Skip to main content

Member Reviews

WILL UPLOAD TO MY INSTAGRAM SOON

As a long-time fan of the Sherlock Holmes Bookshop Mystery series, I was excited to dive into The Incident of the Book in the Nighttime, and it did not disappoint. Gemma Doyle and her circle of quirky, loyal friends are as engaging as ever. This time on a trip to actual London for her sister Pippa’s wedding. The change of scenery brought some fresh dynamics, though I’ll admit I do prefer when the action is set back home in West London (the cozy, fictional one, not the real capital!). Still, London as Sherlock Holmes’s hometown naturally allows for a rich tapestry of Holmesian references, which added a fun meta layer to the plot.

The mystery itself was tightly plotted and thoroughly enjoyable. When Gemma’s ex-husband, Paul Erikson, is found dead after contacting her about a rare book, Gemma finds herself pulled into a personal case with emotional stakes. As always, she’s determined, clever, and just a bit prickly - the perfect amateur sleuth. I didn’t guess the killer ahead of time, which is always a win in my book. Vicki Delany did a fantastic job dropping clues without making the solution too obvious.

While I missed the familiar setting of the bookshop back home, it was still a treat to see the characters interact in a new environment. Gemma remains a character I love to follow, and her voice continues to carry the series with humor, sharp observation, and just enough heart.

If you’ve been following the series, this installment is a must-read. And if you haven’t started yet, do yourself a favor and begin at the beginning, you’re in for a clever, cozy, bookish treat. I’ll be following this series forever and ever!

Thank you, for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Gemma Doyle is back home in London for her sister’s wedding to her friend Grant. All her sleuthing buddies from the bookstore and her beau Ryan are along for what is going to be a wonderful vacation. But when she is surprised by her ex as she leaves the hotel after the wedding, she has no idea how fraught her visit will be. Paul asks her to come to the shop they once owned together as he had something of great value to show her. When she arrives, she discovers him dead and whatever he wanted to show her is nowhere to be found.

When she does discover the letter it appears he thought he could make a fortune on blackmail. But the target is a far bigger person than even he imagined which brings in Pippa, newly married but still as mysterious as ever with her clear ties to the height of power. Gemma cannot help herself and even when Pippa asks her to back off, she still discovers more information that might lead back to her own family. It is Gemma, of course, who uncovers the perp but whether this person will be brought to justice is not a sure thing.

I did enjoy the trip around London with Gemma and the gang although there were a couple of goofs as to the geographical locations that only someone familiar might have caught. It didn’t ruin my enjoyment and I still can give it four purrs and two paws up.

Was this review helpful?

The Incident of the Book in the Nighttime by Vicky Delany is the tenth one in the series and although this is one of my favourite series I can't say that this was my most liked instalment.

I really liked that they are back in London and that this time we get to learn a bit more about Gemma's past. The setting was lovely and we got to see parts of the London that are not always visible to visitors.
The mystery itself was solid. There were some moments that were not so engaging.
The ending was not as satisfactory as I am used to it.
This is a solid read but not one of my favourites.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to netgalley and the publisher for the arc of this one in exchange for an honest review!

This is the tenth book in a cozy mystery that follows a woman who owns a bookshop.

Unfortunately, I had trouble getting into this book. I think it’s maybe because I haven’t read any of the other books in the series.

The writing was a bit slow and just didn’t grab my attention.

I hope others love this one.

Was this review helpful?

Gemma is an intriguing character as she could be on the autism spectrum (ADHD myself) but also with a softer side. The perfid cat is my favourite as usuual.
Excellent mystery, full of surprising twists
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this ARC, all opinions are mine

Was this review helpful?

Part of a long running series, in this adventure Gemma and some of her friends return to London for her sister Pippa's wedding. Gemma is approached by her ex-husband about a book but when she goes to meet him the next day, she finds him in the back of their old store, deceased. Time is spent running down leads both in well described London and the countryside.

Was this review helpful?

Book Review: The Incident of the Book in the Nighttime by Vicki Delany

Rating: 3 Stars

I just finished reading The Incident of the Book in the Nighttime, and honestly, it was a mixed bag for me. On one hand, I really enjoyed the setting and the overall vibe of the story. On the other hand, I had some trouble connecting with the main character, Gemma Doyle.

The plot kicks off when Gemma and her friends head to London for her sister Pippa’s wedding. Things take an unexpected turn when Gemma runs into her ex-husband, Paul Erikson, in the hotel lobby. He’s got a rare book he’s eager to show her, and despite their past, she agrees to meet him the next day at Trafalgar Fine Books, their old shop. But when she arrives with a rare book dealer named Grant, they discover Paul dead in his office. Talk about a shocker!

As Gemma digs deeper into Paul’s life—trying to unravel the mystery behind his death—she’s joined by her best friend Jayne Wilson. They navigate through a web of Paul’s acquaintances, from friends to enemies, and even ex-lovers. The search leads them from London to Yorkshire, and let me tell you, this mystery is far more complex than it initially seems. Gemma’s determination to find out what happened to Paul is commendable, even if I found myself feeling a bit frustrated by her character at times.

Now let’s talk about the cover—seriously, it’s absolutely delightful! It totally drew me in and set a great tone for what I hoped would be an exciting read. The writing itself is quite well done, and Delany has a knack for creating vivid settings that immerse you in the story.

Overall, while I found The Incident of the Book in the Nighttime to be an okay read (and perhaps worth a three-star rating), I think the supporting characters really shone through. They added depth and warmth to the story that Gemma sometimes lacked. If you’re a fan of cozy mysteries with a literary twist, it might just be worth checking out!

⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️

Was this review helpful?

I have thoroughly enjoyed all of the books in the Sherlock Holmes Bookshop series by Vicki Delany. She does an excellent job of pulling you into the story and keeping you interested. There are lots of twists and turns that keep you guessing who is guilty of committing murder. While you are treated to a visit in London, most of the typical characters are present. I love Gemma, Ryan, Jayne, Donald (though he can be right irritating!) as well as her sister, Pippa, and her new husband, Grant. While you could read this as a standalone, I would highly recommend you go back to the first book and get background on the characters as they develop throughout the series. I highly encourage you to get lost in the pages as the author deftly creates a well-developed mystery with delightful characters.

Thank you to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for my advanced review copy. All opinions and thoughts are my own.

For more reviews, please visit my blog at: https://www.msladybugsbookreviews.com/. Over 1000 reviews posted!

Contemporary
Cozy Mystery
Crime
Fiction
Mystery

Was this review helpful?

This is book 10 in the Sherlock Holmes Bookshop series. I have read several but not all of the books.Gemma Doyle and her friends have packed their bags and headed to London for her sister Pippa’s wedding. Waiting for her in the hotel lobby is none other than Gemma’s ex-husband, Paul Erikson. Paul has a rare book he wants her to see–calling it “the real deal”–so Gemma agrees to meet him at their old shop, Trafalgar Fine Books, the following day. But when Gemma arrives, accompanied by Grant, a rare book dealer, they find Paul dead in his office.
Paul had been down on his luck, but Gemma never expected this. Had he borrowed money from people he shouldn’t have? And where is the valuable book he was so anxious for Gemma to see? It’s nowhere to be found in the shop. Because of their previous relationship, Gemma feels she owes something to Paul and vows to find his killer.

Was this review helpful?

Gemma and friends are in London for her sister's wedding ,when she gets involve wtih the murder of her new brother in law.
While Uncle Aurthor deals with his own problems.
Great mystery suspects, drama, twists and some fun.
Enjoy the series.
Voluntarily reviewed.

Was this review helpful?

**4 Stars – A Fun, Quirky Mystery!** ✨

*The Incident of the Book in the Nighttime* by Vicki Delany was my first read in the series, and while it left me a bit confused at times, it was still an absolute blast! I love a good mystery, and Delany’s world is full of quirky characters and twists that kept me hooked from start to finish. There were moments when I wasn’t quite sure what was going on, but I never felt totally lost because the author does a great job of giving enough context to keep things flowing.

While the protagonist wasn’t Donald (he’s actually a side character), I have to say, he was absolutely hilarious and a real highlight of the book! His dry wit and humor added such a fun layer to the story. And that nightclub fight scene? *Definitely* my favorite part—so chaotic, so well-written, and just so much fun!

Even though I was occasionally scratching my head trying to piece everything together, by the end, I felt like I had a pretty good grasp of things. The perfect mix of mystery, humor, and memorable characters has definitely made me excited to check out more books in the series! If you're into quirky detectives and entertaining mysteries, this is a great read!

Was this review helpful?

Gemma is back in another mystery, this time traveling to London for her sister Pippa’s wedding. On arrival, she unexpectedly encounters her ex-husband Paul, who tells her about an intriguing book. Gemma initially hesitates to meet him alone, so she brings her new brother-in-law Grant and a Sherlock Holmes fan, Donald. When they reach the bookshop, they discover Paul has been murdered.

Despite others wanting her to leave the investigation to the police, Gemma feels compelled to dive in and solve the case for Paul. While her dad and boyfriend Ryan go fishing, Gemma and her friend Jayne start to look into Paul’s recent activities. As they gather clues, they may need additional help to solve the mystery. Throughout the story, Gemma tries to enjoy her time with family while also feeling drawn into the murder investigation.

Back at home, Uncle Arthur struggles to manage things alone, with Ashleigh doing her best to help. The narrative presents a complex mystery, keeping readers guessing about the suspects and offers humorous moments, especially during a nightclub scene. The Incident of the Book in the Nighttime features many unexpected twists and turns.

Was this review helpful?

The title and Sherlock Holmes reference pulled me to select this book, and it held my attention all the way through. I haven't read any other books in this series but I didn't feel this took away my enjoyment as the author did such a good job of describing the setting, characters and past events in the rest of the series. The ending was a bit anticlimactic since I had a feeling who the killer was. It was still an enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

Love this series and this one was a lot of fun! The pub brawl had me laughing! Can't wait for more from this series!!

Was this review helpful?

A riveting intrigue with a relatable cast of characters. Despite being the 10th installment in the series, you don't need to have read them all to enjoy it. I found it was a solid standalone piece. Pleasant writing and suspenseful plot. Recommended!

Was this review helpful?

Gemma Doyle is back in London for her sister Pippa's wedding to Grant, one of Gemma's good friends. As Gemma leaves the reception, she bumps into no other that her ex-husband, Paul. Paul asks Gemma to come by the bookshop they started as he has something he wants her opinion on. An old book or something, Gemma is not sure about going but makes a date for the next day. Pippa's new husband is a rare book dealer and Gemma asks him to go with her along with her best friend Jayne Watson. The store is run down and both his employees are there, not doing much. The three-some is directed to his office, but it is too late. Paul has been murdered. The police are called and and Gemma becomes embroiled in the case. Is it more than someone stealing a rare book?

This is a fun read. Gemma is smart and notices things just like Sherlock Holmes. She knows something is off and sets out to discover Paul's murderer. I enjoy these characters and reading about London. The mystery has a few red herrings that kept me guessing. This is a relaxing, easy-to-read escape.

Was this review helpful?

“The Incident of the Book in the Nighttime”, the tenth book in Vicki Delaney’s delightful Sherlock Holmes Bookshop Mystery series, takes bookshop owner Gemma Doyle and friends away from New London, Connecticut to London England for Gemma’s sister’s wedding. While the wedding is a joyous occasion, it doesn’t take long for Gemma to stumble across a murder victim – a victim she knew all too well – and become involved in trying to solve the case. While I missed the American bookstore setting, I enjoyed the visit to London, including Gemma’s sister (and the slow, kind of reveal of what she does for a living) and her parents. There are also glimpses into what is happening in West London – there is a nice subtle sense of humor throughout the book. The references to Sherlock Holmes are well done without becoming overbearing – although I would not want to know a Donald in real life! The mystery is nicely done with just the right amount of suspects, clues, and red herrings – it is extremely well plotted with plenty of twists and turns and a touch of sadness. All in all a great read.

I received a copy of this book from NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Not knowing this was the tenth book in the Sherlock Holmes Bookshop Mystery series, I read this novel as a standalone without any prior knowledge. I did not have the feeling I was missing any information. Sure, the connections between the main cast had been established in earlier books, but Delany gave background information where necessary and let the story unfurl otherwise.

A cosy-ish mystery, set in London, UK, with a cast of characters from both sides of the Atlantic. This leads to a few vocabulary and cultural explanations that I enjoyed very much, especially the remarks about tea.

Will I go back and read the other books in the series? Sure, I am intrigued by the things that have been mentioned (in a teaser kind of way, not spoilers).

Was this review helpful?

Solid installment in a cozy series that is always fun to read.

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the advanced review copy!

Was this review helpful?

Book 10 of the Sherlock Homes Bookshop Mystery has Gemma and friends away from the bookshop and back across the pond for sister Pippa's nuptials. Pippa being Gemma's rather secretive and very business-like older sister who supposedly works for the Ministry or Department for Transport...sure she does. Turns out that Pippa isn't the only one with a secret, no one knew that Gemma had been previously married (GASP). The last person Gemma expected to run into at her sister’s reception was Paul Erikson, the ex-husband. The last thing Gemma expected to do while in London was to find Paul dead in the bookstore she once co-owned with him.

Trafalgar Fine Books, the bookstore that Gemma and Paul owned together is anything but fine, and has become a shop for selling used books. So, is this how Paul found a book that was “the real deal?” That is such an enigmatic statement and sure to create curiosity. Gemma is a curious person regardless of the situation but this one does hit a little close to home. She had loved the charmer once upon a time. Paul wasn’t a bad guy, just not the right guy, so the least that Gemma can do is ask a few innocent questions. Chances are that the local authorities are busy and the information she obtains could be useful even if unwanted. Even Gemma’s boyfriend, police officer Ryan Ashburton, admits that Gemma has a talent for getting people to open up to her. The game is afoot and with Jayne Wilson, the co-owner of the Mrs. Hudson’s Tea Room, as a trusted friend and sleuthing companion. In addition there is also the umbrella wielding Sherlockian, Donald Morris, to add a little muscle on clue seeking outings. Such outings take them from London to Yorkshire, from the old bookstore to tea at the Wolseley.

Gemma has her work cut out for her since she isn’t a local any longer and hasn’t seen Paul in seven years. Suspects are varied and scarce which is both good for the plot but bad for the sleuth. It is most excellent for the reader because you are drawn into the story wondering where the next clue is going to lead Gemma. Speaking of Gemma, she is unlike any other cozy sleuth that I have come across. She has a very logical side much like the great detective. She seems to be the one person (besides Sherlock Holmes) who sees all and deducts everything, so how is it that she didn’t see what a schmuck her two-timing husband was? On the other hand, while she is still quite British with her emotions, she has warmed up a bit since the series starter and her wit is highly entertaining. This is a very good cozy that was a quick read and does well as a stand-alone, much like Ms. Delany’s Tea by the Sea series. If I am not mistaken, gardener Simon from Tea by the Sea made a cameo appearance at Garfield Hall.

Was this review helpful?