Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. A classic enemies to lovers - well, lovers, to enemies, to lovers - which makes it all the more fun. Tensions rise as the characters confront their past and move forward with the future.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really cute, well written read! I loved Daniel and Liyah's growing relationship (and I do adore the 'we reconnect on a plane' trope). Absolutely loved the Jewish representation!

Was this review helpful?

A promising debut featuring BIPOC Jewish summer camp sweethearts who had a falling out and haven't seen each other in years, until they're seated next to each other on a plane and discover that they now have to work together. The main characters have great chemistry and the museum setting was fun.

Thanks to Netgalley, the publisher, and the author for the ARC to review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was a fantastic debut! The enemies to lovers storyline was great, and had just the right amount of spice. Daniel + Liyah's friendship ended years ago while they were away at summer camp but as adults, they ended up being seated next to each other on a flight. The two end up needing to collaborate on a project and well, you'll need to read the book to find out what happens! Definitely interested in reading more by this author.

Thank you to the publisher, SMP Romance, and NetGalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I will submit a review for this title once the demands for the St. Martins Press Boycott have been met.

Was this review helpful?

I made this account and requested my own book just for the purpose of seeing what version they'd used for e-ARCs. now I want to request other books and my feedback ratio is 0% so I am submitting this.

Was this review helpful?

It was pretty solid. Maybe it's just my take on forced proximity trope, but it was done well. Sometimes authors make it such a forced trope where you're just like....uh there's literally 5 different solutions to get out of this. Either way, such a cute little love story between these two.

Was this review helpful?

This has been on my NetGalley back list for a few months now. I missed the opportunity to download it, so I listened to it instead and I’m so glad I did!
Liyah Cohen-Jackson and Daniel Rosenberg were friends at sleep away camp but all of that came to an end when a rumor started about them. Liyah left camp embarrassed and hasn’t seen Daniel in 15 years- until they end up sitting next to each other on a flight back to Chicago from CA. Even though so much time has passed, Liyah is still hurt and Daniel is still befuddled over how things ended. Both are shocked when Daniel’s marketing agency is hired by the museum where Liyah is a junior curator and they now have to work together on a regular basis. Over weeks of working together and weekly drinks with their coworkers slowly the ice between them begins to melt and they begin to see each other as friends and possibly more.
I was so excited about all of the Jewish representation in this book. It was completely unexpected and at the first mention of it, my face broke into a huge grin. I found both Liyah and Daniel to be adorable and I loved how wonderful and caring their family and friends were.
This is Rachel Runya Katz’s debut novel and I’m so excited to see what else she has for us in her writing career. Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for an advanced copy of this. Thank You for Sharing hit the shelves in September of 2023.

Was this review helpful?

This was a good book. I wasn't completely head over heals reading it, but I did enjoy it. I think other readers of this prose will definitely enjoy it. I just wasn't a good fit..

Was this review helpful?

Looooovrd this book. The two leads bounce off each other so well and had me giggling. It was fun and swoon worthy. Would totally recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the multicultural Jewish representation in this book, and the nod to their teen years at sleepaway camp felt nostalgic in the best ways. Until Liyah kept using it as an argument point so many times against Daniel when they reunite as adults and work together as colleagues on projects that could help propel their careers. Liyah really struggled to be vulnerable, as a result from some traumatic relationship experiences during formative years. She made out Daniel to be the villain in her origin story, but after spending months working together, sharing meals and heartfelt moments, their friendship and chemistry blossom into something more. Daniel was really one heck of a book boyfriend (cat dad, hello?!) who was struggling after losing his father, and I'm glad this book demonstrated that grief is not linear and the importance of a support network (family, friends, and therapy). The found family element of the Speakeasy Support Club was so delightful -- I loved their meeting notes and seeing each character develop in their own way. For me, what kept this from being 5 stars was Liyah's stubbornness about not letting go of the past. Thankfully, she had friends in her corner, too, that helped her realize her lovability and worth.
Thank you Netgalley & St. Martin's Press for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I love the enemies to lovers trope, and this was such a refreshing, well-written, and uplifting journey of a story for this couple. Witty banter, loads of charm; this one has it all.

Liyah and Daniel are solid main characters you can’t help but root for. Please sign me up for Rachel Runya Katz’s next book. I’m already excited to meet the characters and cheer them on to love.

I received a gifted copy.

Was this review helpful?

a sweet and surprisingly deep book. I loved the development of the characters. It was a good read and I found myself engaged the while time.

Was this review helpful?

This was not for me. Both main characters just annoyed or frustrated me from the start so I could not get invested in their story or romance at all. 2 🌟

Was this review helpful?

From the moment I picked up this book, I was completely engrossed in this story. Plus, Katz's writing is so beautiful and descriptive that I felt like I was right there with the characters, experiencing everything they were going through.

Was this review helpful?

This was beautiful and emotional - it took me a while to get into this and get in the right headspace to read it but I’m glad I did it! I love the Jewish rep and the Chicago backdrop, it felt really personal. Third act conflicts are always tough for me because I feel like often authors throw in some character regression for the sake of conflict, and while that was kind of the case here, I still enjoyed it overall.

Was this review helpful?

This book was the most infuriating representation of emotionally inept millennials. Incredibly well-written, and incredibly misguided. A friend group that enables poor behavior and immature emotional regulation is not one I’d want to be a part of.

Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

THE REPRESENTATION!! That alone has me screaming praises tor this book. Add to that, such personable characters and playful storyline, I was hooked. A fantastic debut for the author.

I found some parts a little too slow, but the balance was great. I was invested with the characters and their relationship building. Daniel was such a lovely book boyfriend. It would be nice to get a spinoff on some of the side characters. They were all so fascinating and fun!

Thanks so much NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was an excellent romance. Loved the banter and snarkiness. Loved the Jewish/queer/POC rep. Loved the setting (Chicago + Field Museum). Loved that the characters were relatable in both work and their personal lives. Loved that there was a cat!

Was this review helpful?

3.5/5 ⭐️

this was an impressive debut novel by rachel runya katz. it features a dual POV, slow burn, enemies to lovers, second chance romance with forced proximity and a reverse grumpy sunshine couple.

the story was thoughtful and layered, and the emotions the characters go through felt genuine. the author chose to explore important complex topics with nuance: being biracial, misogyny, sexual assault and grief (loss of a parent), and i appreciated those themes being delved into with such sensitivity. there was also a lot of importance placed on mental health and the need for therapy.

kudos for the rep in this book as well and how it felt very natural and authentic. the two main characters are bi-racial and jewish, and we get to see jewish religion and customs through the lens of people of color. the female main character is bisexual and there is a diverse and endearing friend group involved in the story.

the romance was very cute, with a bit of angst thrown in. the two main characters had great chemistry and their banter was funny. the relationship was well developed and not rushed. i would say it was medium on the spice scale for a contemporary romance.

as you can see, this book had a lot of potential and there were many positive qualities to it, but sadly i had a few quips that made me lower my rating.

first of all, it's written in the third person present tense. that's very personal, but i struggle with that kind of POV. it's hard for me to connect with a story written this way. it made for a slow start and it was a bit hard to get into the story.

second, the story felt sometimes unbalanced in terms of tone. it seemed like a fun lighthearted romcom, but then there was heavy emotional content thrown in seemingly out of nowhere. i believe with more editing, the switch between the two could have been done better. the pacing also felt a little off at times.

finally, if you don't like third act break ups and find miscommunication annoying, this might not be the book for you. i know those things bothered me and they made for a lesser romance book for me.

overall, this was a remarkable debut novel with a lot of positive aspects, but it felt short on other points, making it a story with undeveloped potential. rachel runya katz is definitely an author to look for in the future and i have great hopes her writing will only improve with experience and editing. i'm looking forward to their next book!

Was this review helpful?