Cover Image: The Truth About Elves

The Truth About Elves

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Interesting novella. A present day embodiment of the Prodigal Son story, as I see it, and sharing the central themes of love conquering all, the strength of family, and the real purpose of Christmas - family.

Was this review helpful?

In a Nutshell: This had a very creative concept but unfortunately, the writing style and my expectations didn’t match the author’s imagination.

Story:
Curtis works as a bartender in Las Vegas for 9 months and in the Arctic Circle as Santa's helper for the remaining quarter of the year. This has been his life for the past ten years. Prior to that, he was an airline pilot, but a bad plane accident changed the course of his life. During his latest assignment in the North Pole, where Curtis is disgruntled at having been called during a different quarter than his regular schedule, Mr. C (the Claus himself) agrees to give him a different assignment. Unbeknown to Curtis, this assignment involves him having to confront his past. Will he finally be able to put all the grief inside him to rest?
Most of the story comes to us from Curtis’s first person point of view.

Where the book appealed to me:
😍 It was quick. About 120 pages long. So it won’t take too much of your reading time.
😍 For the first time ever, I saw an Indian character in a Santa Claus story in an elf named ‘Prerna’. Woohoo!
😍 The prologue was fabulous. If the entire story had proceeded as the prologue did, this would have been a five star read for me.
😍 The concept is great. Imagine having elves who aren’t short and pointy-eared but regular humans who volunteer at the North Pole for a quarter of the year. Such a unique idea!
😍 The idea of having a holiday book centred around grief and loss is also very different.

Where the book disappointed me:
😕 The writing style needed a bit of fine-tuning. It sometimes contains telling instead of showing. There is a frequent back and forth in the timeline, not just with the accident and the present time period but also with various flashback events that Curtis mulls over in the present. In spite of this, or probably because of this, the story feels quite jumpy and there's no smoothness or sleekness to the narrative flow. (From the author’s bio, I can see that she has a lot of writing experience and even offers writing exercises on her podcast. So I’m not really sure what went wrong here, but in all honesty, I found the content more cluttered than structured.)
😕 There are a few plot points that aren’t explained. The only one I can reveal without going into major spoilers is this: how did Curtis become an elf? We know he had an accident, and we know he started working as an elf after that. But how did he sign up, especially when it is specified that regular humans aren’t even aware of this job profile and don’t know of Mr. C’s actual existence? If one of Santa’s people approached him to join the elves as some kind of redemptive support (which is certainly possible), it would have been such a lovely addition to the story.
😕 One big reason for my disappointment is that bane of all humanity: expectations. From that gorgeous cover, I thought this would be a magical Christmas story focussed on elves and/or Santa. Well, there was a little bit of magic and some elves, and Santa of course. The blurb too didn’t help. It mentions holiday magic and Santa and elves, but it doesn’t say that the story is focussed more on grief and loss than on joy and contentment. I’m not docking off stars for this reason because this particular feedback is more from my assumptions about the story because of the cover and blurb.
😕 The title leads you to believe that elves are a major part of the story. They are. But because the way the book defines elves—elves are Santa’s human helpers and not those magical creatures you have encountered in other Christmas books-- you feel like you are reading a story about regular humans than about elves. Except for a couple of Santa’s interference in Curtis’s life (where the magic is only hinted at), there’s no magic in the book. Every part of the Christmas night is explained in terms of human experience. (Scheduling, planning, material management, work shifts, plane travel, warehouses…) Basically, the story turned a potential holiday fantasy into a regular drama.

As is evident, I loved the idea of the story but didn’t quite enjoy the execution of it. As with every Christmas story, there is a strong moral coming out: coming to terms with your grief, accepting it, and moving on. But because this moral is entirely human, the title is misleading.

I am not sure who the right target audience for this book is. It's not for younger kids or preteens, regardless of what the title suggests. There is reference to death and sex, and of course, they’ll be disappointed to see no magical little men in the story. Teens could find it boring as it's more about the angst of an adult, and the protagonist is also an adult in at least his late twenties if not his early thirties. Adults might not even pick it up because of the cutesy title and cover that are more indicative of a children's story. That leaves us with the YA audience. As there is an element of coming-of-age to the story in spite of Curtis’s being older than the typical age of YA leads, this could work for YA readers. I hope this works for them because every book needs a target audience.

I was very muddled between 1 star and 2 stars for this book, but my prerequisite for a 1 star rating is that it was a waste of my reading time. But at just a little more than 120 pages, I didn’t really waste much time on this read. It certainly had tremendous potential. (And I am a bit more generous towards indie books.) Where it loses is in the poor writing, plot structuring, and deceptive blurb/cover/title. So I’ll go with 2 stars and send my best wishes to the author for her next writing venture. If only this had worked out better for me.

My thanks to Atmosphere Press and NetGalley for the ARC of “The Truth About Elves”. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.

Was this review helpful?

I love reading holiday stories, especially those that give me an insider's glimpse at the behind-the-scene world of Santa, his elves, and the North Pole. It all seems so magical to me.

The Truth About Elves offers a peek at the troubled life of Curtis, a bartender in Vegas for nine months out of the year and an elf for Santa the other three. Who knew elfing could be a part-time gig? Curtis has some issues to work through but with the help of some Santa magic, things just might work out.

This is a delightful little story that offered me a little escape for a few hours as I soaked up the wonders of the North Pole and the ever wonderous world and characters surrounding Santa Claus. I highly recommend The Truth About Elves and hope that you take a little time out of your busy schedule this season to enjoy some holiday magic

Was this review helpful?

I don't like giving bad reviews but this book did not work for me. It's not Christmassy at all and the plot is bizarre.
And I'm left wondering -- how did Curtis/Josh become an elf?

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Atmosphere Press through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thank you, Atmosphere Press.

Was this review helpful?

I liked this book/novella, story was good,not your usual Christmas story but kept my interest and liked ending. I think with a bit fleshing out with more back story and detail would be 5 stars not just the 4 I gave but since this is a first book. Kudos. Thank you to Net Galley the author and the Publishers for giving me opertunity to read this Advance Reader Copy.

Was this review helpful?

I have mixed feelings about this book. At the beginning I was enjoying it and thinking that I could see it being a great Christmas movie, then the story wrapped up so quickly that I felt nothing really made sense. How did Josh/Curtis ever become an elf to begin with? That seems like an important piece of information to be missing. It honestly felt like a large chunk of the story was cut out of the middle leaving just the beginning and the ending.

I'm disappointed. I really wanted to like this one.

Was this review helpful?

This is a fun little story. It isn't really a book more of a novella. I completed it in one sitting of about an hour and a half - I am a quick reader.
Curtis lives in Vegas & lives the life - he works in a bar, earns great money & has the dream life. Yet once a year he disappears for 3 months. He goes to work at the North Pole - elves aren't quite who you thought they were!

I loved this book. Yes, okay there is a Christmassy, feel good theme going on here. However, it is certainly not your standard Christmas "feel good" book. There is a bit of depth and it did make me think.
The whole concept of people taking time out of their lives to work for Father Christmas is wonderful. The picture of the North Pole which is painted in this story brings what is a fairy tale (apologies if that comes as a surprise to anyone) into the modern world.
This story made me smile & I loved it. I was sad it wasn't longer but with hindsight I am not sure that would have worked. A great read, sit back & enjoy something a bit different.

I received a free copy of this book via Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

I found the writing and character development in this story so bad that I couldn't get in to it at all, which is too bad because the premise was very interesting.

Save your money

Was this review helpful?

I want to thank NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for letting me read and review an advanced copy of this novella.

The operation at the North Pole goes year-round, but in this story the elves only work for three months of that time. The elves, who are real people, leave their day jobs from all over the world, and they travel to work at Santa’s operation during their assigned quarter. Yes, there are still Santa and Mrs Claus, reindeer, and the yearly ‘Night of’, but the rest of the story is very modern.

The main story in this book is about Curtis, an elf for eight years (yes, elves come and go), who had an accident in his past and still deals with anxiety and stress. While being assigned to wrapping presents, Curtis tries to get an appointment with Mr C. When Curtis asks to be released from his assigned quarter, Mr C. sends him back to Salt Lake City for a temporary assignment back in the ‘regular’ world. There, he must confront his fears of the past and rejoin the life he once had before the accident.

Will Mr C.’s instincts be correct and will Curtis find joy at Christmas, or will he continue being miserable for the rest of his life?

This was an interesting take on the Santa Claus story, maybe showing how each of us could be an elf and help spread some Christmas cheer.

Was this review helpful?

This is a short and quick read, but well worth the pages and time. The Truth About Elves is a beautiful take on our favorite "little" helpers from the North Pole and I love the idea that it's just normal people needing a place to go before they are ready to be fully back in society; I think we could all use a little help from Mr. C now and then.
This was beautifully written and well thought out.

Was this review helpful?

Curtis was a pilot until a fateful day, when his life changed, and he walked away from his family. His family was grieving and he felt responsible. He worked in Vegas, but for 3 months out of the year he would go to the Arctic Circle and help Mr. C. This year he was supposed to go in the third quarter because this was the 1oth anniversary of the tragic accident. Mr. C. changed it to the 4th quarter and Curtis had no choice but to go when Mr, C said.
When he got there, the other elves, were there and getting their assignments. One of the rules was to be polite, so they had to say hello, tell them who they were and what they did, how long they had been coming here. As we read the book we find this is a way of healing, and until an elf is ready, then he or she comes every year for 3 months. Curtis thought he would be coming the rest of his life, and he was mad at Mr. C for making him come the last quarter when he just wanted to be home alone on the anniversary of the tragic accident.
The story that unfolds is one of Mr. C. trying to help Curtis find his way back to his family, and he sets things in motion.
The book is different, but it offers a glimpse of the elves, coming year after year, because grief doesn't have a timetable, When you lose someone close to you, the anniversary is difficult to go through alone, so Mr C, brings them to be with others, and it can begin the process of healing. I didn't think it was a Christmas story, I thought it was a story of the spirit of Christmas. It is a short book, filled with seeing things in a different way.
I received an ARC from Atmosphere Press through NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book. Very interesting story with a completely unexpected perspective on Santa, the elves and the preparation for the big night. The author has written a tale with heart that kept my interest with just enough clues to the full story. I couldn't put it down.

Was this review helpful?

I took a chance and requested the debut novel by Ekta R Garg called The Truth About Elves and I’m glad I did!

It is supposed to be a Christmas story but, in reality it takes place just before Christmas. The author has created what you might call an alternate world where Santa lives and the business of meeting expectations of Christmas happens. I think Santa does more than we ever knew.

This is a really short book and can be read in an evening. So, I really can’t tell you a lot about it or I would give the whole premise of the book away. I don’t want to get on Santa’s naughty list. I need more books for Christmas!

If you find you have a few hours some night and want to read a cute little story before Christmas, this book will fill that wish quite nicely.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from #AtmospherePress and #Netgalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

This is a neat story about Mr. C. aka Santa Claus and his elves.
Just who are these elves that actually do the work for Mr. C? Are they actually little, funny people with pointed ears ?
They are not at all who you think! they are!
But this is a quick and definitely enjoyable novella that will warm your heart and lift your spirits as we enter this unsure, crazy 2021 holiday season! The book has heart, love and a special mission for one elf in particular.

Give it a try. I loved it!

Was this review helpful?

More of a novella than a novel, but I really enjoyed this holiday offering. Because it was so short, the world building was a bit skimpy - with a few more hundred pages, the way Mr C and the elves really ‘work’ could have been fleshed out. I’d like to read more about this world.

Thanks to NetGalley for providing an ARC copy for my review.

Was this review helpful?

I freely agreed to read and review this title for NetGalley and Atmosphere Press. The concept of this book piqued my interest right away. Curtis, is a former pilot turned bartender, who is recruited by Santa to be an elf for a one quarter of a year shift each year. The recruits are people who all have one thing in common, which was a traumatic event that mentally incapacitated them. I actually wished this book was longer so I could have a few more questions answered. I enjoyed reading this title even though I feel a bit confused by what happened at Curtis’s event and what actually happened.

Was this review helpful?

This is a story with an interesting take on Elves and how they function
Mr C takes care of people who are broken and helps them to get back on the right track
This is a story about forgiveness- forgiving yourself and others , accepting their support and moving on
The sort and the hurt felt was written well and you quickly feel sympathy for Curtis and want him to move on . Even though this is a short story, it is well developed

Was this review helpful?

First I want to say that the book cover is gorgeous and the person that designed it did a fantastic job tying to the story.

The story - well, it was very difficult for me to get interested in this book. I think the plot is creative and a great idea, but for me, it just did not come to paper to begin with. The first half left me wanting so much more. That stated, by mid story I was really enjoying where the plot was leading. Honestly, once the main character was in SLC, I enjoyed the book so much more than the fantasy part.

My rating is a blending of my feelings for the first half and the second half. I think since this is a novella, details are missing, due to keeping it a short length and that takes away from the story.

I want to thank Atmosphere Press and NetGalley for allowing me to read the advance reader copy, with no obligation to write a review. My review is written freely as a hobby, and is totally my own opinion, not influenced by receiving the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Curtis is a simple bartender in Las Vegas. He's single, lives close to his job and also happens to be a part-time elf for Santa Claus.
When he joined Santa, Curtis thought could run away fron the pain of his past. However, now that the 10 year anniversary of that fateful day is coming up and he must return to his hometown to fulfill a promise to Mr. Claus, he'll have to face his own demons and forgive himself.
This novella was quite the emotional ride! It's a small book, but don't let that fool you! The story is heartwarming and Curtis's journey towards forgiveness and self-acceptance in the face of grief is so emotional! It really gave me the feels!
I know it's a little early for Christmas posts, but you should definitely check this book out!

Trigger warning:
-Death
-Plane and car accident
-Alcoholism

Was this review helpful?

This book started out with your typical cutesy type Christmas story with Santa and elves (normal people, no pointy ears here). Then it turned into so much more! The main character is Curtis, a former airline pilot who's life totally changed one day after a disastrous occurrence. He quit flying and is working in Vegas full time and for Mr. C part time.

Curtis' journey is one to find forgiveness within himself and realize that those who love him are also capable of forgiveness. It is really a touching, lovely story.

I was gifted a copy of this book via Atmosphere Press and NetGalley. All thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?