I loveeeee Paige’s writing! I’ve read all of her books and I love the witchy atmosphere she writes about. This one was a little slow in the middle but the story picked up! Recommend for sure!

This is a fun witchy read! The story follows Doreen as she seeks to free her family’s curse requiring she marry by age 30 or die. The plot was interesting but a little difficult to follow at times. I loved Doreen and Ambrose but didn’t feel particularly invested in their romance. It was slow to start and then extremely quick towards the end of the book. The trials and the underworld were unique and very interesting. Overall this is a solid spooky season read!

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the ARC given in exchange for my honest review!

Magical adventure that pulls all the stops! Action and layer upon layer of secrets keep things moving at a fast and tense pace, with many nail biting moments. A must read for paranormal fans!

I really liked the premise and plot of A Circle of Uncommon Witches, and I loved the first half of the book. The characters were interesting, and I was drawn into the story. However, the second half felt like a collection of ideas thrown together, making the plot feel a bit convoluted and hard to follow. The romance didn’t feel believable, and while I understood Stella’s background, her sudden switch didn’t seem fully developed. The trials, which should have been a major highlight, felt underwhelming and almost like an afterthought.

Despite this, I didn’t dislike the book—it was enjoyable, just not as much as I had hoped. I think it had the potential to be phenomenal if it had been more of a slow-burn epic with deeper focus on curse-breaking and a more natural romance. Perhaps their slow-burn romance is the real key to undoing the curse? With that, the whole point of the 'one true love' should have been more fleshed out as the real break of the curse. The quick conflict resolution left me feeling let down. All in all, while I liked this book, I didn’t love it.

I’m always down for a witch and spirit world book. Magic is always a cutie little storyline to move the plot along and I liked this one a lot

I was so excited to read this book. The premise and the bones of this book are really good. I enjoyed the characters and the overall plot. I think it moved too fast for me and became confusing. I wanted more depth though. I wanted to understand the background of the story more and how events unraveled. It felt disjointed in most of the story.

I devoured this book. I LOVE a witchy book and couldn't help but want to read this immediately after I read the blurb. It was everything I could've wanted this fall time of year. It kicked off my holiday fall reading perfectly. If you are looking for a witchy book to get you in the spirit I highly suggest you giev this a try. The perfect amount of witchyness.

This was such a good book to start my fall reading!! Witches, curses, clans, mystery, and a little romance!! I absolutely loved it!! It took a couple of chapters for me to really get into it, but it picked up really quickly!! Thank you to NetGalley and to the publisher for my digital ARC!!!

Perfect fall cozy witch read! Loved the slow burn, enemies to lovers trope and was sucked in from the beginning. As the book moved throughout, it did become slightly confusing with the many plot aspects. The ending was enjoyable which is why I am giving this a solid 4/5 stars.

This book was amazing! The story was very well written and the plot was very well thought out! I would highly recommend this book!

A Circle of Uncommon Witches was the perfect read for fall! A 300-year old curse between covens led Doreen on an adventure to save her family, find love, and learn more about herself on the way.

I was hoping for a bit more character development and to see Doreen refine her powers more. I felt that the main characters fell a bit flat due to the lack of backstory or development.

Thank you for the opportunity of an eARC, and I am leaving this review willingly.

This book has so much potential. The premise is such a cool idea, but between the pacing and the world building, I was often confused and unsure what exactly (and when) was going on.

It was a fun curse breaking adventure love story kind of a tale which would have easily been made epic had it been a bit more clearly communicated throughout.

I would like to thank St Martins and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

I fell into this story and was spellbound. Doreen has an epic challenge to face set in place by her twisted family. While her family is powerful they are bound by Secrets. You are literally transported to another world and the creativity is off the charts. Hang on tight for a wild ride through each separate nightmarish challenge.

Estaba emocionado por este libro; tristemente, no fue lo que esperaba.

La primera mitad me costó mucho trabajo entenderla, porque pasaban muchas cosas que se explicaban a medias o no se explicaba qué estaba sucediendo. Por momentos, sentí que estaba leyendo el segundo libro y que me faltaba enterarme de acontecimientos importantes.


Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

This one was hard to get into. The good parts of the novel was the plot was interesting, with the idea of two cursed people trying to undo the curse. The elements were also quite interesting- powers that are well beyond the reader are also vying for control, mythological beings not usually seen in novels, a complex magical system.

Overall, though, it didn't gel, which is unfortunate because I really, really wanted to like it. As a reader you are dropped into a story already half told, and that feeling never really leaves you. The story can be choppy, with rough transitions and little context. It feels like a rough draft of a story that needs more refinement to be grand.

That's not to say reading it wasn't enjoyable. It was a very interesting read- one that sticks around long after I put it down. In all though, it felt like the bones of something greater than what it is.

Witches? Check. Family trauma? Check. Slow burn romance? Check. Trials? Check, check, check.

Ok, I honestly wasn’t expecting to love this as much as I did. It had the perfect blend of witches, curses, mystery, family issues, deadly trials and finding love against all odds. Doreen is a stubborn, strong willed witch who is hell-bent on creating her own path, rather than follow the one every witch in her family before her has been cursed to follow. When she teams up with an incredibly unlikely (and broody) Ambrose, they cannot stand each other but need each other in different ways to accomplish what they’ve each set out to. I won’t give anything further away, but this was the perfect witchy, spooky season read.

Doreen is a witch who will do anything — ANYTHING— to find true love. She and her entire family was cursed to never find true love and Doreen seeks to break this curse. Her and her cousin are from the 13th generation and will be the strongest generation yet. She ends up releasing Ambrose, the man who cursed her and her family. Doreen and Ambrose goes on a quest and discovers what the truth of love is. While on this quest they both have their own motives and while being together during this, they slowly start to fall for each other.

During the quest you see magical creatures, spirits and trials. You kind of try to help them out while you’re reading in your mind—atleast that’s what I did!

Starting off the book was hard to get into. But once the book found its flow it really picked up. I enjoyed the book but wait til the ending! This truly was a fun read and I hope to see more from the author!

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC! All opinions are my own.

This book suffers from a horribly plain cover, for a book that is very whimsy, full of mystery, with a touch of family drama and trauma. I would place this on the witchy romance continuum as fitting into the autumnal witch vibes but with more seriousness, in a similar category to Hazel Beck's books rather than Erin Sterling's. There is the brief question of - is this going to be a weird age gap vibe? but let's be real, I grew up in the era of Twilight, it really didn't bother me all that much. There is this deep thorough line of familial trauma and air of mystery through the whole novel which I felt was its driving force - though it did drop us in, in a way that made me feel like I needed a couple chapters to orient myself.

I thought there were parts of this book that were enjoyable and parts that dragged. I liked Doreen and Ambrose, but at times, their chemistry felt off. I think that this would be a very enjoyable read for some, but it just wasn't my favorite.

I'm still unsure how to rate this book, as there was parts I enjoyed but also parts where I felt so confused! I enjoyed the slowburn romance, but then felt it turned I to instalove. I also found the dates and history hard to keep up with so that was a bit jarring for me. Overall, a pretty good book for spooky season!