The Valet's Secret

A totally fantastic story!
This book will keep you reading, waiting to see what new twist or turn is around each bend. Just when you think you know what is going to happen, it surprises you by going a different way. It is so good. Kenneth, a widower, has raised his two boys and is pleased to see them moving towards their chosen fields. He has a small estate and is content with his lot, when he receives word that his cousin has suddenly died making him heir to an earldom. Something he never expected or wanted but he finds himself heading to his uncle’s to be trained in all the responsibilities this new position entails. Hoping to escape the looming pressures, if only for a few moments, he exchanges jackets, boots and hats with his valet and takes off on a brisk ride across the countryside. The spirited horse he has acquired has no desire to follow Kenneth’s directions and soon runs Rebecca, who was walking along the footpath in the woods, onto the side of the path to escape serious injury. Rebecca was a widow and former maid who had raised her daughter, Rose, so well that Rose had been able to get a position as a companion. Now Rebecca was living with her father and helping him in his business. She was entertaining the idea of remarriage to a man who she did not love but would provide companionship and an escape from her father’s drunken rages. As Rebecca pulls herself out of the bushes, Kenneth approaches to apologize for the accident. As they meet and begin to interact, they both find themselves drawn together but Kenneth presents himself as his valet making a romance possible. But eventually the truth of Kenneth’s identity will be discovered and any romance made impossible. Add in a stern uncle, a conniving cousin with three daughters, and a powerful and understanding baroness and you get a story that continues to engage and surprise right to the end. A great read! I highly recommend it. Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the copy. This is my review and all thoughts are my own.

The Valet’s Secret by Josi S. Kilpack is an excellent historical romance that had me engaged, enthralled, and cheering through till the end.

Rebecca and Kenneth both are at fairly uneventful spots in their respective lives- both having raised their own children and both widowed. Their assumed futures are abruptly shaken when they meet one another as Kenneth is on his travels to accept a surprising, and uninvited, Earldom after a death in the family. Kenneth masquerades as his valet in a last minute attempt to hold off the responsibilities and change in status and life if for just a few moments, one last time. It is at this moment of escapism that these two destined souls meet and chemistry blossoms.

Unfortunately, duties and societal roles, as well as many family obstructions, are obstacles in what should be an obvious romance. Rebecca finds out whom the real Earl is, and despite their feelings for one another, there are so many mountains placed in their path. Can they overcome all of the challenges to find love, happiness, and a happily ever after?

It was so sweet and romantic to see these two treasured characters overcome so many external difficulties: family, duty, expectations, societal restrictions…and find one another and the future that they both truly deserve. The chemistry was most definitely there…they were perfect for one another, and I am glad to see how wonderful of an ending the author was able to give to two such memorable and well-rounded characters.

The twists, turns, and surprises all added a bit of complexity and added to the enjoyment that I experienced while reading this story. I finished it happy, light, and satisfied.

5/5 stars

Thank you NG and Shadow Mountain Publishing for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.

I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately ( as of 9/25/21 no BB listing has been created and will be posted when it is updated with links added below) and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication.

As a once happily married woman, Rebecca Parker lived a charmed life, but now widowed and working for a living, she feels alone and living a mundane existence. That is until the day a valet speeding by on a horse nearly runs her off the road. Mr. Malcolm Henry is apologetic, gentle, and very handsome. She’s instantly drawn to him, which is why, rather than stopping him from kissing her, she finds herself kissing him back, reigniting a nearly forgotten passion in her. But love at first sight only happens in fairy tales—never to an ordinary woman like her.

But while working in the kitchens during a fancy dinner party, she sees something strange: the valet—the valet she kissed—is sitting at the right hand of the baroness. She realizes that Mr. Henry is not the earl’s valet; he is the earl—Kenneth Winterton.. Will there be a happily ever after?

Add in a drunk father, interfering uncle, evil cousin with three daughters... it's a lot of obstacles standing in the way of true love. The twists and turns keep me reading. :) I really like this version of Cinderella. Love both main characters a lot. :) Very enjoyable.

Thanks to the publisher for providing an arc

I couldn’t put this book down! It was amazing from start to finish. One of those books you want to go back and read your favorite parts over again, so that you can savor them a little longer.

The storyline is loosely the storyline of Cinderella, with a few role reversals at times, and a wonderful regency twist. I loved the nods to the original story, but loved even more the parts that made it unique.

Rebecca was so lovable. How can you not love a walnut throwing woman with good aim, who’s a hard worker, and loving mother.

Kenneth was a worth male lead, who really wanted a woman who he could love, not just live companionably with. In most Cinderella stories the couple is young and naive, but in this story they are both widows, and the wisdom of an older than usual couple made this book even more enjoyable.

I received an advanced copy of this book by Josi Kiloack from Shadowmountain via Netgally. The opinions are my own. This book will be available March 2022! You won’t want to miss it.

Widower Kenneth is on his way to his uncle’s estate, now that he’s the heir presumptive to his uncle’s Earldom but he has one last bit of rebellion in him, and he changes clothes with his valet and rides to the estate. He meets widowed Rebecca Parker and there’s instant attraction. Unfortunately for Kenneth, he introduces himself as his valet. Several meetings later, Rebecca realizes he’s not who he said he was. And this means their roles in society are very different.

Overall, I liked this book. I thought the idea that true love wins over restrictive society roles was nicely done, even if it was a bit unbelievable at times. I loved the baroness, who turns into a champion for Rebecca and Kenneth’s love. I adored that we got a book with “older” main characters instead of the fresh out of the schoolroom haven’t seen anything characters. Unfortunately, I didn’t think they were well written in terms of maturity. I felt like Kenneth in particular was written like a twenty something man who doesn’t understand the reality of life at that time. That’s what really keeps me from giving this a higher rating.

I did enjoy this book as a whole, even though I don’t consider it a favorite. 3.5 rounded up to 4.

As a Cinderella story, this one had cute moments. Other moments were difficult to swallow though. The whole hiding your identity then being found out before you could come clean feels very overdone, and it wasn't convincingly done in this case.

At times it feels like you start to really get to know the characters, at others it feels like the author is just skimming the surface and contradicting what we previously knew about the character. For example, Rebecca is feisty and fiery when she first meets the supposed valet. But quickly melts into his kiss with no hesitation only moments later, with no explanation other than she's lonely and he's good looking.

The story went on like that - with completely out of character moments happening because plot. When it went well, the story flowed easily and was enjoyable to read. But certain aspects felt forced, and made it difficult to fully enjoy. While a fairy tale isn't necessarily meant to be realistic, part of the wonder of them is that you can imagine it really happening, and I did not find that with this one.

There is something special and unique about Josi Kilpack's stories. Her novel, Lord Fenton's Folly was one of the first regency era stories that I read and there began my love of historic novels, especially all things regency. I have been a fan of her work for a long time and am happy to add The Valet's Secret to my list of favorite books by Ms. Kilpack. The Valet's Secret is charming with a fun twist and unique nods to the fairy tale Cinderella. I loved that the characters has to make decisions for themselves that would lead to their happiness, despite what others and the world thought they needed or should do. When everything and everyone appears to be working against the very happiness that they sought, they learned to follow their hearts. Sometimes the heart wants what it wants, even if it doesn't fit into a perfect box or society's demands and expectations. Other times, it takes great courage to follow your heart. True, not everyone gets the chance to chase after their heart's desires, but in this novel it was very endearing and satisfying to see. I highly recommend The Valet's Secret and enjoyed reading it, probably too much, judging by how late I stayed up to finish it one sitting.

Thank you to Josi S. Kilpack, NetGalley, and Shadow Mountain Publishing for my eARC of “The Valet’s Secret” in exchange for my honest review.

In “The Valet’s Secret,” we meet Rebecca and Kenneth, two folks who end up falling in love but are on opposite sides of the class hierarchy. Since it’s a HEA, they are able to overcome the limitations and expectations of their stations to reach their HEA. It’s a very sweet and tender read. I enjoyed reading about two adults, in their 40s, finding a partner again and falling in love. I also really loved some of the humor - I won’t spoil a certain scene but it made me laugh out loud.

I do wish there was a bit more action or interaction between Rebecca and Kenneth. While we get to see them interact a fair amount and you can see their relationship grow and strengthen, I think I wanted even more. And in some ways, I almost wish Kenneth impersonating the valet, Malcolm, went on a bit longer since that’s the title of the book. I was expecting the reveal to be much later or somehow really make a mess of things but that was not the case.

Overall, I did thoroughly enjoy “The Valet’s Secret” and I will be certain to read another one of Kilpack’s novels again.

This was absolutely delightful. Josi Kilpack has done it again! The plot was well-paced and captivating to the very end. The characters were charming. I highly recommend this fun and quick read. Many thanks to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for the advanced copy of the book.

This proper romance doesn’t disappoint. It has a Cinderella theme to it with a regency background. I really enjoyed this. I read this very quickly. I would definitely recommend this to those who love a story with depth and feeling that is sweet.

Excuse me, but why did this book have to end?!? I was swept away in a world with Rebecca and Kenneth. These two people never should have worked being from "opposite sides of the track" but their love overcame all the obstacles. This was definitely a book I was expecting to be as outstanding as it was which are my absolute favorite stories! Author Josi Kilpack has a way with words to lead us all to the happily ever after.

Firstly, I would like to thank Shadow Mountain Publishing, and NetGalley, for the privilege to read this eARC!

Brief Plot (without spoilers): The Valets Secret, by Josi S. Kilpatrick, is a regency era romance. Oh Kenneth is an earl, and one day to get away from the stress he dresses up as his valet for the day. While he’s out he almost runs over Rebecca with his horse, but their chemistry is so strong they end up kissing. What ensues is multiple more encounters with Kenneth hides his true identity and Rebecca falls harder and harder. When the truth comes out Kenneth hast to decide if you wants to maintain his title, or try at love with a commoner, Rebecca.

My review: 3.5/5 ⭐️ While I thought the story was cute, and I love anything that’s referred to as a hopeful fairytale, I just couldn’t get invested enough with this book to read it higher. With the opening scene being the characters meeting and kissing, I hoped for more chemistry. Recently I’ve been reading more historical fiction, and the storyline seem to fall a bit flatter than compared to others. It was still cute, but just not my cup of tea.

Thanks Netgalley for a arc copy of this book for a honest review..  


The Valet's Secret had a lot of twist and turns I was all for it a very delightful read 5 stars 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟









Happy Reading Lisa 📚

This is a unique take on Regency romance. I so enjoy an older love with adults. The heroine was a widow with a 20-some year old daughter and the hero was older with two sons 'in university', as they say. They were only about 4 or 5 years apart in age, which is a wonderful age gap. The hero was just into his title and was also an heir to an earldom, when he was tired of trying to mold himself into his new position. He had been a small landowner with an estate in Sussex. He switched places with his valet so he could ride a horse to his uncle"s estate and have a little freedom. He almost ran down the heroine because he was on a rented, spirited chestnut gelding. (My daughter has ridden her fair share if crazy chestnuts!) By the time he brought the horse under control and walked it back to where he saw the heroine, she had finally extricated herself from the bushes she went into trying to not get trampled by the run away horse. The heroine worked with her abusive father, doing silhouette portraits. She was running errands when she was almost run down. The hero helped her up and overcome by her presence, kissed her. He then escorted her to near her home. They couldn't forget about each other. He was intrigued by this lower class lady and she was intrigued by the valet she just met. The hero lied to her about his identity because he was embarrassed. She was picturing herself in almost-love with someone of the same class as her. I will let you read how it goes.
I enjoyed this story because of the different perspective it gave of a widow of that time period and the sacrifices women had to make since they couldn't own companies, run estates, or have bank accounts without a man. I also like the different perspective of the age of the main characters. Normally you have a young lady and slightly older man. The age differences brings up different perspectives and responsibilities. This was a well written book that was very descriptive. At some times it seems slow, but this book was about life in a small village. The only action and adventure was going to church on Sundays, lol. I was never bored with this story and I enjoyed the entire read. I give this book 5 stars and recommend reading with all due haste.

"The Valet's Secret" is a charming Regency Proper Romance by gifted author Josi Kilpack. Featuring an older couple, both widowed, this tale explores class differences and expectations. There are shades of Cinderella, complete with a fairy godmother.

This is not, however, a fairy tale. There are no magic wands or transforming pumpkins. Working-class Rebecca Parker and Kenneth Bartholomew Winterton, heir to an earldom, are engaging main characters. Walnut-throwing Rebecca is a delight, while fish-out-of-water Kenneth is coping with his new responsibilities. Secondary characters are also entertaining. Rebecca's daughter Rose and the baroness are endearing, while Lady Beth and Mr. Seffton (Rebecca's father), are detestable.

Kilpack's prose is lovely, and this well-edited book is clean. Although I'm unaware if this tale is the first in a series, there are characters here that deserve their own stories.

Thanks to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for an ARC of this engaging novel.

I really enjoyed this story. I really liked how different it is from other proper romances. I loved that the characters are older, experiencing a second change at happiness later in their lives. A true regency Cinderella story.

Rebecca Parker had had a wonderful life, that is until her loving husband dies and forces her to live again under her father's roof. While she enjoys helping with her father's work as a silhouette artist. She knows her only means of escape from her father's home is through marriage and she resigns herself to a marriage of convenience. That is until she is nearly run over by a handsome man on a horse. A man, who she believes is a valet named Malcolm Henry and who also kisses her with such passion, giving her the chance to think there might be more out there than a marriage of convenience.

But not is all as it seems. Mr. Henry does exist and is a valet, but he is not the man who nearly ran over and shamelessly kissed Rebecca. That distinction belongs to Kenneth Winterton, a soon to be earl, who simply wants to enjoy the simple life a little bit longer and disguises as his valet to enjoy some simpler pursuits before assuming his role as earl. Kenneth too is a widower and knows he must find a wife as he assumes his new title, knows Rebecca is far below his social rank, but cannot seems to avoid the chemistry and the fact that he might just love her. But the chasm between their social stations is too large.

This is a wonderful story of second chances and finding true love.

Kenneth Winterton is the heir presumptive to the Earl of Brenston.
Rebecca Parker is a widow working with her father in his business of making shadow art. Years ago she was in service and must take it up again after leaving her father's home. Almost run over by a horse ridden by Kenneth, he and Rebecca kiss. What a kiss! They both want more, but Kenneth has lied about his identity and continues to do so every time they meet. It's not long before Rebecca finds out who he really is.
A heartwarming love story that is built on the difference in class and the impossibility of a life together, or is it? This reads at a fast pace with angst, heartache and a happy ending.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book.

If you're looking for a proper romance book that is outside of the typical mold, this is the author for you! She has several books that feature characters or situations that aren't typical of the genre. In this particular book, the main characters are middle aged widowers with grown children, and they first meet by chance on a road, where they share a passionate kiss. Kenneth tells Rebecca that he's a valet to the earl... but in reality, he's actually the earl himself. Rebecca works with her father as a shadow artist, and her status is nowhere close to that of an earl. While I had difficulty getting over the idea that, in this time period, two strangers kissed on a road and then the woman went out of her way to find the man again, Josi Kilpack presented the idea in a way that made me believe is was reasonable. We got insight into Rebecca's hopes, fears, and challenges, and it lent some credibility to the otherwise unbelievable action. This is a lovely story about finding love a second time, overcoming obstacles, and figuring out what is worth fighting for.

I received an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion and review.

I received a free preview copy from NetGalley and this is my freely given review.

I gave this a 4.5 stars; this was a beautifully written historical romance that touched me deeply. This was the first book I read by this author and I loved the blurb about this because there were so many things that appealed to me. The hidden identity/mistaken identity, the differing classes... but it was so much more than that and it was a story that really riveted me.

The hero, Mr. Kenneth Winterton is a widower, father of two nearly grown men, and an ex-Navy man. He is a mature 48 year old who recently found out that he is to be the heir to his uncle Lester, the Earl of Brenston, since his cousin died suddenly, with no children. His uncle is hail and hearty, but in his 70s, and concerned about his legacy. He wants to ensure that he passes on his knowledge to Kenneth, and ensure that he is well established in the community in the North of England. Especially considering Kenneth did not expect to inherit and his status will be raised significantly, his duties will be augmented, and he is from the South, and an unknown entity to the local gentry. Part of ensuring his status before he inherits is to see that Kenneth marries well, which to the Earl, means a woman from the community, raised to manage the duties of being Countess, and supporting the gravitas and prominence of the earldom.

Kenneth is aware that he is being given a grave responsibility, as well as a significant inheritance, and wants to live up to his uncle's expectations. But he is a grown man of 48 years old, and he is struggling on how to maintain his own individual identity and his needs without losing himself in the quest of learning to becoming the Earl. Part of his angst is the fact that he loves to draw, and loves to ride wildly. He knows he needs to marry, but also wants to find a wife that he connects with.

As part of his minor, hidden rebellions, he sometimes trades identities with his valet, Malcolm, so he can rent horses and race them around the area. On doing so one day, he nearly runs into Rebecca, forcing her off the road while she was walking to meet her daughter. He stops to help her and when she gets over her initial ire with him, they realize they feel a mutual attraction and kiss.
Neither one of them can forget the kiss. But Rebecca is a commoner, and poor, forced to move back in with her father when she became widowed, to raise her daughter. Her daughter is now an adult and has work as a paid companion to a member of local gentry. Rebecca continues to live with her father, and help him with his work, but also coping with his alcoholism and abusiveness.
Regardless of knowing that she is not an appropriate option for him, Kenneth continues to meet with Rebecca, in the guise of his valet, and their attraction becomes stronger, and Rebecca hopes for more with the valet she is falling for.

But of course, as with so many lies, the truth is revealed...

I enjoyed reading about the complexities of their various relationships. The real valet made a nice foil, as both a conscience and an enabler to Kenneth. There was nice depth and realism in the complexities of Rebecca's relationship with her father, and also with her daughter to; including the sacrifices she made to give her daughter some opportunities. She is a character that seems very real and relatable.

It was also wonderful to read a historical romance that was about the hope of mature love and second chances at love. This was not a story about young 17 year old virginal debutantes and their 20-ish rakehell suitors. This was a story of a widow and widower in their 40s, with adult children, and knowledge about the world, and it's unfairness. But also about how hope, desire, passion, and the magic of new love can also exist at that age.

So - as a passionate woman who believes in magic and love, and who is in her 40s; I have to say that I loved this book. I just wish that there was an epilogue or something to let us know how the couple managed in their relationship after they came together. The final road to the HEA was rather rushed for me, especially with the uncle's capitulation, after all his lessons and mechanisms to get Kenneth to select an appropriate wife.

Also it would have been nice to see Lady Beth get some of her comeuppance too - snobby, manipulative bitch.

Wow, this must well be the best book I've read all year! I just wish it had an epilogue!

Josi Killpack's use of language is excellent and her writing flows effortlessly, enhancing the story in the best way.

From the moment Kenneth and Rebecca meet, there's a power and depth to their connection that takes them both by surprise, yet neither are able to deny those feelings. From the beginning, Kenneth knows they're unequally matched—based on his lies, Rebecca believes him to be a valent to Mr. Winterton when, in fact, he is Mr. Winterton, an heir to his uncle's earldom.

With each encounter, they see these feelings only strengthened, and the impossibility of their growing closeness only grows too, especially after she finds out who he really is.

I have read many good stories this year but this one took hold of my feelings from their first encounter. I couldn't help but go along with Kenneth and Rebecca as they fell in love and ultimately fought to be together.

I just wish it had an epilogue.

I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.

5 stars

An excellent read. I didn't expect to like it. It's a clean read and the hero is a balding 48 year old. His would be wife, a widow in her 40s with a daughter in her twenties.

I liked the interaction between the two characters and the wider community. Some of the others in the story were scheming, some misunderstood.

I thoroughly recommend this book and I'll be looking out for more from this author, what it lacks in erotic scenes it more than makes up for in characterisation and dialogue.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

The Valet's secret was delightful. The two main characters in their 40 meet on the road without knowing each other's identity and share an impulsive kiss and the rest is history. Had quite a bit of a Cinderella feel toward the end. The characters could have used more depth and I would have enjoyed more of their conversation. It was implied that they talked for hours several times but we only get a snippit of the conversation. A quick read.

This was a cute and fun read. It took me a little while to get intoThe Valet’s Secret by Josi S Kilpack. However once I really started reading it, I was very intrigued. The Valet’s Secret was different then the other books I had been reading, but it was still an enjoyable read and very interesting.
Rebecca Parker is in a new stage of life. She feels lonely and wants a break from the mundane routine of life. She never expected to meet Mr. Malcolm Henry on the road, and she never expected from him to change her life. However, what will she do when she learns that he is not a valet but the earl - Kenneth Winteron? Can their relationship ever become more? Kenneth Winteron just wants to be free, however becoming his uncle’s heir means rules and stations. He never expected to fall for a woman below his station or to lie to her about who he is. Will he ever be able to gain her trust and maybe grow a relationship?
Rebecca was such a refreshing change of character. She was older and she had lived life. I really enjoyed reading about her and reading about her finding herself. She had gotten married at a young age and raised her daughter, but when her husband died she moved back in with her father and in a way lost herself. Rebecca was so strong. She had endured much in her life, and it was cool to read about her still growing and learning. She was learning how to find herself in this new stage of life and she was falling in love.
Kenneth was an interesting character. He had to grow on me. I didn’t dislike him, but I just had to read more about him before I really understood him. He was also just trying to find his place in the world. He was a bit uncertain about his place and it was fun to read about him learning what it meant to be an Earl. However, he was kind and he truly cared about those around him. He had lived life and he valued people. Kenneth had to figure out what it would mean to love Rebecca and how to build a relationship with her.
Rebecca and Kenneth had an interesting relationship. They were of two different stations. However Rebecca didn't know it at the time and she found a connection with him. It was definitely fascinating to read about them falling in love and interacting, trying to figure out how to make their friendship work, never expecting something to come out of it. I thought that they were such a sweet couple and they definitely balanced each other out. They also had to learn to overcome their differences in stations and work past the whispers of others.
The side characters were also fun! Rebecca’s daughter Rose was super sweet. I loved Rebecca and Rose’s relationship. They trusted each other and cared for each other. Kenneth’s Uncle was complicated but he also cared for Kenneth. The Baroness who Rose worked for was also a character
She was such a strong woman who was a great addition to the story.
The Vault's Secret was a sweet and cute book. It was about characters falling in love and figuring out how to work with their different stations. I really enjoyed it and I would recommend it to those who like historical women's fiction. The Valet’s Secret is a clean historical women's fiction romance.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the publisher through Netgalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion, a positive review was not required.

This was a sweet Regency romance about two people in their 40’s who are living very different lives. Kenneth has recently become heir to an earldom after the untimely death of his cousin. Rebecca assists her drunken, violent father in the making of intricate silhouettes of the local Yorkshire gentry and had been a maid in one of the great houses. Rebecca and Kenneth meet accidentally and fall in love. In spite of tradition and custom of the time, can they overcome all and help each other take on the future?
It’s refreshing to have the romantic leads to be older but the story felt contrived, especially the ending.

This was a very sweet Cinderella-esque story
Premise
York, England, 1819.

As a once happily married woman, Rebecca Parker lived a charmed life, but now widowed and working for a living, she feels alone and living a mundane existence. That is until the day a valet speeding by on a horse nearly runs her off the road. Mr. Malcolm Henry is apologetic, gentle, and very handsome. She’s instantly drawn to him, which is why, rather than stopping him from kissing her, she finds herself kissing him back, reigniting a nearly forgotten passion in her. But love at first sight only happens in fairy tales—never to an ordinary woman like her.

I don’t always enjoy historical type fiction. Sometimes I find it a bit tedious, but not with this particular story. It was well written, romantic, and kept me turning the pages late into the night.

I flew through this book! This was such a fun and charming Cinderella inspired story. I always enjoy how Kilpack is able to incorporate elements into her story that are not always found in typical historical romances. I enjoyed how both of the characters had a past to overcome and how they were able to find love again later in life. I thought this story was a very sweet and charming read- I would definitely recommend!

Well this book was quite a ride of ups and downs...

At first there was insta love... and insta love is really not my thing. They met once (it was described quite shortened and not at all in great detail) and suddendly I was supposed to believe they were in love and sparks were high and flying... (and all even based on a lie!)

But then at about 30% in it got better. The meetings / rendevous got more believable and the sparks more feelable (if thats a word? :))

And at about 80% I started to get annoyed by the book anew because the author started to throw in quite a lot of weird obstacles which were (for the plot) unnessecairily and made the book feel fantastical espescially with the fairytail-like resolution that happened quite suddendly.

Generally this is quite a refreshing out of the usual regency romance story and has an interesting feel to it as both main characters are quite old already and there are only very few nice side characters...

Main Characters: clear backgroundstory, Kenneth somtimes kinda confusing because of the lie that he tells, mostly locigal actions
Side Charactes: mostly mean
Writing Style: good
Content: Clean, just kissing
Violence: Non
Would recommend: Yes

I got a free copy for a voluntarily left review by NetGalley

This was absolutely delightful, there is a place in my heart for ‘Proper Romance” and Josi Kilpack has done it again! The plot was well-paced and captivating to the end. It was refreshing to see older characters with grown children given a second chance at love.
I highly recommend this fun and quick read.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me an eArc to review.

I have to say that I really didn't know how much I would like this book because I just couldn't see how this could possibly end well. To my surprise, though it may seem slightly unrealistic for the time period, I thought the ending was perfect.

This story was a sort of play on the fairy tale Cinderella. A maid meets the "prince" (heir to a title) and so of course their relationship is forbidden. I thought some of the subtle changes were cute though, like Kenneth being the one locked in a tower instead of Rebecca, among others.

It was a sweet read that kept my interest and ended well. Another success for Josi Kilpack and The Proper Romance series.

I read this book on an autumn weekend with a cup of tea...and it was an absolute treat! The initial mistaken identity was fun and the characters lovely to spend a few hours with.

This is a really delightfully written book All of the characters are amazingly crafted, and have some intriguing fears/problems to overcome. This is a steamy plot, that is very entertaining and enjoyable to read..

4 stars *may change

I’ve said before I don’t really mind insta-love, and you definitely have to not mind it for this. Those two meet, like, twice before spilling their deepest desires and worries to each other. It was actually a little funny. Somewhere in the middle I just forgot that they barely knew each other because they acted like they were so well-acquainted.

The protagonists are quite a bit older than I think regency romances tend to have, and I wish it had been explored a bit more past “Ughhoo I’m so old.” Like, yeah, he’s got two fully grown sons in college, but he acts just like a 20 something year old. Besides the uh, you know, 19 year old fiasco. Speaking of, so glad he shut that down, Jesus. Does anyone ever bother to listen to the age gaps in romance books? Because some of them are WEIRD. I swear Kenneth was acting super meta in this book anytime he would talk about all the weird practices regency England had. He gets me.

This book is a lot more…contemporary soft feely-good? Compared to most regency romances, I mean. It’s more for someone who wants to read a romance in the time period without having to read a…bodice ripper.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advanced reader’s copy.

Kenneth Winterton, heir presumptive to the Earl of Brenston, and widower, is taking a ride in disguise wearing his valet’s clothing to have a little freedom, without restriction. On this ride he runs Rebecca Parker off the road. Rebecca is a widow, mother of a young woman, who lives with and works for her father in his silhouette business. Rebecca is slightly injured from the accident, and Kenneth helps her clean a scratch from her face that he caused. As her helps clean up the injury, the two are drawn together and are joined together in their want and loneliness in a kiss, and then another kiss. This was an amazing first kiss scene; and I loved it that it happened right at the beginning of the book; that was a fun surprise! Kenneth describes it as a kiss for the ages.

Aside from the fact that they had never met before, which it was totally appropriate for them to be kissing, there are two tiny little problems: 1) Rebecca thinks Kenneth is a valet to Mr. Winterton, not Kenneth Winterton, the heir presumptive to the Earl of Brenston, and 2) Kenneth is the heir presumptive, and Rebecca is of the working class. This chance meeting and swoony kissing was a great beginning to the Valet’s Secret.

I have to say that I am gushy in love with this novel. It is a beautiful second chance love story that shows that second chance love can be a possibility, and that with true love you can overcome obstacles. It gives hope for all of those looking for a second chance at love. The novel also nods to the great story of Cinderella, which was a nice touch! I loved the author’s dedication, “Dedicated to everyone who is wanting, fearing, and hoping for a second

This was such a fun read with great writing. The story flowed well and the characters were well written. Rebecca Parker is a widow trying to decide what to do with her life now that her daughter is grown. Then Kenneth comes pounding into her life and they share a life changing kiss. Little does she know Kenneth is next in line for a lofty title and belongs to a world out of her reach as an artist's daughter. What follows is a whirlwind romance with twists and turns thrown in their way.
#TheValetsSecret #NetGalley.

When I first started reading this book I was not sure I was going to like it. It seemed there was no way for this story to end well. I kept reading because the story is well written and I was pulled into it. I really liked the story by the end and would highly recommend it.

#thevaletssecret #netgalley

This was a cute storyline with neat characters. I loved the premise and the mystery, with a little romance thrown in.

It's hard not to root for Rebecca and Kenneth in this short and sweet regency romance. I loved the fact that our protagonists were older in life and hoping for a second chance at love, despite their differences in station.

The book was a poignant reminder of the lack of choices un-titled women had during this era. Despite being humiliated upon learning Kenneth's true identity, Rebecca is a strong, proud and admirable woman who carries herself with all the grace of a countess!

This book was an excellent addition to the genre and I recommend reading it upon its release in early 2022.

The Valet's Secret was an exciting read with a well-developed plot, interesting characters, and a strong romance. Rebecca Parker has lived a life of hard work and deals with abuse from her father, both of which make her the more practical of the two protagonists. Kenneth Winterton, however, is also grounded and must learn to balance his identity with his future title of Earl. The pair bond well and have excellent chemistry, making the romance aspect very enjoyable.

I loved how Kilpack laced in tiny details about the time period, from class structure to everyday life aspects. I also loved all the Cinderella elements that really came together in the last act. The "rags-to-riches" concept is present throughout the entire novel and only enhances the characters' interactions. However, I have a few critiques. For one, the pacing was a little fast for my taste. I would have liked to get to know the characters some more before truly diving into the rising action. All their backstory was dumped within the first few chapters, and then they met and it was love at first sight (which I guess makes sense considering the fairy tale theme). There was also this recurring statement that Kenneth's wife, whom he is being forced to find and pick for the Earldom, had the primary job of making *him* a better man and propping *him* up. I understand this ideology is realistic for the time period, which I appreciate, but it was a tad uncomfortable to read when used in context of the leading romance. Lastly - though technically not about the novel itself - the synopsis is somewhat misleading. From my understanding, Kenneth is not the Earl yet but his heir. Also, the summary is worded in a way where it sounds like the novel is from Rebecca's perspective. It's actually in both Rebecca and Kenneth's perspectives, almost every other chapter, in the third person.

Overall, this was a fun and entertaining read! I would definitely recommend it to any Regency fan.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book I received from the publisher through Netgalley. All views expressed are my unbiased opinion.

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.
2.5
I was intrigued by the premise of this book, but it didn't quite captivate me as I hoped it would. The Valet's Secret is a historical romance between Kenneth Winterton, a gentleman and soon to be Earl, and Rebecca Parker, a common artist's daughter. They meet by chance in a less than fortunate first encounter, but sparks fly between the two of them. Both widowed and not expecting to feel this way again, they meet each other again, but Ms. Parker does not know his real identity, as he was disguised as his valet when they first met. If she did, he would never see her again.
I enjoyed the plot and the forbidden romance that was explored between the two main characters. The reason the book fell a little flat for me was because I didn't connect with the main characters, and found them lacking a unique voice and personality. Rebecca is a strong and independent woman who is a little lost in the world after losing her husband, but she felt 2-dimensional and I didn't really connect emotionally. Mr. Winterton is a kind gentleman and is also a bit lost in his new world, but again, I didn't feel that emotional connection, either with him or with the romance built between the 2 characters. The character I did really enjoy was the Baroness who is confident, self-assured, and respected, and coming from a lower place in society, she is also humble and kind. This lifted the story for me as she featured more towards the end. I also enjoyed the writing itself; it wasn't anything special, but it was well done and it didn't feel like a chore to read despite my lack of connection with the characters.
Overall, this was a nice, easy read, with a good plot, and would recommend to anyone seeking a light, historical romance that crosses the boundaries of class.

3.5/5 stars
I was happy to see a book where the main characters, Rebecca Parker and Kenneth Winterton, are in their middle years with older children. It isn’t very common to have this occur and I liked that aspect because it provided more to make it an original story. Both Rebecca and Kenneth lost their spouses and each of them are lonely and eager to start a new life. How far they are willing to risk it is what drives the story.

There were several issues in the book that were tastefully addressed. In this Cinderella retelling, there is the twist of Rebecca having to be rescued by Kenneth from an aggressive, drunken father. The other thing was the societal class barrier of nobility versus the working class was well established and both Rebecca and Kenneth had to overcome this. Good for Kenneth that he realized that being nobility did not make you any better than someone else. I thought it was sweet to see how he was a determined man who chose to convince Rebecca to follow her heart.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an electronic copy of the book. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.

The future earl, Kenneth, dresses as his valet to feel a little more like himself and less of the burdens of his position. While out he practically runs Rebecca down with his wild horse. While checking that she is alright, sparks fly and an instant connection is realized. They meet again, Kenneth again in disguise but before their third meeting, Rebecca encounters him at a dinner where she is serving his meal as the future Earl. The journey that follows while he tries to regain her trust and good opinion is beautiful. It took me a little to get into the story at first, but I was very glad I stuck with it as I could not put it down after. The Cinderella elements were subtle yet striking and the twist of Kenneth being locked into the tower to miss the ball was funny. The thought of a capable man locked in his room trying (unsuccessfully) to break down the door, soaking himself in Sandalwood oil trying to loosen the hinges, is frankly hilarious! I do wish they would have returned to the ball for the final dance and to see Lady Beth set down by her own father for her antics. But I loved that they were able to find their second chance at love and their Happy ever after!

I really enjoyed this book. The characters are compelling and true to themselves. It has a fairytale feel to it that is fun and enjoyable. I love an underdog story.

Overall, I thought this was a pretty cute historical romance. I thought the pacing at the beginning was pretty slow but it picked up rather quickly. I was not completely sold on the instant love connection between the two at the beginning but towards the middle I kind of forgot at times that they barely knew each other. I think there could have been more interactions between the two to add more suspense to the story and their relationship but I did enjoy the interactions that are there.

I also enjoyed the difference in social standing because going against the norm creates a fun spin. I know things would have been different based on the time period in real life but I was happy with the ending.

I thought it was a little refreshing that Rebecca and Kenneth were already in their 40's during the story because I feel like I don't see that very often. I myself am young but that doesn't mean I can't connect with these characters in ways. I also got the hint of a Cinderella story towards the end but it didn't really click with me at the beginning.

This was a fun story that makes you feel good.

An enjoyable read about a mature couple that have a chance encounter that neither can forget. I have been reading romances for many years and when I find a book about a second chance at love I am drawn to it. This is such a book. The characters are nice people finding themselves a bit lost as Kenneth is to become an Earl and Rebecca finding love again after her husbands death and living with her abusive father. Both the couples children are grown. There was a bit too much of insta love and I would have enjoyed more interaction between the couple but this was difficult due to the class differences. The ending was a bit too modern in thinking that this would not have mattered more. I rate this a 3.5*

Josh S. Kilpack has done it again! Josi is a great regency author and has delivered yet another delicious read, perfect for any proper romance lover. Being a young adult I don't typically pick up books with middle aged main characters as I just can't relate to a lot of the themes there, but this book can be enjoyed by most. I liked seeing Rebecca and Kenneth's relationship develop, and learn their motivations for their actions. Josi is good at writing not-your-average regency, and that's exactly what this delivered. Can't wait to see what she writes next!

The Valet’s Secret is a fun entertaining read with a Cinderella type feel to it. It is well written and had great characters. I really liked that the main characters in this book were middle aged. I was a nice change from the usual romances I read.

I also enjoyed the love story between Kenneth and Rebecca. They had instant chemistry and a strong desire to be in each other’s company. But the both had to come to terms with the difference between their social class and figure out how to make a relationship work between them.

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book and highly recommend it to anyone who loves regency romances.

I was very excited going into this book, but something fell very flat for me. We follow Rebecca, a widow who falls in love with a valet. She finally realizes she can love again after the death of her husband…then she finds out the valet was lying to her the whole time and was actually a future earl.

I really liked Kenneth as a character. He was my favorite in the book. He’s kind of dream man material. I also liked Rebecca because of how strong she was. But there were definitely moments when I found her very annoying.

I found the romance was quite well done. I’m not a fan of insta love, but I think something did run deeper with these two. To each other, they were the proof that they could love again. They not only fell in love with each other, but they fell in love with the idea of each other.

I also particularly liked the writing style. It was simple and concise. I don’t read many historical/period romances, but based on this book alone, I would like to read more. I would also like to read more by this author.

The problem I had was the depth. I found that I didn’t really understand what was keeping these characters apart, aside from class. There never was any expression from characters outside of Kenneth and Rebecca that they could not be together. The stakes were also not very high for me. I never really felt Kenneth’s pressure to marry.

While this is a quick and rather light-hearted read, I found myself a little bored by about 80%. I think the author started adding unnecessary elements that prevented the two characters from getting together, as well as villainizing some side characters. I think the author should have added these details in earlier rather than later.

Overall, I still enjoyed this book. It was a pretty easy read, but I think it could have been more in-depth and detailed.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review!

I enjoyed this story of second love and second chances. Josi Kilpack does a great job of getting away from stereotypical storylines and bringing up other relatable life circumstances. A good story to get lost in for awhile!

I was excited to pick this book up. I really enjoyed it.

When first reading the description, I couldn't wait to get it open. It took a bit to be able to get to read this one, and even though I remembered the premise of the story, I had forgotten quite a bit. Stupid me, didn't go and read it again before diving in. That lead to me being thrown by a few things: their ages and their first kiss.

But neither of those things were negative for me. I just needed to change my mindset. Most regency books you read have these young women as the main character and a 21 year old man. But the main characters were in their 40s. I actually really liked that. It was a nice thing to read. And that chemistry!

The first kiss was great, but I think it was a bit too fast, and too sudden for me. Although it was a great place for the book to jump from and a most unforgettable meet cute.

I enjoyed the book. I would read it again.

Rating: 3.5 Stars

This doesn’t disappoint it was such a fun read. The story flowed well and the characters were well written. A romance with a few twists and turns thrown in, what more could you ask for! It was also nice to have characters in their middle years, rather than the usual youngsters..

I enjoyed this Regency romance set in 1819 Yorkshire, England, especially because it involved somewhat older protagonists for once. Rebecca Parker, 42, and Kenneth Winterton, 48, were both formerly married, had children, but lost their spouses. Each of them thought they could never again feel what they had felt before toward someone else.

A chance meeting between them in the woods ends with a kiss that surprises both of them and proves them wrong. But Rebecca is a house maid and Kenneth is the heir to an earl. When they met, however, Kennth was disguised as his valet, Malcolm Henry. Being attired as a valet gives Kenneth more freedom, and Rebecca believed Kenneth was Malcolm, and therefore someone in her own social station.

As Kenneth’s Uncle Lester is trying to prepare Kenneth, Lester’s only male heir, to be the next Earl of Brenston, he insisted that marriage was an essential first step. He paraded a number of eligible young ladies in front of Kenneth, but after that kiss in the woods, Kenneth could think of no one but Rebecca, even though he knew such a liaison could never be accepted.

Meanwhile, Uncle Lester’s daughter, Lady Beth, was scheming to get Kenneth to marry her eldest daughter Jacqueline, only 19, and determined to win Kenneth’s hand. Kenneth, even had he never met Rebecca, couldn’t fathom it: “A nineteen-year-old wife? A woman younger than both his sons with no experience of life? Not in a thousand years did he want such a woman.” But Kenneth underestimated the extent to which Beth was trying to manipulate him.

The pair do have an ally, although they are unaware of it. The nearest neighbor to Kenneth, the Baroness of Grangeford, was formerly a milliner’s daughter. With the support of her husband, the late Baron of Grangeford, her past was forgotten, and finally , after early a decade, her past was forgotten. While it took a long time, in the meanwhile, the two had each other, and enjoyed their love and life together.

But can everyone’s best intentions overcome those of the scheming Lady Beth?

Evaluation: This fun romance with a bit of intrigue will satisfy readers, and have them searching for similar, more unusual Regency stories.

“The Valet’s Secret” by Josi S. Kilpack was a refreshing, light read.

Kenneth is a widower with two grown sons. He has a nice living and is content until his world is upended by the death of his childless cousin. Because of this he is thrust into the role of future earl and heir to his uncle’s title and estate.

On his way to his uncle’s he wants one last moment of freedom before beginning his upcoming role and responsibilities. He changes clothes with his valet, Malcolm and set out on a bruising horseback ride. The horse is uncontrollable and nearly runs a woman down, forcing her off the road before he can be stopped.

As he goes back and tries to help the injured woman he is instantly drawn to her. The feeling is mutual and as a result of their mutual loneliness and ignited passion they share an intense kiss, which neither of them can forget.

The woman is Rebecca, a widow with a grown daughter. Since losing her husband she was forced back to live with her abusive father and has been considering a marriage of convenience to escape her situation. After that kiss, she knows she can never settle for less than love.

After finding out her “valet” is really the heir to an earldom she feels very betrayed and deceived. Being a commoner she sees the impossibility of their situation, as does he. But neither can forget the other and they are continually meeting unexpectedly.

Can there be a future with so much to overcome? There is the question of trust, societal expectations, a domineering uncle, scheming cousins and more. I was kept wondering how these impossible situations could be overcome. The author did not disappoint.

I would have liked to have seen their relationship explored a little longer and more time spent developing it. Also an epilogue would have been satisfying to see the fates of the “villains” in the story. There were some unexpected twists and turns and lots of tension which made it interesting. It was a great Cinderella fairytale story. It was clean, kissing only. No violence or language. I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys Regency and is looking for a good read. #thevaletssecret #josiskilpack #netgalley

Kenneth and Rebecca's story is a fun, easy read! Kenneth is the new heir in line for his uncle's title, something he never thought would happen. Now he faces new requirements in behavior, dress, and speech to live up to his station in life. That means he is no longer free to marry anyone beneath his social class, an unfortunate requirement now that he has found a woman that makes his heart race when she isn't serving a dinner for the upper class.

Rebecca has not felt anything for a man since the death of her husband. But when a handsome (bald?) stranger nearly runs her over, she realizes that maybe she can still feel the rush of young love. But he's unattainable as the heir presumptive to the earl's title and she is in service. It all seems so impossible.

This is an easy read with several unique characteristics. Both Kenneth and Rebecca are in their 40's with grown children and have lost their first spouses. This gives a different air to the story, since both are reasoning adults with less worries about social outcomes (though they do worry about appearances more than I would have expected). But the characters are well-developed with entertaining dialogue. It kept my interest and is worth a read!

Rated PG
--clean romance
--some parental verbal/emotional abuse (mild)
--no language

I received this ebook free from NetGalley. My opinions are voluntarily given.

Set in York, Regency England, Mrs Rebecca Parker is nearly run down by a valet riding on a speeding horse. This chance encounter with the handsome Mr Malcolm Henry, valet to the heir of the Earl of Brenston, immediately blossoms into instant attraction as they share a kiss by the road. Widowed with a grown daughter and needing to escape her abusive father, Rebecca has to look for a job. Hired as a maid by the baroness in the neighbouring estate of Grangeford, she finds herself serving dinner to the baroness’s guests, one of whom happens to be Mr Malcolm Henry - except he’s not a valet at all, he’s the heir to the earldom of Brenston, Kenneth Winterton.

This is a novel about two middle-aged people falling in insta-love upon their first encounter. As the nephew of the current Earl of Brenston, Kenneth was not groomed for the role of the earl until his cousin passed away. I can understand the frustrations and stifling restrictions of this role that was suddenly thrust upon him, and that led him to impersonate his valet so as to obtain that little bit of temporary freedom.

To be honest, I didn’t quite get the whole insta-love thing in this novel. There was little development of the romance for these two characters. I am rather bewildered by the breakneck speed and the intensity of which their feelings grew for each other.

There was also a bit of a reverse Cinderella feel to this story, especially when Kenneth was locked up in his room before the ball and had to be rescued. No fairy godmothers though.

The development of the story felt a little haphazard and the manner in which some of the situations unfolded felt a little unbelievable, so this story didn’t quite work for me. I did however, like that the author touched on social classes and also, the baroness is quite a lovely character.

Thank you to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for the e-ARC.

Kilpack's The Valet's Secret is a refreshingly deep regency romance that shows readers our capacity for personal growth and love are timeless.

There are a lot of regency works out there which are fun, often involving young twenty-somethings looking for their soulmates that end in the honeymoon phase--which is great within its own right. But what happens when the kids are grown and the heroine or hero find themselves in a new phase of life, as many of us do? The result is a satisfyingly mature, yet fun romance that reminds us that we are never too old to fall in love, try new things, and learn how to be brave.

I loved that the heroine didn't fall apart at the first sign of things going wrong, that she picked herself up and bravely moved on to find her way in the world again. I loved that the hero stumbled a bit along the way but learned that pleasing someone else at the expense of his own happiness just wasn't worth it. This made the characters so realistic and inspiring as a reader expecting to read another fluffy regency romance. I couldn't put this book down from the moment I finished the first chapter and was so happy with the plot and ending; that I immediately picked it up again to read through a second time!

I loved this book. It was fast paced enough to keep things interesting but not too fast either. I will definatelt recommend this.

I really liked this book! Rebecca and Kenneth are wonderful characters from different classes. Their first meeting is very fun. I loved the secret meetings and the depth of the characters. I would definitely recommend this book.

I have read other books by Josi S. Kilpack, so I was excited to read her latest book! I will admit that the beginning surprised me a little bit. The kiss was sudden and as I got to know the characters, I'm not sure it really fit with their personalities. There were a few other times in the book that the characters seemed to go against their true nature. Despite that, the story really drew me in and I couldn't put the book down.

I think my favorite thing about The Valet's Secret is that the characters are older with more life experience. Most of the historical romances I have read feature younger main characters. This was a really sweet story of two people finding a second chance at love years after losing their spouses.

Thank you to NetGalley, Shadow Mountain Publishing, and the author for a chance to read this book in exchange for my honest opinion.

Josi Kilpack is quickly becoming a must read author for me, and this title was no exception! Her stories always entertain, amuse and inspire in turn and I will always recommend her stories to anyone who is in need of a light and romantic story!

Such a lovely story! It flowed easily and kept me wanting more to see how this budding romance would commence.

A beautiful story with a strong and courageous heroine. I couldn't put this down! Beautiful writing kept me turning the pages!

This is my first time reading a "proper romance" and I was not let down. Especially since the couple in this book is not your typical couple. They are definitely more mature and both experienced love and romance before (they are both widowers). So, they now a second chance at finding love.

I did enjoy it since it is not the usual type of historical romance I read on a normal basis. The author also uses the trope "love at first sight" or "instalove" where they meet on the side of the road and share a their first kiss within that same meeting. Normally, I am not a fan of that type of stuff, but the way it was done, I found myself literally going "awww",

Both characters face challenges from their past, position in society, gender, and other issues. It is a soft and simple story that is a fairly fast read since you just can't help but for them to be happy together. They pine a lot for each other after the first meeting.

I enjoyed this book very much and it's a simple love story, but it was a very sweet one.

Thank you for Netgalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for sending me an ARC copy of this sweet love story! I highly appreciate it. This is my honest opinion of the book in exchange for a review.

The thing I loved most about this book was that the characters were my age. Middle aged. Not in the first blush of youth. It’s so rare to find books with people so like me! I really enjoyed this story and honestly could have kept going. I’d love to hear how things turned out!

*I received a review copy from the publisher in exchange for my honest opinion.*

The Valet's Secret was a slow burn romance, a Regency Cinderella.

It was refreshing that the characters were older and mature, both are widowed and have adult children. The mature MC's are definitely something that missing in many newer historical romance novels.

Neither Kenneth nor Rebecca feel they fit in their lot in life, and when they meet (a wonderful beginning) they realize that society will have other plans for them and they don't see how they can be together based on their class differences (and of course, the bit about Kenneth disguising himself as his own valet, shhhhhh, that's the secret).

I thought Kenneth read much younger than he was (mid to late-40s.) He just didn't seem as strong a character I would have expected given his past and his age.

What started out at a clipped pace, slowed to a roiling boil. While I enjoyed this book, I didn't connect with the characters or feel their chemistry, even though I stuck with them because I was rooting for their happily ever after.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced review copy of this book. The thoughts and opinions are my own and are freely given.

4-4.5 Stars! This is a super cute read! The main couple both have grown kids and are both widowed, so they’re more “mature” (older) than your usual main characters in a romance. The only criticism I have is that the ending felt abrupt and the book really could’ve used an epilogue to wrap everything up. I’d definitely recommend this book and this author. I’ve never read this author before but this definitely won’t be the last!
*I received this book at no charge & I voluntarily left this review.*

yes! I loved that this was about second chances and the couple were middle aged. Usually the majority of the regency romances involve younger characters so this was refreshing! Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.

The Valet’s Secret by Josi S. Kilpack is a historical romance novel. This book will be published on March 8, 2022.

What if the one person you thought you knew is actually someone else? Can a love build on lies and deceive be strong enough to overcome social rank differences? And when you finally know the truth, it might be a little too late because you’ve unknowingly already neck-deep in love since day one.

Rebecca Parker haven’t had it easy after her husband, David died. In desperate need for a shelter for their then young daughter, Rose, and herself, Rebecca was left with no other choice but to return to her childhood home to live with her abusive, drunkard father. Now, years later, Rose is a grown up and have a job that required moving out of the house while Rebecca is at her early forties, experiencing loneliness she never felt before.

Kenneth Winterton is expected to find the right wife to secure his newly position, the heir to his Uncle Lester, the fifth Earl of Brenston. One faithful day, on Rebecca’s way to meet Rose, Kenneth nearly ran her off the road with his horse. They shared a kiss but Kenneth introduced himself as Malcom the valet.

When I thought this was going to be another interesting take on Cinderella,
“If you agree with my intentions, I pray you will wear the dress the baroness has provided and present yourself to the ballroom at 11:00. At 11:45, the orchestra shall strike up a waltz, and I shall bow over your hand as I request the first dance of the rest of our lives.”

I was proven wrong, because there was a plot twist coming,
1. Lady Beth had locked him in his room.
2. They were going to the ball—his ball—without him. He was a grown man locked in a tower in order to prevent him from publicly declaring his intentions toward his true love.

That’s not all. There’s another one, maybe two plot twists coming. Want to know more? You just have to read the book to find out. It’s coming March 8, 2022. Don’t forget to mark your calendar!

This is a voluntary review in exchange for the e-ARC I received. I’m truly grateful to the NetGalley team and the publisher for the chance. Thank you.
#TheValetsSecret #NetGalley

Calling all fans of historical romance with older main characters - a first for me! It's a Regency Cinderella story about Rebecca and Kenneth who have a remarkable first meeting and then continue to find themselves running into each other in unexpected ways. Kenneth is the recent heir to an earl and must learn everything there is know about his new position. Rebecca is a widow who has found herself in a horrible and abusive living situation at her father's home. There's a lot going on in this tale and it kept me turning the pages as Kenneth and Rebecca's story played out. A truly different HR and yet the HEA awaited. I enjoyed it.

This story was a sort of retelling of Cinderella. It was an easy read with a simple plot. Rebecca is a sweet middle aged woman in the working class who gets a job as a maid in a baroness household. She meets a man, Kenneth, posing as a valet and they have an instant chemistry. What she doesn’t realize until later is that he’s the heir apparent to an earldom.

Both agonize over their attraction for the other knowing they are not socially matched. This goes on for the entire book. I wish there was more to the story, it lacked something. But overall, the book was a cute, quick read and good for those who want a fun little beach read. Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for this advanced reader copy.

Well-written second chance romance. You really got a feel for the characters and their motivations and values. I liked the premise and the tension and chemistry between the two main characters. An enjoyable historical romance.

When I first read the synopsis for this book, I was super excited about the hidden identity/switcheroo of Kenneth's character, but I was also a bit skeptical given the setting is in the year 1819. Maybe my experience is limited, and I will probably be stoned for saying this, but...I was worried we were going to have a Jane Austen romance novel on our hands. You know the kind, a great romance (I mean, everyone loves Mr. Darcy) that is definitely a product of the time, meaning the writing jumps, isn't always clear, and there are a bunch of words I don't know because I was born near the end of the 20th century. However, I found none of these problems with Josi S. Kilpack's novel!

What I liked about this book
1. As previously mentioned, I loved the hidden identity/switcheroo of Kenneth's character. These things never work out well, so as soon as he did this I knew I was in for a good time. I think the thing I like the most about this though was his feeling of guilt that riddled him the whole novel. He truly felt bad that he had hidden his identity and tried many, many times to make it up to Rebecca. To me, that makes him a class act.

2. Let's talk about all of the introspection in this novel. I loved how the internal dialogue and the thoughts each of them had throughout the book really were reminiscent of people with life experience (*cough**cough* old people) and there were SO MANY!!! Never did either of the characters have a thought that made me scoff or go "ugh!". They were mature characters with mature thoughts, and I am here for that!

3. Rebecca is a badass. Plain and simple. While she knows and follows the rules of society in most respects, she also isn't afraid to truly be herself, even after finding out Kenneth's true identity. So many glares, smirks, and sarcastic comments directed at the Earl had me loving Rebecca for the role model she is.

4. The writing is superb! Very easy flow, very nice character and relationship development, and my favorite, short chapters!! The banter between these two is great as far as mature couple drama can go.

5. The baroness, her backstory, and her willingness to help Kenneth and Rebecca really made her stand out as one of my favorite characters. For some reason, she definitely gave me Molly Brown from Titanic vibes (the Kathy Bates version), which is one of the highest compliments I can give. I really want to know if there is anything going on with her and the current Earl!!!

Why it didn't get 5 stars from me
1. There is nothing specific I can pinpoint that I didn't like about this book. It was a pleasant read, but my own rating system dictates I either have incredibly intense emotions about the book or there is some super wicked worldbuilding.

4 Stars!

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advanced reader’s copy.

This is a sweet story of second chances in life. Both Rebecca and Kenneth have lost spouses, had circumstances change and feel out of their element. Their chance meeting on the side of the road begins new hope to their lives.
The characters are well developed, the emotions you feel from Rebecca are real and convincing. Kenneth is a bit rash and has much to learn.
This is a sweet read, another win from Josi Kilpack!

Love at first sight.

That’s how Kenneth and Rebecca feel when they first encounter each other and then seal it with a kiss.

I am not a huge fan or believer of love at first sight, and so The Valet’s Secret was a bit of a stretch for me to really get into, but as I read I couldn’t but fall in love with Kenneth and Rebecca’s story.

At first, Rebecca believes that Kenneth is actually a valet named after Kenneth’s own valet, but that doesn’t work because he knows lying to Rebecca is wrong. But when she finds out that he isn’t who he says he is, she’s devastated because of their classes they can’t be together as they would like.

Kenneth is being trained for the earldom and his Uncle Lester is insisting that he find himself a wife but he can’t forget how he feels when he is around Rebecca. He feels energized in a way he has never been, but neither one feels that it will work out because it’s impossible. Unfortunately or fortunately, Rebecca’s daughter Rose, and her employer the Baroness have seen what they thought they had kept secret. The slip of using each other’s first names is the Baroness's first clue. Enjoyable read!

This light and clean romantic story was exactly what I needed!

I enjoyed how Rebecca Parker and Earl Winterton are drawn to each other and get to know each other. It was a warm and slow romantic build, until of course that explodes because he's been posing as his own valet. Rebecca is obviously hurt, especially as she has to continue to see him as she starts working in a higher society house where he is a frequent guest. And at the moment, the most eligible bachelor in the area.

Rebecca is practical. Her struggles with what her heart wants and what society would allow is very authentic. I love that she has an older daughter who she is very close with . It was refreshing to see a supportive mother/daughter relationship. They are very warm to each other and the daughter Rose really helped build Rebecca's character as a mother but also as a compassionate and kind character

Kenneth Winterton is being selfish because he know he shouldn't keep seeking Rebecca out but there is something about him. What I really liked about their relationship was how they each acknowledged that they were lonely and how the other filled that hole in themselves as companions, as well as romance.

The story moves pretty fast and it's an easy read to get through in one or two sittings. I think it's the perfect read when you want something heartwarming and romantic tied up with a bow.

The Valet's Secret is not your average regency romance, nor is it your average Cinderella retelling. While it wasn't directly a retelling in my opinion, there were several moments that I could see the similarities, and I particularly enjoyed this aspect to the story.

This was a fun, heartwarming read that I finished in only two sittings. It wasn't too deep, but it allowed me to lose myself in the world and get invested in the characters and the romance. I've been enjoying historical romances so much recently, and this one was no exception.

Towards the beginning of the story, I wasn't sure how I was going to feel about the valet in disguise part of the plot. I was worried it wouldn't be properly addressed how wrong of Kenneth it was to continue deceiving Rebecca, but I was pleasantly surprised with how this was handled.

I will say that I did feel the romance started a little too quickly in the beginning. Within moments of meeting each other, Rebecca and Kenneth share a kiss. It bothered me at first, but as they began to grow closer to each other, I didn't mind so much.

The two didn't have mind blowing chemistry, but their relationship was sweet and endearing, and I couldn't help but root for them, especially because their situation seemed so hopeless. I couldn't help but wish for a happy ending for the two of them, and that they would manage to defy all the odds set against them.

I thought it was particularly interesting to see protagonists in their 40s who had both been previously married and were looking for a second chance at love. It's not something I've seen often in fiction, and I thought it was refreshing.

Overall, I really enjoyed the Valet's Secret. It's a light read if you're looking for something in between heavier books. I only wish the romance had moved a little slower, but I am glad I read this one!

This book was a slow build for me. I did not bond with either of them for a time. But Rebecca really grew on me. I liked her strength and wisdom. I liked the way she approached her problems. Reading from the POV of a more mature character (rather than the teenage debutantes you usually find in this genre) was especially refreshing and presented new challenges.

This sweet Cinderella type retelling was a little frustrating for me. For a book trying to fall into the regency era and still be realistic, a few of the main plot points are not what would have happened. If this story was pulled into the future it would have been fantastic.

The way Josi Kilpack brought the Cinderella into it was fun. The dress she wore was beautiful. The evil cousin screwing up the fantastic ending added a great twist. The way the support characters step up in the end to support the main characters added to the pros list. I just had a hard time accepting the set-up of the relationship.

From the publisher: A passionate kiss from a handsome valet becomes a Regency Cinderella story when he is revealed to be an earl.

What a delight! It’s not often that a historical romance leaves me guessing as much as this one did. There are big obstacles to the romance, and I wondered how the author would work through them. But she did so in a way I found charming and satisfactory.

Kenneth has unexpectedly become the heir to an earldom. Rebecca is an educated woman but the daughter of an artist and a former servant in a great house. They meet when he nearly runs her down on a rented horse. He is in disguise as his valet so he can ride with abandon without being scolded by his uncle the earl. After an unpleasant interaction with her abusive father, Rose is out enjoying a simple walk.

Their attraction is instantaneous. Kenneth knows he is wrong to encourage Rebecca when she erroneously believes he is a servant, and yet he can’t help himself. The author does not spin out the misunderstanding for long, and when Rebecca learns the truth she is angry. One of my favorite scenes involves her pelting Kenneth with last year’s walnuts.

A romance between these two people from different classes during the Regency era is far-fetched, but the author sells it. She made it happen for her characters, and I believed it. I love that the hero and heroine are middle-aged. Both are widowed. Both have grown children. Kenneth is balding. Rebecca has fine lines around her eyes. They are mature people with self-confidence and pride. No silly waffling or posturing. I couldn’t help but root for their happily ever after.

This is a gentle read, with no swearing or sex, and the author appears to have done her research about the times. If you enjoy historical romance and think mature men and women deserve to find happiness in love as much as young people do, you might enjoy The Valet’s Secret.

I read an advance reader copy from Netgalley. The Valet’s Secret is scheduled to be published in early March 2022 and will be available for checkout from the Galesburg Public Library.

*I received a free copy of this ebook from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*

This was a cute book the had a Cinderella-ish feel to it, though not too much. I’d call it more of a tribute than a retelling. Both Rebecca (40-42 . . . I can’t recall) and Kenneth (48) were likable characters. Usually I read books about younger characters, so they felt old whenever I thought about their ages. It’s rather funny that I feel that way since I’m 38; it’s not like they’re that much older. It’s all in my head, I know. I also loved the baroness—she was one of my favorite characters. I pictured Lady Beth as Caroline Bingley from the Pride & Prejudice starring Collin Firth and Jennifer Ehle. She was rather a one-dimensional character, as was Rebecca’s father. It bothered me how much Kenneth was frequently treated like a child despite his age.

Although it isn’t one of my favorite books of the year, I enjoyed reading it enough that I will look into the author’s other work. I appreciated that it was a “proper” romance so that I didn’t have to skip sections. That’s not to say to lacked romance and passion—those elements were simply contained within looks, kisses, and mere presence.

I do feel like a little epilogue would have gone a long way. I’d have liked to see how things happened with the ending (or rather, nee beginning)

Note: Nothing wrong.

Rebecca Parker is walking along the road when she is almost run over by a speeding horse running down the road. When she confronts this man, she immediately feels a spark and an unexpected kiss happens.

Kenneth Winterton, an earl, was dressed as his valet when this incident happened and since it was unseemly to be out like that, he intended to keep this a secret, until he found himself unable to think of anyone other than Ms. Parker, who was below his station. What follows is a journey of two people of completely different stations trying to navigate their feelings and yet still live in the world they were born into.

The immediate attraction and kiss part didn't feel completely authentic to me and I felt a little bit of a disconnect throughout the story because of it. But then it ended up being cute and redeemed itself in the end- and unexpected fairy tale. And again- I always appreciate a clean romance!

Thanks to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain for an eARC in exchange for my honest review.

Can you be lovestruck at middle age? Josi Kilpack believes you can as she writes a Victorian Era Cinderella story about an Earl and a maid. Kenneth Winterton is set to become the 5th Earl of Brenston after his uncle’s son dies. He was not born for the position and is not sure of it as well, when he happens upon Rebecca Parker while out riding his horse, masked as his valet. Rebecca is a widow and assistant to her artist father, until problems at home force her back into service. Neither see great love in their future but sparks instantly ignite when thrown accidently together. Propriety and their roles in society are the stumbling block for a future marriage, but neither Kenneth nor Rebecca can seem to move on with what is expected of them.

Kilpack feels that love conquers all when faced with true love, which can hit you at any point, place, and time of your life. Outdated traditions, society and decency are no match when Cupid strikes and Kilpack gives us characters that celebrate, scheme and plot to make sure love wins!

Since I found love at 48, I can relate to getting swept off my feet at a later age. I found it to be a quick, enjoyable read. Just the right type to put good thoughts in your dreams before bed.

A beautiful tale of mistaken identity where hearts and social expectations do not have the same allowances. Wonderfully written, fantastic believable characterization, charming romance. I would recommend this to anyone.

An absolutely adorable take on the Cinderella fairy tale! The Valet’s Secret pulls you in quickly with the very different lives of Rebecca and Kenneth. Their first kiss was quick and a sweet, slow romance followed! I loved that Rebecca has such a positive attitude. She did not feel sorry for herself, nor does she depend on others to take care of her. She is independent, strong and self-reliant. Rebecca has been raised to know ‘her place’ and does not try to veer from it.

In the same way, Kenneth was not raised to be an earl, but due to the death of the earl’s son, now finds himself as the heir. He, too, understands ‘his place’ and what is expected of him. Yet, he cannot stop thinking about Rebecca, nor stop wanting to spend time with her.

These two have not been able to spend very much time together, but both know there is a connection to the other that neither can explain. With a little help from the baroness or their own ‘fairy godmother’ their dream could come true. Of course, there has to be the villain of the romance who tries to keep them apart.

Another aspect I enjoyed about Rebecca was her desire to try to have a relationship with her father. She continued to respect him even in difficult circumstances. Yes, there are times we need to step away from relationships that are hurtful. Needless to say, I loved this romantic tale and find I am really enjoying Josi Kilpack’s writing more each time I read one of her books!

This was a lovely, Maid in Manhattan/Cinderella love story with the second chance at love trope.

Rebecca, the female main character, was enjoyable to read. She’s a driven and independent (for the time period) woman. I liked how she continued to find her own way during her struggles, but she was also wasn’t too prideful to accept help.

Kenneth, the male main character, is one of my favorites I’ve ever read in this type of romance. His inner commentary on his new station, how he “should” behave now versus how he wants to behave, etc. were all so fascinating to me and really well-written! He didn’t seem like every other love interest, like cookie cutter, and I really appreciated that.

Pros: the maturity of the characters—it was something I hadn’t read before, usually everyone is so young, and I found I enjoyed it. The writing was well done, easy to follow, great imagery, great storytelling! The plot was excellent and the different ways the characters had chance meetings (the dinner, the silhouette drawing) didn’t feel forced, but organic and natural. The cheeky glass slipper comment/getting locked in a room and kept from the ball were fun little touches!

Con: it’s really not even a con, so I had to put it here, but I would have loved an epilogue!

This is a gentle historical romance featuring more mature characters who have both been married before and find a second chance at love. There is no melodrama or histrionics; instead we have two very nice and sweet people dealing with life in their middle age. In this particular instance, there is also a class distinction that is the cause of their romantic difficulties.

Story: Rebecca Parker had a happy marriage but, upon her husband's death, returned to live with her unreasonably demanding father. Unhappy but resigned, she has a chance encounter with valet Malcolm Henry one day and finds her heart fluttering again. But "Malcolm Henry" is in reality and Earl - widower Kenneth Winterton. And he will most assuredly lose his position should he remarry to a commoner.

Those looking for a "Georgette Heyer" rather than bodice ripper will enjoy this undemanding read. Yes, characters do feel simplistic and lacking nuance or depth (read: flaws). But this does harken back to old fashion romance reads when people fell in love immediately and the next step was marriage rather than sex. Reviewed from an advance reader copy provided by the publisher.

Kenneth Winterton feels out of place as the new heir to an earldom, so he decides to briefly change places with his valet and give in to his longing to ride swiftly on a horse rather than relax in a carriage. After nearly running over a lovely woman walking by the side of the road, he finds himself irresistibly attracted to her. The problem? She’s the widowed daughter of a local artist and not society’s idea of a future countess. How could there ever be a happy ending for them? Find out in this sweet, witty, and amusing retelling of the classic Cinderella story, set in Regency England.

Thank you to Shadow Publishing for the ARC to read and review,

The Valets Secret is a clean historical regency romance with older main characters, Kenneth is heir to an Earldom. Rebecca is a widow. They meet by chance due to a lovely horse. He lies about his identity. They kiss way too soon and Kenneth continues his deception. The plot was a bit stretched thin for me. DNF after about 12 chapters.

The Valet's Secret is written in a way that makes you just want to keep on reading! It's just a fun, fresh take on a regency tale. I love the way the author took two individuals and gave them both another chance at love. This book has some Cinderella vibes, while being regency. I would not only recommend this clean romance, but would also read it again!

This book was an interesting, regency, Cinderella. It took me a while to get into the story, but I believe it is one that many other readers will adore. I enjoyed the Cinderella aspects of the novel — the meddling cousin, the dress/shoes, the maid and someone of higher standing! I also enjoyed reading about main characters who had already found love in their lives and are finding love again as middle-aged adults. It brought a different dynamic to the book that I enjoyed!

I wished I had felt more chemistry between the main characters throughout the book, but I still enjoyed the overall story. If you like a clean, regency romance with a slight fairytale twist, this may be a great pick for you!

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for the complimentary copy. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Content warning: abusive father

Rebecca Parker, a widow, a maid, and a Silhouette artist’s assistant met the Earl heir apparent of Lord Brenston, who was disguised as Valet, because of an energetic and stubborn horse. And that chance encounter led them to build a budding relationship despite the Earl’s falsehood at first, then a few misunderstandings, and their social class distinction.

This is such an interesting read. I am amazed how much the Author put much thought into retelling the Cinderella Story without it being too predictable. It’s quite smart of her to portray the usual characters of the story in different ways, for example, Lady Beth is like the Stepmother in Cinderella but in the book, she’s the cousin of the Earl, a.k.a the Prince Charming.

Overall, I’m giving this book a 3.5. Although I like how it's written as a retelling of Cinderella, I wasn’t particularly fond of how both the ML and FL breach propriety so much that it sometimes became unbearable to me. I’ll recommend this book to those who like a fairy tale love story.


Got this from Netgalley, courtesy of the Shadow Mountains Publishing (Thank you!) in exchange for an honest review.

One thing that sets this regency romance apart is that the main characters are both in their 40's, with Kenneth being nigh on 50. I appreciated having a romance with older characters and having second chances at love now their first loves have passed on, but young or old, their romance isn't very compelling. Sometimes the words were there to tell me they felt attraction to each other, but there was no spark, no chemistry, that I could really detect between the two of them.

And while romances don't always have a strong plot going on otherwise, this had practically nothing to help it along, which is a real shame when the romance itself is dull and lackluster. There was a small side plot on Rebecca's side with some familial drama, but that was pretty much it. Their insta-attraction, while perhaps understandable and believable, just wasn't enough to drive their story forward.

Not one I would ever come back to, so hopefully Kilpack's next is more of a hit with me!

I received this ARC from NetGalley. I love Josi Kilpack's books and this one does not disappoint. When a hidden Earl and a widow have a chance kiss, it leads to a 2nd chance romance for both of the main characters. This book contain romance, 2nd chance love, and finding true love. A great read if you like regency romance books.

I wish it had been longer! It was far too short so the story or characters weren’t really fleshed out very well. However, I loved that the characters were over 40!

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

This is a fun romance based on a case of mistaken identity.
It’s a mixed class, second marriage, clean historical romance.
The relationship began with a surprising kiss but became a lovely friendship which was challenged when Rebecca realized Kenneth was the earl, not the valet.
It’s a beautiful romance with a somewhat surprising HEA.

Rebecca Parker is a lonely, Forty-Two-year-old, widow, and a mother. She had a daughter that she loved immensely. They lived with her father, and it was not a happy house. To get away from her father, it was an abusive relationship, she thought she would marry and settle in a loveless marriage. Her husband had been dead about eight years.

Malcolm Henry was his Valet, but he was more than a Valet. He was also a dear friend and served with him in the Navy. Kenneth Bartholomew Winterton was the heir to his uncle. His cousin had died, and the title would come to him. Malcolm and Kenneth would trade clothes and shoes. He would slip out of the carriage and get on a rented horse so he could ride. His uncle did not allow it except to use it for limited use convenience. He was running the horse and almost ran over her. She had to jump into some bushes. It was such a lovely story. They got to know each other. They met in town about once a week.

They were older but still had to fight, including themselves. Round and round they went. They felt they could not ignore the difference. The biggest problem for them was a different status. He is an Earl and she worked as a maid. I loved this gentle and loving story.

I received this ARC from Net Galley and voluntarily reviewed it
(less)

flag comment · see review

Josi S. Kilpack has written another great regency romance!

The Valet's Secret centers around Rebecca Parker and Kenneth Winterton. After Kenneth nearly runs Rebecca over, the pair share a kiss. However, when Kenneth introduces himself, he uses his valet's name: Malcolm Henry. But when he's true identity is revealed, will Rebecca forgive the lie? Or will the fairytale romance have a not so happy ending?

I really enjoyed this! The Valet's Secret has some Cinderella elements, which was pretty cool to see! I also liked the two leads. It's interesting to note that the two leads are older, with Kenneth being 48 and Rebecca being in her early/mid 40s. Also, even though there's some insta-love, the author makes it make sense. Also there's some interesting dialogue concerning age gap relationships, especially with Kenneth and how he does not like 19 year-olds trying to flirt with him, which is kind of refreshing in this genre.

All in all, I really liked reading this regency fairytale. It was a sweet tale of two people discovering their own fairytale, when at least one of them believes that they have outgrown fairytales.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for the eARC! I really appreciate the opportunity to read this.

TW/CW: domestic abuse

Oh, this book was such a delightful read! It has Cinderella vibes going on, but not so much that it overtakes the story. In all honesty, when I began reading it, I forgot that the description mentioned it being a "Regency Cinderella Story" and didn't much notice the similarities until the book was almost completed.

The book was charming, sweet, and heartwarming. The biggest surprise to me was that the main characters weren't your typical 20-30-year-olds. Rebecca was 42 and Kenneth was 47 (or 48? it was mentioned once at the beginning of the book.) with grown children. It was refreshing to see characters who are mature.

Both Rebecca and Kenneth are dealing with their new seasons of life; both having lost their spouses several years prior. Kenneth having to step into his unexpected inheritance as an earl and Rebecca having to deal with working and living with her abusive father.

This was the first book that I've read by Jose Kilpack, but I will definitely be reading more from her!

Note: I received an early copy through #netgalley for my honest review. All opinions are my own.

I literally read this in less than 12 hours. I could not put it down! I truly enjoyed the whole storyline! Josi just know how to write such amazing descriptions and her plots are out of this world! I am surprised everytime! The swooniness was awesome and I loved the characters! Kenneth and Rebecca were such well fleshed out characters!! I will read this one again!

I loved this charming Regency romance featuring a quest for second chance love between a wonderful hero and heroine in their 40s. The attraction is instant, but deceit and class distinction throw a wrench into the relationship! Encased in a fairy tale atmosphere reminiscent of Cinderella, the unique plot twists and turns with some surprises as it flows smoothly toward a satisfying ending. The characters, primary and secondary, are engaging and realistic. If you are looking for a light and entertaining Regency read, this one is sure to delight.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

A sweet, love-at-first-sight story of two people who thought perhaps love was a thing of the past for them…until, one day it wasn’t. Kenneth finds himself poised to inherit an earldom he never anticipated would be his. Rebecca is a widow trapped in a mundane existence, working for her living with her increasingly abusive father. When Kenneth and Rebecca chance upon one another, the connection is instant, heated, and unforgettable. And unfortunately, it’s also a case of mistaken identity for Kenneth meets Rebecca while posing as his valet in order to escape the pressures of his new life. But the heart wants what it wants, and Kenneth cannot forget her. Nor can he allow her to know who is really is! Continuing the ruse of being the valet to the future earl in order to continue to see the woman who makes him feel alive - well, it seems his only choice. But it can only end in disaster and broken hearts if (and when) she discovers his true identity!

This story was a heartwarming, Cinderella-like tale of second chances and fairy tale love. I found it refreshing to read a love story about two people who are more mature, both in age and in life experiences. Despite dire circumstances and insurmountable odds, the build-up and conclusion didn’t bear the same angst or heartbreak as other books of this genre often do. This is a chaste, closed-door Regency romance. Thank you to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Kenneth and Rebecca's love story is about two people who are divided by class who through by chance met and shared a passionate kiss Then the rest was history.

Kenneth wasn't totally forthcoming to who he was to Rebecca when they first met. He told her that he was valet but he is actually an heir to an estate. He kept up the ruse for a bit but was eventually found out and Rebecca struggles with the idea that such a match can happen due to their stations in life. There wasn't a lot of outside forces preventing them from being together. Rebecca was having the conflict of feeling on the inside that with her station in life that such a thing cannot happen. More of an internal struggle than anything.

You do see the abusive relationship between Rebecca and her father. She had to move in with her father again due to losing her husband. Upon living there, she did a lot of the artistic work that her father was supposed to be responsible for. Then eventually lead to him being too verbally and physically abusive towards her.

You also see the pressure that is on Kenneth to marry to have a new countess at the estate. Even though there were many eligible women in his area, he only had eyes for Rebecca. You can see his conflict of knowing he is above his station to be around her, but he cannot deny his attraction.

What I like about this story is that Kenneth and Rebecca were in their 40's. They have married and lost their spouses. They also have kids and they were naturally feeling lonely. It felt more of a mature read in this story. The ending kind of reminded me of a retelling of Cinderella which was sweet.

The only thing I wasn't too thrilled was the pace of the story, it did drag in the middle, but it picked up at the end. It is beautiful and I enjoyed this read very much.

I really struggled to get into this book. I felt as thought the beginning was a bit slow setting up the story and I wanted to be more drawn to the characters than I was. I am not a huge fan of romance between older characters and was surprised to realize that these characters were past the age of a usual courtship and romance. I felt as though the story would have been better fitted to a younger couple with the plot point featuring a mistaken identity. It just seemed a little out of character for an older man with responsibility to pretend to be a servant just to go riding. It wasn’t my favorite from this author.

#TheValet'sSecret #NetGalley

A retelling of Cinderella, with a twist. Both of the main characters are widowed and in their forties. Rebecca Parker, has been living under her father's roof, even though, she is in her forties, her father treats her like a child.
Kenneth Winterton, is in line for the earl, but just wants to be his own person. The current earl, is determined, to find Kenneth a wife. A brief encounter has made its mark on Kenneth, and he isn't willing to give into his uncle's schemes. I really enjoyed reading this, retelling of Cinderella.

I think The Valet's Secret really maximizes the tensions created by Regency era society and the class structures that ruled at the time. Both Rebecca Parker and Kenneth Winterton wish to escape their current lives in some way. After meeting under false pretenses, they find themselves falling for each other, despite his pending Earldom and her decidedly common existence. Is there any hope? Could the protagonists every be together?

I was excited to read about two main characters past the age of 40s, both widowers. That being said, I was a little disappointed with the lack of maturity in both characters, given their life experiences. Their internal struggles seemed naive and both offered little resistance to the ways they both were subjugated to others. The ending sort of came out of left field, and was motivated more by the observant Countess on the sidelines than either of the of the protagonists.. That combined with with the personality transplant that Kenneth's uncle receives made the ending much less satisfying than the build up.

This is a beautiful love story of mistakes and forgiveness, growth and strength. It was kind of fun to have a story about a middle aged couple. It reminds us that live isn't just for the young. We all deserve to find our match.

I was very excited to recievd an arc from netgalley for this book. I love the author and this book did not disappoint. A wonderful story about finding love that is right for you not for who people want you to be. The characters were well rounded, and relateable. I felt a connection with them as I learned about their lives.

Summary: Rebecca is a struggling widow living back home with her father and with one loveless marriage proposal on the way until a valet on a rogue horse nearly tramples her. The horse and the valet both leave her breathless especially after that scandalous kiss, a kiss she cannot stop thinking about and neither can her mysterious Valet, Malcolm Henry. However, Malcolm is not all that he seems the Malcolm that nearly ran Rebecca over is actually Kenneth a soon-to-be Earl whose every relation is trying to find a suitable wife for him. To Kenneth none of the respectable women compare to Rebecca however their destiny for a star-crossed romance may not even be an option once she realizes that their relationship all started with a lie.

Thoughts: This was very cute Kenneth and Rebecca were very cute together and I love that the grand gesture was a giant bust but still worked out in the end. The Baroness was my favorite character and I now need a book about her romance with the Baron. I was pleasantly surprised by how precious she was and how acceptiong of the romance between Kenneth and Rebecca. The daughter, Rose kind of annoyed me I understand why she behaved as she did but her Rebecca is her mother and she is allowed to have a life and secrets outside of Rose wether she agrees with them or not. I do wish we actually got to meet Kenneth’s sons and saw more of Malcom because the little we saw of him wasnt enough. I do love historical romacances and i appreciated that this one had very limited drama and the class issue was quickly overcome without theatrics. However, my favorite part of the book did have a bit of drama involving Kenneth Rebecca and some walnuts and I heartily approve of Rebecca’s use of them he definately deserved it. I like how they addressed the class in issue and quickly got rid of any issues for possible miscommunication overall this is a super cute fun little historical romance that I will be indulging in again.

This is a nice, mistaken identity christian romance. This type of story isn’t my usual genre, but I enjoyed it. The Christian references exist in one bit of monologue by the heroine. There is kissing between the H and h, four in total, I think.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Looking for an easy-read romance happening in the 19th century? Then this is definitely something for you!

The book is well written and moves at a comfortable pace. It has a perfect vocabulary, neither repetitive nor difficult. The characters are quite sweet and interesting, and the relationships and history between them is what drives the book forward.

The plot is quite typical for a historical fiction, but it is still a pleasure to read and a book I'll recommend to anyone interested in the Bridgerton-series. It is not a steamy romance, but a sweet and more grounding kind of love. A pleasure for anyone, but especially fans of historical fiction.

Cinderella story meets the regency era! I liked this book. It was a fast read and the plot moved along quickly, but it was way more modern fairytale than regency story and readers should keep that in mind.

The plot moved fast and I almost wish the stakes were higher for the characters overall. The baroness is simply the best character in the story and held the plot together.

Rebecca and Kenneth meet on a whim and share a kiss. Except Rebecca thinks that Kenneth is actually a valet, Malcolm Henry. There is insta-love as this middle age widow with an abusive father and a middle age man who was thrown into being the heir to an earldom try to figure out their relationship.

Insta-love isn’t always my thing and I think it’s one of the things that made me iffy about liking this book. Their first meeting seems so rushed and unrealistic that they would instantly be all the other could think about. I also feel like the characters were lacking some depth, they’re both sweet and figuring out how to live within their social station but I sometimes wanted more. This was a well written book that is sweet and clean but I think I just wanted a little more realistic excitement and character development.

What a great idea for a book! I always love it when the hero or herorine are hiding a secret or pretending to be someone else. Well done!

"The Valet's Secret" by Josi S. Kilpack
Sincere + Sweet + Fate + Kiss = Good Story
I loved this story.. not to long, not to short, sweet and clean romance at its best, and a goodly amount of angst to keep you on the edge of your seat, so to speak. I am so glad I chose this story to read. For me I wish Kenneth & Rebecca would send me one of those "newsy" Christmas newsletters that folks send telling about what has happened in their wee corner of the world over the past year. And maybe include what's happened to the rest of the cast of characters. Truly a fun, at moments tear-jerking story that is well worth the read. Happy Reading ! !
NOTE: I received an ARC of this story from the publisher
This review expresses my honest opinion of this story.

A passionate kiss from a handsome valet becomes a Regency Cinderella story when he is revealed to be an earl.
York, England, 1819.
As a once happily married woman, Rebecca Parker lived a charmed life, but now widowed and working for a living, she feels alone and living a mundane existence. That is until the day a valet speeding by on a horse nearly runs her off the road. Mr. Malcolm Henry is apologetic, gentle, and very handsome. She’s instantly drawn to him, which is why, rather than stopping him from kissing her, she finds herself kissing him back, reigniting a nearly forgotten passion in her. But love at first sight only happens in fairy tales—never to an ordinary woman like her.
Still, she cannot stop thinking about Mr. Henry and the kiss they shared. The more time she spends with the earl’s valet, the more she knows she cannot in good conscience allow Mr. Timoltson to continue to court her, even though a marriage to him would provide her financial security and independence from her overbearing father’s control. The heart wants what it wants, and her heart wants Mr. Henry.
But while working in the kitchens during a fancy dinner party, she sees something strange: the valet—the valet she kissed—is sitting at the right hand of the baroness. She realizes that Mr. Henry is not the earl’s valet; he is the earl—Kenneth Winterton.
This story is like a fairytale. Maid becomes a likely countess.
Rebecca and the would be earl make a great couple.
This is a new to me author.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and NetGalley. This in no way affects my opinion of this book which I read and reviewed voluntarily.

I don’t usually enjoy the second-chance trope, particularly when one or the other was previously married. But I guess it shouldn’t surprise me that Josi Kilpack’s excellent writing can pull me in despite everything. The hero and heroine in this both had previous marriages. There is also some mistaken identity, another not very favorite trope of mine, especially when it drags on and on. Thankfully, the valet’s secret doesn’t last too long, and we’re able to move on quickly.

I thought this was a superb mature romance. There is definitely an instant connection between the main characters, but I got a sense of them taking the time to get to know each other. It all felt plausible and realistic to me until the end, which felt a little fantastical and unreal compared to the rest of the book. But it’s Cinderella! So you just suspend disbelief and go with it. A fun historic retelling that focuses on finding love again and overcoming the disparity between societal classes.

This was short and sweet - a lovely fairy tale of a Proper Romance. I loved that the characters are mature (both in their 40s), so it’s in essence a second chance love story, in that they’re both widowed and experiencing love for a second time. A little class conflict tossed in for good measure, and mwah! Chef’s kiss!

I received a copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

I was pleasantly surprised that this story is about Kenneth Bartholomew Winterton, a widowed 48 year old heir to an earldom and Mrs. Rebecca Parker, a 42 year old widowed maid. You usually don’t find regency books about older men AND women. Usually it’s a younger woman with an older (by older I mean 35 year old) man.

The story follows Winterton learning the ropes of becoming an Earl, from his uncle. Getting out of the Royal Navy when his cousin Edward, the heir to the Earldom of Brenston passed away and giving up his rather leisure lifestyle of a widowed bachelor, did not sit well with Winterton. So whenever he had the chance he swapped clothes with his valet, a good friend from his Navy days Malcom, and went for a horse ride.

When Winterton and Rebecca cross paths, it’s not romantic or slow. His temperamental horse almost runs into her, so she jumps off the road into the bushes.

When Winterton helps her with a cut on her face, while she rests her ankle, sparks fly and he can’t stop looking at her.

I think this was a beautiful story about a second chance at love, that doesn’t regard boundaries.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

So, this is one of my favorite Josi Kilpack books. I loved that it was totally different from the norm of mainstream regency. I loved the interwoven Cinderella vibes I got. The meet cute got things started right away. Like, right away! I liked the mystery and intrigue with the mistaken identity trope and enjoyed reading that these characters were older. If you’re looking for something new, I recommend this one!

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the copy. All thoughts in this review are my own.

I found this to be quite an unbelievable Cinderella story. The hero is rather a cad as he hides his identity from the heroine by pretending to be his own valet. They are quite attracted to each other, but she comes from a working class family and has worked in the past as a maid. He is heir to an earldom. She is quite aware that there is no hope for them other than a dishonorable affair which would only harm her. Then we’re asked to totally suspend disbelief in how this all gets happily resolved.

I voluntarily reviewed an advanced reader copy of this book that I received from Netgalley; however, the opinions are my own and I did not receive any compensation for my review.

The Valet’s Secret is a sweet Proper Romance with a fun twist on the Cinderella fairytale. It’s a quick read for those days when you’re looking for something ridiculously frothy and light. My one complaint is that the main characters lack the maturity and confidence you would expect from people in their 40’s, particularly for the historical era the story is set in.

Thank you NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for a digital copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
#TheValetsSecret #NetGalley

Love can be a hard thing to find. Rebecca and Kenneth both found it in their youth and did not believe that it could be found a second time.

This is a sweet story of two mature adults who find the zing of attraction and fight to hold on to it even though it seems impossible.

I really loved the fact that the couple in this romance are in their forties. They both have children from previous marriages and realize the gift it is to love again. The problem they face is that their relationship would be frowned on by society. He comes from a noble family and she is from humble circumstances. Despite the impossibility of a relationship, neither can deny the attraction and feelings that develop between the two of them.

Rebecca and Kenneth's story is a feel-good story. Love can and will find a way. I loved the characters, the plot, and the setting.

If you want to find a good book that leaves you feeling good and full of hope, this is one that fits the bill.


Source: I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.

Call me corny, but I love a good Cinderella story. The Valet's Secret is a sweet take on the classic tale, full of tenderness and humor, as well as a few nods to previous iterations. And it's a mature romance! The hero is in his late 50s and the heroine is, I believe, somewhere in her 40s, and it was lovely to watch two nice people from different worlds navigate their blossoming relationship. The conflict with her abusive father felt unncessarily melodramatic, and I can think of more interesting ways for that relationship to have played out. Likewise, there was opportunity for more depth with the male lead's female relatives that could have been a great twist on the old story. But these are relatively minor quibbles, made up for by the other wonderful supporting characters (I'm looking at you Rose, Baroness, and Malcom). And the main focus really is on the love story, which I happily rooted for and will recommend to anyone who wants a tender love story about good people.

My thanks to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for providing an eARC in exchange for an honest review.

🌟🌟𝑩𝑶𝑶𝑲 𝑹𝑬𝑽𝑰𝑬𝑾🌟🌟

𝑺𝒀𝑵𝑶𝑷𝑺𝑰𝑺

Kenneth is suddenly need to become an heir to his household after the supposed to be 'heir' died unexpectedly. However, one day he met a commoner woman and fell in love with her at the first sight while he pretending to be a valet. So, he lied to her purposely in order to meet her again.

𝑪𝑯𝑨𝑹𝑨𝑪𝑻𝑬𝑹𝑺

KENNETH- He is a single dad and a very swoon worthy guy. I absolutely adore his personality.😍 Very gentleman!! 🤧. He was single since her wife died and need to become an heir because of his cousin die. His life changed 360 degree from someone who lives a normal life and become someone who everyone looks up to, an EARL. Besides, the way he trid to win Rebecca back when she knows his real identity is adorable. I respect him when he keep pursuing Rebecca eventhough he know he can't get get married to a Maid, but he's ready to sacrifice everything just for her. AHHH😍😍

REBECCA- A single mom who lives with her abusive father. She is a strong willed girl and I love how tough she is eventhough she is in low status. I love how she knows her worth and keep striving to improve herself.

𝑷𝑳𝑶𝑻

I rarely read historical romance and I don't expect to love it. The plot is kinda cliche but really addicting. It keeps getting better and better. The short chapter make it easier and allow you to as fast as you could. One thing for sure. The amount that I tried to speak and act like a british overwhelm me. 😂 😂. I even re-enact it. So good 😂😂.

I have only a few problem with the plot which throughout the ending. I think it can be much more dramatic than it is to bring out the tension. It a waste there is no scene of Kenneth's sons though. Rebecca's daughter have a scene in the book and it gave a glimpse of their relationship. Besides, I want to have more scene of Rebecca and Kenneth. Honestly, their relationship develop quite fast and I think the author really want to rushed out to end this book that makes the plot seemed like a normal romance.

𝑶𝑽𝑬𝑹𝑨𝑳𝑳

I adore it so much. I will recommend it for someone who wants to try a light historical romance. The characters, the plot is all good. 😍. It feels like you are watching a historical romance series. The drama, the tension and the plots makes you craving for me. And its rare to find a love stories for middle age man and middle age woman. So, the book is very unique and interesting on its way. 💕💕

𝑻𝑹𝑶𝑷𝑬𝑺

-HISTORICAL ROMANCE
- MIDDLE AGE COUPLE LOVE STORY
-FORBIDDEN LOVE
-LOVE AT THE FIRST SIGHT
-DUAL POV

Thank you netgalley, the author and the publisher that give this amazing e-arc

York, England, 1819

A kiss on the road between strangers ignites passion they both had forgotten. Hope for more than a loveless marriage makes Rebecca look to the future. However, the man she kissed has a secret that may destroy her hope for a second chance at true love.

After I finished reading this one, I had to take some time to think about it. I wanted to love this one. I was intrigued when I saw that our two protagonists were of a mature age, and I do love a second chance romance. I was not expecting for them to be so far apart socially. This made for a drama I did not enjoy and an ending I didn’t find believable.

That’s not to say they were uninteresting. I was sympathetic to Rebecca and her struggles. While I enjoyed Kenneth’s storyline, I kept forgetting that he was a man in his fifties. Beyond a few complaints of feeling old, he did not behave like a father of two young men. I would have believed him to be a young man himself with how easily he bowed to his uncle’s wishes.

The insta-love meeting, with them kissing even though they were strangers, made me cringe. I might be wrong, but I only counted them meeting ten times in the entirety of the novel. This did not make me believe their love was one that could endure the criticism of society.

As with all of this author’s works, it is well written. I could easily envision the scenes in my mind. However, it was not an instant favorite.

Readers who do enjoy fast-paced romances with mistaken identities may enjoy this.

I enjoyed this book. It was a fun and cute historical romance! I enjoyed the characters and seeing them grow and fall in love.

1819 and the novel starts out in rather unusual circumstances. A woman out for a walk, the heir to the manor also
out on an uncontrollable horse. They meet, he rather knocks her down and then kisses her. Quite unusual for 1819.
Completely out of the ordinary.

He is taken to be the valet to the above heir, she is just a maid, separated from her husband to boot and in poor
circumstances. Not the most opportune background for a romance. But unlikely though it is, it does happen. It was a
light hearted romance with a background of arrogance amongst the aristocracy, definite class barriers, an abusive
marital relationship and love conquers all.

Nice.

4.5* Josi Kilpack has created a story with a perspective that is dealt with less often in the romance genre.  I felt that I understood the main characters' points of view, even though I do not have personal experience with their life situations.  The emotions and reactions felt authentic, the Cinderella-inspired changing of station challenges were thoroughly explored, and the range of interpersonal conflicts rounded the story out. 

I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed are completely my own.

3.5 stars, rounded up. The rounding is due to the end, which was a fun switch on a classic trope.

Generally, I thought this was a solid, sweet romance. It is closed door, which is typically not my preference, but I found this charming overall, with some small niggles here and there.

The hero Kenneth has lived a modest gentleman’s life, when he is elevated in position to heir to an earldom. He is a widower and has two nearly grown sons away as school, and he has come to live in his uncle’s home to learn how to be the earl. The heroine, Rebecca, is a widow, who now lives with her father again, helping with (doing most of) his cameo work. He is a verbally abusive father, which is an important part of the plot. She has grown daughter, who works as a companion.

The h&h meet by chance, when Kenneth nearly tramples Rebecca with a wild horse he has borrowed, while in disguise as his valet. Their first interaction was notable and they saw a kinship in each other, two lonely souls recognizing each other. I particularly liked their first kiss.

While there was quite a bit I like about this story, the pacing was pretty slow, and the h&h have trouble finding time for each other. I also thought the hero was too indecisive for much of the story — I like more initiative typically in a hero. And, while there was some character development, there were areas that were unexplored — like the relationship between the hero and his sons. Possibly there were just too many characters to fully explore some of this relationships.

Overall, I would recommend if looking for a traditional-style historical romance. It was a lovely read despite some hiccups.

<I>Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a chance to read and review this book. Views are my own.

Hidden identity! Oh, I could feel the heroine's shock and confusion when his identity is revealed! I enjoyed seeing how they would work this out! A wonderful story!

I received an advance reader copy. This review is my honest opinion and voluntarily given.

The Valet’s Secret is a sweet Cinderella style Regency tale that left me smiling and filled with gratitude. One of the things I really enjoyed is that both Rebecca and Kenneth are middle-aged and know a thing or two about life and their heart’s desires. I love that they are both loyal to their family and expectations placed upon them. I also really enjoyed that there are people who love and care about each of them and champion for their love story to succeed. I love how they met and how they both realize there is more than life than just getting by; there are second chances available, even if they come at a cost. The storyline blends together perfectly and despite the deception early on, there is room for redemption and happiness again. An all-out swoony tale that captured my heart and made me root for second chances. I highly recommend this fantastic, sweet regency story.

I received a complimentary copy from the publisher via NetGalley and all opinions expressed are solely my own, freely given.

The Valet’s Secret by Josi S. Kilpack, 288 pages. Shadow Mountain Publishing, 2022. $16.
Language: G (0 swears, 0 “f”); Mature Content: PG; Violence: PG
BUYING ADVISORY: HS - OPTIONAL
AUDIENCE APPEAL: LOW
Kenneth is pretending to be his valet when he meets -- and kisses -- Rebecca. Despite the best of intentions, Kenneth’s deception hurts Rebecca when she discovers the truth because she is a maid and he is heir to an earldom, a combination that is socially unacceptable. With every reason to say no, why do they want to say yes?
Kilpack quickly informs readers that her main characters are in their forties (48- and 42-years-old, respectively), and I nearly put down the book in my surprise, unsure that I could relate to such characters. Despite the age difference, I found myself understanding their conflicts between what they wanted and they were told they should do. I became invested in their lives and wanted to see things turn out well, and I enjoyed the details reminiscent of Cinderella stories.
Reviewer: Carolina Herdegen

Thank you very much Netgalley and the publisher for an advanced copy in exchange of an honest review.

This was the first book I have read by the author but it will not be the last. I enjoyed it very much from the beginning to the end.

The first thing I want to point out about the book is the plot. It is set in the regency era and I loved that. The author manages to create a perfect atmosphere in which you are immersed from the first moment and that traps you. I also really liked the fact that the characters are adults (both over forty) because that makes it much more interesting. Besides, the characters act according to their age and that is to be appreciated.

Regarding the main characters, I have to say that I loved them. Both Rebecca and Kenneth. Despite being an instalove I really liked how their relationship develops. Fighting against conventions is not easy but here the protagonists manage to do it and fight for what they both want.

Special mention to the Baroness, Malcolm and Rose, as they are the ones who play such an important role at the end of the book. I didn't expect it and I loved it.

The only thing I didn't like was the abrupt ending. I would have liked the book to have continued a little longer, but that's a completely personal opinion.

A book that I didn't expect to surprise me so much and that I enjoyed a lot. Highly recommended.

A story of hidden identity set in Regency, York, England. Kenneth is heir to his Uncle's Earldom. His Uncle is pressuring him to marry a local woman as it is important for him to belong in the neighborhood. As a way of escaping all the pressure he wears his valet's close to go horse riding through the country. He almost runs over Rebecca in the lane. She likes him and they are able to steal away and meet several times. When she finds out who he really is she is upset. There love can never be real because of their different stations in life. Can Kenneth convince Rebecca, his Uncle, an the neighbors that it is a good match.

I know the author from reading her culinary mystery series and happily read her latest Regency Romance. It's a bonus to support an author who lives and writes in my own home state. Rebecca Parker is a widow who lives with and helps her artistic father create silhouette portraits. She has worked in service before marriage and raised her daughter with enough education to be a companion to a local baroness. While walking she is literally run off the rode by a stranger on horseback. He claims to be the valet to the heir to the earldom. They share a spark and a kiss that neither can forget.

Kenneth Winterton is the unexpected heir apparent after the death of his cousin. He is a widower with two sons in school and has comes to train at his uncles side for his future inheritance. His uncle insists that one of the first things he must do is to marry, preferably someone local, that will help him establish his place in the community. Of course while all the wealthy ladies are being presented to him his mind is elsewhere.

This is a light play on a Cinderella story. I love that it isn't about young love but a couple in their 40s who are lonely and have a lot of live still to live. There is emphasis on station, duty and place that are obstacles to love. I love Rebecca's relationship with her daughter Rose. And the Baroness, who gets the role of fairy godmother, is a delight. Somethings are harsher than I expected and a few things a little contrived but I enjoyed the story and am happy with their HEA.

For people who enjoy well written, clean, historical romances. Thank you to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.

Give me every regency Proper Romance. This was absolutely lovely. The characters, the story, I laughed out loud and some points. I highly recommend if you love regency romances. This one will tug at you in the best way.

I didn't know what to expect from a story about an older couple who both had had previous marriages, but this story is such a happy feel good read! You should read this story because it does deal with an older couple which is more unique in this genre. It is delightful!

I loved this book by Josi Kilpack! I loved that the characters were older then in the typical Regency novel. I also loved how well written the story was because it kept me engaged the whole time. I also loved how the story unfolded and how I came to adore the characters and how I was cheering for them the whole time. This book was very well done and one I will read again.

I received a complimentary book from publishers, publicists, and or authors. A review was not required and all opinions and ideas expressed are my own.

This was an enjoyable romance, unique in the fact that the main characters were in their forties, which definitely gave them some depth. I really liked Rebecca's character--I loved her practicality and how she pressed forward with life (and her walnut-throwing skills). I was wary of the mistaken identity plot, but it was over quickly, rather than dragging on and on, which I appreciated. I also really liked the Cinderella twist. I would have liked an epilogue to see just a little bit more of Rebecca and Kenneth, but all in all, this was a nice clean romance.

I read an ARC provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

I very rarely read books where the main characters are around my age - most of the Regency books I read revolve around people who are in their early 20's - so I kept getting surprised when I'd read something in this story about Rebecca and Kenneth having grown children and other "old people" things. (I can call them old, since I'm in that boat too, right?) Anyway, not gonna lie, it was a little weird. Not a bad weird, just different from what I'm used to.
Other than the age thing (and the kissing a complete stranger. THAT was weird.) I really enjoyed this story. My attention span seems to be shorter and shorter these days, so it's not that often where I find a book I'm happy to read for hours on end. This was one of them. The characters were engaging, and I was rooting for both of them, although I wasn't sure how it was going to work out in the end. Having read so many of these types of romance books, I love to be happily surprised every now and then.
My keeper bookshelf is getting a little tight, but I'm very happy to squeeze this one in there. (And perhaps find room in my house for another bookshelf?)

I had not read the description or the reviews before requesting and reading this arc...

Was a bit reluctant when I saw that the male MC was 48 years old...  within the first few pages we get to know he is nearly bald (oh no i don't have any problems with bald MCs just that I thought it might be about a middle aged person but still in his prime with all hair and hot body etc. So this changed my mental picture - that's all)..

I definitely did not want the other MC to be  muchhhh younger than him (again i don't mind age gap romances just that my current mood isn't preferring it). She's also in her forties - so that eased my mind.

Am glad that I did not stop reading and super happy that I picked this up..

A different storyline written differently. It had all the required aspects fun, drama, love, secrets and twists. A well paced and interesting story.

Overall, an enjoyable read.

A second chance historical romance that felt like a Hallmark movie, which are great to enjoy every now and then to pass the time. Just don't go in expecting characters with depth and flaws or award winning plot twists. This is a palate cleanser. A wholesome, quick, and easy read that I finished in one sitting. The author's writing was great, albeit predictable, and I'd suggest it as beach read. A book you don't need to throw all your attention in to follow along with. The romance is mild and something I would expect my mom would enjoy.

**Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me an advanced copy of this book and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion. I am posting this review to my Goodreads account immediately and will post it to my Amazon & Instagram accounts upon publication.

Thank you so much to NG and the publishers for sending me an ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review!

I really enjoyed how the main characters were mature in age! They were very well developed and I really enjoyed reading about them, Their circumstances couldn't be more different but ultimately bring them together in their loneliness!

If there is any one reason to read this book (and there are certainly more reasons than that!), it would be due to the fact that the characters are both in their forties. Historical romance tends towards younger characters, ostensibly in the name of accuracy, but love doesn't have an expiration date and in Romancelandia, no one needs to be on the shelf unless they decide to be there. (I'd argue this is true for contemporary romance as well, but that's a different discussion.) Josi S. Kilpack's charming story explores love coming to its protagonists later in life with the same attention to detail and warm heart that I've seen in her other works, and if you're looking for a nice, clean Regency, this is worth your reading time.

Title: The Valet's Secret
Author: Josi S. Kilpack
Genre: Romance
Rating: 4.0 out of 5

York, England, 1819

As a once happily married woman, Rebecca Parker had a good life, but now widowed, working for a living, and her only child grown, she feels invisible, tired, and lonely. That is until the day a valet speeding by on a horse nearly runs her off the road. Mr. Malcolm Henry is apologetic, gentle, and handsome. She’s instantly drawn to him, which is why, rather than stopping him from kissing her, she kisses him back, reigniting a nearly forgotten passion. But love at first sight only happens in fairy tales—never to an ordinary woman like her.

She sees Mr. Henry again and feels the possibilities growing until, while working in the kitchens during a dinner party, she sees the valet she kissed sitting at the right hand of the baroness. Mr. Henry is not the earl’s valet; he is the heir to the earldom—Kenneth Winterton.

Heartbroken, angry, and betrayed, Rebecca does not trust Lord Winterton and refuses to accept his apology. But when Lord Winterton proves he is as kind and gentle as “Mr. Henry” was, she finds herself willing to give him a second chance. But will he take a chance on her? He needs a wife to help him in his place in society, and nothing about Rebeccas life does that . . . except how he feels when she is with him.

This was a solid read. There are a lot of class dynamics at play here, and somehow I find it difficult to believe that an earl and a maid ending up together would be even an option in this society…but I wasn’t there. Rebecca becomes much surer of herself when dealing with her father—thankfully—in part because of her friendship with Kenneth. He is also conflicted about his new role in society, and he’s not sure he likes it, but Rebecca’s support helps him take a stand for what he wants and believes, instead of just going along with the wishes of everyone around him.

Josi S. Kilpack is an award-winning author. The Valet’s Secret is her newest novel.

(Galley courtesy of Shadow Mountain Publishing in exchange for an honest review.)

(blog link live 3/12.)

I loved that the h/h were mature adults - in their forties with grown children. It made for a nice change. The story moved along quickly and all the characters were very likeable and you could tell they were trying to be good people. Nice twist on a sweet "Cinderella" story!

I was invited by the publisher at netgalley.com to read and review this book. I am thrilled for that opportunity. Let me preface my review with the fact that this was my second book that I reviewed by Josi S. Kilpack, the first being Lavender and Lace. I am officially hooked on this author and have read over 6 of her books in the last month! I can’t get enough of them!

Turning to our story, The Valet’s Secret, what I liked most was that the main characters were individuals who were a bit older and had previously been married, now both widowed. Kenneth comes into different circumstances and he leaves his old life behind to fulfill a family obligation to become the next Earl. Rebecca continues to try to find her way dealing with living and helping her father, an artist, but proud of the accomplishments of her own daughter. These characters become like your own friends and as the plot gradually continues, you become invested in the lives of both Kenneth and Rebecca. Will they find love? Will they be discovered? Will Rebecca’s father make amends? The ending is wonderful and I found myself cooking dinner with my ipad propped up so I could read and cook at the same time! I could not put this book down.

Anything that Josi S. Kilpack writes will be a sure winner and The Valet’s Secret did not disappoint! I have to hurry back to my current read, The Vicar’s Daughter!

I have to agree with other reviewers that I wish there was an epilogue. I really enjoyed Kenneth and Rebecca's story, but I wish there had been a little more to the ending. I won't say what so I don't spoil anything. Kenneth and Rebecca have quite the meet cute. Wow! They are so good and sweet together, yet it seems impossible to make it work. I really enjoyed getting to know each of these characters and their struggles, as well as their strengths. I loved the Baroness as a secondary character. This was a fun story that was hard to put down.

I received a complimentary copy from the publisher through Netgalley and this is my honest review.

Romance, period, sweet
Lovely sweet romance with discussion of character and class and what really matters in life. Rebecca and Kenneth's chance meeting and subsequent moments is sweetly drawn. Their separation by class, chance encounters, secrets revealed, and building hope for their romance as they worked through the things that seemed insurmountable, was a perfect portrait of a more mature couple that were drawn to each other across class lines.
Loved the role of the secondary characters, and while this primarily focused on Rebecca and Kenneth, they helped portray both of their characters, developed the plot well, and gave the flavor and color to this novel that helped it stick in my mind and heart.
Lovely Cinderella retelling with a flip of some of the story elements that made for a fun twist. I know I will savor this and re-read it again for details and the small tender moments that make this novel shine. More of a 4.5 for me as a reader.
I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review. My opinions are my own.

This story took me a few chapters to get into, it’s my first book with a second-chance at love featuring older MCs. But that didn’t make it any less of a book. In fact, I enjoyed it just as much as any of my other #properromanceseries books.

I don’t want to share too many of the Valet’s Secrets (see what I did there? 🤓😏🤭🤣), but I really think you will love this once you get to the first kissing scene (because Jodi gives us MULTIPLE) 😍💋💋

Thank you @netgalley for my complementary advanced reader copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

I received an ARC from the publisher and am voluntarily posting a review. All opinions are my own.
The Valet’s Secret puts a sweet Regency spin on the Cinderella story. There’s a wonderful exploration of class differences on multiple levels, from between the couple themselves, to hierarchy among the servants.
I really like that both leads, Rebecca and Kenneth, are in their forties, and have lived life and experienced loneliness and loss, and are currently struggling due to their respective positions within their families and in society. Rebecca is a widow, but she is still dealing with an abusive father. Meanwhile, Kenneth is being compelled by his uncle to consider a prudent marriage to a society lady, but he is drawn to Rebecca instead.
The romance between them is interesting, because it seems like it starts with a moment of impulsive passion, but the more they interact, you find that it’s about them seeing kindred spirits in each other on a deeper level.
I also enjoyed insights into Rebecca’s life in service, especially given her daughter ends up in a position above her, working for the same employer. While I’ve heard quite a bit about status among the aristocracy and how people could rise and (in some cases) fall, learning more about the hierarchy there, especially when it’s crossed with a parent-child dynamic, was intriguing.
This book is a wonderful historical fairytale from start to finish. If you love historical romances with no sex, I would recommend checking this one out.

Will their differences be impossible to overcome …

I discovered the author with her previous release which I loved, so I was eager to read more of her work.
This story is so different, and so heartening, a kind of Cinderella tale’s revisit with more mature characters.
And while both have lived, lost and fought their way on life, their first fun encounter is rather unexpected from full grownups. A shared kiss and a heir masquerading as his valet.
From this stems a sort of friendship which probably would never have happened if not for the initial deceit.
Kenneth made his life in the crown navy until he had to retire as a widower to take care of his sons and estate. He just did not expect to become later the heir to an earldom. He tries to learn his future duties, but he longs for the simple and quiet life he had prior to his cousin’s passing. Why he went on a wild horse ride, to clear his head and refocus as he feels like he is drowning.
Rebecca has made do with the blows life sent her way, and as she was considering entering in a new union without much to expect from it, outside a way out of her abusive father’s household, everything is put under a new perspective after an eathshattering kiss. She learned she was still a living breathing being, able of sensations and feelings outside the tepid sentiments her current suitor arouses. What she did not see coming was that “Mr Henry” was no heir’s valet but the heir himself.
Together they face the insurmountable reality of their differences, yet before Kenneth became an heir, them being together could have been a possibility, now it is more an impossible dream.
Kenneth and Rebecca are two persons tossed by the storm of life, they keep their head above water, accepting their change of circumstances, yet Kenneth refuses to compromise his heart in the process. But what can he do against the wagging tongues and their present differences.
Luckily for them both, they have a kind of fairy godmother lurking in the shadow…

A lovely revisit of the classic fairytale with two Cinderella as the hero is also facing a change of status, one he would have happily avoided if fate had not intervened.
4.5 stars

𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 kisses

I have been granted an advance copy by the publisher, here is my true and unbiased opinion.

I simply adored this. I admit to not knowing of the author's work but the idea of reading a regency romance with main characters in their 40's was intriguing enough for me to request an arc. I also did not realize this was a proper romance but that would never hold me back. I have a bit of a soapbox stance when it comes to proper/clean/closed door romances and being a hopeless romantic, I don't believe sex equals romance. I don't think you need the on page action to deliver what I read romance for, to fall in love right along with our couple as they do.

I loved meeting Kenneth, our hero who is 48 and suddenly the heir to an earldom. He's been a Royal Navy officer and lived as his own man for so long, never learning the ways of the aristocracy because it was never meant to be his life. When he is on his way to meet his Uncle and begin his "How to be an Earl" lessons, he decides to swap jackets, hats and shoes with his best friend and now valet, Malcolm, to ride a wild rented horse to Brenning Hall, his new home and get a small bit of freedom before the heir shackles are locked.

Rebecca who is 42, is a widowed woman of the working class who is currently living with her artist father after the death of her husband. After a visit with her grown daughter, Rebecca is enjoying a walk in the sunshine when the sound of hooves alerts her to an out of control horse with an out of control rider that causes her to dive into bushes or get run over.

This, dear readers, is our meet cute and it ends in the best possible way... a passionate kiss that neither Kenneth nor Rebecca can forget. Especially when Kenneth doesn't give his real name but that of his valet.

From there we get the push and pull between these two and their chemistry that seared my hands it was so heated. Kenneth and Rebecca like one another, they are INTO one another and both being lonely humans who have lost their spouses and children are grown, they know what a connection means. And these two have a connection.

But there is this lie between them and while Kenneth wants to come clean, he doesn't want to lose what he feels with Rebecca. But lies have a way of revealing themselves when they’re least expected and my heart broke when Rebecca learns the truth.

This book, I have the biggest smile on my face right now. I couldn't put it down. The writing first of all is so easy and comfortable. It's rare that you can pick up a book and fall into it with ease that you don't realize the time has passed because you were simply enjoying being told a story. The author has a way to paint a romance as well as Kenneth can sketch a landscape and Rebecca can create a silhouette.

I love a story of class differences in romance. It brings on this angst that is believable because we know history and how important class was to society. But we also know our fairy tales and that Cinderella got the prince in the end. Speaking of Cinderella, I couldn't help but feel this has a bit of the Cinderella to it but more in the likeness of the Drew Barrymore/Dougray Scott film version of Ever After. That isn't a bad thing because I love the holy heck out of that movie.

I feel I am already rambling and haven't said much. I just loved this story.
I loved how they met. How they meet again. I love the first scene at the walnut tree. I loved when this made me cry, made me laugh, made me sigh and made me fall in love.
This road to a happily ever after wasn't easy for Kenneth and Rebecca but they know love is worth it.

This book is so worth it.

Honorable mention to the baroness for her wise ways. She is an excellent fairy godmother. And to the real Malcom for knowing these two are hopeless yet helps them anyway.

Josi Kilpack has a magical way of pulling me into her books and this one was no exception. I'm not a big fan of reading about couples my age or older for some reason, and although Kenneth (48) and Rebecca (42) are right in there, it didn't bother me as much as I thought it would and I was rooting for them to find love, happiness, and companionship once again.

I love how this author tackles more difficult topics and things not written about as much in the Regency time period and with a stretch of the imagination, this story delivers a Cinderella feel to a couple mismatched in status, but the electrifying first meeting had me desperate for more.

Kenneth is someone who came to his title later and is grappling to find his footing in a world so foreign and Rebecca is stumbling to find security after discovering the true nature of her father. Yet they each complement each other in only the best ways possible and their meetings and interactions were simply wonderful.

I loved the flow and progression of the story and even the villainous characters were well-written, drawing up a lot of feelings and emotion. I loved wallowing in the depths of hope. This book was so much fun and was very entertaining, especially with the surprising hints of swoon.

Content: mild abuse/violence; mild romance

*I received a complimentary copy. All opinions expressed are my own and were voluntarily given.*

The Valets Secret, by Josi S. Kilpack, is a historical romance about two mature and like-minded people, a widower and an earl-to-be.
I really enjoyed this book! I loved that it was about a more mature couple in their 40’s, and that they both had grown or nearly-grown children. It was a lovely little spin on a well-done trope, and I’ll definitely be reading this one again.
I would recommend this romance to any lover of the genre, and maybe even to those who don’t typically read the genre, as this was a unique little twist on things. 4 well-deserved ⭐️.
Thanks ever since much to Shadow Mountain Publishing and NetGalley for gifting me this copy of the book for review.

A unique Regency from Josi Kilpack! I liked that the characters were older and the fun ties to the Cinderella fairy tale, but I think the story had more potential. I wanted to get to know the characters more so I could understand them better, and parts of the story were repetitive. The Valet’s Secret will definitely appeal to many readers, it just wasn’t my personal favorite. 3/5 stars

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

After a chance meeting (and a reckless kiss), an aristocratic widower falls in love with a widow chambermaid and each must decide whether their love is worth the upset their forbidden romance might cause.

This sweet (clean) Regency romance is undeniably a Cinderella story (complete with a ball and glass slippers) yet the telling feels fresh and engaging--probably because of the loose connection to the fairytale early on and the twist of the future-earl's deception. It is also always refreshing to see a mature couple in a Regency romance. Rather than a debutant and the rakish youth, Kilpack gives us a widow and widower in their 40s, both with grown children. As they reconsider the restrictive norms that keep them apart, they are also reconsidering their lives--how they have lived in the past and how they may be ready to break out of their society-dictated boxes and start anew. A fun, quick read for fans of clean historical romance.

I struggled a bit with reading this book. There are many lovely things about it, but there were some aspects of it that I couldn’t get over, which affected my reading experience of it.

I did like learning about silhouette artists and how the profile process worked! I had never thought of it before, and it was an interesting part of the story!

There are a few Cinderella elements sprinkled in the story too, and it was fun to watch for those to come up. The ending was sweet, and I liked how it all played out, though I would have loved an epilogue.

I have really enjoyed other books by this author and I look forward to reading more by her in the future!

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

I picked up The Valet’s Secret needing a break from “reality.” And since I’ve read a lot of Josi S. Kilpack’s novels and most of the Proper Romance offerings, I knew this book would hit the spot.

I wasn’t wrong.

It’s not as deep as Kilpack’s All That Makes Life Bright (which remains my favorite of her novels), but I didn’t need it to be. The Valet’s Secret is smooth and quick paced with just the right amount of romance and charm.

Rebecca and Lord Winterton and likeable and engaging characters. They’re well developed and their story played out as expected — with a few twists and turns to give readers something worth turning the pages. It’s a great option for readers who enjoy gentle romances.

While The Valet’s Secret isn’t tailored for the YA market, Shadow Mountain’s Proper Romance line, particularly its Regency Romances, evoke the sort of Jane Austen sensibilities that do appeal to young adults. Even though the protagonists here are older, fans of the line will enjoy it no matter their age.

My biggest complaint about this book is that I wanted an epilogue! I wanted to see the faces of people like Lady Beth when it is announced that not only is Kenneth to marry a maid but that his uncle condones the match. The ending is cute but I just wanted to see that little bit more.
This is loosely based on Cinderella and it has a fairy tale ending of course. I thought it was funny that Kenneth was the one locked in the tower. Really both he and Rebecca have elements of Cinderella in them.
I thought it was an enjoyable read and loved that the main characters are older and both on second marriages.

Sex: no
Language: no
Violence: yes, physical and emotional abuse
*I received a complimentary ARC through NetGalley and voluntarily chose to review it.

I had not considered until now how most historical romance books are centered around less experienced characters who are half my age. It was lovely to read a story in this genre with mature protagonists of my own age (in their 40s) for a change. It is a testament to the author's skill that the reader feels these characters' discomfort and yearning and resolve so keenly, and equally feels their guarded hope and elation at the possibility of a second chance in life. We all want to be genuinely admired for who we are. This is a beautiful love story.

4.75 ✨


This was just amazing. I am wholeheartedly in love with this book 💕💕💕

Kenneth Winterton, the future Earl, loved to disguise himself in his valet's clothes so that he can go on the horse rides that he really enjoys, and on one of these rides he meets Mrs. Rebecca Parker.
When kenneth Winterton meets Rebecca Parker for the first time it's a love at first sight. Both of them find it very hard to resist the attraction between them.
Kenneth is charmed by her to the point where he decides to keep the fact that he is not a valet a secret. As they find that they have many things in common despite their different social classes, Kenneth becomes afraid that revealing his true identity would drive the only woman he cares about away.

As Kenneth becomes more and more attached to Rebecca, he finds himself in a difficult situation where he has to chose between the future and the woman he loves.

OMG, this book was so good. The writing style was amazing, and the characters were very charming. As I read more, I found myself rooting for them.

This was simply one of the best romance books I've ever read. I loved that the characters were middle aged and more mature. This definitely had lots of angst, but it was just so good.

If you want to dip your toes into romance, I highly recommend this book.

Thank you to Netgalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I'm not an historical reading but this one got my attention.
This story has the Cinderella vibes, with all the rich society and the help.
Rebecca is a widow,42, help his father with paintings, but unfortunately the relationship is an abuse one.
The book was a little slow pace, Kenneth was a fine character, (48) .
He was determined to live his life with freedom, trying to respect the protocols of his position.
.
This One is close door romance, Rebecca is a wonderful character full of love, and fierce.
.
Thank you netgalley for the arc.
.
.

As a once happily married woman, Rebecca Parker had a good life, but now widowed, working for a living, and her only child Rose is grown & companion to a Baroness, she feels invisible, tired, and lonely. That is until the day a valet speeding by on a horse nearly runs her off the road. Mr. Malcolm Henry is apologetic, gentle, and handsome. She’s instantly drawn to him, which is why, rather than stopping him from kissing her, she kisses him back, reigniting a nearly forgotten passion. She sees Mr. Henry again and feels the possibilities growing until, while working in the kitchens during a dinner party, she sees the valet she kissed sitting at the right hand of the baroness. Mr. Henry is not the earl’s valet; he is the heir to the earldom—-Kenneth Winterton.
A well written gentle romance of misunderstandings. I really liked both Kenneth & Rebecca both are mature, both have lost spouses & both fall in love. A charming read of finding love but can they overcome a deceit, however unintentional, & then there’s the class divide. There are strong secondary characters. I was routing for the pair as they were perfect for each other, there are a couple of surprises & support from an unexpected source. The ending was a bit pat but didn’t stop my enjoyment
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read

I have read many of Josi's books, but this one in particular is my new favorite of hers! First of all, I loved the setup of the book. The chapters were short and changed perspectives which helped the story move quickly and made sure I didn't lose interest. I am a sucker for Cinderella retellings, which this book did in a beautiful and subtle way. I especially love the way Kenneth and Rebecca both had their own "Cinderella" moments; it seems lots of the times, the male character just stands around a lot! This was not the case for Kenneth, and it endeared his character to me. There is also the wonderful fact that both Rebecca and Kenneth are in their 40s, which is not the typical age of romance protagonists. I thought this was great representation of a community traditionally underrepresented by the romance genre. Additionally, I love that this was a romance about people of different stations that actually works out! It seems in most books I have read, the lower class character ends up actually being high class, disguised as a servant or something, and everything works out. This is all well and good, but I would like for more romance novels to actually address class divisions in the regency period rather than skirt around the issue entirely. Not only were all these aspects of the book unique and engaging, the romance itself was to die for! A wonderful captivating romance about true love and second chances.

I absolutely adore fairytale retellings! Josi Kilpack’s The Valet’s Secret is a creative twist on Cinderella with a “prince” in disguise and a second chance love story to boot. It isn’t very often you see Regency romances with characters who are in their 40’s and I loved this more mature take on falling in love again.

Kenneth and Rebecca are both at a crossroads. Having both lost their spouses and with grown children, each is anticipating a new start in life. Kenneth is now the heir to an earldom after the death of his cousin and Rebecca is forced to live with her father after her husband’s death. The two meet when Kenneth nearly runs Rebecca down with his horse. There’s an immediate attraction that leads to a surprising first kiss, but more than anything, they see in each other the loneliness and longing for connection.

Dressed as his valet, Kenneth knows he should reveal his true identity, but he wants more than anything to prolong contact with Rebecca. As the two meet again and again, each meeting is more powerful than the last, but when Kenneth’s secret is discovered, will they risk everything to forge a life together or will society, duty, and family push them apart?

Josi Kilpack is a marvel at creating complex yet sympathetic characters. I couldn’t help but cheer for Kenneth and Rebecca to find a way. The side characters are interesting with some who are domineering and abusive and others like Baroness Konold who are delightful.

Rebecca was such an enjoyable character. She’s passionate, talented, self assured, strong, and resourceful. One of my favorite parts was when she pelts Kenneth with walnuts for deceiving her. Kenneth is not the typical earl to be. He’s artistic, sports a shaved head, and is more comfortable dressed as a valet than a peer. I love that while other women are introduced to him he can’t forget Rebecca.

I didn’t realize this was a fairytale retelling until towards the end. I appreciated that many elements from Cinderella were there but with a unique spin. With a passionate yet clean romance and enjoyable characters, this story really drew me in and touched my heart. Highly recommend to fairytale retelling and Regency romance lovers. I received an advanced copy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own and my review is left voluntarily.

I have read so many regency era stories that I love when I find one with an unexpected or not often done storyline.
Josi brings a sweet story between two individuals who are in their 40’s. They both are widowed and onto new paths in their lives. A chance encounter brings them together and even though circumstances due to class should keep them apart they are drawn together again and again. Can they find a second chance at love again and with one another?
What will they do to obtain their happily ever after?
A sweet romance that started off a little slow for me but picked up by the first kiss and I LOVED the ending.
Thanks to Netgalley and Shadow Mountain for sending me a copy. All opinions expressed are my own.

A chance encounter, a passionate kiss and a handsome man galloping away leave Rebecca to wonder what just happened. The Valet's Secret features two widowed individuals, who never felt they'd love again until that one fateful day.

This inta-love story in told from both, Rebecca and Malcom's perspectives. The heart of their love story is their loneliness, and longing for a second chance at happiness. The only draw-back is Malcom didn't share his true self. He's heir to his uncle's earldom NOT a valet.

Malcom, a gentle, romantic man wants to fight for love not "who" societal expectations deem he should marry. You easily find yourself rooting for their happily ever after in The Valet's Secret. Finally a romance novel where the heroines are in their late 40's.

Thank you Shadow Mountain Publishing for the advance reader copy. #TheValetsSecret #NetGalley.

Overall I enjoyed this “Cinderella “ story that featured more mature characters . We get insights into both of their POVs which was nice, but I would have preferred a bit more interaction and dialogue between the two main characters earlier on in the book.

Thank you to Shadow Mountain and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book.
This is the second time I read a novel of historical romance with an older couple, and I think it's really nice.
At the end of the Regency, a sweet romance between Kenneth and Rebecca, both widows, now have a second chance to find someone who will understand them.
This is a kind of Cinderella story, clean romance, well written and a lovely story.

'The Valet's Secret' was a delight for me to read. Josie Kilpack has captured the Regency era that I had grown to love through Georgette Heyer. The relationship that unfolds between the main characters was fraught with difficulties, misunderstandings and tenderness. The right touch of villainy was thrown in to provide an entirely satisfying story which end I could not anticipate turning out well. I highly recommend this book to all.

When his cousin's death makes him the heir to an Earl, Kenneth is far from happy. His uncle is desperate to train him up to the position, and the constant need to be 'proper' and behave in a way very unlike himself make him want to kick up the traces. Taking a gallop with a new horse disguised as his valet (the only way he can get away with such behaviour), he nearly runs over a not-so-young lady - and when he comes back to check that she's okay, stuns them both by kissing her. Unfortunately, when she asks his name, he gives that of his valet. But he finds it impossible to put Rebecca from his mind, even though he knows that there can be nothing between them due to class differences. Then she finds out, after more clandestine meetings, that he lied about his identity... Can there be any happy ending to such a tangle?

I have to admit that the idea of unexpectedly becoming heir to a high position sounds as horrible to me as it apparently did to Kenneth, so I felt for him in that way. At the same time, his valet was definitely right about how idiotic and thoughtless he was being towards Rebecca, so that side of things was a little annoying. Nevertheless, I appreciated the way that Rebecca made the best of things and stood up for herself when it seemed appropriate - those walnuts? Great! I suspect that the ending is probably highly improbable in real life, but hey, I wouldn't want to read it if I didn't know they'd have a happy ending, so I appreciated the way that it was finally brought about. All in all, clean, enjoyable and satisfying. Recommended.

Note that I received a complimentary copy of the book from NetGalley. I was not required to write a positive review and this is my considered opinion of the book.

I. Loved. This. Book.

If you generally trust my opinion on books and that’s all you need to know, then stop reading and go put it on hold at your library, or buy it at your favorite local bookstore.

If you want to know more, read on.

It was so refreshing to read a romance novel about people in their 40s, rather than their late teens/early 20s. People who were both widowed, and didn’t realize how lonely they were until they met someone like them.

Of course, it wouldn’t be much of a book if Kenneth had been truthful from the beginning. And it wouldn’t have been much of a book if they hadn’t both had social expectations to try to live up to, which of course prevents them from thinking they could be together.

Thank goodness for meddling old baronesses.

Near the end, it begins to resemble the “Cinderella” fairy tale, enough that I was quite worried—there wasn’t enough time for a big plot complication and a happy resolution.

The characters here are well drawn, the dialogue natural, and the plot complications believable. It wasn’t completely without editing issues, but it I read an ARC, so hoping they were fixed by publication time.

Possible Objectionable Material:
Deception. Loss of spouses. A fair bit of kissing. An abusive parent.

Who Might Like This Book:
Anyone who enjoys “proper” (i.e., clean) romance, particularly of the regency period. Those who enjoy seeing mature characters fall in love.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my opinion.

This review also at https://biblioquacious.blogspot.com/2022/03/romance-two-ways.html

Finally a historical romance novel that doesn't revolve around a girl barely entering society!

I really liked how the characters were older and their experiences were spoken clearly, especially Rebecca--she was portrayed as a strong woman who didn't bend to the whims of what the love interest wanted from her.

A great twist on the cinderella relationship and mistaken identity trope!

This is not your typical regency romance book and in a good way. This story was about second chances and the couple was in their 40’s. It had aspects of a Cinderella type story but didn’t follow the usual character roles. I enjoyed the character interactions. I feel like the character growth for Kenneth happened off book but we were given a bit more insight for Rebecca. A well written story and enjoyed it.

What a deliciously good book. I'm all about growth these days. I love when characters start out obviously flawed or make big mistakes at the beginning. It is then that I know there will be loads of growing. Kenneth made some pretty clear mistakes at the beginning. His was a slow progression, but a clear one. It was fun to follow along on his progression.

Rebecca's wasn't so much growth, but self acceptance. She slowly realized her worth and that SHE would determine who she was and wouldn't let people treat her in ways that they had in the past. Put both characters together and you have a wonderful love story. And the Baroness. Just a delight. She was a scene stealer for sure! But in such a good way.

Finally, I loved the Cinderella overtones. But not just for Rebecca. I love the gender swap Cinderella aspect. I loved that Kenneth got his own Cinderella story. Overall, just so much fun to read! Josi S. Kilpack never disappoints!

I love the fact that the main couple is older widowers who had given up on finding love again and were ready to settle before quite literally running into each other. It makes for some great tension and interactions that a younger couple would not get to experience. Not to mention the fact that it's not often we see middle-aged characters in romance getting their happily ever after.
Kenneth and Rebecca are very obviously perfect for each other if it weren't for the fact that the former is heir to an Earldom and she's her father's helper in his art studio. It's really enjoyable to see them come up with reasons to see each other even after Kenneth's deception is found out. The plot works to push them together the more they try to stay apart and it's perfect for pushing the whole 'destined for each other' angle of the romance. I particularly enjoyed the fact that Kilpack really pushed the idea being willing to fight for who you love and not letting society dictate your life.

Very happy thanks to NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for the romantic read!

This reminded me of Ever After with a few role reversals. It was well-written and an enjoyable read! Rebecca and Kenneth were enjoyable characters and I liked the fact that they were older and also that this story didn't fit the typical regency mold. I recommend to fans of regency romances!

I enjoyed this Cinderella inspired novel about two people who get a second chance at love.

This isn't a typical Regency historical romance. While we do have two protagonists who ignite passion and love between themselves, it doesn't happen in the usual ways which was fun. It was a surprising and clever story that still had beautiful romance, swoony kisses and engaging characters. I appreciated the subtle uniqueness like the protagonists' ages, Cinderella inspired experiences for both of them, and the unexpected climax at the end. This is a lovely story that shows the power of love to overcome impossibilities and the beauty of second chances.

Rebecca is a fascinating and fulfilling protagonist. I enjoyed getting inside her head and getting to know her. I admired her determination, her passion for life, her hard working nature, and how she finds joy in small details despite her trials. Life has not always gone the way she had hoped and she has experiences true grief and pain, yet she is optimistic and hopeful. It was fascinating to hear about her work creating silhouette screens and the incredible attention to detail to make those. I also loved her relationship with her daughter, Rose.

Kenneth was also an intriguing protagonist. I always enjoy getting inside the male protagonist's head because it gives a clearer picture of who they are. Kenneth is so likable. He is a stranger and lacks confidence in a difficult new role. I appreciated how he seeks to balance learning about and being loyal to his duties as heir with his deep desires for love and connection. The ways he seeks to help those around him, especially Rebecca, helped build his character and made me like him more. I also love how he found ways to show his love and his ultimate plan to win over Rebecca. He knew it would be hard, but not harder than life without her.

The romance is unique and exciting from the early parts of the book. I haven't read many historical romances that begin with the first kiss so early in the book. That was a bit disorienting but their passion was also beautiful. Both Rebecca and Kenneth has been lonely for so long, their immediate connection was lovely to read about. And I appreciate that their connection builds after that initial interaction. They want to find time to be together and get to know each other. After their initial relationship which isn't entirely truthful, they seek a relationship built on trust and friendship. I was rooting for these two from their first kiss! I knew they would find a way even thought it seemed impossible.

Overall, I enjoyed this Cinderella inspired romance. The clever ways Kilpack includes scenes and details from the original fairy tale were really fun! Some were entirely unexpected! I enjoyed the story and learning about the time period especially the silhouette prints. I would have liked a bit more at the end like an epilogue or extra chapter detailing their life further down the road. But overall, a really enjoyable read!

I was lucky to be gifted an eARC of this book to review. This book follows Kenneth, who has just become heir to an Earldom after the unexpected death of his cousin. After moving in with his uncle to learn the trade, he runs into a local woman named Rebecca and the sparks fly. The only problem, she thinks he’s a valet.

The biggest thing that I was not expecting going into this book are the ages of our main characters. Both Kenneth and Rebecca are in their 40s. This was such a happy surprise for me! When reading historical romances, it is often that our main couple are in their 20-30s and just figuring out life. It was lovely to see both of these characters, who have been in previous marriages and have seen a little bit of the world, fall for each other in a pretty tough situation. The character development by both, but mainly Reecca, was amazing to see. I loved watching someone truly find themselves, and prove you are never too old to do so.

This is definitely not the fluffy romance I was expecting, and I loved every minute because of that. It was so refreshing to see a couple have all the lovely moments you would expect from a romance, but also have them deal with some of the tougher aspects of life. Huge trigger warnings for familiar abuse, so just be aware of that going into this story.

Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed my time reading this story and never wanted to put it down. There was something about Kenneth and Rebecca that had me enthralled the entire time. I think people who love Downton Abbey will really enjoy this story, and I will definitely look into other books by this author.

I will never get tired of Cinderella retellings. Forbidden romance. Hidden identities. A whole lot of drama. And one fantastically horrible woman trying to ruin it all. Really, what’s not to love?!
Throw a regency twist on the tale and you have ‘A Valets Secret’. And is it ever good!!!

Kenneth has lived a fairly full life. He married, had two sons, lost his wife. And held a position in the Royal Navy. Now at 48 years old, he finds himself starting a whole new life beyond his control.
He has inherited the title of Earl, and with it move to a new estate, join a new society and find a wife within it!
It’s really quite the adjustment!
And then he meets Rebecca. Who makes him forget all those responsibilities, and live in the moment.
Just one kiss on the side of the road, with a near stranger. Neither of their lives will ever be the same.

Do you love Cinderella stories?! You need to read this one! It has so many wonderful twists to it, you won’t even feel like you’re reading a retelling. I feel like I have seen Cinderella in a whole new light! This story was brilliantly done, and I am so glad I picked it up!

Thank you NetGalley and Shadow Mountain Publishing for the complimentary e-arc of this book. All opinions are my own.

Content: clean
Romance: kissing
Violence: abusive parent (not descriptive)
Language: none