The Gilded Butterfly Effect
A Novel
by Heather Colley
You must sign in to see if this title is available for request. Sign In or Register Now
Send NetGalley books directly to your Kindle or Kindle app
1
To read on a Kindle or Kindle app, please add kindle@netgalley.com as an approved email address to receive files in your Amazon account. Click here for step-by-step instructions.
2
Also find your Kindle email address within your Amazon account, and enter it here.
Pub Date Oct 21 2025 | Archive Date Feb 15 2026
Talking about this book? Use #TheGildedButterflyEffect #NetGalley. More hashtag tips!
Description
Fans of Mona Awad, Ottessa Moshfegh and Dark Academia rejoice—your newest “weird girl” antiheroes are finally here in this darkly comic and unflinching campus novel for the age of prescription pills, impossible beauty standards, and weaponized friendships.
When introverted loner Penny transfers to a midwest university in search of the all-American college experience, she finds herself under the intoxicating influence of Stella, a glamorous, damaged sorority girl with a razor-sharp wit and a bottle full of secrets. As their unlikely friendship deepens into obsession, both young women spiral into a hall of mirrors—haunted by frat-house cruelties, prescription drug dependencies, and the brutal expectations of modern femininity.
Narrated in alternating voices, The Gilded Butterfly Effect exposes the glossy absurdities and grim realities of contemporary campus life, exploring themes of body dysmorphia, mental health, sexual assault, and peer manipulation with both ferocity and humor.
Colley isn’t afraid to put campus life under a microscope, examining complex topics ranging from sexual assault to prescription drug abuse to body dysmorphia with an unwavering steady hand. The Gilded Butterfly Effect is a delightfully twisted (and timely) read that promises to deliver loveably imperfect female protagonists, humor, and a whole lot of dysfunction.
The Gilded Butterfly Effect is the debut novel by author Heather Colley, whose short fiction has writing won The Oxford Review of Books Short Fiction Prize, the Hopwood Award, and the Desperate Literature Short Fiction Prize Shortlist.
A Note From the Publisher
Similar Reads: Perfect for fans of Mona Awad’s Bunny, Ottessa Moshfegh’s My Year of Rest and Relaxation, with a nod to the campus literary tradition of Elif Batuman’s Either/Or.
Dual Narratives: Alternates between two captivating voices—Stella, a sorority girl struggling with trauma and self-perception, and Penny, an outsider navigating the elite social scene—creating a dynamic and layered storytelling experience.
Complex Female Characters: Features a nuanced and evolving friendship between two young women who mirror each other's struggles, showcasing themes of identity, self-destruction, and resilience.
Social Commentary with Humor: Balances a dark exploration of campus life with moments of biting humor and wit, making it both thought-provoking and entertaining.
Compelling Villains: Introduces unforgettable antagonists like Trip Swindle, the leader of a toxic fraternity culture, whose actions spark critical reflections on power and misogyny.
Award-Winning Author: Marks the debut novel of Heather Colley, a celebrated writer with accolades that promise high-quality, engaging prose.
Topical Themes: Explores critical societal issues, including the dark side of Greek life, the impact of trauma, and the commodification of mental health care, appealing to socially conscious readers.
Perfect for Discussion: A thought-provoking book ideal for book clubs or academic settings, sparking conversations about feminism, privilege, and the modern college experience.
Advance Praise
“Think Mean Girls on uppers. By turns savage and sympathetic, Heather Colley’s The Gilded Butterfly Effect skewers the absurd theatre of college life with ferocious wit and style. Told in alternating first-person narratives, it lays bare the dark, narcotic heart of sorority culture.” —Damian Fowler, author, Falling Through Clouds
”A sharply observed novel that deploys innovative language to get deep into the psyche of women at one of the most pivotal times in their lives. An engaging and thought-provoking read.” –Amanda Eisenberg, author, People Are Talking
“The Gilded Butterfly Effect spreads like a stain, dark and irrevocable, as the characters chase the edges of their own destruction. At once jarring and hypnotic, bitter and full of desperate hope, the voices of its two narrators entwine and pull each other to pieces. Heather Colley has invented a new rhythm of language, or perhaps pulled one out of the depths of consciousness. A singular and unforgettable debut.” —Devon Halliday, author, To Stay, To Stay, To Stay
“With an academic laxness that’s almost charming, and armed with pharmaceuticals taken not for recreation but to restore the humanity the Greek system has taken away, Colley’s characters collide with a system where betrayal is as transactional and expected as a course assignment. The Gilded Butterfly Effect is a rowdy, utterly compelling journey through the debauchery and moral reckonings of contemporary university Greek life.” –Laura Hulthen Thomas, author, The Meaning of Fear
Marketing Plan
Targeted Social Media Campaigns:
Platforms: Focus on Instagram, TikTok, and Twitter to reach a younger, college-age demographic.
Content: Share quotes from the book, character spotlights, and humorous but thought-provoking posts about campus life and mental health. Use hashtag #TheGildedButterflyEffect.
Influencer Outreach: Partner with book influencers, especially those focusing on feminist literature, contemporary fiction, or dark humor, to promote the book.
2 Book Club and Campus Outreach:
Pitch the book to college book clubs, sororities, and mental health organizations on campuses as a discussion starter.
Arrange author visits, Q&A sessions, or virtual talks at universities.
3 Pre-Release Buzz:
Use NetGalley and Edelweiss to distribute Advance Reader Copies (ARCs) to reviewers, bloggers, and early readers.
4 Bookstore and Library Promotions:
Offer promotional kits to independent bookstores, including posters, bookmarks, and table displays highlighting the book’s humor and social relevance.
Work with libraries to organize reading events, discussions, or panels on campus issues tied to the book’s themes.
5 Media and Press Coverage:
Pitch articles, interviews, or op-eds from the author to major outlets covering campus culture, feminism, or contemporary fiction.
Secure coverage in outlets like Bustle, The Cut, and Teen Vogue, which align with the book’s themes and target audience.
6 Creative Marketing Strategies:
Interactive Quizzes: Create an online quiz like "Which Gilded Butterfly Effect Character Are You?" to engage readers.
User-Generated Content Campaign: Encourage readers to share their “relatable campus moments” tagged with #MyGildedButterflyEffect.
Available Editions
| EDITION | Other Format |
| ISBN | 9781953103628 |
| PRICE | $18.00 (USD) |
| PAGES | 276 |
Available on NetGalley
Featured Reviews
Carol T, Reviewer
'We all know exactly what beauty is. And we all know what it is not.'
First, some constructive criticism:
The narration of the POV characters felt very similar. On one hand, it makes sense because they are the products of the same flawed time, but on the other hand, there should still be flavors to them. It was only towards the end, when they talked/thought about each other, that it became apparent that they were, in fact, different people. I think if there had been more external reminders of what the other sounded like, e.g., halfway, one of the POV characters mentions that the other has a meeker voice, and vice versa, then it would've been easier to distinguish them.
The praise:
This book captures perfectly what it was like to be a young woman in the millennial generation. The brutality of the hierarchical ranking of girls in how they appease patriarchal systems. The extensive brainwashing that leads to external abuse and self-betrayal. All with a very engaging writing style.
I've read this in two days, and the moods I was in heavily shaped my experience.
On day one, I was in a bad mood because I was sick, sleep-deprived, and just all around bitter. Then I picked up this book with its dry and straight-shooting narrative, and it felt like exactly what I needed. I was no longer alone in my bitterness, and this book was like getting to confide in the kindred spirit I've been looking for my entire life! Every single description felt like hitting the nail on the head on an experience I thought I had long forgotten, but suddenly felt completely emersed in again.
The second day, I had enough sleep and overall felt better, and from then on, the book was just heartbreaking. I felt so much for the POV characters, and I found myself grateful for how far I've come in unlearning the horrors that were once normal to instill in the minds of young women.
Overall, great read.
Thank you for trusting me with the ARC. I have also posted on Goodreads.
Reviewer 1848931
3.5 rounded up to 4 stars. Thank you to Net Galley for the ARC!
How far are you willing to go to balance the sanctity (depravity) of D1 school Greek life and maintaining a certain image? Heather Colley’s debut novel asks this question and more. With 2 first person POV’s and a 3rd person omniscient to get into the minds of more minor characters and add context, the book after about the first 1/3 really picks up pace and becomes something you won’t want to put down.
I think there is a lot in this book grounded in reality, but sometimes there’s a suspension of disbelief needed, at least for myself based on my own undergrad experiences being involved in Greek life at a smaller D1 school, ironically not super far away from Ann Arbor. However, for a reading experience, I could get around my suspension of disbelief and really enjoyed this novel.
Colley writes exciting and stimulating prose, and I am excited to read more of her work in the future. A solid debut novel. If you enjoy dark academia and the seedy underbelly of college life, you will enjoy this book.
Eliza L, Reviewer
Oh my goodness this was so good! So dark and disturbing and engrossing.
Colley put into words so many weird and sad and true feelings and experiences that happen during this time in life. This is definitely not a feel good book. The truths that Colley brings out about girlhood, college life, misogyny, and female friendships are really dark. That said - loved it. Totally worth the read.
Kathryn M, Reviewer
I was hooked from the cover and description, it was everything that was promised and enjoyed the overall feel of this book. It was engaging and thought the overall storyline was so well done and was hooked from the first page. The characters had that feel that worked and I enjoyed how different the voices were in this type of book. Heather Colley wrote this so well and was glad I got to read this.
Readers who liked this book also liked:
