Not bad not great. Thought this would have been more centered on the abortion clinic of it all versus a family dynamic. Think that maybe would have been more engaging

I was unable to finish this book and thus will not be posting a full review. Unfortunately, I found the story to be confusing. Thank you for the opportunity and your consideration.

This novel had a lot going for it—mystery, family secrets, and a chilly Cape Cod setting that felt perfect for a wintry, slow-burn read. I appreciated the intergenerational lens and how it tried to weave together history, motherhood, and identity across multiple perspectives.

But for me, it didn’t quite deliver the emotional or narrative payoff I was hoping for. Mary is a sympathetic character, and her search for the truth—about the fire, her birth mother, and her family’s murky past—is compelling in parts. Still, the pacing dragged at times, and the multiple threads didn’t always come together in a satisfying way. The plot had promise, but it sometimes felt more meandering than mysterious.

I’d still recommend it to readers who enjoy literary mysteries with complex mother-daughter dynamics and small-town intrigue. It just didn’t light a fire for me the way I wanted it to. 🔥

i really do enjoy character driven books. especially ones where we learn some deep truths.
this is such a realistic point of view too. the starting point of things being exposed often happens by just one thing and its ripple effect. like often doesnt go kaboom "here are you secrets" but its in the little moments,the nuggets we find, the threads pulled. in this is what happens for one adopted woman. a health clinic is burnt down. but there is sooooo much more to it. and they relate to our main characters whole life, her parents and the secrets being kept from her.
i never knew what way this was going to go. i didnt want to think her adoptive mother would keep secrets as a hurtful thing. you always want believe a parents decides things good or bad to protect right? so i was surprised and didnt like which way the book swung. but was it to stay that way?#
there is a unique writing style from this author. and i think id like to read more of her to see if it stays the same or was just the way she laced out this book.

This was an amazing discovery, lots of secrets and thrilling involved. I didn't regret jumping headfirst into this. An amazing discovery

I wanted to really enjoy this book but there were too many things that didn't get resolved or was pointless.
The MC has this silly titles for simple things that gets
annoying.
I read some reviews that say everything was wrapped up in a nice box at the end but it was not. It is hinted at it like one character says the put the accelerant down but never says they are the one to light the fire.
Does Mary ever find out about the Chief? Does the memory of that night ever come back?

I wanted to love this book but unfortunately I only liked it. I really struggled to connect with the characters and I found it to be predictable at times. Please give it a go yourself you may find you really like it.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the eARC in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own.

It's an interesting premise but I fear the execution falls flat. I find myself dislike the main character so much that it's hard to enjoy the story.

Unfortunately I DNF at 50%. I found this book boring and could not engage with the characters. Not for me. Thank you to Netgalley and Alcove press for ARC.

definitely promising and fulfills much, but not all, of the promise. what you get on the tin. 4 stars. tysm for the arc.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

I was hopeful that this story would follow a similar line of a strong main character with secrets and lies hiding in her past (or even her present) but unfortunately I just didn’t like anyone in this book. It’s so hard to connect when everyone involved is kind of terrible. I was just really disappointed that I wasn’t compelled to like the characters as much as I had hoped.

The plot is interesting, but it’s also somewhat predictable in where it goes. The social commentary is a bit hamfisted too, which is a shame. I did enjoy the twist and appreciated how everything got tied up in a neat little bow with all the characters.

The cover art is worth a mention too- it’s beautiful! I get what this book was trying to do, I just don’t feel like it fully got there.

It's all kind of a bummer when you find yourself disliking the characters more and more as you go on. Like, surface level dislike is one thing, but I began to legitimately want had things for them...Some of the pottery stuff was nice.

I'm sure this book is right for someone, but I was bored almost the entire time. I kept finding myself doing other things instead of reading, since reading felt like a slog.

I suppose when I expect a book to be feminist, I want the women to have a sort of redeeming quality - I love women's wrongs, but not this kind, if that makes sense? Sometimes it felt like the author was trying to hit a trauma quota, which bothered me greatly.

Oh well. Onwards and upwards.

Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove Press for an eARC in exchange for my honest review.

Such a great book about a time past, yet so timely. The writers style is unique, straddling humor and pathos. I really like it when she takes me on "character journeys" through dialogue and scenes. I learn so much more about each character this way. The small Cape Cod town is a character in itself. The visual, granular prose reflects an artists sensibility (the protagonist being a potter!) The "mystery" is propulsive and keeps me reading. At the same time the story tells of a very important time: when women did NOT have choices and were exploited. The Old Lady Gossip Militia is an origin story, both hilarious and warning of what unchecked chatter can yield. I find this, a cautionary tale, timely for the moment we are in. Love this book!!!

Highly recommend this book! Stiles' writing is extraordinary and her characters are so well developed. When a mysterious fire strikes a small New England health clinic, long-held secrets are revealed. Loved getting to see the "other side" of Cape Cod. Told through multiple POVs, this book has a darkly humorous tone that kept me wanting more. I really enjoy books that explore important topics (here: pregnancy, abortion, and adoption) through story and this one didn't disappoint. A must-read for anyone who loves mysteries and thrillers with quirky, dark characters!

Thank you so much to NetGalley for a copy of this book it was really good and I would rate it 3/5 stars!

**Features:**
- Uncovering family secrets
- Explores themes of identity, belonging, and family
- Murder and arson mystery where the main character is a key suspect
- Unreliable narrators

**Synopsis:**

Mary Newcombe knows that fire has many uses. Most of the time, she uses it for pottery in her Brooklyn studio. However, once a year, she makes an obligatory trip back to Cape Cod with her son to visit her adopted mother for Christmas. This holiday promises to be like any other until a fire breaks out in her father’s old clinic. The police are in search of Mary’s cousin, Jimmy, who has disappeared and Mary quickly finds herself on the suspect list as well. Meanwhile, her mother Birdie seems to be keeping more secrets than usual and her son seems to be growing more and more distant. It doesn’t help that Mary had one too many and can’t remember what happened that fateful night. Mary’s only chance at answers is to start digging deep into her family’s history. However, some skeletons are better left buried.

**Thoughts:**

This book has fascinating characters and a dark, mysterious plot. The fact that it can so quickly turn the usually idyllic Cape Cod into a place that feels cold, sinister, and isolated really speaks to Newcomb Stiles’s ability to create an atmosphere. This book has been recommended to lovers of Lessons in Chemistry and Where the Crawdads Sing however, I wouldn’t strongly liken it to either book. I imagine that the ‘feminist’ bent of this book through its exploration of reproductive rights and the fact that the main character is being suspected of a crime in a small town setting are the reasons for the comparison. However, Hush Little Fire is far darker than either of these other books and has morally complicated characters that are hard to truly root for. Where I really liked the way these themes and characters were explored, readers should be aware that the places this book is willing to go and overall vibes are completely different.

Despite being told from multiple characters’ perspective, this book has an odd, wandering style to it. There are enough clues in each chapter to keep the story moving and make sure you never lose the sense that everything is connected. However, it can also feel a little scattered and chaotic. Additionally, there are few just purely odd interactions and ‘moments’ different characters had. As a result, I found the book really hard to stay fully invested in. The mystery unfolds in an interesting and satisfying way, but I also felt like the book was holding me at arms length the whole way. Despite that, it is still well worth the read if you are looking for an intriguing, mind-bending mystery.

Hush Little Fire, my first book started in 2025, almost became my first book not finished in 2025, as I had a little struggle getting into the story. Once I became more comfortable with the wandering flow, and got further into the story, I started to appreciate the author's style more. The characters are realistic and believable, and the setting is described well. I liked how the different story lines tied together the further along I read, and how everything wrapped up well by the end.

The premise sounded interesting but unfortunately this did not hold my attention. I didn't particularly like any of the characters and it just didn't end up being what I thought it was going to be. We do find out who set the fire and who Mary's parents are, so I appreciated answers to those questions.

Kindly received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

I liked this book. It was interesting, had good writing, and a good pace to it. I liked the secrets and family drama that comes out, it made it entertaining and kept me intrigued throughout reading.

Thank you to NetGalley, to the author, and to the publisher for this complimentary ARC in exchange for my honest review!!!