 stars

the premise of "by any other name" was what drew me in, but unfortunately, it didn't quite raise to my expectations of what this book could be. i can't say that i didn't enjoy it, because i had fun reading it and it's so easy to get through - i finished it in a day.

i didn't quite understand the relationship between the two main characters, because it wasn't developed at all. there isn't much chemistry between them either, so the fact that they fell in love based on a few days spent together is a bit far fetched for me. noah and lainie just didn't make much sense together. i kinda think we're supposed to ship them together after seeing how she was treated by her fiancé, but i had nothing to root for.

now, the main conflict of this book wasn't great. i really didn't like how she reacted to the realisation of noa calloway's identity. she acted so unprofessional and rude towards an author that didn't owe her anything. it was so weird to see her almost put her job in jeopardy because she couldn't grasp that said author had a secret - and she got mad at them for keeping the secret. as if authors can't have lives besides writing.

noah didn't have much of a personality, in my humble opinion. he was there as a love interest and that's it - nothing exciting about him. nothing to root for, no reason to ship him with the MC. some interactions he had with lainie kinda made me cringe a little bit. like he instantly likes her after she was so rude to his face. very little logic to support his actions.

i loved lainie's aunt. the book got 100% better whenever she came around. the other side characters were pretty standard - the gay best friend and the mom. the mom friend complained so much about her marriage that it became annoying at some point, but alas. tbh, the side characters were stereotypes personified. not much to say about them, but they certainly had more character than noah.

thank you to netgalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Loved the premise and really enjoyed the read. Noah/Noa and Lanie were so cute together. But I thought there would be more tension or more obstacles for getting together. The plot was almost too smooth.

Was this review helpful?

I simply adore when I find a new-author-to-me that rocks my reading world. I’m sad to say I’d never heard of Lauren Kae until I requested BY ANY OTHER NAME because the premise sounded so good.
Lanie ( Elaine) is a romance book editor at Peony Press. For 7 years she’s been editing her all-time favorite author, Noa Calloway’s. But they’ve never met. Noa is uber introverted, secretive, and doesn’t crave the limelight.
But then Lanie is promoted to editorial director and forged with getting Noa’s new book – 4 months overdue – to press and she is forced to meet her idol.

What’s that old saying about meeting your idol? They may not be the person you imagined?

So begins a great romance story that I finished in one sitting because I simply had to know what happened.

Lanie is my kind of girl – a true romantic at heart and down to her soul. Lauren Kate writes her like she’s her best friend, like she knows Lanie and has forever. Her backstory is tragic, yet lovely, and her present-day situation is a common one to all single women in the world.

I’m struck by the Wizard of Oz quote ( which I’m paraphrasing)– When you go looking for your heart’s content, don’t go further than your own backyard, Lanie finds love in her own backyard, and before she even knows it’s love!

Amazing.
Thank you to Negalley and Penguin for allowing me a sneak peek at a truly lovely book. I am now a Lauren Kaye fan!
5 well-deserved stars!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you netgalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I was intrigued by the premise of this novel; a hungry, young editor looking for an opportunity to do what she loves and meet the author of her dreams. When she does meet the author she gets the surprise of her life and the adventure and friendship that follows is epically romantic and sweet. Noa finally writes the novel of all novels and its based on real love. only I felt their love story felt rushed and flat. Just wished for a more climactic ending.

Was this review helpful?

What a cute surprise. I wasn’t sure what to expect when I started this book but I couldn’t put it down.

Lanie is a romance editor who absolutely loves elusive romance author Noa who writes under a pseudonym and does no press or publicity. Lanie believes in the happily ever afters written about in Noa’s books and has molded her own search for her true love based on the books. She has a fiancé that is great on paper but it’s clear from the beginning that they want different things for the future. When a promotion at work puts her face to face with her idol, her world is spun and she begins to question things. In order to help cure Noa’s writers block the two set off on mini explorations to get the ideas sparking. This book is a love letter to New York and also explores the beauty and magic of Positano - two of my absolute favorite places to visit. The book was a cute rom com and I enjoyed every minute. My only complaint was the ending was rather abrupt and I would have liked to have seen a tad more on the after part of the love story. All in all a super cute, fun read that I highly recommend.

Thank you to NetGalley for the chance to read an arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The cutest cover for the cutest book; what a pleasure By Any Other Name by Lauren Kate was. The friendship was cute; while I did not enjoy that she was engaged, it was a cute story nonetheless.

Was this review helpful?

O.M.G THIS BOOK! I requested it and I'm very happy that I got approved for this book. Thank you NetGalley and Putnam! This book has a very good cover (seems like a very cute romance!) and Lanie is lovable for me! And also the chemistry between Lanie and Noa is really intriguing and I love it! The characters felt alive for me, and the writing is, simply put, AMAZING! Lauren Kate, you've done it again! I really recommend this book to those who loves a cute romance with great-chemistry characters (especially the main characters) and good writing with a cute cover!

Was this review helpful?

The cover and blurb drew me to read this contemporary romance. Lainie has been promoted to her dream job working as an editor to the publishing company's biggest writer. Her job is contingent on getting the latest manuscript which is months over due. She learns that Noa Calloway is actually a pseudonym for Noah Ross and he's having writers block. She decides to help him find

I liked: Their friendship, playing chess, finding possible meet cute locations.
Her friends and grandmother enrich her story.

Disliked: She is engaged till 42% of the way through.
There didn't seem to be much chemistry. There were outings and talks but no heat.
Much ado about coming out as male author of romances.
I liked the story within the story the Noa writes.

Overall I enjoyed the story but usually I love characters that love love. But I didn't see why they should be together anymore than her previous fiancé. They were both good guys although Noah is more convenient. Clean for language and intimacy is off the page. Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group Putnam for an ARC ebook in exchange for an honest review. (3.5 stars)

Was this review helpful?

By Any Other Name was a pleasant surprise. I wasn't expecting such a strong reaction from Lanie when she learned of Noa's real identity. I loved the book but wish they Noah and Lanie had connected a little more throughout the story. The story was sweet with a friends-to-enemies-to-friends-to-lovers romance that leaves you wanting more. I would like to see a sequel or follow-up story to give us a glimpse into Lanie and Noah's happily ever after.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed reading this. I liked how their romance developed throughout. I was initially worried that upon reading that Lanie has a fiance in the beginning of the book that lead up to their eventual breakup would drag on but was pleasantly surprised that it did not. I do think her initial reaction to finding our Noa Callaway is actually a man seemed a bit much. I can see the shock but the utter outrage seemed a bit too over the top at first. I have mixed feelings about it. I understand her reaction as they were online friends for years but I would think with her years in publishing that having any author known solely by their pseudonym, it would not have been as completely shocking to find out they are different than their publishing persona. I also thought the story ended somewhat abruptly. Their relationship came full circle but I think an epilogue that places a few months after would add to the story. Like how did the launch party in Italy go? Could they keep working together after the start dating or did Noah have to switch editors? I would love to know the answers to those questions. Overall I thought it was a lovely book and a well written and developed romance.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me a digital copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I'll start by channeling my inner Voldemort: I confess myself...disappointed.

Insta-love, weird time jumps, unprofessional behavior from both of our leads, and 0 spice. :( I liked Noah, couldn't stand Lanie. This had promise, but there were way too many things that happened juuuuuust right to get these two together.

Was this review helpful?

By Any Other Name
Lauren Kate
Lanie and Ross
Lanie is an editor at Peony Press and their bestselling author of romance noels, Noa Callaway turns out to be a man named Noah Ross. Lanie feels duped that she has been working with an author she assumed was a woman. Noa is behind on the delivery of his next book and Lanie’s position as editor is provisional on her getting his manuscripts to Peony within 3 months. She’ll have to work through her anger. But as she works to help him find a story that will inspire him to write, her anger starts to change to something that looks like love.
What a beautiful book! Lanie and Ross are so well drawn and real. The fact that Noa the writer is actually Noah Ross, a man, give this enemies to lovers trope a real twist. Their road from anger to love was endearing and absorbing.
I would recommend this book to my patrons.

Was this review helpful?

When her boss decides not to come back after her maternity leave, Lanie finds herself in what was supposed to be her dream job -- editorial director and editor of the publisher's most successful author, Noa Calloway. Unfortunately, her promotion is contingent on getting Noa to complete her latest manuscript, which is already four months overdue. She's worked with Noa for years as a junior editor, so she feels she knows her pretty well. But she's never met her. No one has, because Noa Calloway is famously reclusive and refuses to tour, meet readers, or attend meetings. Lanie needs to assure Noa's success, and in doing so, her own. This is a truly fun romantic comedy with great characters and a well paced plot. I look forward to recommending it to readers.

Was this review helpful?