Not gonna lie, I was pretty bored. I wasn't into the writing or the characters. And from the symopsis, I wasn't expecting the time travel element; I was expecting more of a multi-timelime- multi-generational type of story.

1922, Brigid is offered her heart's desire in return for betraying her Goddess. When her daughter disappears, she wonders if it was the right thing to do.
2022, Evermore is ruled by 2 powers. Ophelia Gallagher, Brigid’s descendent, and her fellow witch Finola McEntire fight the creatures that attack the villagers as best they can. When Brigid awakens in this time, they wonder if they can fight the evil that lurks in this time.

This took me a while to get into this one and I am sad to say it was not exactly what I was anticipating. I felt there were many underdeveloped and missing explanations of the magical system and sub characters that I was often left confused. I did enjoy some characters which will definitely have me trying out this author again in the future!

𝗧𝗵𝗲 𝗟𝗼𝘀𝘁 𝗪𝗶𝘁𝗰𝗵 𝗯𝘆 𝗣𝗮𝗶𝗴𝗲 𝗖𝗿𝘂𝘁𝗰𝗵𝗲𝗿 follows Brigid Heron a healer who protects Evermore from witches who seek to release the Damned from the Otherworld. But Brigid longs for something her Goddess does not approve of. Betraying her Goddess will take Brigid on a journey of a lifetime. Will Brigid ever get what she wanted? Was going against her Goddess worth it in the end.

While I love witchy book The Lost Witch was more epic adventure than the usual witch vibes. I did want more magic and felt this one read more as a fantasy which is my least favorite genre.

3.5 stars but I can see other people loving the story more than I did because of the adventure and fantasy aspects.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for this copy in exchange for an honest review.

I liked this book but I found it difficult to get into. We are told events rather than witnessing the characters experiencing things going on around them. The plot is enjoyable but slow, however by 70% of the way in the suspense, drama and action increased tenfold and it was impossible to put the book down.
Luc and Brigid were working together better as she had her memories back and I liked them as a couple. I just felt that the author spent too much time building the story that a reader could easily stop reading before they get to the good stuff.
Finola and Ophelia were entertaining characters and I enjoyed their banter.
The podcasts were an odd but quirky and fun addition to the story.
I recommend this book if you like witch stories, magic, fantasy, and books set in Ireland.

Brigid Heron, a dynamic witch and healer, has been won over by Luc Knightly. Now with a daughter that has fallen ill, Brigid will do anything. Even use the magic of the Lough of Brionglóid. Only once she makes that deal, she's swept away, along with her daughter. When she comes to, she has no memory of how she got there, or where she even is. Turns out it's now 2022, and her hometown is under attack because of the deal she made all those years ago. With the help of a couple of friends she makes along the way, can she figure out how to fix her mistakes before it's too late?

This is another beautifully built journey by Paige Crutcher. The world is so vivid, it's impossible to not get swept up along with Brigid as she tries to make sense of a brand new world. Brigid, being from the 20's and having to figure out life in 2022 was one of my favorite parts, as was the characters banter and friendship. I will say if a lot of build up and/or world building isn't your thing, and you know this already, this may not be the best book for you. However, if that isn't something you've decided yet, I would highly recommend taking Brigid's journey. I, personally, really enjoyed the build up, and how the events unfolded, and how everything was well balanced. I especially enjoyed the "present day witches" and how they were already so close and how ready they were to welcome Brigid into their lives and worlds. It had a undercurrent of girl power that I really enjoyed, and I loved that I could picture the ladies really well. Brigid was a really great leading character as well. She wasn't a damsel in distress and I feel like she could have easily become that. I have really enjoyed Ms. Crutcher's first two books and I can say with confidence I will pick up whatever she puts out next. She is an author who definitely knows how to immerse the reader in her world and I love every second of it.

Brigid Heron is a witch mostly content with her life as a witch in service of her goddess on a little island off the coast of Ireland. All she wants to be completely happy is a baby without the hassle of having to bind herself to a man. So she asks her goddess for help and gets turned down. In steps a dark god of mischief with an offer she can't refuse. One thing leads to another and Brigid finds herself 100 years in the future with no memory and the island sealed off from the rest of the world and overrun by monsters escaping from the magical lough on the island. Luckily for her, her descendants have been taking care of things while she was gone and are more than happy to help her right whatever it is that went wrong. The god is still around and refusing to tell all he knows, and there's also an evil coven of scary witches dead set on releasing all the evil trapped within the lough. Many magical battles and adventures ensue.
I'm a bit torn on this one because it's like the author herself was torn as to what type of book she was writing. There are moments when it's serious modern fantasy and high stakes, end-of-the-world stuff, but then there are snippets of the silliest, slightly dumb that completely took me out of the story. I get why they're there and they really set the tone for the modern world Brigid suddenly finds herself in, but they really took me out of the story. It was akin to snippets of sugary pop music slipping in between some very hard metal. Slightly jarring.
However, I did enjoy the romance and how well Crutcher wove the magical elements and folk creatures of Ireland into the story. The throughline of decisions and changing to accept mistakes or that some things are just meant to be is a great element of the story that pays off beautifully in the conclusion.
Overall, it's a solid story that pulled me in and had me rooting for the good witches to win the day with an added bonus of some romance.

Happy thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Griffin for the early read!

The Lost Witch is a quest of a mother searching for her lost daughter. Brigid is not only a mother but also a powerful witch. She is transported to a future time, but how and why? Brigid has to figure out the why and how with the help of some powerful witches. However the time is running out.

The premise of time travel, powerful witches, a demigod, a Goddess, modern day witches and a cute little town is fantastic. I can imagine this town with the lake and the greenery of that place. The descriptions are really good and the fantasy elements are great.

However, the descriptions of magical beings was a little lacking. A context or glossary would have helped a lot. It was a bit slow in the middle and the story does get affected by it. The constant back and forth of Brigid's memories is confusing. I would have loved more of Brigid and Knightly's story as well.

Overall, I enjoyed the story and the characters of this book. I was transported to this magical place of Evermore and I want more of it.

Thank you St. Martin's Press, St. Martin's Griffin and Netgalley.

This book had a little bit of everything. It was a paranormal story with witches, gods and monsters. It involved different worlds and time periods. And blended in with it all was a fair dose of romance.

Brigid Heron is the main character in this story. She is a talented witch but even with her abilities, she can't manage to have a child. Desperate for a baby of her own, she makes a deal with a demigod, Luc Knightly. Everything progresses as it should it life until their daughter becomes ill. Brigid is willing to do anything to save her daughter. This leads to a breach in the world she knows. Then the story jumps one hundred years into the future and Brigid has no memory of those missing years. But the world she has re-entered is nothing like the one she left. Not only has it moved along and become more modern, it is full of monsters that are entering through the Lough. Brigid knows she's missing important clues to her life before but she isn't sure how to recover those memories. She connects with two of her descendants and together they fight the monsters and try to put things right. She's also reunited with Luc who she apparently fell in love with before and appears to still have feelings for. I really enjoyed the way this story blended everything together. It all felt as if it worked. In addition, Brigid and Luc's romance was touching. It was evident that he would do almost anything for her but wanted to let her remember in the most gentle way possible.

AUDIOBOOK: I also listened to the audio version of this book and the narration was quite enjoyable. It really lent itself to this story and fit the characters voices, in my opinion. Sometimes the audio version isn't as enjoyable for me, but in this situation I think it was moreso. This was a book where it made the story more fun. 4 stars.

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC. I voluntarily chose to read and review it and the opinions contained within are my own.

The Lost Witch is my 1st book by Paige Crutcher. The premise sounded intriguing a witch from the early 20th century finds her suddenly awakened in 2022.

The book opens in 1922 when witch Brigid Heron is living on the ouskirts of Evermore off the coast of Ireland and an acolyte to the Goddess Brighid and protector of the Lough of Briongloid, but Brigid has a secret, she desperately wants a child and the Goddess will not, or cannot accomodate. Enter Luc Knightley an agent of chaos who wants to allow the monsters that reside in the Lough free rein. In exchange for the child Brigid wants, the goddess will lose her acolyte and chaos can reign. Brigid’s betrayal of the Goddess costs her more than she can bare. When her daughter is taken by the Lough, Brigid vows to find her. She then disappears for 100 years. When she wakes up she finds a whole different Evermore where the monsters of the Lough have been unleashed and the people of the town are in danger. Brigid works with two modern day witches, Ophelia and Fiona to right the wrongs from her past.

This was an intriguing book of fantasy,. I enjoyed the world building and the story was engaging.

Thanks to Netgalley, St Martin’s Press and the author for the chance to read and review this book.

This one started out pretty good but I found it to be a bit repetitive and sometimes confusing and I wasn’t at all invested in the story or characters. By the end I was pushing through. It would have been a DNF if it wasn’t a Netgalley read.

I liked the humor in the book but wished that we got to experience more of the enemies to lovers story, the two characters basically just jump from one to the other without much banter and fun in between.

Initially there was a lot that worked for me with this one but I just needed it to dive a little deeper and mix up the chaos a bit more because it felt like the characters were in the same fight from beginning to end and it got a bit boring.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for providing a free ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Amazing read! The dual timelines are seamlessly intertwined and make this story so engaging! I loved the characters and the complex relationships they develop along the way. Excellent setting descriptions and a nice pace make this book a must-read for anyone who enjoys a witchy thrill!

The Lost Witch follows Brigid Heron who time travels from 1922 to 2022. Back in 1922, she lived in the small town of Evermore on an isle in Ireland. As the synopsis states, Brigid is seduced by Luc Knightly of a rival coven and ends up traveling 100 years in the future with no memory of the past. In 2022, she must work with her descendants, Ophelia and Finola, to try and reverse the past. Luc is also in present day with his memories still intact.

The author paints the picture of both timelines well, but the pacing is a little off in places. As the reader is piecing the story together while Brigid is slowly regaining her memories, it can be difficult to navigate the plot. There are the demons and other creatures that were released by accident through the time travel, so everyone must work to try and save everything. There is a nice “classic-ness” with the good versus evil idea that was comforting as a reader, but I do wish there were more directions for each plotline. There are a lot of holes to fill as the story moves forward, so I like that there were POVs added from a few of the characters, including Luc.

As Luc and Brigid were together years ago, it was nice to see the flashbacks about how this romance developed. I did expect more from this part of the story as I did not feel it enough to place it among the romance genres. Instead, I found this to be more women’s fiction where it is mostly about Brigid’s journey and growth. The writing itself was good, but the mixture of prose with the modern was a little difficult to follow at times. I love the mystery aspect and putting the puzzle together, but there is a little too much ambiguity at times where it distracted me. During those moments, I found myself skimming the paragraphs, so I wish that the transitions and details were given a little more care.

**I give a special thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin’s Griffin for the opportunity to read this novel. The opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.**

Happy Release Day!!

3.5 Stars

The Lost Witch is a magical forbidden romance between Good vs Evil.

In 1922, our FMC Brigid is living her life in Evermore, for the most part, "happy", but the one thing she wants the most is a child, even if that means betrayng her coven. Our MMC Luck Knightly, head of the dark and mysterious Kightly coven offers Brigid what she wants most...and she jumps for it. Jump to Evermore of 2022 where the world is full of mosters and all things Dead. Brigid appears there with no memories, Lost to what happened and what's going on she joins the local coven in order to find what she has lost and to help saving Evermore

Brigid learns there are consequences for her actions, causing The Damned (monsters) to come through The Lough (the portal). She finds a distant relative Ophelia. Ophelia and Ophelia's roommate and friend Finola have been fighting The Damned to protect the town. She also finds Luc Knightly - who has his memories of Brigid - who seems to want to help her, but his dark magic is what caused all this to happen.

I enjoy magic, fantasy and I liked the added mystery of finding out what happened to Brigid. Overall, I liked The Lost Witch, it took me a while to get into the story. Feeling lost myself with the plot. Most of the story is through Brigid's POV, which means we as the readers are lost with what happened for a while. We go gain different perspectives later on in the book - Luc's being one. This is when we get more of the "romance" aspects, but I felt it was pretty weak for what I was expecting. There are some HEA but also HFN endings since this is going to be a series.

I liked the unique world building in this story and the magical quality of the writing. There were plenty of fascinating characters throughout the book to keep me entertained but the middle of the book where she's trying to recover her memory gaps was a bit slow. To be honest, I was suffering with the flu while reading this and having trouble staying awake anyway, so the lag may have been my own fault. Overall I thought it was an original and unique story with a good plotline and the conclusion was really good.
Thank you to St. Martin's Griffin for an advance review copy of this book. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

I ended up starting and stopping this read a few times at the beginning; it was just hard for me to get hooked for a reason I couldn’t quite pinpoint.

However, the premise was unique, the female characters were strong/fearless/funny and I enjoyed the second half of the book much more than the first. The author’s writing style is almost lyrical and she did an excellent job at creating a magical world that was deeply atmospheric. I believe readers who enjoy female bonds (and similar reads such as Practical Magic) will enjoy this read. For me, it fell a short of being a fantasy romance (as marketed) and left me wanting more.

I have received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

I recently finished reading "The Lost Witch" by Paige Crutcher and was thoroughly entertained from start to finish.

One of the things I loved most about this book was the rich, immersive world-building. Crutcher does an excellent job of creating a fully realized magical universe, complete with its own history, rules, and factions. The characters are also well-developed and diverse, each with their own motivations and flaws.

The plot is fast-paced and filled with twists and turns that kept me on the edge of my seat. The tension builds throughout the book, culminating in a satisfying and action-packed finale.

Overall, "The Lost Witch" is a thrilling and well-written novel that will appeal to fans of fantasy and paranormal fiction. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a captivating and immersive reading experience.

3.5 stars = I liked it with nits. Witch and healer Brigid, dedicated to the goddess Brigid, is successful at helping the folk in her town but desparately lonely. She makes a deal with a chaos demigod to get a daughter, only to lose her child while at the same time putting the world in peril from a portal that releases damned creatures.

The Lost Witch was a mixed read for me. First what I liked. I liked the two witches, who become Brigid's coven and allies in trying deal with the fallout from the portal. I loved Knightly, the chaos demigod, he is so sad and mysterious. The scenes with him were my favorite parts of the story.

My biggest nits with the Lost Witch have to do with pacing. It is very slow to get rolling. This is partly due to the fact that after a brief introduction and set up, the story jumps to the future where our lost witch Brigid has lost her memories. It takes her quite awhile to figure out what has gone on when she wakes up to find that a hundred years have passsed. My other major problem is with the structure of the book. Many of the early chapters end with blog posts by Brigid's grand niece and all the chapters begin with spells. Both of these 'extras' combine to periodically drop the momentum gained in the chapter. Fortunately, the blog posts stop at the last quarter of the book when the action comes to a peak and things finally get good. For me, The Lost Witch would have worked so much better without them - especially the final blig post which directs us away from a nice moment for Brigid.

I did really like the final part of the book, so ended up liking The Lost Witch overall.

ARC courtesy of the publisher via NetGalley - release date December 27, 2022 - this is an unpaid review.

This book was an interesting read with the two timelines and was something that I wasn’t expecting. It took me a bit to get into the groove of the book. The characters were likeable and entertaining. I love the incorporating of the text from the spell book. I was unlike any other witch book that I’ve read. The timelines gave me almost an Outlander time travel vibe while still being unique on its own. Overall an okay book for what I believe is a standalone book.

I didn't enjoy this one as much as The Orphan Witch but this one was still enjoyable. I wish there was a little more of Brigid's story in the beginning, I enjoyed finding out more about her during snippets in the book. It just felt a little rushed for me.