I was really looking forward to this book after having read Authentically Izzy last fall. I think Positively Penelope is even better. It helps to read Authentically Izzy first, since Basham doesn’t waste any time in this new book to introduce the country of Skymar or the relationships between Izzy, Luke, Penelope, and Josephine. Once again, I had a horrible time putting the book down, laughed hysterically, and stayed up way too late to finish it. I loved it, and I do hope Basham writes one for Luke now!

"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own." #PositivelyPenelope #NetGalley

This book is a positive delight from the first line to the last. I adored Penelope in Izzy's book and she screamed for her own book, so I couldn't wait to dive into the pages of this novel. On my goodness, it was a true, laugh out loud joy to read this book. The story was filled with twists and hiccups, but there was such delight and fun. And fairy tales. And princesses. And Julie Andrews. Gene Kelly. All the things I adore. In one place. And such fun. And the kissing. Pepper does enjoy writing kissing books. I highly recommend this sweet, fun, romantic romp of a book. It was wonderful!

Penelope's sister, Izzy, met her soul-mate in the island kingdom of Skymar. Now Penelope is doing an internship there for her college degree. She is working toward a career in theater production and this is the opportunity of a lifetime. Her introduction to the country of Skymar was less than stellar and her first impression was a bit off-putting. Never-the-less, the intrepid Penelope is not going to let those curmudgeonly vibes dampen her spirits nor her ideas for helping the theater she has been assigned to help. Through her work, she helps Grandpa Gray find his feet again, she helps Matthias Gray overcome his deeply imbedded pain, and she brings the family's theater back to life, all while sprinkling her brand of pixie dust over everything.

Pepper Basham has written a very non-formulaic romance novel that is laugh-out-loud hilarious. I would guess that 90% of the novel is epistolary through the media of text messages and emails. The reader has to get over halfway through before there is any real narration to the story. She has included overt, dastardly villains; and some sneaky villains who are a bit more clandestine with their shenanigans. There are a couple of mystery characters that are hard to figure out but whose identities are revealed later on in the book. They all add to the warp and weft of the book to make a cohesive story come to life. Penelope's "never say die" attitude is one of the most endearing aspects to the book and her work ethic in bringing the theater back to its former glory are something to behold. The float in the parade was the cherry on top of the sundae that was Penelope's magic.

This is a fun, five star book, with two thumbs up, and a parade float that will take you straight to Narnia.

This follow up to Authentically, Izzy was perfect! I’m not even a huge lover of musicals, but this book had me *almost* wanting to hum along! We met Penelope in the first book, but not like this. She is all sunshine, sweetness, and sassiness and if her brand of optimism could be bottled, the world would be a lovelier place! Penelope took Skymar by storm and no one was safe from her charms, especially Matt and his adorable daughter, Iris! The only problem with this book is that it ended!

I was given an advanced copy of this book and all opinions are expressly my own.

Authentically Izzy was my favorite book from last year so I had high expectations for this. Thankfully, it did not disappoint. Penelope is at first a lot to take in with her big personality and childish optimism. But as the story unfolds, you get to know her for who she is, and soon wish you had more of her traits.

I loved all the musical references! And Audrey Hepburn quotes!

Huge Thank You to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson for the opportunity to read this ARC!

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Positively delightful!!! I seriously could get lost in a world of never ending stories between Izzy, Penelope, Luke and Josephine. These characters are so much fun! Their texts and emails to each other are a hoot, in addition to being loving family correspondence. From the bookish Izzy to the musical theatre and positively fashionable Penelope, I can hardly wait for Luke's story.

"I've found that leading with positivity is a great way to face any situation in life, even if my older siblings doubt my logic." "Don't get me wrong. I'm not a leader. But I am a...what's a good description? An encourager with an innate herding impulse? LOL."

Penelope is a force to be reckoned with her positive attitude, her singing, her fabulous ideas, her hard work, her baking skills, and her ability to see potential in everything and everyone. There is no one quite like her and she earns the love of many in this foreign island of Skymar where is is completing her internship. She loves fairy tales and suddenly finds herself having fairy tale moments with some of the sweetest people. I fell in love with Penelope, the Gray's, especially the-at-first-grumpy Matthias, his sweet, sweet daughter Iris, and Grandpa Gray.

Royalty, dancing, romance, mystery, villains, family history, the importance of community, and a ball! Such a delightful story, and I absolutely loved all the Julie Andrews, Audrey Hepburn and Gene Kelly references!

I highly recommend Positively Penelope (and you must read or listen to Authentically Izzy first).
Thank you to the publisher and Net Galley for allowing me to read an early copy. All opinions are my own. I can't wait for my preordered copy to arrive for a special place on my keeper shelf.

As a fan of Izzy, I had high hopes for Penelope, and I was not disappointed. The characters in this book make you wish you knew them in real life. And the positively quirkiness of Penelope is so endearing.
I love that Pepper writes beautifully hilarious rom-com books that you want to read over and over again.

Thank you netgalley for the arc copy!

I think that this was absolutely perfect. I couldn't have enjoyed it more. This was as good. I loved it.
I just reviewed Positively, Penelope by Pepper Basham. #PositivelyPenelope #NetGalley
[NetGalley URL]

This book was such fun! I needed this!
I enjoy a cute read, and this one met my expectations all the way!
I read this book in one afternoon!
I could not put it down!
These young ladies have quite the story to tell.
The girls are such a delight to get to know through texts, letters, and emails!
This title made my soul feel full and satisfied.
Fans of Izzy will be sure to delight in Penelope's story, too!
Penelope is a friend that you definitely don't want to let go of!
My favorite thing about this book was the humor that Basham adds throughout the novel. My other favorite thing is the bond that these young ladies have. Something that I've yearned for all my life, and I love finding it through books like these.
Thank you, Ms. Basham for bringing that joy to life once more!
5 stars for a job well done!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.

"Love is worth it all".

What a beautiful and absolutely wonderful story from start to finish! If it's even possible, I love this book even more than Authentically, Izzy. The happiness and hope and love spilled over every page and I never wanted to put it down. Can I give 10 stars?

Please tell me there is a story coming soon for our favorite brother Luke? I'll be first in line.

I received a complimentary copy of this book for review. All opinions expressed are my own.

Ahhhh, one of my favourite trios is back!! I didn’t think it was possible after loving Izzy’s story so much, but I loved Penelope’s story even more!

From the prologue alone, I was grinning like crazy. In fact, the entire book had me laughing so hard that a couple family members checked in to make sure I was okay. Just peachy & reading top-notch humour. Seriously, if you need a spoonful of sugar & laughter — read this book!

A few of my favourite highlights being…

✨ The humour
✨ The classic movie references
✨ “Did you just turn Chris Pine into an adjective?”
✨ Alllll the Julie Andrews’ references
✨ Luke in protective big brother mode & showing up for Penelope. (And just Luke in general, haha!)
✨ Grumpy-Sunshine
✨ Iris!
✨ Penelope’s “Mary Poppins” bag… this is so me 😂
✨ Matt calling Penelope, “the pixie”
✨ No love triangles, miscommunications, or third act breakups!


But for all the laughs, it wasn’t fluffy or mindless. It was heartfelt with a giggle — amusing and yet woven together with deep, thoughtful themes. It’s a story about friendship, community, family & belonging, dealing with grief, and the meaning of true love (being that you shouldn’t have to change yourself to make yourself acceptable to others). And of course, the power of a little “magic.” 😉

All I can say is that I loved every minute of this book, it gave me a dose of laughter & sunshine just when I needed it, and I cannot wait for Luke’s story next! 😍


*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.

These books are so dreamy and I never want them to end! Penelope is such a great character and someone you instantly want to be friends with. She has such joy and exuberance inside of her. Grandpa Gray is another fascinating character as well as Iris! Gosh, I can't say enough good things about this book and hope the author has the next one out as soon as possible.



Thanks so much to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own.

Pepper Basham has done it again!

Positively, Penelope is a spectacularly sweet sequel to Authentically, Izzy. (If you haven’t read Izzy’s book yet, I recommend you read it first. There are a lot of references to it in Penelope’s book.)

With more wonderfully whimsical characters (Grandpa Gray, Matthias, Iris, and Gwynn…just to name a few), the same fantastic fictional foreign land of Skymar, and plenty of laugh-out-loud moments combined with a slow-burn sweet romance, Penelope’s story is “practically perfect!”

I laughed.
I cried.
I loved it!

My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (5/5 stars)

And I can’t wait for Ms. Basham to write Luke’s story!

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Another fabulous Edgewood family Skymarian tale!

Having been obsessed with musical theatre, “The Sound of Music”, Chris Pine and Gene Kelly at different points in my life, I LOVED this story (spoiler alert: I am the target audience!). Add in fun banter between siblings (please tell me the next book is about Luke? He needs a happily ever after despite his protestations!), some wonderful new characters with the surname Gray, and a nefarious situation with the competition, and I was hooked!

I love Ms Basham’s brain, especially the way her character voices are clear, never muddled. There was more “live action” in this book than in “Authentically, Izzy”, but still heaps of fun emails and text messages to read and enjoy.

Loved this story so much... the whimsy and the romance. I also appreciated Brodie popping in occasionally... cos we all love Brodie. And now we love Matt.

And Luke. *begs with hands steepled for the next book to be about Luke*

I had to start this book as soon as I finished reading the first book in this series. I got done with Izzy and had to start Penelope. It was the best decision ever! These books are so fun and I can't wait until the next one comes out! I'm invested in this family now.

In this book, we follow Penelope as she goes to the islands that Izzy is relocating to with her Brodie. She's going to help revive a theatre. And maybe some of the people in the theatre as well.

I loved watching Penelope's positive attitude in action and her Mary Poppins bag. Add in the adorable little girl and it was a lovely book. But then you've also got romance. The problem is that someone is sabotaging all of the hard work Penelope is doing. She can stay one step ahead but it feels like for every two steps forward they take two steps back.

Can Penelope find out who is behind the sabotage? Is there anything she can do to stop it? Can she get the right brother in the bargain?

I loved this book so much and can't wait to find out the rest of the family's story! Also, can I mention I really wanted some pictures or illustrations thrown in to show the twins? They have such cute outfits that Penelope buys for them that they wear but we can only see it in our minds and I wanted to see it for real too!

I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received through Netgalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.

Reading an 'epistolary' novel is an interesting experience. This is a nice blend, the first half is heavier on the emails and text messages, and then the second half has more 'as it happens' narration and inside heads.

I found this style fascinating, and I read all 7 hours over the course of 2 days. I'd read the first book in the series already, so knew somewhat what to expect, and it was great getting to "see' familiar faces again, as well as getting to know Penelope better. There were several times my heart ached for the characters, and a couple of times I wanted to knock heads together.

But Penelope's determination to choose Joy, even when she's hurting, is beautiful. Pollyanna-esque, but deeper. and she's not afraid to tell it like she sees it, even when that's going to upset someone's apple cart. She does it with kindness, and it shows. I want to be Penelope when I grow up.

I love the interplay between Izzy, Luke and Penelope, (and Josephine). The Family connection is so nice to see.

I received a copy of this book from @Netgalley and chose to review it here. All thoughts are my own.

Love this book! Penelope is such a great role model of joy, energy, kindness, and fun all while being hardworking and business smart! Can’t wait for Luke’s book!

I absolutely adored this book! Positively, Penelope is a sequel of sorts to Authentically, Izzy, following Izzy’s beloved cousin, Penelope. Now, I loved Izzy because I related to her as the person I am, but I love Penelope because she represents the person I’ve always wanted to be! She’s endlessly positive, sings and dances at random, picks her skirts based on twirl factor (something I’ve done myself in the past), and has a God given gift for loving and encouraging people. How can you not love her?

I’ll admit, I guessed the “mole” pretty early on, but I don’t think the mystery was as important as the other factors of the book.

I absolutely adored Penelope’s relationship to Matthias and Iris. So sweet. And her relationship to Grandpa Gray was heartwarming to say the least. And the romance was swoon worthy.

I also appreciated watching how Penelope came to figure out and accept what God had for her future, even if it wasn’t what she originally thought.

I cannot say enough good things about this book. Just read it, Y’all!

Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson for providing me with a review copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

Pepper Basham has done it again! Positively, Penelope is the PERFECT sequel to Authentically Izzy! The only thing that might be better?…….when Luke gets his own story!!!!
Where do I begin? Pepper does a wonderful job of mixing in the Appalachian culture, Rambo movie quotes, and musical theater. Three things that normally wouldn’t go together, blend seamlessly.
I honestly didn’t think I would like Penelope as much as I did! I felt she was childish and lived in fairy tale dream land. But I was wrong! Penelope’s relationship with Matthias had me smiling from the beginning! As usual, the kissing moments were worth the wait!
I’m calling it now….this story has the BEST first kiss moment out of all of Pepper’s other stories!

If you loved Authentically Izzy, then you will absolutely adore Positively, Penelope! Even though it’s a sequel it can totally be read as a stand alone. But why would you?

I highly recommend this to anyone who loves a good contemporary romance!

I received an early copy of this book via Netgalley. All opinions expressed are mine and given freely!

This is a delightful book! Familiar characters join some new ones in a story that is filled with love, romance and even a little mystery! I LOVE Matt! What a scrumptious man! The love story is so sweet! This is a book that I could read over and over!
I was provided a copy from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Penelope is a ray of sunshine. She takes puts the music in musical. But Penelope has just flown away from her home nest. And the adventures awaiting may not be quite what she was expecting. There's 2 brothers, an old theater, a job opportunity (or 2), a little girl who wants to be a princess, and grandpa. But Penelope is determined and makes the choice to be positive throughout.

I loved the musical and book references. I loved the letter writing. I loved how this all came together!

"She's not like anyone I've ever met before. She sort of attaches herself to people and then convinces them of things they don't realize they're going to agree to until it's too late."

"Has she bewitched you body and soul?"

"Story is the key to what we bring to the stage, how we present ourselves online, and even how we engage with one another. We all have stories, but in our hearts, we all LOVE stories..."

Another fun book with the email dialogue along with in person happenings. Penelope has taken an intern job in the Skymar Islands, but a different place than the last book. She’s totally in her element and spreading sunshine wherever she goes and to whomever she meets. We meet the Gray family, Alec, Matt, Gwynne and Grandpa, as well as a few others. Josephine still doesn’t understand how her siblings can just go so far away. Izzy is still in the US, and Penelope is only interning though. Izzy is her supportive self and Luke is his sarcastic self. Her first impression of Matt isn’t great, but she loves his daughter, Iris. Alec is gone a lot, but does try and spend some time with her when he’s home. She bonds well with Grandpa and learns a lot from him of the history of the theater she’s to bring back to life. Page turning story and a total delight. Looking forward to the 3rd book. I do wonder how Luke’s text messages will come across when it’s hit turn to write.
A complimentary copy was provided by Thomas Nelson via NetGalley. A review was not required and all thoughts and opinions are my own.

This may be my favorite book of the year. It's definitely become one of my all-time favorites. Shifting from quiet, reserved Izzy's POV in the first book to bold, vibrant Penelope's in book two was jarring at first. But, just as she does with everyone she encounters in the story, Penelope quickly won me over, embracing her role of leading lady.

You can not help but love her optimism and authenticity as she faces challenges head-on, always hopeful for a positive outcome. The character growth and romance (the absolute sweetest) unfolds at just the right pace, building towards a climax and finale worth waiting for.

I enjoyed meeting a fascinating new cast with the added bonus of getting to check in with favorite characters from the first book. This charming modern-day fairytale is the perfect blend of conflict, humor, amour and a heartwarming tale that will hold a special place with me for always.

Pepper Basham infused some sort of special magic into this book, because it delighted me from the first page to the last.

Penelope is the best kind of sunshine heroine. Her joy isn't a naive optimism, but a conscious decision she's made to bring wonder and beauty to the world around her. I love her desire to see the best in people and how quick she is to forgive. It's beautiful to see the way she draws Matthias out of his grief and brings hope back into his life.

This book is about family and community, love and second chances. It's a grumpy/sunshine, friends-to-more romance. It truly is one you don't want to miss.

I was captivated and immediately engrossed by this delightfully entertaining narrative thanks to Penelope, a character I liked hanging out with. I enjoyed her family, the way they interact with one another, and the outside world is charming. Just as you enjoyed Authentically Izzy’s book-related knowledge, you’ll enjoy Penelope’s movie and theatrical trivia.

I appreciated how this novel was told through letters, texts, and emails. In this narrative, Penelope makes every attempt to keep the Darling House Theatre, open. Her efforts were admirable. By showcasing this local resource, she gives the town and the theater hope by identifying this local treasure.

Of course, the part where Penelope embarks on a mission to introduce princesses and fairy tales to Matthias’s small daughter Iris was fun and compelling. You will adore Penelope, her zeal for life, theater, and everything related to the Darling House Theater. If you enjoy Mary Poppins, The Sound of Music, Sundays at Tiffany’s, and other classic film trivia, you will adore this story.

The significance of true love, as well as friendship, community, family, and belonging, are all explored in the novel. Along with joy, laughing, and sunshine, it also addresses bereavement. The third book in the series will introduce readers to Penelope’s brother, Luke, that has me intrigued. I liked the way the author drew me into this mystery, and I enjoyed the wonder and charm of this story. It was impossible to put this book down. It’s a fantastic getaway that your book group will adore.

Disclosure of Material Connection: I requested and received a copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins!
The Book Club Network blog https://psalm516.blogspot.com/

I loved this story by Pepper Basham, the characters and storyline were so fun!

I just reviewed Positively, Penelope by Pepper Basham. #PositivelyPenelope #NetGalley
[NetGalley URL]

This book just made me so happy and I absolutely LOVED it! Authentically Izzy was one of my absolute favorite books from last year so I was highly anticipating the release of Positively Penelope… and it was so much fun!🥰

You know those books that are just fun to read? Well, this is one of those books. I loved the characters, the setting, the humor— all of it. I was basically smiling the entire time I read this book.💗

First of all, I absolutely LOVED these characters!
Penelope was just wonderful. She adores Julie Andrews and Audrey Hepburn, classic movies, theater, musicals, fairytales, and vintage things— and I completely loved her character! She was just such a fun character. I really just wanted to be besties with her and make sugar cookies and watch Audrey Hepburn movies all day.
And then we have Matthias. I loved both him and his adorable daughter Iris. He’s a very grumpy, cautious, and serious guy in the beginning but then Penelope comes along and flips his world upside down. The sunshine/grump trope in this book was the best!🥰 I adored Matt and Penelope together. The romance was seriously adorable. 💗
I loved getting glimpses of Izzy, Brodie, and Luke again! I love them all so much. Izzy and I are kindred spirits, and Luke is pretty much my favorite. He’s hilarious and made me laugh constantly. I really can’t wait for his book!

I felt like this book was the perfect mix as it was told through texts, emails, and third person. I especially enjoyed getting more third person narrative in this one! I do love these cousins’ text message/email conversations. My life would be 100% more fun if I could be on their group chat.😂

This book just made me so happy. I laughed out loud multiple times and was smiling pretty much the whole time I read it. But this book is more than just a story that will make you laugh and smile. It also has deep moments too and I loved that!

In conclusion, I loved this book! It was just so much fun to read! It was everything I hoped it would be and more. I am SO excited for the next book in this series!
If you love the sunshine/grump trope, theater, classic movies, and epistolary novels, I think you will love this one!☺️

*Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for sending me an ARC in exchange for a review. All opinions are my own.

Positively Penelope was absolutely amazing! Penelope made my musical loving heart smile! A perfect read for anyone who loves Broadway, Julie Andrews and romance!

I absolutely adore this series! Positively Penelope is such a sweet story about second chances. I adore the characters (and loved the updates on characters from Authentically Izzy) and the setting and everything about this book. I also can’t wait for Luke to get his own book.

Positively , Penelope
By Pepper Basham
Pub Date: August 1, 2023
Thomas Nelson
Christian Fiction, Romance, Contemporary
I absolutely loved reading Authentically, Izzy last Fall. Please read that one first because it explains so much.
This is a great read also! Mystery, songs, bicycling, twirling, baked goods, and much more make this a book I’m happy to recommend. Delight from beginning till the end,
5 stars

Musical theatre fans will love this fun song filled novel that reads like a musical. If that’s possible. But this novel shows us like Rogers and Hammerstein that impossible things are happening every day. Julie Andrews and Audrey Hepburn fans will find every reference bringing a smile to their face. And if you’ve ever worked in a theatre you know they’re always struggling so this was so accurate. Penelope is me at twenty-four. Young yet given so much responsibility in a theatre. I could relate in so many ways. If only theatres were run actually run by straight single fathers who dance.

I absolutely, positively, (sorry, I couldn’t help it!) loved this book and Penelope who brings her optimistic and fun-loving outlook to the people of Skymar when she is given the opportunity to help revitalize an old family-run theater. What Penelope is able to accomplish not only for the theater, but the town, and the Gray family in the time that she is there as an intern is remarkable.

There were so many things I loved about this story that I gave it a five star rating. Throughout the story I found gems of truth about faith in God and His care for us that had me highlighting quite a few things that I plan on returning to later. The emails that Penelope sends to her family back home are so fun because she half explains things and leaves her family hanging. It’s up to them to prod her to finish her stories and fill in the details or send someone to check on her to make sure she is all right. I loved Penelope’s character, her infectious outlook on life and caring of people, and her ingenuity. I think we all need more Penelope's in our life.

If you like romantic comedies, faith inspired stories, and a book that will make you smile, this one is for you! I consider this to be the second book in the series of the Edgewood siblings, but it can be read as a stand-alone novel. However, I can.not.wait. to read Luke’s story who is Penelope's brother!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. A positive review was not required, and all opinions are my own.

Positively, Penelope can be a stand alone read, but I highly recommend reading the delicious Authentically, Izzy first. Readers will not regret that solid decision. Here's a clever tale of a unique set of close siblings and family. Surrounding witty dialogue and mystery, emails and texts among the quartet provide witty commentary to Penelope's adventures and misadventures.

What a joyful read and absolute delight to revisit the island of Skymar and its residents. Strong themes of faith, hope, grief, loss and above all, hope, pervade the text and create a fullness to the story.

I can hardly wait for the arrival of Loyally, Luke in 2024!

I received a copy of the book without obligation. This review is my opinion.

This book is even better than the first-and I LOVED the first one! Again, this book is told mostly using e-mail and texting, although it does have more traditional story telling than the previous book.

I absolutely love Penelope. Her zest and positively absolutely shines in this story. Not only does she change the people she comes into contact with, but she encourages the reader to look on the bright side of life in the process. The Gray brothers play an important role in her story, and it’s fun to see how Penelope figured out her true self as the story progresses. The enchanting island the author created in the first book is just as wonderful and whimsical. The writing is amazing and fun and this is a book you will enjoy!

*I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

What did I love…So much!

All the names are perfect! Like seriously Matt surprised me! Iris, Penelope, Alec….

I love all the play (and some book) references and then to turn it into a theater rescue just tired it together beautifully.

Pepper always puts such a sweet touch to her romance stories. They are clean and lovely and you want to keep reading them.

This book ends too soon and makes you laugh all the way through!

'Positively, Penelope' is practically perfect in every way! I just loved this book. It is funny, and heartfelt and charming, with villains and misunderstandings and joy. Please read 'Authentically, Izzy' (the first book of these two) to find more joy and happiness. Pepper Basham provides a reading experience that is inventive, uplifting and inspiring. If I could give it 10 stars I would. Now all I can say is bring on Luke!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.

PERFECTLY MAGICAL IN EVERY WAY. 5 STARS. LOVE THIS SERIES - SUCH GREAT COMFORT READS! I have to say, these characters make these stories. Authentically, Izzy is one of my favorites books of all time and this sequel did NOT disappoint ya'll! This series is just a good time all around and an ultimate comfort to me. Bonus points here for the movie and theater lovers -as this has all the PERFECT classic movie vibes with Julie Andrews, The Sound of Music, Grease, Cinderella, Rambo and so much more! Perfect princess vibes - yes please! THANK YOU PEPPER for the most magical stories.

Positively, Penelope follows Penelope Edgewood - you would have seen her and her siblings, Luke and Josephine in Authentically, Izzy and they're just a GREAT time! Told in e-mails and text messages, plus the traditional narrative story, we follow Penelope as she travels to Skymar for 3 months to be an intern at one of the most historical theaters on the island. She works with Matt Gray, the business manager of the theater, plus we see his daughter, Iris, Grandfather Gray, brother, Alec and sister, Gwynn. Together they make up this century old theater group that is in desperate need of saving. That's where Penelope comes in! Her marketing skills and experience are going to be put to the test as they work to save this theater.

We get to see messages from primarily Izzy and Luke, with some from Josephine as well. Loved all of these great conversations. I can't wait to listen to the audiobook because the narrators will be the same as Authentically, Izzy and they are WONDERFUL! They truly bring these conversations to life!

Like I said, what makes this story is our wonderful cast of characters! Penelope is so wonderful! She is positive, kind, generous, full of sunshine and a genuine heart! Then we have this grumpy-sunshine guy - Matt - who I LOVED! He has been through such hardship with his divorce and the loss of his mother and grandmother - he doesn't know how to begin again....until he meets Penelope. :) I LOVED the relationship between them and Iris too - Iris was so precious! I loved a good story with a single Dad trying to make his way who can find love again - SIGN ME UP!

I hope you all will pick this book up - as if I haven't sold you enough :) - it truly made me happy and feel like a princess would. :) What a magical place - to be in Skymar. I am so ready for Luke's story! If you love theater, movies, fairytales and just feel good stories - this is for YOU!

Thank you to Thomas Nelson and NetGalley for a copy to honestly read and review. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Oh, My Sweet Goodness!
This second book in this new series by Pepper Basham is so delightful!
I felt so connected to these characters because of the way the author has written it.
This book is mostly written as an Epistolary novel. If you’re not familiar with what that is, it’s where the story unfolds mostly through texts, emails, and phone calls by the characters.
It’s not as much as the first book in this series, but it’s still a significant part and I’ve found that I LOVE it!
The banter and dialogue flow so smoothly and it brings life to each character. I could just hear their wit and relate to many of their struggles and joys.
In this book, Penelope (who is the youngest of all the relatives) is away in the charming town of Skymar. From the minute she steps off the plane, she encounters crazy people and experiences many things. Her life in the dramatic theater world takes center stage and she’s loving it.
I truly enjoyed reading this book because I could relate to many of the things. I LOVE the world of theater and enjoyed picturing all the many parts that go into keeping a theater alive.
Pepper Basham presented a charming tale that actually had depth and humor all wrapped up in the conversations these characters had. There were also bits of wonderful life lessons that deeply touched my soul.
I highly recommend you pick this book up for a delightful read. You just might find yourself dreaming of taking a trip across the ocean to see rolling hills and white cliffs. Or maybe take a trip into a theater to watch a musical.
I was given this book by the publisher which did not influence my review in any way, all thoughts and opinions are my own.

Positively Penelope is
A real life fairy tale romance with all the feels! Pepper Basham has the perfect knack for nailing swoony real-life romances.
Penelope gets her own dream come true fairy tale in this rom-com set in the perfect back drop of Skymar. Penelope brings joy and positivity everywhere she goes. Even the old, aging Darling theatre where she’s hired on as a marketing intern. Matt, a grumpy, single dad is doing everything to keep his family’s legacy from dying out. Penelope bursts into his world with song, dance, and princesses. His daughter, Iris, loves all the princesses and fairytales. Matt is captivated by her creativity and genuineness to bring life back to the theatre. In fact, the entire Gray family is charmed by her ability to round up the masses and inspire excitement. There are some slips, trips, and bumps along the way, but life has a way of settling out just as it needs to.
The delightful emails and texts from Authentically Izzy continue in this second novel of the series (you can enjoy without reading that one first, but it does add to the humor and appreciation of the siblings bantering back and forth).
Now we just need Luke’s HEA!!
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher via NetGalley and all opinions expressed are solely my own, freely given.

Such a delightful read, one you won't be able to put down. Pepper D. Basham brought a smile to my face, along with several chuckles.

Penelope lands a dream job and turns on her magic, capturing quickly the love of a little girl, and even her dad, Grumpy Matt.

She spreads her love and faith and baked goods around and brings back to life Grandpa, and gets him excited, but life cannot run smoothly, and there is a mole doing their damage. Yes, I guessed whom the mole was but loved how the whole situation was handled!

A story that begins with a lot of texts and emails, and pulls you in, and who doesn't love Peter Pan?

Now I can't wait for the next book in this series!

I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Thomas Nelson, and was not required to give a positive review.

To Pepper Basham - BRAVA!! What a wonderfully entertaining story. Penelope is so delightful and full of all the things we love about princesses and fairy tales. I really enjoyed this story so much. It was great to reconnect with the characters we met in Authentically, Izzy (with all their good-natured sibling banter) and to meet new ones. I especially loved Matthias and Iris and Grandpa Gray.

On the surface, Penelope might come across as carefree, but I love how Pepper allows us to see the depth of character and wisdom she possesses. Penelope knows people often don’t take her seriously because of her cheery nature and this quote sums up her perspective: “I’ve chosen joy, but that doesn’t mean I didn’t have to fight for it. And sometimes, that fight starts as soon as I wake up in the morning.”

Pepper has penned the perfect rom-com, theatrical story for Penelope. We had humor, romance, a little mystery, with a touch of royalty and I enjoyed every minute! I received an early copy for review. The opinions expressed are my own.

Penelope Edgewood is an eternal optimist. Matt Gray is a single dad recovering from heartbreak. When Penelope comes to work for Matt’s family as an intern at their failing small town historical theater, clashing is inevitable. As Penelope works to turn around the fortunes of the Gray family business, will her opinion of Matt turn around as well? Told in a clever email and texting format, this humorous, lighthearted tale of hope is a breath of fresh air and sunshine.

Positively Penelope by Pepper D. Basham is the sequel to Authentically Izzy. It is a charming story about Izzy's cousin Penelope. She has just graduated college and goes to Skymar to help restore an old theater. When she arrives she finds their finances in shambles as well as a lot of work needed on the theater. Penelope dives into the work with enthusiasm. She loves all things Julie Andrews such as Mary Poppins and The Sound of Music. There are many references to songs and dances by Gene Kelly. She, meets Matt, a single dad with an adorable daughter, Iris. Although this is a fun and upbeat book, someone is trying to steal ideas that only Penelope and the members of The Darling House theater troup know about. This book has it all!! Comedy, romance, mystery and a surprise ending!! It's magically delicious!! It will be published August 1,2023 but it can be pre-ordered now!! I thank the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC of this book. I loved the feel good vibes and give it 5 stars!! I was under no obligation to give a positive review. All opinions are my own.

Well this just about broke the Swoon Scale™️. Oh my word, did Ms. Basham just give everything here.

Will you check out this trope combo:
Jaded grumpy hero/Optimism avalanche sunshine heroine
Single dad (just the right amount of cute child presence)
Workplace forced proximity with lots of competence
Bit of an age gap
He falls first and a smidge of grovel
The only acceptable kind of quasi-love triangle: the Clear Winner love triangle
And of course, predominant presence of wonderful bantery written communications.

Much like with the first book, even as an epistolary fan, it took me a minute to settle in, and, especially in this story, I was wondering how the written communication format would work to keep us invested in this scenario (our grump meet-cute was told not shown *miffed*). But, never fear, a third person dual POV enters just when we need it, and it’s all systems go, so effective. Really applaud all the pacing/format choices and by that third act when Grumpy Gray is already all in and we have reveals, rescues, declarations, grand gestures and reunions, I repeat, optimum swoonage.

Because this is the kind of life-affirming swoony romance progression where you can see exactly where it’s going, love to see it coming and rejoice when it so-satisfyingly arrives. Isn’t that the heart-tinglingly steady predictability us romance readers yearn for? But then it also exceeds your expectations as you’re bombarded left and right with a very special brand of grump-goes-Gene-Kelly charm in a dreamy Northern European landscape. I’m serious, friends, we have a brokenhearted accountant/dance teacher hero with impressive eyebrows on our hands, ok?

And Penelope is all gotta-love-her, generally oblivious, charming chaos, with her often-rambling, incomplete narrative emails, her dreamy outlook, but with all the creativity and know-how to back it up. She literally barrels into this theater family and community’s life and learns you can have both what you dream and what you need, looking fabulous and quoting Audrey Hepburn as you achieve it.

The Edgewoods are everything and more. Luke’s up, I’m so ready.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC.

Content notes: kissing only, unresolved grief, mention of infidelity and familial abandonment.

Positively, Penelope was positively an absolute delight! I enjoyed getting to return to the world of Skymar and the Edgewood siblings. This book reads like a love letter to the Theater (and Julie Andrews) and I adored every reference and line. I liked all the tropes woven into this book: slow burn, gentle grumpy/sunshine, workplace romance, love triangle with brothers, traveler in a foreign land, single dad, grandpa matchmaker, etc. So many wonderful things to love about this book!

“Positively Penelope” was such an exuberant, warm, and comfy read! I had loved Authentically Izzy and was so excited to see more from Pepper D. Basham and the world she created.I loved the epistolary style. It made it seem all the more relatable and down-to-earth. The theatrical and fairytale-ish qualities added to the magic and charm. I enjoyed getting to return to the world of Skymar and the Edgewood siblings. This book reads like a love letter to the Theater (and Julie Andrews), and I adored every reference and line. I liked all the tropes woven into this book: slow burn, gentle grumpy/sunshine, workplace romance, love triangle with brothers, traveler in a foreign land, single dad, grandpa matchmaker, etc. So many wonderful things to love about this book! And what a sweet, uplifting romance! We need more books like this to bring a little light into the world. I have already preordered my physical copy!!

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. My gratitude to Thomas Nelson Fiction and NetGalley!

I adored Authentically, Izzy. I was ready to dive straight into her newest book.

Positively, Penelope by Pepper Basham was so quirky, fun and delightful.
I absolutely loved this book. It hooked me and kept me turning pages until I was done. The character development was strong, and the premise was amazing.
The story of Penelope and Matt was enchanting and adorable!
Basham is a master at storytelling who draws the reader right into the story.

"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own."

Thank You NetGalley and Thomas Nelson for your generosity and gifting me a copy of this amazing eARC!

I enjoyed returning to this series with Penelope's story! She is such a fun, hopeful character. I connected with her immediately! This book has fun references to musicals and is in a delightful setting.

Like the book before this one in the series (Authentically, Izzy), this novel mostly tells the story through emails and texts. So many wonderful words come to mind after just finishing this novel yesterday. Humor, heart, lightness, tenderness, the appreciation for sibling relationships. Fans of the theater and classic musicals will rejoice over the delightful references peppered throughout the pages. This is an inspy rom-com that’s sure to bring loads of smiles and happy sighs. I’m SO EXCITED for Luke’s story next!

Penelope's story was everything that I'd hope for and more!!! I fell in love with her bubbly and vibrant personality when I listened to the audiobook of Authentically, Izzy! These Edgewood siblings and cousin are the best! Izzy Edgewood, Penelope Edgewood and Luke Egdewood! They are so much fun and kept me laughing with their antics, big brother vibes, sibling inside jokes, love and support, guidance and protection, best friends and a whole lot more!

I loved the combination of letters, emails and texts in this mostly epistolary type novel. There are several scenes that are not in epistolary form and have the characters in person having dialogue. I loved having both. Each form brings out different aspects of the characters' personalities and thoughts and feelings.

Penelope was so much fun! She's just darling and has a larger than life personality! She's cheerful and caring about others. And her musical theater and theater knowledge is the best!!! I'm a huge theater fan and this just made me smile the whole way through! I've been in several musicals but haven't been in one for a few years due to life and schedules but reading this has me wanting to dive back in and enjoy being a part of a show! And all of the Julie Andrews and Gene Kelly and Audrey Hepburn references just had me grinning! They're some of my favorites!!!

As she steps into her role to help save the Gray family's Darling House Theater through her marketing skills and just all around amazingness, she runs into a few bumps and might catch a few bruises. But never fear she's super and finds ways to glow and radiate sunshine!

But there are two Gray brothers, Matt and Alec, whom she has to work with and navigate daily. Add in a cute little girl, some hilarious moments of embarrassment, a mole, witty banter, pitter patters of the heart, a big surprise, a job offer, family, friends, a bicycle, baking, princesses, costumes, a parade, a nefarious rival, dancing, hats, skirts, glitter, rain, a Princess, a ball, sea monsters, deception, and love...and you have a charmingly delightful book that you won't want to set down!

And can I just throw out that there I'm extremely excited for Luke's book!!! *Insert squeal* Seriously, his personality and dry humor crack me up. When the author announced that his book is happening and did a cover reveal, I was one happy reader!!!

If you haven't had the chance to read Authentically Izzy, which is the first book, do yourself a favor and read it! You have plenty of time to do so before Penelope's story releases! A perfect summer read!!!

Content: Clean. Some kisses but nothing further!

I received a copy from the publisher, Thomas Nelson-Fiction, via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.

Happy Reading!!!

This book was super cute and the author is extremely talented. This story is told in an email and texting format with the main character Penelope’s siblings. Penelope is super cheerful, positive, and you can see the Mary Poppins correlations sprinkled throughout. If you read authentically Izzie, you’ll be reintroduced to characters but this book can stand alone on its own. I just super enjoyed the authors character creativity and cheer in this story.

I enjoy ANYTHING written by Pepper Basham (I’m sure even her grocery lists are entertaining!). But seeing this was the second book in a series, I decided to read the first book (Authentically Izzy) before diving into this one. I immediately fell for Isabelle and Brodie - it was so easy to identify with that creative but uncertain librarian and her Skymar pen pal. But her over-the-top cousin Penelope?! I was sure this second book couldn’t have the same comfortable flow. Was I ever wrong! Such a classic romance! I love the difference in age and heart-experience between Penny-girl and Matthias. The healing balm she brings to all the Gray family AND their vintage theater is almost magical. More than once I found my eyes misting up. I recommend YouTube for a making your own sound track as you read. Now I can’t wait for the third book in this series!

Charming, delightful, and magical in every way! I absolutely ADORED this book!!

Penelope is hired as an intern to help turn around the struggling Darling Theater owned by the Gray family. Her insightful plans quickly begin to change things and her positivity and optimism make a deep impression on the Gray family, most especially on single father Matt and his daughter Iris.

Matt has closed himself off from the world to avoid getting his heart broken again but even his grumpy wall cannot stand when faced with Penelope's sunshine. He finds himself falling for her but when she returns home at the end of her internship, he is sure to have his heart broken again.

What to love:
Grumpy/sunshine romance
Dual POV
Single dad
Movie and musical theatre references
Sabrina-esque vibes
Bike riding lessons
Grandpa Gray
The parade
Dancing the waltz
Masquerade ball
Hero to the rescue
The first kiss!!!!!!!
Sibling text threads

The first 25% of this book is in epistolary format, meaning that it is told only through texts, emails, and letters. After that point, there are still some texts and emails but it is also told from the dual POV of Matt and Penelope.

I enjoyed the beginning, especially the sibling text threads, but also appreciated when we had the regular POV as well. It was balanced very well!

I am pretty sure I had a goofy grin on my face through this entire book. The characters, the setting, the stars-in-your-eyes romance, even the little mystery sideplot, I loved it ALL.

If you are a fan of Hallmark movies, the theatre, broody and wounded heroes, or even just a charming romance full of pixie dust and fairytales, then you absolutely need to read this book. This gets a very enthusiastic 5 stars from me and I cannot wait for Luke's story!

I received a complimentary copy but a positive review was not required.

Positively, Penelope is an absolutely charming book! This heartwarming romcom is told mostly through emails and texts, a format that I adore! Penelope and Matt are the stars here—she is joyful, fairy-tale-believing, oftentimes singing; he is serious and guarded. She has been hired to help his family’s struggling theater, and it was a delight to watch Penelope work ver magic with not only the theater, but also with Matt! Watching their romance unfold was romantic and inspirational and fun!! The setting of this book is unique, the characters are (mostly) enchanting, and I loved every moment.

That balance of heartwarming and hilarious. A cheery book that’s easy to read, and the perfect break from my normal suspense books. Penelope’s sunny spirit shines through the pages, making her a relatable character.

This book is just delightful! It is an epistolary novel for the most part. We get Penelope's thoughts as well as those from her brother and two sisters through texts, emails, and phone calls. About half way, the novel does move away from emails/texts and such.

Penelope Edgewood is all hearts, flowers, unicorns, princesses, and glitter, with a touch of show tunes. I just adore her. I love a heroine who has a flair for the dramatic (working in theatre is perfect for her) even in her wardrobe choices--she loves a good hat!

Penelope travels from her home in North Carolina to the (fictional) country of Skymar to help a family save their crumbling theatre. Her sunshine personality is a wonderful foil to the family's resident grump and accountant, Matthias. The people who run the Darling Theatre cannot help but fall in love with Penelope, her persistence, and her positivity. Even Matthias, who is nursing a broken heart himself, eventually caves. However, someone is trying to sabotage the return to glory of the Darling Theatre, and it's up to Penelope, Matthias, and the rest of the family to figure out who before Penelope has to return to North Carolina for a new job.

I am honored to have read Positively, Penelope by Pepper Basham. It is a magical, special story full of vulnerability and heart, and I was so there for every minute. The characters are lovely. I adore Penelope and her positive outlook on life. Matthias is the perfect hero — a great father to his daughter, Iris, and exactly the sort of man a woman like Penelope needs. Iris is a completely sweet and endearing little girl whose energy is effervescent. And Grandpa Gray and Gwenn are awesome. In this story, the reader is back in the wonderful world of Skymar with its beautiful scenery, fantastic and lovely communities, and delightful Scottish-like accents and customs. I enjoy the setting as much as I love the characters! And then there are the many poignant themes and topics discussed. There is so much I want to say about this story, but can’t because I don’t want to spoil a single second of this outstanding tale of restoration, romance, and happily ever after. All of this weaves together to create an excellent story, but what touched me the most is that Basham allows us readers into a grief journey via Penelope, Matthias, Alec, and Grandpa Gray. I don’t know if this is intentional or not, and perhaps I’m a tad sensitive to grief (even fictional grief) right now because of my own recent losses, but Positively, Penelope became the cathartic read I didn’t even know I needed.

There are many, many moments in this story that really gripped my heart in regards to grieving the loss of a loved one, but it’s something Alec says that resonates deeply: “[The loss] didn’t seem fair or right, and we were expected to go on with our lives as if this catastrophic thing hadn’t happened” (loc. 4543). I’m not going to lie, I had to put the book down for a minute to have myself a good cry. Alec is 100% correct. The death of a loved one feels wrong…so, so wrong. The loss also feels completely unfair; and, at least for me, it’s really hard not to get angry. The hardest part is that in our society there is no time given to mourn. My job gives three days of bereavement. After that, it is expected that you will be back to work as if nothing life-altering has just happened. It’s a shame that we, as a society, don’t have more compassion towards those who are hurting due to loss. But I am grateful for people like Pepper Basham who recognize the need to sit in sadness for a minute or two in order to get to the heart of what grieving really is. Who acknowledges that it is a seriously heartbreaking process that needs time and grace to work through. That it leaves a person-sized hole in our hearts that we don’t ever really recover from. And I am super appreciative that Basham reminds us through Penelope that the best way to deal with grief is to talk about the people we’ve lost. When we tell their stories, and remember how we were a part of those stories, it helps ease some of the pain and heartache.

Positively, Penelope is a wonderful story — one I won’t soon forget. It is beautiful and must be experienced. If you are a fan of well-written fiction with BIG heart, sweet romance, and a great happily-ever-after then you have to grab a copy of this story ASAP. You do not want to miss out on this amazing journey.

I received a galley copy of this novel in eBook form the publisher, Thomas Nelson, via NetGalley, in order to review. In no way has this influenced my review. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Positively perfect in every way! This was an absolute hit by Pepper Basham! Penelope’s story has such warmth and comfort, it’s impossible not to love it. Authentically Izzy had already become one of my favorites, but Penelope’s story was perfectly done. As a lover of theater and musicals, this was so much to read. I did have my broadway playlist on while reading it, and made it a thousand times better. I just know Penelope would appreciate a broadway soundtrack to her life.

Penelope is completing an internship at a historical theater in Skymar. Working with Matt Grey, the manager of the company, to bring the theater back to life proves a challenge when competition is fierce. Penelope, in all her optimistic cheerfulness, is determined to succeed. She is underestimated due to her positive and cheerful attitude, but it doesn’t deter her from her goal. Matt has suffered heartache and loss. His guarded heart only has space for his daughter, Iris.

Penelope and Matt are very interesting characters with two very different outlooks in life. Yet, those differences make for a fun and witty dynamic. The humor was top-notch and I was just laughing out loud the whole way. But it also had its serious and heartfelt moments. It was a perfect combination of lighthearted, humorous storytelling with plenty of heartfelt lessons. I loved the themes of friendship, love, and community that it’s displayed throughout the book.

This is very much a grumpy/sunshine trope, one of my favorites. But I really liked that grumpy didn’t equal rude, which it often happens in grumpy/sunshine tropes. One of my favorite characters here was Iris. She was a precocious little girl, who just needed a little bit of “magic” in her life. I loved everything about this book! It was the perfect combination of humor, depth, and love. I cannot wait for Luke’s story!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own. I was not required to write a positive review.

I love this book! Penelope is an absolute joy. Pepper Basham continues with the Edgewood family support system. This time Penelope is traveling to the county of Skymar. She is off to her internship readers learned she had applied for in Authentically Izzy. She and her family keep in constant contact through messaging and phone calls. This makes for a different kind of reading feature for the beginning of the book. (I had a hard time adjusting to this technique when reading the first book of the series but was prepared to enjoy it with this story.)
Penny is a joyous young lady who loves the theater, musicals and the magical romance of princesses and heroes. She soon meets and charms her way into the hearts of most of the Gray family who owns The Darling House. This theater on the island of Fiacla is in dire need of rejuvenation. Penny just may be the person who can bring joy back to the family and the one-hundred-year-old theater. There are some very interesting characters here, delightful seven-year-old Iris, her great-grandfather and college student, Gwen. There's also two single men, the handsome Alec and the grumpy Matt, father of Iris.
The book has a great touch of humor, some intrigue, deep faith and a sweet romance. I really enjoyed it. It's better than a movie by you know who!
I received an advanced readers copy from publisher Thomas Nelson and NetGalley. This is my own unsolicited opinion of it. I cannot wait for brother Luke's story!!

Positively Penelope
This was a fun story. Pepper Basham is a CF romance writer and I am usually not into reading romance. But I would call this a love story, a light and terrifically fun love-story. Love stories seem to me to be based more on character and romance often based on appearance. I read Authentically Izzy first and this is a sequel to that delightful story. Penelope is a young, quirky, vintage move buff, with a vivid imagination. Her sister Izzy, from the first book, is a book quoting fun character. I really enjoyed all the references to Gene Kelly music, and memories of old movies with him dancing were welcome. Pepper did a wonderful job creating such interesting characters with a good story line. Good emphasis on overcoming first impressions and forgiveness. Like the story of Izzy this is mostly letters, or texts back and forth between the family, that allows the point of view to float back and forth between who is writing. I needed this light, fun story.
Thanks to #NetGalley, #Pepper Basham, #Thomas Nelson Fiction

This book has great potential to be my top read for 2023. I can't remember the last time I laughed so heartily at a book. I have seen some negative reviews from folks who don't enjoy epistolary style novels and if that's not your cup of tea, I wouldn't recommend this one as it's probably 2/3 in that style, but the style made the particular brand of humor work so well. This is the 2nd book in the Skymar series. If you've read Authentically, Izzy, you're familiar with the characters and the fictional country of Skymar. If you haven't, this story will stand on its own, though. This book follows Penelope, the youngest of the Edgewood siblings/cousins. When she receives an internship at a family theater in Skymar, she's thrilled to go on an adventure across the world and see the land that her cousin Izzy has come to love. What she doesn't expect is to fall in love in the process.

This book had such a sweet love story, great character development, good family dynamics, LOTS of witty banter and more laughter and joy than I could shake a stick at. I did have misty eyes a time or two as well - this book brought out all the feels, but the overall feeling of the book is whimsical. Knowledge of musicals - particularly Sound of Music is helpful as well, which I was glad for as that one is one of my favorites. I thoroughly enjoyed Penelope's joy and spirit and the creative ways she breathed life into a dying theater. The story was good, the characters were wonderful and the ending was thoroughly satisfying. If you enjoy fun contemporary rom-coms, this is one I would heartily recommend.

Special thanks to Thomas Nelson and NetGalley for an advance e-copy of this novel. I was under no obligation to provide a review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.

This was one of the cutest books I think I’ve ever read in my life:) Oh my heart!
I was constantly smiling or gigging.
I adore Penelope, she is so funny and relatable! I wish I could be her friend, but reading this book made me feel like I was which was so much fun!
This book has one of the most sweetest romances! It was tender, caring, loving, and passionate all at once!
I absolutely adore all of the film and literary references in this book, I may have shrieked when a certain line from pride and prejudice was referenced,
it made my whole day!!
Singing in the rain is a very special film to me and my family, hearing it mentioned in this story made me cry happy years:)
The Edgewood family is so similar to my own, it is so fun and funny to read!
I truly have only good things to say about this book, it was a lovely, and delightful experience! I highly recommend!
🎧🚲💌🎭
-grumpy x sunshine
-love triangle
-family drama
-small town & island
-slow burn till it’s not;)
-funny family dynamic

Thank you so very much to Thomas Nelson and Net Galley for the arc in exchange for an honest review!

'Are you sure you want to start a professional relationship with a personal objective to sprinkle fairy dust into the life of a man who may not respond positively to your brand of joy?'

As a reader, yes Luke...we all want Penelope to spread her joy to the grumpiest of men!!!

This book.
All of the stars.
All of the thumbs.
All of the praise.
All of the things.

Perfection. I know no one wants to live up to perfection, but this book truly is perfection.

It's balanced in all things. happiness/grumpiness, hope/doubt, live life fully/coast through life, etc.

If you love witty banter, pop culture references, nods to all the classics (we learn from Luke sometimes the term "classic" means different things to different people... if you know you know -- and believe me, you want to know lol), swoony romance, happiness, hope and perseverance this is the book for you! If I missed something that you would relate to more insert that here:__________ because this book is for EVERYONE and I am convinced that EVERYONE needs this kind of happiness in their life.

Penelope is pure joy. From her theatre background, wardrobe, inner thoughts, dreams and her crazy, good skills she will endear herself to you forever.

The Grays...I'm lumping them all in one because they are such a fun family. And dare I say a real-type family. The kind that even when they don't know what they are doing, lose their way, their zest for life...they are a family through and through.

Luke. Luke gets his own paragraph because who of you out there that have been reading this series is not ready for more Luke. Sarcasm has never come across a page better than with Luke. He is good for the soul.

Get this book and read it for everything that is amazing in this world, because bits of it have been sprinkled throughout like fairy dust...and 'who couldn't use a little more happiness in their life'?

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Content/triggers: Grumpy/Sunshine, workplace romance, single parent, dream setting, theatre/pop culture references, great dialogue and banter, great friendships, family relationships (some strained some not), romance, kisses only and a good chance you'll laugh out loud multiple times.

Last year, I fell head over heels for the wonderful, whimsical story that was Authentically, Izzy. It ended up being one of my favorite reads of the year, and I couldn't contain my excitement when I discovered that the author decided to make it into a series. After loving Penelope's character in the first title, I knew she deserved her own story, and I couldn't wait to dive right in. I was a little worried that I wouldn't end up enjoying this one quite as much, since bookish titles are usually more my style than theatre ones, but I needn't have worried. Pepper Basham has delivered another wonderful rom com style romance that kept me reading way past my bedtime, and had me wanting more and more from these adorable, swoon worthy characters.

Penelope's got a big heart for the world around her, and when a dream internship opportunity has her traveling to Skymar to help bring a beloved theatre back to life, she'll stop at nothing to see her dreams come true. With her heart being torn between two brothers who couldn't be more different, finally getting the opportunity to live her out childhood dreams come to life, and trying to get on top of the dastardly individual who seems determined to steal every one of her marketing ideas, Penelope's Skymar adventure is bigger and grander than she ever could have prepared herself for.

I absolutely adored this title from start to finish, and it's every bit as wonderful and amazing as Authentically, Izzy was. Penelope is such a sweet gal, and I think any reader will find themselves wanting to root for her on her somewhat tipsy turvy way to happily ever after. The author has truly created a literary style paradise setting in the lovely region of Skymar, and I enjoyed how this one dives even more into some of the history introduced in the first book. This entire novel felt like a love letter to classic movies, chick lit, and old fashioned romance, and I never wanted to see it come to an end.

Definitely one of my favorite reads of the entire year so far, and I have no idea how I'm going to wait until next year for Luke's story to release.

Final Rating: 5/5.

I cannot recommend this title enough! Do yourself a favor and not only pick this one up, but also pick up the first book as I can guarantee you won't be disappointed. If you're a fellow lover of epistolary novels, then this is definitely the series for you as quite a large portion of the plot is told through hilarious emails and messages between Penelope and her siblings and cousin, and it made a great story even better in my opinion.

Thanks so much to Thomas Nelson for allowing me to advance read and review this title!

I voluntarily read and reviewed a complimentary advance reader copy of this novel from the publisher (Thomas Nelson) via Netgalley. I was not required to give a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own, and this is my honest review.

What a delightful sequel! I read “Authentically, Izzy” again to prepare me for reading this book, and I have to say that I love both books so much. A reader could very well read “Positively, Penelope” without having read Izzy’s story, but I am so glad I read them back to back as it made the stories both that much more enjoyable for me. Penelope is a stereotypical bubbly, glass is always half full, lover of all things musicals, theater, and fun. She is a deeply caring person too, and her biggest character trait, beyond her positivity is her loyalty and desire to serve others. Readers will be thrilled to follow Penny as she meets the Gray family and works her magic at their amazing historic family theater. This story took twists and turns I did not expect, and I loved watching it all unfold on the pages. In true Penelope form, this story is filled with family, drama, laughter, tears, miracles, romance, and intrigue. Everything a theater buff would want in a tale, and I think many readers would enjoy as well. I highly recommend this book as a great escape into fiction, and I will be telling my book friends about it, too!

I requested and received a copy of this book for review. The words and thoughts expressed here are wholly my own.

Such a cute second book! I will say it was harder for me to get into because the formatting of this ARC was a nightmare- why is there a logo every other page??? It was so distracting and made me not want to read this book, but I pushed through because this is one of my most anticipated releases of the summer! It was so cute and just makes me want to recommend this series even more. I love the letter writing/email aspect of this series and it continued to shine in this book. All of the characters in these books are so fun and unique- they may be some of my favorite characters of all time.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to review this book- just please Thomas Nelson change your formatting for these arcs!!

#PositivelyPenelope #NetGalley
This is a sequel to Authentically Izzy and the story would make more sense if you read both books in this series. Penelope was quirky and fun. I loved her fettish for Julie Andrews and the Sound of Music, her quotes from movies and that she loved to sing at odd times. Penelope comes to the country of Skymar to intern at a theater, and ends up finding out that it is close to closing down. Penelope decides to try her best to make it thrive. I loved the conversations back and forth between the siblings. How Luke loves to tease his sisters.

“The world could do with a little more kindness and positivity and random acts of singing, don’t you think?” —Penelope

Penelope practically oozes with positivity and creativity. And she’s channeling every ounce she can muster into saving The Darling House theater. With any luck, she just might bring an actual smile to a certain grumpy Mr. Gray’s face. But someone isn’t on board with Penelope’s plans. Mischief, mystery, and mayhem ensue—there’s even a kidnapping too! (Note: Though this book reads wonderfully as a standalone, readers will enjoy it even more after reading Authentically, Izzy.)

An epistolary novel written largely in the form of text and emails, Positively, Penelope is witty, charming, unputdownable, and practically perfect in every way!

*Thank you to @netgalley and @tnzfiction for the complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Positively Perfect!

This story had it all! I loved getting to visit Skymar again but meeting new and wonderfully charming characters.

We get the same feel from this book as we did from the first in the series, Authentically Izzy. Much of the story unfolds through written correspondence like emails and text messages. But we also get the third person point of view story telling. Ms. Basham blends these techniques so seamlessly that the reader gets carried along in the best way possible.

I was invested in what would happen from the first page to the very last! That doesn't always happen. Sometimes I get bored with an ending of a book but not this one!

I've been inspired to try to make chocolate éclairs now! I've even researched recipes. That's in my agenda for the weekend! If Penelope says they are surprisingly easy, I must give them a go!

The only thing that I can think of that would make this book better is listening to it! I hope to be able to do that once it is released. Izzy was so amazing on audio. I need to hear those accents again!

I do wish to thank Netgalley, Thomas Nelson and Pepper Basham. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

** “The biggest dreams are the ones that take the most risk, but they’re worth it, Iris. You may just have to make it through the hard things first.” **

Pepper Basham delivers a delightfully lovely epistolary story with “Positively, Penelope,” billed as a standalone but companion novel to “Authentically, Izzy.”

Izzy’s cousin is set to travel to the captivating island of Skymar, where Izzy recently found love and purpose, to intern at an old family theater in desperate need of some marketing help. Penelope joins forces with the Gray brothers — hunky Alec and the enigmatic yet kind Matt — to incorporate new ideas to save The Darling House. But when a rival theater seems to keep stealing her ideas, she’s concerned her plans will be severely thwarted. Will she be able to save the theater, and sort out her feelings for two very different brothers?

Written mostly in letter form — emails and texts — “Positively, Penelope” is filled with both funny and romantic moments, as well as moments that will allow the reader to pause and evaluate their own dreams and desires.

Basham creates delightfully quirky characters readers will fall in love with, as well as filling “Positively, Penelope” with some great themes, like following one’s dreams; encouraging others; getting people to believe in themselves; rediscovering your joy, and we have to choose and even fight for joy; the magic and joy of creativity; the past and present can live in harmony; seeking love (“Love has a way of being much bigger than we imagine”); and the importance of home.

Fans of epistolary novels like “The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society” as well as authors like Katherine Reay will love this story, which is due out Aug. 1.

Five stars out of five.

Thomas Nelson provided this complimentary copy through NetGalley for my honest, unbiased review.

I fell headlong into this fine fun laugh-out-loud epistolary romance, one I did not want to end. I adored it as much as book one in the series, Authentically, Izzy: It helps to read it first but Positively, Penelope can be thoroughly enjoyed solo.

The author writes such fully fleshed characters, whose flaws just make them more endearing, and this time Penelope, Luke, Izzy, and Josephine -- along with the country of Skymar -- return again to the compelling pages. A must-read destined to become another fav from a versatile author who writes with such verve and wit that all her books will make it to your TBR list. Highly recommended!

Positively Penelope did not disappoint! I was so afraid that it would not be as good as the first book but it was. I laughed outloud and often found myself wishing I could be in Skymar with Penelope & Matt! Sweet friendships, theater, family and love all wrapped together in one amazing story. Pepper Basham, you did it again.

What a delightfully fun read! I loved it so much! It was just as good as the first book, Authentically, Izzy. This could be read as a standalone, but I'd still recommend starting with Izzy just because it's so good.

I literally laughed out loud numerous times and had a smile on my face for the majority of the book. It's such a feel-good romance, but it has a lot of depth and heart, too. It wasn't just fluff, and I loved that.

This was full of wonderful and likable characters. I loved Penelope's positivity and joyfulness. It was contagious! I also loved her tenacity and determination to help The Darling House. I instantly fell for Matthias. Yeah, he was a grump, but he was such an endearing one! And despite that grumpiness, he was such a stand-up guy. A gentleman with a surprisingly great sense of humor. I also loved the secondary characters too. Grandpa Gray, Iris, and Gwynn—the list could go on and on.

If you're looking for a laugh-out-loud, heartwarming, and sweet romance, grab a copy of this book. You won't be disappointed.

I received an advanced copy of this book via NetGalley and voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and comments are my honest opinion.

Be prepared to dive into a world that radiates positivity, love, joy, and happiness, and is full of twists and turns with laugh-out-loud vibes and so many amazing references to movies and music.
It's sweet and fun such as our beloved Penelope.
It's a grumpy X sunshine
Single dad
An epistolary novel with a lot of banter and zero spice.
Penelope travels to Skymar for 3 months to become an intern at a historical theater on the island which is in desperate need of savings. There she meets Matt Gray the theater manager a grumpy single dad who had lost his belief in love and magic.
Together they will save the theater and Penelope might just be the key to his happiness again.

I loved the Skymar books. The 1st one was pure joy and now Penelope's story did not disappoint.
Everything was perfect from A to Z and I highly recommend you pre-order this book
You Will LOVE IT 😉

Thanks to @NetGalley and the Publisher for granting me an ARC of #PositivelyPenelope in exchange for my honest review.
Xoxo

This book feels like a continuation of the first book, Authentically Izzy, and was a four star for me until the last part of the story when suspense kicks up a notch and ends on such a sweet note that I decided on five stars. It is told in the same format as the first one with of lots of emails and texts, in the epistolary form. We see the same humor and wit between siblings/cousins, Penelope, Izzy, Luke, and sometimes Josie. What fun they have with banter and teasing, all interspersed with love! Penelope is doing an internship in Skymar, home of Izzy's boyfriend, Brodie, following her college completion. Sunny personality Penelope meets grumpy Matt Gray at the airport, but things get better the more that the two are together. She makes a special bond with Matt's sweet little daughter, Iris. She is working with the Gray family to revitalize their theatre, The Darling House and finds such history and special love in the artifacts and memories. She does a wonderful job and wins the hearts of the family and community. Filled with movie quotes and references, this is another fun and uplifting read. I am looking forward to reading Luke's story.
I received a copy for the purpose of an honest review. These are my thoughts.

An utterly delightful romantic comedy, with a determinedly optimistic heroine ready to tackle any challenge with faith, love, and pixie dust!


Penelope comes to Skymar to help a struggling local theater, and the burst of creativity and light that she brought to every situation. She is indefatigably positive, and I loved how she brings out the best in people inspiring them to hope again. Iris is so adorable! I loved the relationship between her and her siblings, as they communicate through text, email, and phone calls throughout the story. Luke is definitely still a favorite, and I'm interested to see how his story will play out as he is a man of few words.

This was such a fun read, filled with heart, a grumpy-sunshine romance, and great musical theater references. I loved Penelope's zest for life, and how she shares it with others. Matt is a man who has gone through a lot in the past few years, but he has a heart of gold and is an excellent father.

Overall, a completely enjoyable addition to the series with heartwarming new characters, and engaging plot, written by an author who knows her audience well. I loved the humor, excellent chemistry between Penelope and Matt. Highly recommend, and can't wait for Luke's story!

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Positively, Penelope is “practically perfect in every way.” I loved this delightful, uplifting book! It’s the second book in the Skymar series, and though it can be read as a stand-alone, I totally recommend reading Authentically, Izzy first. Since this story is told mainly in texts and emails, you’ll appreciate knowing what happens in Izzy’s book before you read Penelope’s. That way you won’t get spoilers from her book!

I flew through Positively, Penelope because I just could not stop reading! Penelope’s personality is lovely! She’s always trying to see the best in every situation and person. She loves the theater…especially musicals! Just reading her emails, texts, and dialogue uplifts you! I just completely adored her! I love her family, Izzy and Luke (and Josephine…she is in the book less than the others) with whom she emails and texts. Luke is so funny, and I’m so excited to read Loyally, Luke!

Positively, Penelope has clean, swoon-worthy romance, wonderful characters, laugh-out-loud humor, and an uplifting story. I give this much more than five stars and highly recommend it!

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.

I recently finished reading (listening to) Authentically, Izzy, book one of the Skymar series, and it was delightful. I was so excited to dive into Positively, Penelope after getting to know Penelope throughout the first book as she offered encouragement and positivity to her cousin, Izzy. I hoped that this book would live up to the fun and romantic atmosphere created in that first novel. Well, I was thrilled to find a story that I loved even more than the first!

Positively, Penelope was the perfect blend of epistolary and in person dialogue. The swoon factor was there in spades, with a grumpy and heartbroken single dad hero, a sweet daughter, and the delightful Penelope who was able to weave her uplifting spirit and love for all things theater into the entire Gray family.

I simply adored this story from start to finish and I must now wrap my mind around the fact that it will be so long until book three, Loyally, Luke, is released next year! It will be a very hard wait!

I believe that readers could pick up Positively, Penelope and enjoy it even if they haven’t read Authentically, Izzy. So, if you are really wanting to dive into this book without having read book one, go ahead, you should be fine. I, however, love reading book series in order when I can. I do think that it is fun to get to know Penelope, Luke, Izzy, and even Josephine through the emails and texts of Authentically, Izzy first. Then enjoy seeing Penelope get a truly swoon worthy happily ever after in this book.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

Penelope has traveled internationally to help use her background and education in theater to help save a family owned theater that has been around for generations but is now failing. This family has faced heartache and grief, but Penelope is determined to make a difference with her knowledge and her own brand of optimism.

Never have I felt more like the grump from a grumpy/sunshine trope than I did while reading this book, because Penelope is certainly on another sunshiney level. Positively, Penelope does a great take on the grumpy/sunshine trope. Penelope is very positive, to the point where others often do not take her seriously. Matt has seen quite a bit of heartache and has buried some of his passions regarding his family’s theater as well as the desire to laugh or smile with ease. At first, Penelope was a bit much for me to handle. But, like Matt and others throughout the story, she really did grow on me. It became more evident that she wasn’t blindly optimistic, as many had accused her of being. She had the plan and knew how to put it in place.

I had struggled to adjust to the mostly epistolary nature of book one in this series (Authentically, Izzy) until I read it in a physical format. However, I found it much easier to read Positively, Penelope, even as an e-book, now that I am used to this particular style. It definitely helps break up the narrative when there are emails and texts conveying conversations. Also, it helped keep me interested when there were some sneaky, underhanded things happening (kept vague so no spoilers!). I kind of guessed what was happening, but it still made for an interesting read. Hopefully that helps get you interested to read too! I am very interested in reading Luke’s book next.

I received a complimentary copy of this book and I’m leaving an honest and voluntary review.

Penelope is thrilled at the chance to do an internship at a theatre in Skymar and is determined to do her best. But the theatre is approximately back in the Dark Ages as far as a web presence is concerned. Then there's 'Grumpy Grey' to reckon with, not to mention his charming brother who any woman should be glad to consider her knight - but whose charm somehow seems to fall a little flat. Throw in a possible mole at the theatre, and Penelope has plenty on her hands. Nevertheless, she is determined to conquer all obstacles in her own inimitable style. But when faced with a choice between an old dream and a new, which should she choose? And must choosing one meant the loss of the other?

Content warning: This is a book best read when alone, to avoid having to explain to others why you're laughing so much! I loved it from the very start, just like Izzy's story - but possibly this book even more? Penelope is a very not-me character, but she drew me into her life from page one and welcomed me. I loved the way Izzy and Luke supported her, helped her when she needed it, but avoided the (often well-intentioned) pushiness/nosiness that is so common in families (okay, so maybe Josephine doesn't escape it - but we don't see much of her). I also loved the way that we get shown the 'surface Penelope' with hints of her internal dialogue, but gradually get to see what she's really like inside - it was a great reminder that there's often more to people than shows on the surface. Excited by the hints of Luke getting his story next, and REALLY looking forward to it. A delightful book full of both laughter and heart. Highly recommended.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Positively, Penelope is the second book in the Skymar series by Pepper Basham. I HIGHLY recommend you read the first book, Authentically, Izzy before reading this one. Otherwise, you will get spoilers, miss a few things, but mostly, miss out on a great first book of the series.

"If you were able to learn how to wear that pink bunny suit from Legally Blonde on stage in front of a pastor and his entire youth group, I think you can do anything."

I loved getting to know Penelope through her adventures in Skymar. Penelope is hilarious and her propensity for not finishing a story (in text/email) makes her more so. She is an extremely positive Polly-Anna, casting out sunshine wherever she goes. She can be clueless at times, which also adds humor.

Just a few things that helped this story shine:

grumpy/sunshine
cute child
single dad
wonderful cast of characters
witty banter
plenty of LOL moments
nod to Classic movies

This story was hard to put down and it kept a smile on my face. There was so much to enjoy!

I appreciated the references to Mary Poppins, Julie Andrews, Grease, the Sound of Music, and more! There are so many quotes (like the one I shared above) that are hilarious, especially in context. I loved Positively, Penelope, and can't wait to read Luke's story in Loyally, Luke. It also makes me wonder if Josephine will get her own story, although she doesn't seem to be as much of a main character as Izzy, Penelope, and Luke. 🤔

Thank you to Justreads Publicity, Net Galley, and the author for the opportunity to read this book. I was not required to provide a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own. I had pre-ordered Positively, Penelope, but sadly it was not here before I needed this review to go out. However, it is one for the keeper shelf and I can't wait until my paperback copy arrives!

I just finished Positively Penelope by Pepper Basham, the second book in her Skymar series. Oh. My. Word. Y’all. It was just as adorable and magical and…(using a Pepper word) fairytale-ish as book 1. I just adore her characters, Penelope and Matthias. If you have not started this series, you are so missing out. Now…I need book 3. Please hurry Pepper!!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions expressed are completely my own.

Positively, Penelope by Pepper Basham is book #2 in her Skymar series. This is my first book from her and I absolutely LOVED it! Have you ever read a book that you thought oh man this is going to be terrible? How will I ever make it through this one? That's how it was for me in the very beginning. I will warn you now. This book is mainly told in texts and e-mails back and forth between various people. It can be kinda confusing at first, but hang in there. I did and then the sun started shining and my whole world became Penelope's whole world. It needed up being the best book. Penelope has such a great outlook on life. She brings joy wherever she goes. I know I need to be like her. It was such a refreshing book and the end...OMS! I cried tears of joy, so yes there was an epilogue. I can't wait to read the next one. I'm going to go back and read Authentically Izzy. You do not need to read the first book to follow this one, but you do get to know about Izzy and Brodie throughout the 2nd book. Izzy is one of the people who Penelope texts and e-mails back and forth. So if you love a book about saving an old theater house, a lady who loves musicals and old movies and wears vintage clothing, and a grumpy man who isn't actually grumpy once you get to know him then this book is for you. Plus you get to meet said grumpy man's daughter and his sweet gramps too. I also really adored the relationship Penelope had with her brother, sister, and cousin. It was refreshing to see such a great family relationship. I really can't wait for Skymar #3. Counting down the days. I was given a copy of this book, but all opinions are my own.

Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious awesomeness! I adored this book! It was everything my romantic, musical loving heart could ever want. Pepper Basham delivers a delightful, magical, feel good, grumpy/sunshine romance with endearing characters, witty humor, all the favorite musical/pop culture references, and even a hint of mystery. Like with Authentically, Izzy I absolutely fell in love with Positively, Penelope.

Penelope Edgewood’s talents are put to the test when she accepts a 3 month internship in Skymar to revive the old Darling House Theater. Armed with a sunny disposition, creative solutions, a Mary Poppins bag full of amazing things, and the support of her lovable siblings/cousin, she begins tackling the theater’s problems. Soon her cheerful positivity and love for the theater affect everyone around her including her grumpy business manager Matt Gray. But, not everyone is happy with the changes Penelope’s making. Someone is out to sabotage her and the theater. It’s going to take Penelope’s unconditional love and know how to pull off a miracle and save the theater.

All the love for this book! I adored Penelope and Matthias! In Authentically, Izzy, Penelope came off as a bit naive and we didn’t get to see the full facet of her personality. In this story, she really shines and we see her depth and the true kindness she possesses. Penelope chooses joy and her example affects everyone around her. She’s a breath of fresh air and it was pure delight reading her story.

The flip side of the coin is Matt or “Matthias.” This lovable grump has been through a lot in the past few years. Unfortunately, he’s temporarily lost his joy and mistakenly bans fairytales and princesses from his young daughter Iris’ life. Penelope brings back the magic with singing, baking, and watching “almost” princess movies like Tangled with Iris. When he sees the happiness she brings to not only his life but everyone around her, he begins to rethink his grumpy ways. I loved their romance with him teaching Penelope how to ride a bike, dancing in the theater, and his sacrifices.

Told mostly in epistolary form, I enjoyed reading the witty, heartfelt, sometimes snarky (Luke) emails and texts. All the Edgewood relatives’ personalities really shine and you can’t help loving them all. It was especially fun to see a new side to Luke and I can’t wait for his story! I thoroughly enjoyed new characters introduced like Grandpa Gray and Gwendolyn. I loved all the musical references and the quotes from Julie Andrews and Audrey Hepburn. I also loved the message of choosing joy. Even the villain has a story and manages to tug on your heartstrings.

You can’t help but smile while reading this story and I guarantee you’ll find yourself singing those amazing show tunes from Phantom of the Opera to My Fair Lady! Highest of recommendations for this exceptionally, practically perfect, clean romance! I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own and voluntarily given.

Positively, Penelope is the second book in the Skymar series following Authetically Izzy. Both stories are told through the texts and emails sent between Izzy, Penelope and Luke. Authentically Izzy was about Izzy finding love and now it's time for Penelope to find her prince charming.

The email exchanges between Izzy, Luke and Penelope are hilariously entertaining as they poke fun at each other. Each character really has their own quirky personality. Some of the quirks Penelope has is that she is afraid of sea monsters, loves Julie Andrews and references musicals. Penelope was a really fun character to follow along and relatable in some ways like her fear of things from the ocean-haha.

The romance kept me on the edge of my seat waiting for Penelope to come together with her prince charming. The theater element to the story and romance made it more worthwhile to read about. Every part of this book was sweet right up to the very end when they finally come together. There were definitely some surprise moments at the end you'll want to read!

Thank you Netgalley and Thomas Nelson for this ARC so I could review it!

Many thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for the eARC of this book!

Positively, Penelope follows Penelope (of course) as she gets her chance to go to Skymar and participate in an internship with a local theater, The Darling House. A theater that has seen better days, she determines to help the owners of the theater, the Gray family, bring it back to life. Problems arise when she notices that a rival theater company is somehow stealing her ideas for the Darling House. Plus, she has caught the eye of the two Gray brothers, businessman Alec and single father Matt.

First, I loved Penelope's character! She loves happy endings, she doesn't deny the troubles of the world, and she is kind. She is an overall likable character! Plus, it never hurts to have a love for the great Julie Andrews - I could relate with her in that regard! Granted, I have never met a person as positive as her, but I don't doubt there are people in the world like that. Also, I appreciated how the author balanced Penelope's super positive outlook with Matt Gray's somewhat pessimistic outlook on life. However, Matt learns as the story progresses that it's okay to dream and be positive again. Their relationship is a great example of the grumpy/sunshine trope, and I loved it. It was well done! I will say, as the story moved forward, the anticipation over Penelope and Matt's relationship had me thinking, 'Get together already!!!'

I enjoyed the progression of the story and the pacing was perfect, in my opinion. Compared to Izzy's story, it felt like there was more at stake in Penelope's. I enjoy plenty of conflict in the books I read (I blame my creative writing professor a couple of years ago for this haha).

Ultimately, should you read this book? YES! It is a sweet, easy read with complex emotions sprinkled throughout, most notably grief. If you haven’t read Authentically, Izzy yet and you’re beginning this one, I do think you could get away with it. However, some of the plot lines mentioned in this one won’t immediately make sense, so I’d recommend you read Authentically, Izzy before starting this one.

Positively, Penelope, by Pepper Basham, is “practically perfect in every way.” There is a sunshine / grumpy aspect to the story, and one of the most incredibly sweet romances imaginable. I absolutely love Penelope. She is all rainbows, princesses, glitter, and sunshine. I read Authentically, Izzy first and I thought it was an amazing book, but wow, Penelope’s story is even better, even if she has trouble finishing it at times. The sibling love and family aspect is one of my favorite parts of the book. Also, when reading the text messages and emails between everyone it seems like you’re part of the family too. I can’t wait to read Luke’s story next!

I was provided a copy of the book from the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review, and all views and opinions are my own.

Penelope takes an internship in Skymar to help revitalize a historic theater during it's centennial celebration. A new big name studio has come to town and seems to keep stealing her ideas. Is there a mole at the theater? I loved this book and absolutely adored the characters that Pepper Basham created! Penelope is such a fun but relatable character and I really enjoyed how her bubbly self was able to break through the grief and sorrow of some of the characters and bring about change. This book is such a fun read. I enjoyed the fact that a lot of the story is told through texts and emails. Highly recommend for lovers of contemporary romance. Can't wait to read the next book in the series.

I received an eARC of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.

I loved this book. Penelope was quirky and delightful. She’s one of my favorite heroines ever. She doesn’t play games. She’s honest even when it could be embarrassing. She chooses to see the positive in things and in people. She’s full of pixie dust and fairy tales. She’s the perfect foil for Matthias who has been hurt and guards his heart.

I loved their interactions. Matthias’ sarcastic humor and the way Penelope responded was priceless. I didn’t want the book to end. I can’t wait to read about Luke and to see who could possibly win his heart. His text responses were so funny. I enjoyed it all from beginning to end.

Thank you to Thomas Nelson for providing me with a free e-copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

I am smiling from ear to ear as I think about this book! The characters were so authentic and endearing and the story was filled with hope, humor, mystery, and romance. And can I just say that Pepper Basham writes the best kissing scenes! This was mostly an epistolary novel that took me a moment to jump into like coming into the middle of a conversation but it didn’t take long to get into the flow. I loved the banter between Penelope and her family members whose texts and emails gave the readers knowledge of what had transpired and lent some insight into Penelope’s feelings and inner thoughts. Penelope herself was so upbeat, kind, enthusiastic, courageous, hopeful, persistent and smart. She sprinkled sunshine and baked goods wherever she went sometimes to the chagrin of others including closed off and curmudgeonly Matthias who was in desperate need of her positivity. If you enjoy books that will leave you feeling good and wishing for more then this book is for you. I can’t wait for Luke’s story! I received a complimentary copy of the book from the publisher via NetGalley and this voluntary review contains my honest opinions.

Such a refreshingly fun and romantic story!

I enjoyed this book as much as I did the first installment of the series (Authentically, Izzy). This is also written mainly as an epistolary novel with texts, letters, emails, chats, etc. I appreciated with this novel, as with the first, that the written messages were realistic and not just long info dumps.

I adored Penelope, who has traveled to island of Skymar for an internship in the theater. She soon comes to realize that the theater is in trouble, both financially and because the two brothers, Alec and Matt, who run it, do not agree about anything. Penelope loves movies, theater, and has a deep adoration for all things magical and romantic. She wants to help save it, but there are so many things against them.

This novel is engaging from the first page and Penelope's jubilant, quirky personality is infectious. There's a bit of mystery (who is GK, the person with whom Penelope has been corresponding?), lots of singing, and captivating banter between all of the characters. There is a great deal of humor, but some very poignant and faith filled moments to balance out the lighter ones. The overarching theme of dealing with grief hit home so squarely with me, and the author's words brought tears to my eyes more than once. I know that the author has had some deep grief of her own and the way she conveys it on the page elevated this book for me beyond the usual rom-com.

What a lovely book, and I cannot wait for Luke's story! Mr. Cynical better watch out!

Positively, Penelope by Pepper Basham is an absolute gem! This book captured my heart with its enchanting blend of romance and music. Pepper Basham has truly outdone herself, delivering a delightful and magical story that left me feeling uplifted and satisfied. The characters in this book are incredibly endearing, and the witty humor sprinkled throughout adds an extra layer of enjoyment. What's more, the author seamlessly weaves in beloved musical and pop culture references, making the reading experience all the more enjoyable. And just when you think you have it all figured out, a hint of mystery adds an intriguing twist.

Just when I thought I couldn’t love a book family more, along came Positively, Penelope. I absolutely loved Authentically, Izzy and this book is even better! Penelope’s character really stood out in the first book so I couldn’t wait to read her story.

Penelope is a ray of sunshine that we all need in our lives. She does everything with joy, is prepared for anything, loves big, and enjoys making others happy. Oh and did I mention she carries a huge “Mary Poppins bag” and loves hats and shoes?

This story is full of twist, hiccups, princesses, fairytales, tons of Julie Andrews and Gene Kelly references, family banter, friendship, and love. The first half of the story is told mostly through emails, texts, and occasional phone calls between the family members which are so fun. It really makes you feel like part of the family.

This book also has quite the troupe combo that includes a jaded grumpy hero & sunshine heroine,
single dad with an amazing little girl, workplace forced proximity, a bit of an age gap, he falls first, and of course a love triangle. Oh and that ending. Be still my heart!

I would definitely recommend this series to everyone and I can’t wait for the next book so we can see how Luke’s story develops.

I was provided a copy of the book from the author/publisher. I was not required to post a positive review and all views and opinions are my own.

“Sometimes a girl just wants to be rescued now and again. Why is that so wrong?”

This story is one of the most charming and adorably sweet books I’ve read. I couldn’t get enough of Penelope’s “spoonful of sugar” personality, full of bright, vivid optimism and “Grumpy Gray’s” grumpy, cloudy demeanor, which he has good reason to possess.

“Sunshine and sugar have to be one of the best happiness combos in the world. And tea. And chocolate.” Penelope can brighten any corner of the room, or of the world, for that matter. I loved watching her take off across the ocean for a wonderful internship opportunity and see the magic she sprinkled around, the changes she made, and the lives she touched. But I especially loved watching her delve into new emotional territory.

Basham does a phenomenal job of engaging the reader and dropped me right into a beautiful story of love and healing, all through letters, emails, and messages, with several moments of in-person exchanges that completely melted me.

This is the perfect story for those who love grumpy-sunshine, Julie Andrews, theater, magic, single parent romance, and Audrey Hepburn, with a lovely setting in Skymar.

Positively Penelope is a delight in every way!

Content: mild romance

Dear Followers,

If you are in search of a five star read that will leave you with a smile on your face and song in your heart, then look no further than Positively, Penelope by Pepper Basham!!!

Penelope, a recent college graduate, has accepted a marketing internship in Skymar. Her main objective is to revive the historic Darling House theater. While once a thriving staple of the community, the Darling House is on the cusp of closure. While Penelope is the perfect person for the job, her jaded employer Matthiases, mistakes her positive outlook for having her head in the clouds. Will Penelope be able to save the Darling House and win over Matthiases in the process? Or will she be forced to return home before finishing the job?

PS: Positively, Penelope is the second book in the Skymar series. It features everyone’s favorite glass is half-full cousin, Penelope Edgewood. I must admit that I was a little apprehensive going into this book because I connected so much with bookish Izzy from Authenticall, Izzy and have limited knowledge of musical theater. Luckily, Pepper Basham wrote a book that is not only accessible, but enjoyable for musical theater novices such as myself.

PPS: I highly recommend reading if you are fans of clean romances that are written in an epistolary format, and feature the grumpy-sunshine trope.

PPPS: Special thanks to Pepper Basham, Thomas Nelson, and Netgalley for allowing me to read this book in exchange for my honest feedback!

I really really really liked Authentically, Izzy- but let me tell you- I LOVED Positively Penelope! Penelope is definitely one of the most positive characters ever! She is fun, organized, adorable, and downright jolly 99% of the time, and reading her story was a blast! She was the perfect match to her hero, even though she took a while to realize it. It was a delight seeing Skymar and family interactions through her eyes. I thoroughly enjoyed all the musical references, though there were a few I didn’t recognize. The mystery was fitting, though I kind of had it figured out early on, but that didn’t bother me a bit! Mathias is a handsome, broody hero who needed someone just like Penelope to draw him back into the light. “A spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down” as Mary Poppins says, and Penelope is that sweetness to everyone she encounters! I also enjoyed the themes of faith and trusting God. I can’t wait to read Luke’s story in book 3!
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for my review copy. These are my own thoughts; I was not required to write a positive review.

I never thought I'd fall so in love with epistolary novels but I am completely smitten!

This book is completely enchanting as well as addicting. I fell in love with the characters and the story.

The banter between the siblings and their inside jokes was pure fun and just made me smile.

Have you ever met a character you'd love to meet in person and have a cup of coffee with, Penelope is just that person.

I'm really looking forward to Grumpy Luke's story. If I know Pepper Basham like I believe I do I think Luke is in for quite the rude awakening.

Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book via the publisher. I was not required to write a review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

I’m completely in love with the Isle of Skymar, the Edgewood sibling group, and sweet, effervescent Penelope. The epistolary format (told mostly in texts and emails) really captures the dynamic between the siblings, down to the unfinished thoughts and lightning quick subject changes, and has some extra intrigue as we don’t know exactly who Penelope has been corresponding with from the Skymar theater troupe. Iris is precious, Matthias (and oh, what a cinnamon roll he is!) was charming, and we really get to know his heart. But truthfully, Penny steals the stage with her creativity and her depth despite (or perhaps because of) her bubbly personality. I listened partly on audiobook, and while I did not at first love the female narrator, listening to the story definitely brought another dimension to the story as a whole. I was very touched by the overarching themes of loving, grieving and choosing joy, and the mysterious circumstances surrounding Penelope’s internship in Skymar make this another very exciting , engaging, and lovable installment of the Skymarian series! I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a positive review.

I’ve been excited to read this story since I had to to finish reading Authentically Izzy (fabulous). Izzy was great and Penelope, even in her secondary role in that story, leapt from the pages. Here as the heroine in her own story, she doesn’t disappoint.

This time around, Izzy’s cousin Penelope travels to the Skymarian Islands to try and rejuvenate an historic theater. Unfortunately, a chance run in with one of her new bosses sets the tone of their relationship as frosty. But while she’s trying to win Matt Gray over, his younger brother Alec thinks Penelope should be treated like a princess. The romance of her dreams ensues.

Penelope’s cheerful attitude begins to work its magic on the island. However, just as things at the theater start turning around, Penelope’s secrets for success are somehow leaked to a rival company. And at the same time, Penelope starts to wonder if she really wants a fairytale relationship.

There are so many things to love about Positively Penelope. As ever with a book by Pepper Basham, the plot is very clever. This story is filled with musical theater references with a supporting cast of character hats. What’s not to love about that? The character development is touching and I cannot wait for the third trip to Skymar. Highly recommended. I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley. The opinions are my own.

What a delightful book! This is a sweet romance that has wonderful characters and just the right amount of fun to keep you turning the pages. I loved reading this book!
I received a complimentary copy from Thomas Nelson--FICTION via NetGalley and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.

I loved this story. Penelope is a rare human, one who is constantly believing in the wonder of the impossible and encouraging everyone she meets. Reading her story was simply an uplifting experience and frankly, I didn't want it to end.

I've worked in the past with a couple of ladies who reminded me of Penelope and I'm now able to see them in an even fonder light. I do wonder if this is the attitude God would have us all live, with an ever-expanding heart for Him and others.

Penelope travels to Skymar on an internship working at The Darling Theatre that is experiencing some difficulties due to the matriarch's of the Gray family, who own and run the theatre, having recently died. Penelope dives into her role inspiring everyone with her inventive ideas, willingness to roll up her sleeves and daring to dream the theatre can be restored to its former glories. In the meantime, she is courted by the two Gray brothers, well technically, only by Alec, but Matthias, the elder one is her boss and after an initial dismissal of Penelope's charms, it's not long before he begins to see her beauty and wonder.

Told mostly through epistolary emails and texts (like the first in the series) we get a first hand insight into Penelope and her family's emotions and character. Luke, her brother, is fabulously sardonic while fully devoted to his madcap sister.

The story also deals with some challenging themes around grief and its related trauma. Basham handles this gently as the Gray family collectively grapple with the loss of the two matriarchs. Penelope with her infectious encouragement is able to draw Grandpa Gray out of his sullenness and Matthias' loss of confidence as a result of his divorce. It's wonderfully satisfying and uplifting.

I feel very blessed to have received an early ebook copy of the novel from the publisher via NetGalley with no expectation of a positive review. However, I'm certain I will purchase my own copy so it can sit boldly on my bookshelf as it should.

I LOVED THIS BOOK!!!

It was a fantastic sequel to Authentically Izzy, and only reiterated that Pepper Basham and I would be fantastic friends in real life. Ha! :D Her sense of humor, trains of thought throughout the book, and many movie references were so on point with my own--it was almost eerie. :) But I am 100% not complaining!

I do recommend reading _Authentically, Izzy_ before reading this one; it builds on prior events and explains a lot. ;)

Excellent, excellent read, with plenty of literal-LOL moments. If you ever need a truly funny read, this is it!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Sunshine in book format!
I love how Penelope's positivity spreads throughout the book! She is such a fun character! I also loved the hint of mystery and intrigue and the magic of Skymar that is displayed throughout the book.
The story starts out as emails and texts between characters and then about halfway through the book changes into a more typical story. The formats used worked well for the story.
This was a sweet romance, I'd rate it G/PG for kissing. I love Pepper Basham's books and this was another great addition! I can't wait for Luke's story!

Short review:
Read this book for a light heart, laughs, and a touch of mystery.

Long review:
I had so much fun reading this book! I had gotten Authentically, Izzy at Baker Bookhouse when I was there for the Fiction Readers Summit, and while reading that and talking to Vickie about it, she told me I HAD to read Positively, Penelope, so of course I preordered it AND requested it from Net Galley. Now I REALLY need Luke's story to be released (Pepper, could you get on that, please?)!

I'm not a bubbly, sunshiny girl (I would definitely be the grump in any relationship), so I wasn't sure how Penelope would rub me, but I loved her! I loved Matt, Iris, Gwynn, Grandpa Gray...the whole cast is just delightful.

And Luke. Oh, Luke. What a wonderful big brother he is. If I had an older brother, I would definitely want him to be Luke.

I have no good way to end this except that I just loved this book!

~I received a complimentary copy of this book. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.~

Positively, Penelope by Pepper Basham is the second novel featuring the Edgewood family and it is positively entertaining. I love the Edgewoods. As in Authentically Izzy, a good portion of Positively, Penelope is relayed through emails and text messages. I enjoy the witty banter exchanged between the family members and you get a real feel for the personalities of the characters and how much they all love each other. Penelope is a modern-day Merry Poppins for sure. She’s vivacious, loving, and always sees the silver lining. Matt Gray lives up to his name at first. His life is gray except for his daughter Iris. Grumpy Gray as Penelope nicknames him blossoms as the story unfolds and it’s such a beautiful thing to see. There’s a bit of a mystery because someone is trying to sabotage the success of the Gray’s theater. There’s plenty of romance, always a little kissing, and a positive faith message. All the things you expect from Pepper Basham. While I received an advance reader copy from Thomas Nelson through Netgalley, I also purchased the paperback to add to my every-growing Pepper Basham collection.

This book!!! Dying! I loved every single word! The characters, the theatre, the music, the romance! Perfection! I loved this book! Enjoy and read the first on

"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

I highly recommend Pepper Basham’s Positively Penelope to anyone who enjoys a wonderful faith filled romance with a happy ending. A reader who loves the theater will delight in the community theater setting and Penelope’s love of all things drama. This book can be read as a standalone but reading Authentically Izzy first will enhance the reader’s understanding of the characters and setting. I eagerly await the next book in the series. Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for my advanced review copy. All opinions and thoughts are my own.

I honestly didn't expect to love Positively, Penelope as much as I loved Authentically, Izzy. But Pepper has outdone herself. Positively, Penelope was positively delightful!

When the heroine carries a Mary Poppins bag and channels her inner Maria von Trapp, you know you're in for a treat. Penelope is one of those perpetually positive people who are not always understood by others. But when she lands on Skymar to help save the Darling Theater, her belief in the healing power of cookies and dancing will endear her to the hearts of the entire Darling family. 

But will she find a leading man who is worth giving up her home and family for? Or is it possible that "some of the best characters played the secondary roles"?

If you love musicals, Julie Andrews, or good clean romance with a bit of intrigue, then don't miss this new release in the Skymar series by Pepper Basham.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book! It was a fantastic continuation of the story world created in Authentically, Izzy, and while I maybe enjoyed Izzy's story a little more than this one, I thought this one was better written as the transitions between epistolary and narrative were more smooth and less jolting. I'm so looking forward to Luke's story! Absolutely cannot wait, and I think it's going to be my very, very favorite!

I received a complimentary electronic copy of this book from NetGalley.

Another five star read from Pepper Basham. This author is quickly becoming one of my favorites.

A sweet romance that includes Penelope the beloved cousin of Izzy from the previous book. Penelope is trying to help a failing theater and finds love. These books are stand alone but definitely enjoyed reading them together.

I laughed out loud so many times. I can’t wait to read Luke’s story.

Thank you netgalley and publisher for allowing me to read and review this book. All opinions are my own.

What a delightful book! I really enjoyed this one! I started reading the book via an electronic copy but when it was released got my hands on the audio version. I loved it with the accents. Penelope was a fun character in Izzy’s story and I’m so glad she got her own. She has such a good attitude and positive spin on everything. She gets to use her skills to try and save a theater filled with history in Skymar. Not only that but the family that owns it needs some of her positivity and cheer as well. I enjoyed the continued banter between Penelope, Izzy and Luke. I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All views stated here are my own.

Charming and quirky. Heartwarming and funny. "Positively, Penelope" by Pepper Basham is a sheer delight from the opening number to the final curtain call!

With sparking effervescence, Basham combines nostalgic musical references, hilarious sibling banter, and a swoony grumpy / sunshine romance into an epistolary novel worthy of a standing ovation.

Practically perfect in every way, this loverly story is sure to make 'em laugh with an endearing cast of characters who feel like real people and true friends on the street where you live. I have confidence that once readers meet Penelope, Matthias, Izzy, and Luke, they'll read all night—in their own little corner, in their own little chair—and still beg for more!

If you're a theater kid at heart, "Positively, Penelope" is sure to be your cup of tea—with an extra spoonful of sugar!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. A favorable review was not required. All views expressed are my own honest opinion.

Positively Penelope is the second book in the Skymar series by Pepper Basham. It is unequivocally just as delightful and charming as the book that came before it. This story is mainly written in text correspondence between various characters and is humorous, heart-warming, quote-worthy and thought-provoking. It’s an absolute gem of a story and one that you won’t want to miss.

Penelope is an eternal optimist who eagerly takes a theater internship in Skymar with the purpose of updating and revitalizing the family-owned Darling House Theater. She is full of ideas and brimming with hope and good cheer. Penelope is a character in her own right: one-of-a-kind, creative, vivacious and unapologetically positive. She is also, however, realistic and inspiringly relatable. As she takes the village and the theater by storm, transforming all she meets with her youthful energy, she also finds an unexpected, romantic connection; one that she’s always dreamed of.

Through Penelope, the author encourages us to not lose hope, to never give up, and to always look for the good in any situation. Her example gently nudges us to see that good things can even come out of heartbreak. This story is truly unique, humorous, hopeful and inspiring. Positively Penelope is meaningfully memorable and a new favorite.

Penelope or Penny as her relatives call her is an upbeat, energized person who loves the theater and all things Julia Andrews and Audrey Hepburn. This North Carolina native has an internship in Skymarian working at the Darling House. Penelope is there to bring the theater back to life with her marketing strategies. She accomplishes so much and falls in love with the family that owns the theater. She not only helps to bring the theater back to life, but she brings back joy to this family. In the end, Penny gets her own fairy tale ending. The book uses emails and text messages as a way to tell much of the story from Penny's point of view. I highly recommend this book. Since it is clean and uplifting fiction with a little twist, it is suitable for any reader.

"Positively, Penelope" by Pepper Basham is a delightful romance novel that enchants readers with its heartwarming story. The book's endearing characters and charming setting come together to create a tale of love and growth. Pepper Basham's writing skillfully captures the emotions and nuances of relationships, making "Positively, Penelope" a feel-good read that leaves a smile on your face. This novel is a perfect choice for anyone who enjoys a sweet and uplifting romance that reminds us of the power of love and second chances.

It was fabulous returning to this family and the island of Skymar. I even come to love the side characters. I wouldn't mind a story on the other brother or sister from this book or for the sister of Brody from book #1. Pepper Basham creates characters you can really connect with, emphatize, understand even when not agreeing completely. Yes, even the villian in the end. The familial relationships and dynamics were wonderfully shown.
I enjoyed the nods to all the classic films. I loved the escapades Penny got herself into. She also had a bit of magic in her like a Mary Poppins yet she wasn't cheesy or cliche in anyway. I found the characters written as authentic which added to the flow and enjoyment of the story.
I appreciated the realistic challenges to their romance between the two main characters. I wouldn't classify this as a complete love triangle story. There is one brother who really sees her and this is more of a finding yourself and slowburn romance. I simply loved Penny's birthday outing scene/chapter. You just wanted them to be together but didn't know how. This was a great part of the plot. It was done well and really held this reader's attention. The ending was sweet with a grand yet simple gesture. A perfect ending for the character Penny. I really can hardly wait for Luke's story. He really is a great character. The sister Josephine Martin had even improved from book #1. I found her to be likeable when with the last one not so much. This was a pleasure to read and I reccomend the audiobook as well. The accents are fantastic.

Pepper writes the best stories! I always know that if Pepper wrote it, I’m pretty much guaranteed to love it. Penelope is no exception to that rule. This story is charming and delightful and positively perfect! Penelope is impossible not to love and Mathias is pretty wonderful too. I also loved that at least one scene in the book reminded me a bit of one of my favorite movies ever “Enchanted.” I also loved grumpy Luke and all his Rambo references. There is one character that I wanted to completely throttle but I am hoping that we get his story and redemption at some point…so fingers crossed for that!

I received a copy of this book from the publisher and also purchased my own Audible copy. All thoughts are my own.

The second book in Pepper Basham's Skymar series, 'Positively, Penelope" is a delightful sweet romance. I adore this little island country, but even more I enjoy the sarcastic but supportive banter of the Edgewood siblings. The first book, "Authentically, Izzy" was also a fun and lighthearted read, and I'm very much looking forward to book 3 for Luke's story.

Thanks to Net Galley and the publisher for the complimentary digital review copy of this title.

Positively, Penelope
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Author: Pepper D. Basham

I requested a digital advanced readers copy from NetGalley and Thomas Nelson and providing my opinion voluntarily and unbiased.

Synopsis: Penelope Edgewood is practically positive in every way, so when, fresh out of college, she is awarded a paid internship to help save a century-old theater on the island of Skymar, she jumps at the chance. After all, a crumbling theater needs the special touch of someone who reveres all things vintage and adores the stage.

Unfortunately, not everything is as it seems at Darling House Theatre. Finances are in shambles, the local theater group is disenchanted, and the two brothers, Matt and Alec Gray, can’t seem to see eye-to-eye about how to run their theatrical business. So, of course, it’s the perfect place for Penelope to shine her own personal brand of sunshine.

With a little help from GK, the person emailing her encouragement along the way, she puts all her heart into helping the Grays save Darling House. But between Matt’s ever-present skepticism, Alec’s tendency to treat Penelope a little too much like the “princess” she thinks she wants to be (until someone actually started treating her that way), a grandfather who is stuck in his grief, and a mysterious person stealing Penelope’s marketing ideas, she’s not sure her optimism is enough to make a happily-ever-after of her own story, let alone The Darling House’s.

Between an adorable little girl, a matchmaker, a sea monster or two, and a copious amount of musical references, can Penelope draw enough confidence from her faith, her family, and her adoration of all things Julie Andrews, to find the thief and save the theater . . . without getting her heart broken in the process?

My Thoughts: This book number two in the Skymar series. This is written as an epistolary novel, just like the first book in the series, “Authentically, Izzy,” focusing on emails, texts, chatting, and emails with some conversation mixed in. Not everyone will like this style of writing but it really works for this storyline. Penelope travels out of the county for an internship at the theatre, however, when she arrives, she sees that the theatre is in complete disarray, mainly because the two owners, also brothers, cannot agree on anything. As Penelope puts her heart and soul into saving the theatre, will it be enough? This follows the tropes of island living, grumpy v sunshine, and single dad.

Penelope is quirky, energetic, positive, and just infectious. Penelope is a fun character, easily liked, and more easily able to connect to. Mixed in to the romance is a bit of a mystery of who G.K. is. Matt is grumpy, a single dad, and has more grief than others, grief that he has not fully processed. The characters were well developed with depth, witty banter, chemistry, and creatively woven. The author’s writing style was complex, humorous at times, poignant at times, thought-provoking, and engaging. There is some faith interweaved with the grief that really grabs at your heart but then there is lighter banter that balances it out. So much singing and dancing, you could feel it through the pages. The author did an amazing job with detailing the island life of Skymar. It made me feel like I was there and definitely an island I would love to visit if it existed.

This novel is written differently than most in emails, chats, texts, and other communicative details, however, it is relatively easy to follow and know which voice is speaking. The conversations between the characters were the best. I loved the reference to the classic movies, some of which I grew up on. I highly recommend picking up this book.

Positively Penelope is positively delightful, as we are transported once again Skymer, a fictional island that is a cross between Scotland and Switzerland.

Penelope is a dreamer that has personality that permeates the atmosphere around her. She is light, and hope and all the happy things that many in our world turn away from. Wanting nothing but the best for the people around her, Penelope moves, heaven and earth to make good things happen to the gray family and the darling House theater. I love how she refused to quit, no matter how many hiccups came her way in the revitalization of the old theater.

In the town where I live, we have an old vaudevillian theater that our area has watched flourish, then succumb to a fire, and be rebuilt better than it was before. So this entire story had a tender place in my heart also being a theater brat at one time, Penelope’s determination was heartwarming, and even made me feel like anything is possible.

Oh, Matthias, he was a delight to read. Seeing hints of a Scottish accent, played right to my Scottish heart. Watching his heart open up after a couple years of grief and turmoil was definitely the highlight. He is a passionate man that grieves as hard as he loves.

Their chemistry is positively perfect in every way.

Penelope just radiates positive energy, she is very uplifting. Her energy spreads to those around her while working at the theatre. Matt and Izzy are a cute father daughter duo, their inclusion of Penelope into their lives was seamless and entertaining. Loved reading this book, great to see what Izzy and Brody are up to.

Loved the story and characters and superb writing. Highly recommend for a clean romance with christian undertones.

THE EASIEST 5 STARS FOR A CONTEMPORARY ROMANCE !!!!!!

Seriously, I don't remember the last time, I enjoyed every single second of a contemporary romance. Positively Penelope was positively perfect in every way:
- real characters with real dreams, relationship issues, family dynamics, doubts, fears, and joys
- the romance was PERFECTLY paced with a deliciously satisfying conclusion (AND NO THIRD ACT BREAK UP, hallelujah)
- The theater/musicals love seeped in every page. Not just the shows, but the community aspect as well
- I loved the family dynamics of Penelope and her siblings and the Gray family
- Laugh out loud moments often!
- the texts between Penelope and her siblings made me realize how much I appreciate my siblings as well <3
- I really appreciated Penelope's inner dialogue about her dreams for her future and her feelings for Matt. Both were honored and both were upheld!
- I expected the villain's identity, but it was still heartbreaking all the same. I'm glad the resolution was full of hope for them!

So excited for Pepper's next book, about Luke ;)

This book had me laughing, swooning, fangirling, sighing, smiling, and even falling in love.

If I was an extrovert, Penelope and I would be twins. (Except for her red hair and my bookish tendencies which are more akin to Penelope's cousin, Izzy.) I already loved Penelope in the first book - "Authentically, Izzy" - so reading her own story was incredibly entertaining. I mean who doesn't want to wear cloche hats and walk around with a Mary Poppins bag? She could have been the main character in a thriller and I would probably still read it because she is so fun. Also, Penelope starring in a thriller, @pepperbasham, I think you've got a story idea right there.

Then, I met Matthias Gray and... well, you know me...

*Anna adding Matthias to already infinite list of fictional crushes.*

Matt's inner dialogue was so sweet and the way he fought his feelings for Penelope made my heart throb. Their relationship was almost slow-burn and their chemistry... *chefs kiss*. I've always liked grumpy/sunshine romances but this book solidifies my love for the trope.

I also loved getting to read about their deepest fears, and how they see themselves and the world. They teach each other lessons that help them to grow as individuals. The character development was really well done, and yet it's not super heavy or intense so that it still feels lighthearted. It was the perfect balance.

I can't wait till March to read the final book in the Skymar trilogy, "Loyally, Luke". Is there any way you can move the release date Pepper? Pleading emoji.

Although, I'd recommend reading "Authentically, Izzy" first, don't miss out on Positively, Penelope! It will keep you smiling for days.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Pepper Basham is one of my new favorite authors. The book, Positively, Penelope is wonderful. I recommend everyone should read this book.

**I received an ARC of this book courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions expressed in this review are my own and given freely**

POSITIVELY, PENELOPE is an epistolary novel that re-introduces the reader to Penelope. We got to know her pretty well in the first book, Authentically Izzy, but now we learn even more. Penelope travels to Skymar to work for three months at a historical theatre on the island. Penelope has experience in marketing and they are hoping she can come up with a plan to save the theatre. POSITIVELY PENELOPE is filled with twists and turns that will have you laughing out loud! When Penelope meets Matt her life changes no matter how grumpy he always seems to be. He is a single dad to Iris and isn’t interested in A relationship as he has had his heart broken in the past. That’s all I’m saying!

POSITIVELY, PENELOPE is exactly why I love Pepper Basham’s books. She always leaves me with a big smile on my face and screaming for more. That’s how wrapped up I get into her writing. Pepper has become one of my very favorite go to authors and I devour her books like a fine box of chocolates. I try to take my time and read slowly to make it last, but usually half way through I lose all control and flip the pages like a mad woman!! Penelope also loves to bake which made me love her that much more!

Pepper Basham has once again left me in tears and crying for more. I now know I will devour everything this awesome author writes and do it all easily with a smile on my face and tears in my eyes. I really loved POSITIVELY, PENELOPE Wow wow wow!! From the very first page I was emotionally invested in all of these wonderful people. Please, you have to give Pepper Basham a try! You won’t be sorry. I can’t wait to read more by one of my very favorite authors. I have made it a quest to catch up on the rest of her books because her writing is just that good. She makes her readers feel every emotion her characters are feeling to the point where you feel as if you are right there, struggling along with them. Now we have to patiently wait for Luke’s book!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson through Netgalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

This is book two to the Authentically Izzy series in the fictional town of Skymar, featuring none other than sister, Penelope.

This is another epistolary story. (a novel in the form of letters…and/or texts/emails.) A unique format that gives You’ve Got Mail vibes. This story has an air of mystery to it as well with a secretive emailer.

This book contains all the things we love from a Pepper Basham book—humor, fun, mystery, charming characters, great banter, and (duh) kissing. 😏😉

This is a hit for fans of theater, Julie Andrews, princesses/fairytales, classic movie references, annnnd —>

Tropes:
Grumpy x sunshine
Small town
Single dad

You’ll find Penelope’s character to be adorable, sweet, fun, theatrical (think: Elle Woods meets Mary Poppins) and of course, positive. She’s sweet character to get behind.

Next up will be the charmingly hilarious and witty Luke Edgewood (brother to Izzy and Penelope).

This book was SO. FUN. These characters just grab ahold of your heart, and the story and setting are just so immersive. Once you dive in, it is hard to pull your head back out! Once again, I loved the epistolary format, but I also loved that there was more split between traditional storytelling format and the emails/texts. I feel like the author really hit a sweet spot with this book!

A true ray of sunshine. This contemporary romance, told mainly through texts and emails, follows Penelope as she travels from America to Europe to intern at a failing theater. Her unfailingly positive attitude could be just what the Darling House Theatre needs to get back its spark. She also may bring some light back into the lives of the theater's owners, the Gray family... and maybe find true love along the way? There's definitely some magic to be found in Skymar.

This novel was utterly delightful! Penelope is such a fun protagonist. You can't help but smile at everything she does. I loved reading the correspondence between her and her siblings. Epistolary novels always appeal to me. The theater setting in a beautiful European inspired country is also a big plus. The romance is clean and sweet. I loved watching Penelope heal Matt's broken heart. I have not read the first book in this series, which follows Penelope's sister Izzy, but after reading this one, I will definitely be picking it up, as well as the next entry which gives her brother, Luke, a chance at romance. The mystery in this one was a bit obvious, but other than that, it's a perfect 10 for me.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

"Do you remember how Grandma Edgewood always said that I had a remarkable gift of making a first impression? (Now that I think about it, I'm not sure whether she meant that as a positive thing.")
Armed with optimism and her own version of a Mary Poppins bag, Penelope heads across the pond to work for a family owned theatre. She loves her position and the people she meets. But when some seemingly random events halt her progress in bringing the theater back to life, she wonders if they are being sabotaged. Can she discover the truth?
This novel, primarily told in epistolary style, is the sequel to "Authentically Izzy." I recommend reading that one first. The characters are rather wonderful and do need the introduction.
Like all books by Pepper Basham, there is plenty of humor, romance, and unexpected faith. At first, my reaction to Penelope's enthusiasm was similar to Matthias (the hero of the book.) I wasn't too sure about her over-the-top persona. But I came to appreciate her joy. I did really enjoy this book and do recommend it!
I read this book through NetGalley. I wanted to read and review it. All opinions are my own.

This is a fun romcom by Pepper Basham. I really enjoy the characters and the banter between the family members. I love seeing the characters grow and being themselves. I like how these characters feel like friends who you want to know what is happening in their lives. This is a very fun series.

I received a complimentary book from publishers, publicists, and or authors.  A review was not required and all opinions and ideas expressed are my own.

I had a hard time with the ARC, so I waited for it to drop on Hoopla. The audiobook is EXCELLENT. The accents and having the characters’ voices so clearly distinguishable made all the difference in the world. The production was excellent, and it really made Ms. Basham’s book shine!

I have a hard time with 100% epistolary, so I really appreciate the way she begins this one that way but then transitions to add narrative as well. It really clinches those feelings at all the best moments!

I always love her heroes, and Matthias is no exception. And Penelope! Can I just say, what a perfect sunshine heroine? I love that she’s been underestimated, written off, and faced grief, but she still manages not to be dimmed. It’s no wonder everyone loves her pixie magic. And now that we’ve gotten to read Izzy and Penelope, I am DYING to get to Luke!!

As always, Pepper Basham delivers with wit and charm and great kissing scenes. I can not wait for Luke's story to round out this trilogy!

I loved Penelope’s story! I also loved getting to dive back into the Edgewood family dynamics and the land of Skymar.. Penelope’s quirkiness and lovable character jumps from the pages of this book. If you’ve read Authentically, Izzy, you’ve got to read Positively, Penelope!

“All the world is made of faith, trust, and pixie dust.” ~ Peter Pan

Be still my heart!! Positively, Penelope is an absolutely delightful read for theater enthusiasts and rom-com aficionados! From its clever musical and movie references to its engaging storytelling style, this book hooked me from start to finish!

“I’m beginning to realize that it’s okay just to be happy and try to spread that happiness around.” ~ Pepper Basham

After enjoying Authentically, Izzy, book one of the Skymar trilogy, but being disappointed by the lack of faith in the storyline, this second installment was the perfect blend of everything I look for in a Christian contemporary novel!! Positively, Penelope wasn’t about chasing after your heart; it was an exploration of family, life’s purpose, and redemption. God hears our prayers and knows our hearts, and when we trust Him to lead us to the right path, He will work it all out in His perfect timing!

“There is something special about belonging somewhere. It’s an indefinable sort of something, but when you are away from it for a little while, you know.” ~ Pepper Basham

The blend of romance, humor, suspense, and mystery found within the pages of Positively, Penelope was flawlessly executed. Each element contributed to a truly engaging storyline with witty banter and MANY laugh-out-loud moments. The nods to Chris Pine and Julie Andrews added an extra layer of charm, while the exploration of faith and forgiveness brought surprising depth to this light-hearted narrative.

“The biggest dreams are the ones that take the most risk, but they’re worth it, Iris. You may just have to make it through the hard things first.” ~ Pepper Basham

The characters were a fabulous ensemble! Penelope’s fiery personality and determination to make the impossible possible made me instantly adore her. Matthias was the handsome grump who stole my heart after a few chapters. And Luke was the ultimate big brother and the perfect balance between his sisters’ eccentrics; I can’t wait to read his story next!

“Your ‘hair looks beautiful in the moonlight’? (Do girls really want guys to say things like that?) How does your hair look the rest of the time?” ~ Pepper Basham

Positively, Penelope was not just a romance; it was a heartfelt journey of self-discovery and second chances. Pepper Basham’s writing was exceptional! From emails and texts to actual storytelling, the mixed styles were an excellent blend that captured my attention and heart. Positively, Penelope earned its place among my top five favorite books; it’s the book version of my favorite pick-me-up rom-com movies that I will revisit time and again.

“The world could do with a little more kindness and positivity and random acts of singing, don’t you think?” ~ Pepper Basham

If you’re looking for a heartwarming rom-com with a touch of theater magic, look no further than Positively, Penelope. It’s practically perfect in every way. 😉

*Thank you, NetGalley and the publisher, for providing me with a pre-release copy of this novel. All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.*

Authentically, Izzy, Pepper Basham's first book in her Skymar series, set me up with some pretty high hopes for Positively, Penelope, book #2 and I was NOT disappointed!!! I loved all of the references and quotes from Audrey Hepburn, and the total fan-girling over Julie Andrews. Add in some Gene Kelly and Singing in the Rain, and you have a wonderfully nostalgic character in Penelope.

Fresh out of college, Penelope Edgewood is offered an internship at a historic, family-owned theater in the tiny country of Skymar. She is enchanted with the history of the theater, even though it has gotten pretty run down since the death of its founder. As she brings her positive outlook to the job, the people's attitudes begin to change. Her ideas show promise, and new life for the theater, but someone in their ranks is out to sabotage the re-opening. Her ideas keep being appropriated by their biggest competitor, from her ad campaigns right down to stealing a touring theatre troupe to perform "The Sound of Music" that she not only found, but arranged to bring into Skymar.

Matt and Alex Gray are the brothers in charge of the theatre now, but their grandfather is the man who owns it. Matt's daughter immediately falls in love with Penelope, but it takes Matt much longer. Alex is supposedly on the road most of the time "promoting" the theatre, but he makes time to take Penelope out to lunch to listen to her ideas for the theatre. Grandpa Gray is a reclusive older man who lost his enthusiasm for the theatre when his wife died. Could Penelope be the spark that brings the Gray men back to the theatre that has been a huge part of their family?

I loved Penelope and her practically encyclopedic knowledge of all things Julie Andrews, and Audrey Hepburn. She dresses in skirts everywhere she goes, and once she learns how, she rides her bike everywhere on the island. She carries a "Mary Poppins" bag that has every conceivable emergency fixer upper item inside. While she's not "practically perfect in every way" like Mary Poppins, she is practically positive in every situation, which is just as good.

I enjoyed listening to this through my Libby app. Since it is written as a series of emails and texts between characters, it was much easier to tell who was speaking/writing at any given time when I could hear their voices. I highly recommend the audio versions of both Authentically, Izzy, and Positively, Penelope. I look forward to listening to Loyally, Luke when it comes out.

Readers who enjoy contemporary romance with a lot of giggles should pick up both books in this series! I loved them!

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for granting me free access to the advanced digital copy of this book.

Positively, Penelope

by Pepper Basham

I wondered if Pepper Basham would follow up the very bookish epistolary novel Authentically, Izzy with another epistolary novel. If so, could it be as good, as fun, as the first? How do you write an epistolary novel in the twenty-first century anyway, a time when letter writing for personal reasons is rare? Basham continues her humorous style with Positively, Penelope told mainly in emails and text messages between Penelope who has taken a job as an intern helping the marketing team in the country of Skymar and her brother and two sisters who live in the Appalachians. There is also some third person narration thrown in. As a drama major, a very dramatic teacher of elementary age children, and a lover of storytelling and princesses, I can identify so much with Penelope who attacks life with more gusto than I can dream of mustering!

Penelope is trying to rescue the dying Darling House, a theater whose owners and managers lost their spirit with the deaths of the mother and grandmother over a short span of time. Penelope with her positive attitude spreads joy wherever she goes with her smiles, singing, and creativity. Two brothers, Matt and Alec, are grumpy but could make romantic heroes in the story as they fall under Penelope’s spell along with their father, Grandpa Gray. Matt’s daughter Iris who has not been allowed to enjoy fairy tales blooms under Penelope’s friendship as they share a love of pink and princesses. While Penelope seems like cotton candy fluff, she is actually quite bright. Unfortunately, every idea she comes up with is stolen by a rival theater; it seems a mole has invaded the Darling House team.

Silliness, suspicion, fear of sea monsters, a cute seven year old, costumes, royalty, creativity, and clean romance make Positively, Penelope a fun novel; I’m packing my bag for Skymar right now.

I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Rating: 5/5

Category: Romance, Fiction, Christian

Notes: 1. #2 in the Skymar series. It could be read as a standalone, but I wouldn’t want you to pass up the very bookish first novel, Authentically, Izzy.
2. a lot of humor as the siblings banter with each other
3. Christian undertones woven subtly into the book
4. #3 has already been published about the flannel wearing, bachelor brother in the family, Loyally, Luke

Publication: August 1, 2023—Thomas Nelson

Memorable Lines:

But no wonder he’s grumpy. Anyone who is against fairy-tale talk, singing in public, dancing on the sidewalk, and general hat-wearing has to be a sad sort of person.

Because story is the key to what we bring to the stage, how we present ourselves online, and even how we engage with one another. We all have stories, but in our hearts, we all LOVE stories (even if it takes some of us longer to admit it…kind of like a smile. Some people need more encouragement to smile than others, but you should really know a smile makes all the difference).

He came up to me, dismounted, and shot me this dazzling smile before saying, “I’ve always wanted to rescue a damsel in distress, but I never realized one would be so lovely in the rain.” Heaven HELP ME! Who says stuff like that? Only Skymarian men who ride on white horses in the rain????

This sequel surpasses the first—and I loved the first book! While it continues to use e-mails and texts as a primary narrative style, there’s also more traditional storytelling this time around.

Penelope absolutely shines as the heart of this story. Her vibrant personality and unwavering positivity are infectious, not only transforming the lives of those around her but also inspiring readers to embrace optimism. The Gray brothers add depth to her journey, and watching Penelope discover her true self is both heartfelt and uplifting.

The enchanting island setting remains just as whimsical and captivating as in the first book, providing the perfect backdrop for this delightful tale. With its charming writing and light hearted fun, this is a story you’re sure to enjoy!

I really liked this book on my first read, but my reread bumped this one up to a loved status. I think reading it so close to the first book the second time around endeared me even more to Penelope and her kind heart. Throughout the book it is revealed over and over that Penelope leads with her heart, but that is she not just all feelings, she has smarts too. I loved this take on an uber feminine character. She is the most fun and girly, but that adds to her strength, it doesn’t detract from it.

Thank you to Thomas Nelson and Libro.fm for the gifted title. All opinions are my own.

If you're looking for a low-spice rom-com that's laugh out loud funny, let this be the book you pick up! A grumpy male main, a bright and cheery female main, a musical theater setting, and learning to fall in love again is all that this one has to offer and more. With lovable characters and witty banter, this is simply a fun read from start to finish. Pepper Basham is a master at her craft and does rom-com so well! This is a must read!