Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I read and adored the author’s first book and had high hopes for this novel that brings us back for the first book’s MCs’ wedding (this is an interconnected series and I would suggest reading Bend Toward the Sun before attempting this).

Duncan was such a great character in the first book yet in this one, I barely recognized him from those earlier glimpses. Same for Temperance. Both MCs read as surprisingly immature for their ages.

For a second chance romance, I didn’t feel the chemistry between the two MCs, and spent the book feeling like we were told more than shown (80% in and they’re still not together). The pacing was slow and the connection between the two doesn’t read as authentic.

It took me a couple of months of putting it down and picking it back up to try again to work my way through this one.

I really wanted to love this and I’m sorry that I didn’t enjoy it more. Devon’s writing is, in places, engaging and wonderful - I will definitely read Mal’s story (if one is forthcoming).



Thank you to St. Martin’s Griffin and NetGalley for the DRC

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐⭐
🌶️🌶️

𝗪𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝘁𝗼 𝗲𝘅𝗽𝗲𝗰𝘁:
- Forced proximity
- Decades of pining
- Second chance
- Dual POV

When I’m not in the mood for a sugary sweet romcom, THIS is the type of book I want. Bursting at the seams with angst, Right Where We Left Us bring you back to the Brady family (that I absolutely love) and follows Temperance and Duncan - with lots of cameos from Rowan and Harry 💕.

The way Carley Fortune encapsulates the lakeside setting, Jen Devon encapsulates the vineyard/farm setting. Through luscious descriptions, you 100% feel like you are sitting in with the Brady’s as a part of the family and you will feel all the same emotions as the characters on the page.

Temperance and Duncan have spent the last 14 years fighting the cosmic pull they have towards each other (with the occasional hook up) so yes, this is a very slow burn - but the chemistry is explosive. You get to dive deep into what Temperance and Duncan are experiencing and the growth they each must go through before going all in with each other.

Right Where We Left Us is a phenomenal second chance romance with enough pining to satisfy you for weeks to come.

Was this review helpful?

Temperance and Duncan have known each other most of their lives but things fell apart quickly. All grown up, they are stuck being around each other as her best friend marries his brother. I wanted to love this book but it was a really slow burn and I just didn't really feel the reasons they weren't able to be together was enough for them to not wanting to fall back into old ways. Overall it was a cute story and I enjoyed this read but wasn't a favorite.

Was this review helpful?

I adored “Bend Towards The Sun”, so I was excited to dive into this book (the second in the series).

This book features another another Brady son, Duncan and long time family friend Temperance.

What I liked about this book:
- great, flawed but likeable characters
-idyllic setting
-witty and enjoyable banter

What I didn’t like as much:
-second chance romance is my least favourite troupe
-how long and drawn out the reveal was for the reasons these characters broke up years ago

While I still love this author, this book wasn’t my favourite.

Thank you to St. Martins Press and Netgalley for providing me with an ARC of this book to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

Some second chance romance is great and some is just too slow of a burn. This one was just too slow for me.

Thank you Net Galley and St. Martin’s Press for letting me review!

Was this review helpful?

3.5 rounded up

This slow-burn second chance romance was a fun read. The banter was laugh-out-loud funny and I liked the chronic illness rep. I wished there’d been more of her illness shown, but most of it was references and off-page. I also found the shared history between MCs a bit muddled. I often felt like I was missing something.

It definitely made me think more than I was expecting with a simple romcom. There were a lot of characters to keep track of and even seeing references to those characters later in the book necessitated me to pause and think about who they were again in relation to the two MCs. There were also a lot of metaphors that were insightful but sometimes a bit much as well as small bits of wisdom parceled out within the story that was a nice touch. When it came from Gia, I found myself a bit more confused at what message she was trying to relay, but maybe that’s just a quirk of her character.

I didn’t read the previous book in this series, which features the story of two other characters in this book, but that didn’t impair my experience with this book as it is its own standalone within the series.

Worth it for the banter and show-burn spice though. Definitely looking forward to Mal and Frankie’s story.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you St. Martin’s Press & the author for review copies, including our #travellingARC!

“Second chances are when you weren’t ready for your first.”

I loved Bend Toward the Sun for all of its emotion, vulnerability, and real romance between Rowan and Harry, but one of the great parts of the book was being introduced to the Brady family – both those related by blood and those by association. I was thrilled we got to return to Cloud Tide to read Duncan and Temperance’s story. They both loved each other so much that they both got in their own way when they were teens, but years of backsliding and keeping things at arms length have not served either of them well. Right Where We Left Us is a story about two souls destined to be together and giving up the fight against fate in favor of their hearts. It’s a page-turner and you want to scream at them but know they need to be complete fools in order to figure out their truths.

Was this review helpful?

Cute second book in the series. Second chance romance. Some steam. If you liked the first one you will enjoy this one too! Love the Brady family and their vineyard.

Thank you to Netgalley & the publisher for an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are mine alone.

Was this review helpful?

This book made me feel all the feels, and I loved it so much. Jen Devon's writing just hits me hard in the best way possible. I loved Duncan and Temperance so much, and watching them reconnect was a joy. Also, if we don't get Mal's book, I might riot. If you loved Jen's first book, I highly recommend this one.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Griffin for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book.

Fair warning, this is book 2 of a series but isn't described as such. There are so many characters, I think if you haven't read Bend Toward the Sun, you might be lost. I loved the first book and so wanted to love this as much. Sadly, not so. It was so repetitive that I ended up skimming a lot of the Temperance/Duncan plot line and reading about the others in the family, which for me was more satisfying. I never did understand why Temperance kept pushing Duncan away. For fourteen years! I love the Brady family and will definitely read more if (hopefully) this series continues, especially if the next one is about Malcolm and Frankie.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great family and second chance romance. There was a strong cast of primary and secondary characters and a really great storyline and setting.

Was this review helpful?

Read if you love forced proximity and second-chance romance. The plot fell short in a number of ways, the reason the main characters can't be together is pretty dumb tbh. don't read this if you also hate miscommunication.

Was this review helpful?

Temperance Jean Madigan and Duncan Bradley spent a summer together when they were 18. Since then they have been on and off again. They have been off for a while now. There is this family wedding and TJ’s sister who married Duncan”s brother has a best friend Rowen who is marrying another Duncan brother. The Bradly Family decides to do a bit of meddling and get the two back together. This is the most adorable story of family and friends doing what needs to be done to get two back together. In the end all are happy

Was this review helpful?

This book is the second in an interconnected series about the Brady brothers, sons of parents who recently followed their dreams
And purchased a defunct vineyard that they are bringing back to life. I highly recommend reading the first book, Bend Toward the Sun before reading this one. It is advertised that these are standalones but I attempted to read this ARC and had to put it down and read the first book before proceeding with this one due to the characters and their relationships being initially confusing. Reading BTTS helped clear everything up and was a phenomenal read. That being said, I feel terrible writing this review as I loved the first book but struggled with this one. I didn’t understand why this couple couldn’t be together and flow of the story didn’t feel organic and the chemistry didn’t feel authentic. A few times things jumped from cold to hot and back again so fast I had to go back and make sure I didn’t miss something. I love this author’s writing this story felt confusing and I had trouble being fully engaged.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley, the publisher, author for the opportunity to read and review this book before it releases.
This was a DNF at 10% for me. Chapter 4. I couldn't with the style of writing. I kept hearing a Helen Mirror style narrator reading the pages aloud to me. It read like a documentary.

Was this review helpful?

Right Where We Left Us is the second in Jen Devon's inter-connected romances based on the Brady family's vineyard. It isn't necessary to have read Bend Toward the Sun before this one, but it will deepen your understanding of the setting and the friend group surrounding the main couple.

Temperance and Duncan had been intensely and secretly in love as teenagers then had a mysterious, dramatic, and traumatic split. Over the years since, while Temperance has become a doctor and Duncan the de facto manager of his family's vineyard, they have occasionally had fiery, secret hook ups but mostly attempt to avoid each other. Now Temperance's best friend and Duncan's brother are getting married and avoiding each other isn't an option.

These two have huge communication issues. Both have complicated careers and want more control over them. Both struggle with family expectations and are supported by their found family/friend group but even with them they're not willing to be fully open. Both also are kind and thoughtful people, which is a rarity that I found delightful.

Their angsty journey back to each other is a mix of pain and healing, and is both sexy and emotional. The only unfortunate thing was that they took so long to communicate that the complications that had kept them apart felt a little too convoluted.

Despite this quibble I did enjoy reading Temperance and Duncan's journey. I especially appreciated the depth of the portrayal of the group of characters and their interconnections, and of the intriguing setting, which made the story a rich read.

Was this review helpful?

Jen Devon once again ripped my heart out and then painstakingly stitched me back up again, all while making me believe in love again. Jen could have easily don’t flashbacks for this book, but she beautifully unveils secrets and history with each chapter. Jen’s writing is beautiful and poetic and the Brady family is so well developed and complicated. Everyone should be reading Jen Devon, she’s on par with the Emily Henry and Kate Clayborn’s if the romance genre. I CANNOT wait for her third book. I think Jen’s new book will always continue to be better than her last.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this one was a DNF for me. First of all I had no idea it was an interconnected series. It took me sometime to figure out the characters and thier relationships. Then I just couldn't understand why Duncan and Temperance couldn't be together. It didn't make much sense. I love angsty romances but this one was not for me or maybe second chances are not for me.

Was this review helpful?

This review breaks my heart as I absolutely loved Jen Devon’s debut. It’s shelved as one of my favorite contemporarys ever. In that book, I was obsessed with the characterization of Duncan, who was hilarious, sexy, and charming.

In this book the premise of Duncan’s character fell apart. I felt like his character did a complete 180 from the bits we saw of him in the first book. I can grapple with a charmingly humorous character having depths to him (which is what it should be!) but I felt the outward humor was gone and he was just this defeated character trying to make something of life and wanting his love to ‘see’ him. I was unable to connect those two characters. Maybe if I hadn’t gotten a glimpse of him in the first book, he would’ve been more palatable.

I can see Duncan wanting to be deserving of Temperance and his issues with feeling unappreciated and not the smartest, but it wasn’t given enough gravitas and didn’t, again, connect with my initial impression of him from the last book. Temperance read more or less the same but also defeated from the first book.

Second chance romances are my favorite. However, structurally, this book had a lack of momentum. We’d get interactions between Duncan and Temperance here and there before 1. getting long bits of backstory or 2. the sheer number of the Brady family and side-characters coming into play. I wanna say for the first third they don’t even spend too much time together on page.

Romance: I don’t understand their hang ups or why Temperance couldn’t be with Duncan. It wasn’t even a miscommunication trope, it was something so insidious and overly complicated and vague that I didn’t get why they were apart. I guess the bones of the misbelief is there but the dots wasn’t connected enough to package it well to the reader. Like I didn’t get how her background and family life connected to her not being with Duncan. Even after I finished the book, I still don’t get what was their character conflict. The stakes weren’t established and it made the book a slog to get through.

Pacing: At 82%, they still weren’t together as a couple so as the reader I was unable to buy-in to their HEA. The pacing was incredibly slow, and created a stop and go effect which was really frustrating, and thus took me almost two months to finish. Their entire connections feels unearned and unjustified. I think they had their reckoning around 87% and were officially together and by then it was too late for me to believe into their HEA.

That being said the reason I stuck around was because Jen Devon is amazing way in her writing craft and her words were a delight to read.

1.5 star

Was this review helpful?

I really liked Bend Toward the Sun and this was a solid follow-up. I really enjoy how in-depth Jen Devon goes into the vineyard. It makes for a really beautiful setting. I liked Duncan a lot in the first book so I was glad when I saw that this book would be about him and Temperance. I will definitely read the third book whenever she writes one about Mal and Frankie.

Second-chance romances can be hard to pull off sometimes. My biggest complaint about this book is that I couldn't understand why it took them 14 years to get back together. The reasons didn't feel justifiable, especially when they were still seeing each other and hooking up over the years. I thought the things that kept them apart in the first place would be a much bigger deal than they ended up being.

Was this review helpful?