The Roots of Educational Inequality
Philadelphia's Germantown High School, 1907-2014
by Erika M. Kitzmiller
This title was previously available on NetGalley and is now archived.
Pub Date 03 Dec 2021 | Archive Date 03 Dec 2021
The Roots of Educational Inequality chronicles the transformation of one American high school over the course of the twentieth century to explore the larger political, economic, and social factors that have contributed to the escalation of educational inequality in modern America.
In 1914, when Germantown High School officially opened, Martin G. Brumbaugh, the superintendent of the School District of Philadelphia, told residents that they had one of the finest high schools in the nation. Located in a suburban neighborhood in Philadelphia's northwest corner, the school provided Germantown youth with a first-rate education and the necessary credentials to secure a prosperous future. In 2013, almost a century later, William Hite, the city's superintendent, announced that Germantown High was one of thirty-seven schools slated for closure due to low academic achievement. How is it that the school, like so many others that serve low-income students of color, transformed in this way?
Erika M. Kitzmiller links the saga of a single high school to the history of its local community, its city, and the nation. Through a fresh, longitudinal examination that combines deep archival research and spatial analysis, Kitzmiller challenges conventional declension narratives that suggest American high schools have moved steadily from pillars of success to institutions of failures. Instead, this work demonstrates that educational inequality has been embedded in our nation's urban high schools since their founding. The book argues that urban schools were never funded adequately. Since the beginning of the twentieth century, urban school districts lacked the tax revenues needed to operate their schools. Rather than raising taxes, these school districts relied on private philanthropy from families and communities to subsidize a lack of government aid. Over time, this philanthropy disappeared leaving urban schools with inadequate funds and exacerbating the level of educational inequality.
“In The Roots of Educational Inequality, Erika M. Kitzmiller provides a clear and meticulously researched inquiry into the racial and economic inequality which has plagued America’s public high schools for over a hundred years. In her groundbreaking study, Kitzmiller brilliantly utilizes both ethnographic and quantitative methods to expose ‘how these institutions were founded to provide different opportunities and resources to Black and white children.’ Readable and thought-provoking, this volume is of interest not only to educational specialists but to everyone who cares about equality in public education.”
—Henry Louis Gates, Jr., Harvard University
Available on NetGalley
Average rating from 7 members
The Roots of Educational Inequality: Philadelphia's Germantown High School, 1907-2014 by Erika M Kitzmiller shows that the "failure" of many schools were seeded from their inception to fail. Through the in-depth case of Germantown high school and extensive research on national trends and policies Kitzmiller makes a very strong case for the failure being one of the system rather than failures of many individual schools. I can't do the research credit by trying to summarize many of the factors that contribute so I will (likely oversimplify) one of the main points. This will also include some of my feelings as well as her research, so any misstatements will be mine and not the book's. Even when Germantown was new (and most of the things about Germantown can be applied to schools across the country) the tax revenue was not really sufficient to maintain the school. So philanthropic sources were found, which for affluent and even most middle class communities can compensate for governmental underfunding. As the dynamics of the community changed, what is usually called white flight, so did the dynamics of being able to raise extra funds. Since the government didn't want to increase taxes, the school became underfunded, then underperforming. But the cause was not white flight, that was just the catalyst that exposed the initial problem, underfunding. This process then leads to many urban schools as well as many rural schools in poor areas to be considered failures. The communities served by the schools tend to be predominantly communities of color and/or poor communities, thus unable to make up the difference between what an adequate school needs and what the school boards and local governments are willing to allocate to the future of the country, namely the education of our young. My oversimplification glosses the many social and cultural aspects as well as the details of the policymaking. Kitzmiller, however, goes into detail on all of this with this longitudinal study that covers the history of this particular school from every vantage point. I find it hard to believe that the powers that be weren't perfectly aware, very early in the twentieth century, that they could attain their racist and classist ends without ever being openly so. Just make it look like what happens is both natural and the fault of those who are being victimized by a system stacked against them. Whether you agree or disagree with my view, you owe it to yourself to read this book with an open mind. If you truly believe I am wrong then you should have no trouble refuting all of the research and evidence. But if you read with an open mind then maybe you will come to agree with at least some of what I said. If the education of future generations is at all important to you, then learning what is here can only be a positive thing, but dismissing it out of hand just shows where you fall when it comes to equitable education for all of our children. Reviewed from a copy made available by the publisher via NetGalley.
I had originally requested this book under a different pretense, but I'm thrilled that I kept reading even when it did not match my initial conception of what this book might be. As somebody in a 'third world country' I feel that educational inequality is as common as day and night and so to see it playing out in a case of one particular School as selected by the author provides for an interesting read. History teaches us important lessons in this book and it is my hope that many other such topnotch scholars like the author of this book will undertake such microcosmic studies and present an in depth picture. The public school system needs overhaul, yes it absolutely does. A weak public education system is sure shot way to corrosion of society, some affects of which, we are already seeing. This is a strong recommend for anyone looking to understand the importance and manner of conducting such a study, apart from the all important topic that it deals with.
Educational inequality is not new nor is it extinct in public education. Kitzmiller’s historical view of Germantown High School in Philadelphia, PA was an eye-opener. Inequalities were present from almost the beginning and plagued this educational institution to its closing days. Racial and economic inequality play a key role in the educational system for these Philadelphia residents. Of particular interest was the differing accounts of the students’ experiences. There were such varying accounts of events for students attending during the same timeframe. The experiences for minority students were quite different from the experiences of white students. While there were many student accounts in the book, there were not many accounts from faculty members. I wonder if the educators from Germantown were even aware of how their practices impacted students. This book should be essential reading for all educational administrators in the K-12 system. As we grapple with educational inequalities in the US, there are lessons to be learned from this book.
After working in a High School with a student body with a high percentage of people of color I was able to directly see the inequalities that go on in High Schools that have this type of student body and we most often see these inequalities happen in High Schools that are in a big city. This book does a really good job of finding the balance of educating the reader as well as using real world scenarios to apply that education that way the reader can see the inequalities in a real world setting. This topic is one of vast importance and the more our society relies on education to make a living the more important this topic will get because not only do these issues affect kids while they're in High School but these issues affect the futures of the children which is not something that should be ignored.
A great look at Germantown High School- the beginning and how it got here. Philadelphia is not known for currently having good schools. It’s interesting to see the roots of how we got where we are. It’s good to know there are people trying to change the issues and be what the students need.
This book was rather hard to get through. I found the subject interesting and important as public education is still vastly unequal and separated by gender, race, and class. However, the book was rather stale with all the quantitative information. I found the qualitative aspect really enjoyable to read. Actually hearing the stories of students in Philadelphia from decades ago until now was the part of the book worth reading.
After taking over three pages of notes as I read this remarkably thorough and resonating journey through the life of Germantown High School in Philadelphia, I spent time just thinking over some of the many irrefutable points this book makes. It is not easy to read from a human standpoint---several times I had to reread a passage because the theories and "reforms" seemed so counterproductive to learning; for example, the allocation of inadequate funds, charter schools and the emphasis on testing along with the ever-present cruel reality of race as a determining factor in a student's ultimate success. The central take-away of this work is that Philadelphia was never prepared to completely finance this high school from its inception in the early 1900s. The 120-year fight to keep the school relevant and thriving ended with its closing just a few years ago. This saga of the decline of an American high school could have taken place in any number of cities across the United States, but Philadelphia is a meaningful choice as the home of Benjamin Franklin (a great believe in education) and the Liberty Bell. Philadelphia also stands out as one of the poorest urban school districts in the United States. Following the reading of this book, I studied a map of Philadelphia to visualize what was happening to education in this city. I also followed up my reading with a e-mail to author Erika Kitzmiller thanking her for giving me new insights on how complex are the issues of education in the United States.