Cover Image: The Primacy of Doubt

The Primacy of Doubt

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I really enjoyed this book. Palmer writes about a lot of different topics, but his explanations were clear and they are ones I'm sympathetic with (the parts about doubt and uncertainty in models). I also really liked that he separated his personal new ideas about quantum theory in its own section at the very end instead of sprinkling it through the book. It makes it easier for the reader to understand what's standard knowledge and what's the author's own beliefs. Overall, I enjoyed this book.

Was this review helpful?

This book has three parts and Part One is excellent but Part Two is borderline worthless and should be skipped in its entirety. Part Three is mostly the author's opinion and as such is okay. The author does an excellent summary of Newton's Three-Body Problem and Henri Poncaire's proof which showed that non-linear dynamic systems can not be predicted since they are chaotic. Ed Lorenz discovered this regarding weather. This presented very bright people like Palmer who desperately want to forecast long-term trends to adopt a process that they call "ensemble prediction" which is as Poncaire demonstrated a fool's errand.

Was this review helpful?

This is one of the best NetGalley books I've read in a long time. I tend to read new science titles that focus on math, physics, or astronomy, and I prefer they aren't popularized too much in their approach. PRIMACY OF DOUBT meets the bill, stopping short of actual math but definitely giving a qualitative treatment to a difficult topic. The author talks through how various chaotic systems (not just "chaos theory") can benefit from being analyzed using ensemble systems that contain some level of random noise to allow for uncertanities in the initial conditions. This applies to weather, climate, pandemic forecasting, econmics, even our brains. If you don't mind thinking a little while you read and can put in the effort to slow down and follow along, this one is well worth it.

Was this review helpful?