The Mystery of Insch Brae House is an atmospheric and intriguing mystery that combines family secrets, history, and a beautifully drawn setting. Susan Fiddes creates a story filled with suspense and curiosity, inviting readers to uncover the hidden truths surrounding a fascinating old house and the people connected to it.

The setting is one of the novel's greatest strengths. Insch Brae House feels like a character in its own right, with its history and secrets adding a wonderful sense of atmosphere. Fiddes skillfully builds a feeling of mystery while weaving together the past and present, keeping readers invested in discovering what lies beneath the surface.

The characters are thoughtfully developed, with their personal journeys adding emotional depth to the central mystery. The story balances investigation with themes of family, belonging, and the lasting impact of choices made long ago.

The pacing is steady and allows the mystery to unfold gradually, which will appeal to readers who enjoy slower-burning, character-driven stories. Those looking for nonstop action may find the approach more reflective, but fans of historical mysteries and atmospheric fiction will appreciate the careful storytelling.

Overall, The Mystery of Insch Brae House is a captivating read with a strong sense of place, intriguing secrets, and an engaging mystery at its heart.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.

This was a charming mystery with an engaging cast of characters and a wonderfully atmospheric setting. The investigation unfolded at a satisfying pace, and I enjoyed piecing together the clues alongside the protagonists. Cozy mystery fans will find plenty to enjoy here.

This book had a great gothic feel, and the suspense level was perfect. It kept me reading while allowing the plot to develop naturally. I enjoyed the characters and was eager to see how it played out. I will recommend this to students.

I thoroughly enjoyed The Mystery of Insch Brae House. It combines gothic atmosphere, historical intrigue, and an engaging mystery into a story that kept me guessing from beginning to end.

The setting is wonderfully immersive. The old house almost feels alive, filled with secrets waiting to be uncovered. I loved the slow unraveling of the mystery and appreciated that each new discovery added another layer rather than simply answering questions.

The pacing strikes a nice balance between suspense and character development, allowing readers to become invested in both the mystery itself and the people trying to solve it.

If you enjoy atmospheric mysteries with richly described settings, hidden family secrets, and a touch of gothic charm, this one is definitely worth reading.

Great childrens fiction book with strong characters like Muriel 💕

Cute without being too cutesy 😊

Fun unique storyline and just fun laidback book 📖

enjoyable mystery that kept me curious from beginning to end. It doesn't rely on shocking twists or fast-paced action, but instead builds its suspense steadily, letting the atmosphere do most of the work. The old house itself felt like a character, full of secrets waiting to be uncovered, which was easily my favorite part of the novel. I found myself piecing together clues alongside the characters, and that made the reading experience satisfying. While I guessed parts of the mystery before the reveal, I still enjoyed seeing how everything came together. It may not become a favorite of mine, but it was a solid, entertaining read that I'd recommend to anyone who enjoys classic mysteries with an eerie, old-house setting.

A Gravity Falls type mystery meets funky scottish setting. Great detective novel for kids that would watch horror movies if only their parents allowed it

What worked:
The author describes a mysterious, depressing setting for Muriel, as she’s sent to stay with a guardian she’s never met. Miss Floss demeans her at every opportunity to the point where Muriel is afraid to move about the house. The house itself is drab and dusty, with most of the rooms standing empty. However, food surprisingly appears outside her bedroom door, but it seems Miss Floss doesn’t know anything about it. Strange sounds and Muriel’s curiosity lead her to begin investigating the house.
The author uses short chapters, which should appeal to young readers. The conflict focuses on the history of Insch Brae House, since Muriel doesn’t understand why it’s in such poor condition now. She deduces that it may have been a school where Miss Floss once worked, but Muriel wants to know why she’s now so sad and bitter. A young boy from town joins Muriel halfway into the story, and together, they follow clues to uncover what happened to the house and Miss Floss. The truth involves bullying and a tragic love story and builds to a surprising climax.
What didn’t work as well:
The prologue and an early chapter describe Muriel’s father in India. He’s injured during an earthquake, and her mother travels there to be with him. However, her parents aren’t a major part of the story, and readers may be disappointed or surprised by that. Perhaps the parents will be more present in the book’s sequel.
The final verdict:
The plot isn’t a suspenseful mystery, but it features unique characters and a heart-warming ending. I suggest you give it a shot.

The Mystery of Insch Brae House is a charming middle grade mystery. Muriel is shuttled off suddenly and without explanation with an employee of her grandparents to a home her mother remembers fondly from childhood. Muriel tries to discover why she was sent to Insch Brae House while also figuring out the strangeness of the place.

I enjoyed the way the mystery of the house unraveled itself, though it was a bit slow. Muriel’s imagination about her survival and detective skills were a delight. I could imagine her inner monologue, and it was fun. While Muriel’s temporary caregiver is rather unkind, her new, local friend brings some interesting adventures to the story.

I enjoyed the mystery aspect of The Mystery of Insch Brae House, but found the pacing a bit slow and the ending a bit too tidy and unbelievable. Muriel and Christopher, however, were great.

Thank you to Net Galley and the publisher for an advance copy. Opinions in this review are my own.